Spiritual support in end stage heart failure (ESHF): a randomised controlled feasibility study  Linda Ross1, Jackie Austin2,Paul Jarvis1, Sara Pickett3 

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction to the unit and mixed methods approaches to research Kerry Hood.
Advertisements

The term carer is taken to mean informal caregivers This psychosocial intervention is addressed to the primary caregivers of diseased persons with a serious.
End of life research in COPD
Caroline Glendinning Emeritus Professor of Social Policy Social Policy Research Unit University of York College of Occupational Therapists/Skills for Care.
Support and Assessment for Fall Emergencies (SAFE) Trial An evaluation of the costs and benefits of computerised on-scene decision support for emergency.
Modelling the impact of service innovation in Stroke Care Tanaka Business School: Imperial College. Lead researcher: Dr Benita Cox Background Stroke is.
Emotional Well Being on an Acute Stroke Unit Implementation of a Mood Screening Pathway Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust Dr Amanda Campbell - Clinical Psychologist.
Clinical Knowledge Summaries CKS Heart failure - chronic Primary care management of end stage chronic heart failure. Educational slides based on the CKS.
24/09/14Tracy Livingstone All Wales DNA/CPR Policy The story so far……….
Wellness in Mind Nottingham City Mental Health and Wellbeing Strategy Homelessness Strategy Group Nov 2014 Liz Pierce, Public Health, Nottingham City Council.
The PAN-Care Project Development and testing of a comprehensive care planning service to enable patients with end stage pancreatic cancer die at home Department.
MAST Safety (Domain 2) Clinical Effectiveness (Domain 3) Reinhard Prior, HIM, Berlin May 5, 2010.
Telecare knowledge network workshop: Evaluating telecare implementation The Safe at Home Evaluation in Northamptonshire Dr. John Woolham May 2007.
Hertfordshire Partnership NHS Foundation Trust Dementia: Palliative and End of Life (EoL) Care Is Everyone's Business Beke Tshuma Palliative and End of.
5 Ways to Health and Wellbeing Alison Paul Health Promotion Specialist.
The third international stroke trial (IST-3) effect of thrombolysis on outcomes at 18 months in 2348 patients in long-term follow- up cohort The IST3 collaborative.
Can an evidence based coaching intervention improve outcomes for older people with congestive heart failure (CHF) and their informal caregivers within.
LifeCIT Development and pilot evaluation of a web-supported programme of Constraint Induced Therapy following stroke (LifeCIT) Meagher C 1, Conlon A 2,
South Wales Cardiac Network Cardiac Rehabilitation Advisory Group Meeting Aneurin Bevan Local Health Board Cardiac Rehabilitation Service Suzanne Indge.
Insert name of presentation on Master Slide Annual Quality Framework Quality & Safety improvement Reporting.
Dementia NICE quality standard August What this presentation covers Background to quality standards Publication partners Dementia quality standard.
Aim: Describe how new health care professionals are deployed
Implementation of a lung health clinic in high-risk individuals in South East London: a prospective feasibility cohort study Background In 2013, lung cancer.
admissions in residents in care homes.
Integration, cooperation and partnerships
How to show your social value – reporting outcomes & impact
Evaluation of CT Coronary Angiography (CTCA) and Cardiac Magnetic Resonance (CMR) in patients presenting with Acute Chest Pain (ACP) at A&E Background.
THE HEALTHCARE SUPPORT WORKER
Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire McGill Pain Questionnaire
Clinical Knowledge Summaries CKS Heart failure - chronic
Dr Marcello Bertotti, Senior Research Fellow University of East London
Dr Daniel Anderson Consultant psychiatrist
LATEST RESEARCH JUNE 2015 Formed in 2009 the Aston Research Centre for
Development and feasibility testing of a complex intervention
The guiding principles of prudent healthcare
Gloucestershire End of Life Strategy
The DEPression in Visual Impairment Trial:
MUSIC THERAPY INTERVENTION
NICOR A NICE Commissioned Pilot of Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) for Ablation of Cardiac Arrhythmias Withers KL 1, Patrick H 2, Cunningham.
Dr Marcello Bertotti Senior Research Fellow
Starting out on a clinical academic pathway: the experience of a newly- qualified nurse Sarah Lea Faculty of Health and Social Care, London South Bank.
Dr. Thomas Richardson Clinical Psychologist (1,2)
A New Type of Worker: Developing the End of Life Carer
The authors have no competing interests to declare.
Introducing 1000 Lives Plus
BRIGHTLIGHT: from first glow to now – what, why and how
Amanda Lilley-Kelly Senior Trial Co-ordinator
Laura Donato [Mentor: Wendy Bjerke] College of Health Professions
Dr Linda Ross, BA, RGN, PhD, Reader, University of South Wales
1000 Lives Plus Update Andrew Cooper Monday 5 September 2011
Museums, health and wellbeing: Methodologies for measuring impact
Dr. Muhammad Ajmal Zahid Chairman, Department of Psychiatry,
Day 3 Psychosocial care, spirituality & bereavement
Nottinghamshire: the context
Big Mental Health Survey: Senedd Briefing
Dr. Maryam Tajvar Department of Health Management and Economics
Frailty: Calculating quality and cost
D1 How agencies work.
Introducing 1000 Lives Plus
Epidemiological Terms
2018 …………Linda Rendle.
To what extent do disease severity and illness perceptions explain depression, anxiety and quality of life in Hidradenitis Suppurativa Alicia Pavon Blanco,1.
Associate professor Mark Morgan Bond University
Measuring outcomes Emma Frew October 2012.
Social Care Research Martin Knapp
NHS LONG TERM PLAN.
Outcomes from social prescribing
Palliative and End of Life Care for patients with Dementia
Dementia: Barriers to accessing quality End of Life Care and Role of Admiral Nurses Chris O’Connor Consultant Admiral Nurse Dementia Fellow   
Implementing a carers assessment tool at Woking and Sam Beare Hospices
Presentation transcript:

Spiritual support in end stage heart failure (ESHF): a randomised controlled feasibility study  Linda Ross1, Jackie Austin2,Paul Jarvis1, Sara Pickett3  1School of Care Sciences, LSE, University of South Wales 2Cardiac Rehabilitation Services, Nevill Hall Hospital, Aneurin Bevan University Health Board (ABUHB) 3Swansea Centre for Health Economics, Swansea University This study was funded by the Nevill Hall Thrombosis & General Research Fund support (experimental group n=22). Spiritual support (average 1 hour discussion using a purpose designed Spiritual Enquiry Tool) was provided by trained volunteers in patients’ homes at 2 monthly intervals over 6 months (4 visits). Measures of study outcomes (WHO-SRPB, HAD, EQ5D) were completed at 0, 2, 4, 6 months by both groups. Analysis Descriptive statistics and Repeated Measures ANOVA to explore within and between group differences.   Selected Results with follow-on questions 1.No significant effect of spiritual support on spiritual wellbeing (SWB), anxiety/depression or quality of life (QOL) was found. The study was limited by its small sample size but the following trends were identified and are worthy of further exploration: -The control group showed a marked worsening in SWB (-1.7 points), anxiety (+0.8 points) and QOL (-8.0 points) between months 0 and 2, whilst the experimental group showed a marked improvement in QOL (+4.0 points) and anxiety (-1.2 points) at this time. Depression scores increased in experimental patients (+0.9) and decreased in control patients (-0.6) at the end of the study (months 4-6). Is there a group allocation effect? -SWB dropped by 4.8 points in patients reporting deterioration of symptoms between months 0-2, so is there a link between SWB and symptoms? 2. Recruitment and data collection took much longer than expected. We had estimated that 65 patients would be recruited over 9 months with data collection taking 15 months. In reality it took 18 months to recruit 47 patients and 2 years to collect the data, mainly because of high co-morbidity and mortality.  References 1 Koenig H, King D, Carson V (2012) Handbook of religion and health. OUP, New York 2 World Health Organisation (2002) WHOQOL-SRPB Field Test Instrument. WHO, Geneva 3 Department of Health (2009) Religion or belief. A practical guide for the NHS. London, Crown 4 Welsh Government (2015) Health and Care Standards. Crown 5 NICE (2004) Guidance on Cancer Service. Improving supportive and palliative care for adults with cancer. London, NICE 6 Ross L, Austin J (2013) Spiritual needs and support preferences of people with end stage heart failure and their carers. Journal of Nursing Management, 23, 1, 87-95 Background Evidence demonstrates a positive association between the spiritual part of life and mental (anxiety, depression, quality of life) and physical health1. Spiritual care is important, featuring within healthcare policy and guidance internationally2, nationally3 and locally4, especially at end of life5. There is evidence that people with ESHF experience significant spiritual needs (e.g. for hope and to make sense of their illness, life and the future including their death and what may lie beyond) alongside the physical and emotional challenges of their illness, and that spiritual support would be valued6. Further research is needed to determine if spiritual support enhances spiritual wellbeing and quality of life and mitigates against depression and anxiety in ESHF, but information is needed to inform the design of such a study.   Overall Aim To carry out a feasibility study to inform the design of a future RCT to investigate the effects of spiritual support on spiritual wellbeing, anxiety, depression and quality of life in end-stage heart failure patients (NYHA IV/V) . Research Questions: 1. What is the effect of spiritual support on spiritual wellbeing (WHO-SRPB), anxiety/depression (HAD), and health related quality of life (EQ5D)? 2. What is the likely effect size of the WHO SRPB Tool measuring Spiritual Wellbeing2 (to inform power calculation)? 3. What is the cost of delivering the intervention (NHS Resource Use Questionnaire)? 4. What is the likely uptake/drop-out rate in patients (to inform sample size and power calculations)? 5. How much time is needed to deliver the intervention and to collect data? Method Prospective random allocation over 18 months of all consenting eligible end-stage heart failure patients in ABUHB (n=47 from possible 270) to receive standard care only (control group n=25) or standard care plus spiritual