More Reasons Why Customers (the Small and Mid-Sized are Joining the Largest) are Adopting a Terms Push Back Strategy and What Suppliers Can Do to Fight.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Working Capital Management
Advertisements

The Operating Cycle and Merchandising Operations 6.
© 2003 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Limited 8 8 Chapter Sources of Short-Term Financing McGraw-Hill Ryerson©2003 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Limited Prepared by: Terry.
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING A USER PERSPECTIVE Hoskin Fizzell Davidson Second Canadian Edition.
ACCOUNTING FOR MERCHANDISING OPERATIONS
Short-Term Financial Management
Accounting for Purchases and Cash Payments. Buy goods from supplier Sell merchandise to consumer.
CHAPTER 23 Consumer Finance Operations. Chapter Objectives n Identify the main sources and uses of finance company funds n Describe the risk exposure.
MSE608C – Engineering and Financial Cost Analysis
A.T. Kearney 82/ Supply Chain Financing Dr. Dale S. Rogers Nevada Logistics Institute Reno, NV 13 August 2015 Dr. Dale S. Rogers Nevada Logistics.
18 Management of Accounts Receivable and Inventories ©2006 Thomson/South-Western.
Needles Powers Principles of Financial Accounting 12e Accounting for Merchandising Operations 6 C H A P T E R ©human/iStockphoto.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western Chapter 23 Short-Term Financial Management Professor XXXXX Course Name / Number.
CDA COLLEGE BUS235: PRINCIPLES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS Lecture 10 Lecture 10 Lecturer: Kleanthis Zisimos.
Inventories. Learning Objectives 1. Identify the differences between a service business and a merchandising business. 2. Explain the recording of purchases.
Analyzing Financial Statements
Copyright © 2014 Nelson Education Ltd. 6–1 PowerPoint Presentations for Finance for Non-Financial Managers: Seventh Edition Prepared by Pierre Bergeron.
Copyright ©2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning Chapter 17 Management of Accounts Receivable and Inventories.
CHAPTER 7 Managing Supplier Financing. Use of Supplier Financing  Accounts Payable:  Refers to buyers use of supplier financing to purchase inputs needed.
Cash Preservation Cash Management: Is How A Business Survives!
Chapter 12 Accounting for Receivables. 2 Receivables... Amounts due from individuals and companies - expected to be collected in cash. Frequently classified.
Chapter 2 Analysis of Working Capital Cycle Order Order Sale Cash Placed Received Received Accounts Collection Accounts Collection Accounts Disbursement.
College lesson five credit cards presentation slides 04/09.
Chapter 4 Completing the Accounting Cycle
Principles of Management
More Reasons Why Customers (the Small and Mid-Sized are Joining the Largest) are Adopting a Terms Push Back Strategy and What Suppliers Can Do to Fight.
Short-Term Finance and Planning
5 Accounting for Merchandising Operations Learning Objectives
Managing the Firm’s Assets
Retailer Presentation
merchandising operations
Working Capital Management
Chapter 2 Analysis of Working Capital Cycle
CHAPTER TEN Liquidity And Reserve Management: Strategies And Policies
Supply Chain Logistics: management of the flow of things between the point of origin and the point of consumption to meet requirements of customers or.
Financial Statement Analysis
Types of Receivables Amounts due from individuals and other companies that are expected to be collected in cash. Amounts due from customers resulting from.
SELLING TO THE SMALL AND MEDIUM SIZED BUSINESS: CREDIT, FINANCIAL AND LEGAL ISSUES FOR THE CREDIT TEAM Scott Blakeley, Esq. Susan.
Chain of production and channels of distribution
5 Accounting for Merchandising Operations
Ch. 17: Working Capital Management
The Supply Chain Finance Solution
EXPORT FINANCING OVERVIEW
Accounting, Fifth Edition
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Working Capital Management
Working Capital Management
Sports and Entertainment Marketing
CREDIT and its importance.
Chapter 16 Financial Management and Securities Markets.
Teens lesson eight credit cards presentation slides 04/09.
CHAPTER TEN Liquidity And Reserve Management: Strategies And Policies
Accpick was launched in 1988 …
Accounts Receivable and Inventory Management
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Teens lesson eight credit cards presentation slides 04/09.
Text A The future of e-business
LESSON 9-4 Accounting for Cash Payments
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Certified General Accountants
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Teens lesson eight credit cards presentation slides 04/09.
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Teens lesson eight credit cards presentation slides 04/09.
Ch. 16: Short-Term Financial Planning
Strategies and Insights to Control your Business
Copyright © 1999 Addison Wesley Longman
Financial Statement Analysis
Foundation Concepts. Working Capital Management Supply Chain Financing and Dynamic Discounting.
Presentation transcript:

More Reasons Why Customers (the Small and Mid-Sized are Joining the Largest) are Adopting a Terms Push Back Strategy and What Suppliers Can Do to Fight Back Frank Sebastian Director of AR, Credit and Collections Frank.Sebastian@adidas-group.com Larry Lipschutz, CCE Director of Credit & Collections llipschutz@frenchgerleman.com Scott E. Blakeley, Esq seb@blakeleyllp.com

The Supply Chain and Trade Credit Trade credit as driver of the economy Less expensive than external financing The origin of TPS: Credit crunch of 2008 Large companies sitting on record cash holdings but increasing the days to pay suppliers Customers stretching supplier terms to preserve cash and fill working capital gaps Inventory purchases are biggest cash drains Customers extending payables has become a best practice

The Supply Chain and Trade Credit Source: Credit Research Foundation

A Customer’s Request vs A Customer’s Request vs. Demand for Extended Terms: How Indispensable is the Customer (and the Supplier)? The Voice of the Supplier’s Credit, Sales and Management Teams.

The Supply Chain and Trade Credit Customer strategy for extending supplier terms Financially sound customer Financially struggling customer Re-credit score and supplier due diligence Formal vs. ad hoc TPS Accommodative vs. Punitive The small to medium sized customer vs. the large customer

Key Terms for Large Company TPS Cash Conversion Cycle(CCC)- Number of days to convert account receivables into cash flow. Days Payables Outstanding(DPO)- Number of days payables outstanding relative to purchases of inventory (cost of goods sold) Days Sales Outstanding(DSO)- Sales per day relative to average receivables Days Inventory Outstanding(DIO)- Cost of goods sold per day relative to average inventory levels

The Supply Chain and Trade Credit Added Reasons Customers are Rolling Out TPS Benchmarking: Customer’s Competitors Forcing TPS Customer Mergers Supply Chain Financing Moves Downstream The Press and the Cottage Industry of Consultants International Influence

PAYMENT TERMS AND SUPPLY CHAIN FINANCING COSTS COST OF CARRYING A/R   Ending A/R Annual Borrowing rate Daily cost of borrowing - Annual Rate / 360 Daily cost of carrying the A/R (Daily Rate x AR Amt) Example 20,000,000 4% 0.011111 % 2,222.22 Line #   New Terms Former Terms SCF Terms, Option 1 SCF Terms, Option 2 2% 10, N30 Formula 1 Invoice Amount 500,000 2 Payment Terms 75 30 15 10 For SCF, Days until Supplier Bank partner pays 3 Discount Amount 0% 2% Cash Discount for Early Pay 4 Suppliers Interest Rate 4% Either borrowing rate or Internal Rate of Return 5 Daily Rate 0.011111% Line 4 / 360 6 SCF Rate n/a 3.25% Supplier's Bank Interest Rate for Vendors 7 Daily SCF Rate - 0.009028% Line 6 / 360 8 Days Carried Same as Payment terms, Line 2 9 Suppliers Carrying Cost 4,167 1,667 833 556 Line 5 x Line 8 x Line 1 Days Financed 60 45 For SCF, New Terms (75) - Line 2 11 Finance Charge (Discount) 2,708 2,031 Line 7 x Line 10 x Line 1 12 Cash Discount 10,000 Line 3 x Line 1 13 Payment 497,292 497,969 490,000 Line 1 - Line 9 (or Line 10, for discount terms) 14 Net Payment 495,833 498,333 496,458 496,302 489,444 Line 13 - Line 9 Effective Discount 0.830% 0.333% 0.708% 0.740% 2.111% (Line 1 - Line 14)/ Inv. Amount PAYMENT TERMS AND SUPPLY CHAIN FINANCING COSTS

Government Response to TPS U.S. Supplier Pay Voluntary program aimed at larger companies – no maximum number of days to pay. Rather, these companies sign a pledge to reduce their DPO with smaller suppliers European Union (EU) Countries EU has adopted legislation for EU countries to have companies sign up for a supplier Prompt Pay Rule (PPR)

Credit Team’s Form Response to TPS 8677 Logo Athletic Court Indianapolis, Indiana 46219 T +317.895.7000

Supplier Strategy for Dealing with TPS

Supplier Strategy for Dealing with TPS Contract Controls

Supplier Strategy for Dealing with TPS

U.S. Public Companies with Industry Leading DPO’s Exhibit A Company Industry Rank, Avg. DPO in Latest Quarter vs. Industry Peers Historical Performance Rank, Avg. DPO in Latest Quarter vs. Co.’s Last 12 Quarters Primary Industry Pitney Bowes 99 100 Office Services and Supplies Arena Pharmaceuticals Biotechnology ITC Holding 85 Electric Utilities Expedia 92 Internet, Retail Goodrich Petroleum 97 89 Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Advance Auto Parts 96 Automotive Retail Cheniere Energy Partners Oil and Gas Storage and Transportation O’Reilly Automotive 95 Sotheby’s 94 Specialized Consumer Services MarkWest Energy Partners Cheniere Energy Edwards Lifesciences Healthcare Equipment South Jersey Industries 91 Gas Utilities Barnes & Noble Specialty Stores SemGroup 88 j2 Global 87 Internet Software and Services Xilinx 86 Semiconductors Informatica 84 Application Software Best Buy Computer and Electronics Retail Pioneer Natural Gas Resources Molycorp 83 Diversified Metals and Mining Dell Computer Hardware Waters 82 Life Science Tools and Services Actavis Pharmaceuticals Carrizo Oil & Gas 81 Coty 80 Personal Products Universal Health Services Healthcare Facilities U.S. Public Companies with Industry Leading DPO’s

Meet the Competition Form Exhibit B [Customer’s Letterhead] Dear [Vendor (your company)], This letter confirms that [Competitor] has offered us a sales arrangement for extended terms which includes: Product/Service involved:______________________________________ Terms of payment:____________________________________________ Date of offer:________________________________________________ Quantity of product/service involved:_____________________________ This information is provided to allow [Supplier] to meet the offer of [Competitor].   Sincerely, [Customer] Meet the Competition Form

Trends in Extended Terms Survey What is your firms annual sales revenue? In the last 12 months, how many existing customers requested extended payment terms beyond standard? What is generally your first action? Is there a formal policy to address these? Is the Robinson Patman Act considered? What are the driving factors that lead to accepting these? What percentage offered a Supplier Financing Option as a means to discount invoices before payment terms maturity? How does your team view the recent increase in these types of requests and the effect on working capital? When you accept requests, do you charge interest for additional carrying costs or charge back discount fees incurred from SFO? Have you lost business/revenue after refusing a request? Do you think a company’s brand strength/recognition/size can help refusing these requests without loss of revenue? Do you believe stronger legislation should be passed to protect smaller regional suppliers with lower brand recognition, against larger companies demanding extensive credit terms?