Critical raw materials and their link to the EU & Global Challenges Mark Mistry Nickel Institute Working Session on Critical Raw Materials Brussels 24th September 2013

Critical Raw Materials for future of EU (2010) 1.0079 H Hydrogen 2 4.0026 He Helium 3 6.941 Li Lithium 49 114.82 In Indium 31 69.723 Ga Gallium 74 183.84 W Tungsten 44 101.07 Ru Ruthenium 41 92.906 Nb Niobium 78 195.08 Ta Tantalum 39 88.906 Y Yttrium 21 44.956 Sc Scandium 71 174.97 Lu Lutetium 70 173.05 Yb Ytterbium 69 168.93 Tm Thulium 68 167.26 Er Erbium 67 (164.93 Ho Holmium 66 162.50 Dy Dysprosium 65 158.93 Tb Terbium 57 138.91 La Lanthan 64 157.25 Gd Gadolinium 63 151.96 Eu Europium 62 150.36 Sm Samarium 61 (145) Pm Promethium 60 144.24 Nd Neodym 59 140.91 Pr Praesodym 58 140.12 Ce Cer 51 121.76 Sb Antimony 45 102.91 Rh Rhodium 27 58.933 Co Cobalt 77 192.22 Ir Iridium 46 106.42 Pd Palladium Pt Platinum 76 190.23 Os Osmium 4 9.0122 Be Beryllium 12 24.035 Mg Magnesium 4 9.0122 Be Beryllium 4 9.0122 Be Beryllium 5 10.811 B Boron 6 12.011 C Carbon 7 14.007 N Nitrogen 8 15,999 O Oxygen 9 18.998 F Fluor 10 20.180 Ne Neon + Graphite + Fluorspar 11 22.290 Na Sodium 12 24.035 Mg Magnesium 12 24.035 Mg Magnesium 13 26.982 Al Aluminium 13 26.982 Al Aluminium 14 28.086 Si Silicon 15 30.974 P Phosphorus 16 32.065 S Sulphur 17 35.453 Cl Chlor 18 39.948 Ar Argon 19 39.098 K Potassium 21 40.078 Ca Calcium 21 44.956 Sc Scandium 22 47.867 Ti Titanium 23 50.942 V Vanadium 23 50.942 V Vanadium 24 51.996 Cr Chromium 25 54.938 Mn Manganese 25 54.938 Mn Manganese 26 55.845 Fe Iron 27 58.933 Co Cobalt 27 58.933 Co Cobalt 28 58.693 Ni Nickel 28 58.693 Ni Nickel 29 63.546 Cu Copper 29 63.546 Cu Copper 30 65.38 Zn Zinc 30 65.38 Zn Zinc 31 69.723 Ga Gallium 32 72,64 Ge Germanium 33 74.922 As Arsenic 33 74.922 As Arsenic 34 78.96 Se Selenium 34 78.96 Se Selenium 35 79.94 Br Bromium 36 83.798 Kr Krypton 37 85.468 Rb Rubidium 38 87.62 Sr Strontium 39 88.906 Y Yttrium 40 91.224 Zr Zirconium 41 92.906 Nb Niobium 42 95.94 Mo Molybdenum 42 95.94 Mo Molybdenum 43 (98) Tc Technetium 44 101.07 Ru Ruthenium 45 102.91 Rh Rhodium 45 102.91 Rh Rhodium 46 106.42 Pd Palladium 46 106.42 Pd Palladium 47 107.87 Ag Silver 47 107.87 Ag Silver 48 112.41 Cd Cadmium 48 112.41 Cd Cadmium 49 114.82 In Indium 50 118.71 Sn Tin 50 118.71 Sn Tin 51 121.76 Sb Antimony 51 121.76 Sb Antimony 52 127,60 Te Tellurium 52 127,60 Te Tellurium 53 126.90 I Iodine 54 131.29 Xe Xenon 55 132.91 Cs Caesium 556 137.33 Ba Barium 57-71 La-Lu Lanthanides 72 178.49 Hf Hafnium 78 195.08 Ta Tantalum 74 183.84 W Tungsten 75 186.21 Re Rhenium 75 186.21 Re Rhenium 76 190.23 Os Osmium 76 190.23 Os Osmium 77 192.22 Ir Iridium 77 192.22 Ir Iridium 78 195.08 Pt Platinum 78 195.08 Pt Platinum 79 196.97 Au Gold 79 196.97 Au Gold 80 200.59 Hg Mercury 81 204.38 Tl Thallium 82 207.2 Pb Lead 82 207.2 Pb Lead 83 208.98 Bi Bismuth 83 208.98 Bi Bismuth 84 (209) Po Polonium 85 (210) At Astatine 86 (222) Rn Radon 87 (223) Fr Francium 88 (226) Ra Radium 89-103 Ac-Lr Actinides 104 (267) Rf Rutherfordium 110 (281) Db Dubnium 106 (271) Sg Seaborgium 107 (272) Bh Bohrium 108 (277) Hs Hassium 109 (276) Mt Meitnerium 110 (281) Uun Ununnilium 111 (280) Uuu Ununnunium 112 (285) Uub Ununbium 114 (289) Uuq Ununquadum 57 138.91 La Lanthan 58 140.12 Ce Cer 59 140.91 Pr Praesodym 60 144.24 Nd Neodym 61 (145) Pm Promethium 62 150.36 Sm Samarium 63 151.96 Eu Europium 64 157.25 Gd Gadolinium 65 158.93 Tb Terbium 66 162.50 Dy Dysprosium 67 (164.93 Ho Holmium 68 167.26 Er Erbium 69 168.93 Tm Thulium 70 173.05 Yb Ytterbium 71 174.97 Lu Lutetium 89 (227) Ac Actinium 90 232.04 Th Thorium 91 231.04 Pa Proactinium 92 238.03 U Uranium 93 ((237)) Np Neptunium 94 (244) Pu Plutonium 95 (243) Am Americium 96 (247) Cm Curium 97 (247) Bk Berkelium 98 (251) Cf Californium 99 (252) Es Einsteinium 100 (257) Fm Fermium 101 (258) Md Mendelevium 102 (259) No Nobelium 103 (262) Lr Lawrencium Out of 41 investigated substances, there are 14 elements & element groups & substances with high economic importance & high supply risk

Critical Raw Materials for future of EU (2013 draft) 49 114.82 In Indium 5 10.811 B Boron 13 26.982 Al Aluminium 31 69.723 Ga Gallium 81 204.38 Tl Thallium 52 127,60 Te Tellurium 84 (209) Po Polonium 51 121.76 Sb Antimony 33 74.922 As Arsenic 83 208.98 Bi Bismuth 50 118.71 Sn Tin 14 28.086 Si Silicon 32 72,64 Ge Germanium 82 207.2 Pb Lead 47 107.87 Ag Silver 29 63.546 Cu Copper 79 196.97 Au Gold 111 (280) Uuu Ununnunium 48 112.41 Cd Cadmium 30 65.38 Zn Zinc 80 200.59 Hg Mercury 114 (289) Uuq Ununquadum 3 6.941 Li Lithium 1 1.0079 H Hydrogen 11 22.290 Na Sodium 87 (223) Fr Francium 45 102.91 Rh Rhodium 27 58.933 Co Cobalt 77 192.22 Ir Iridium 109 (276) Mt Meitnerium 46 106.42 Pd Palladium 28 58.693 Ni Nickel 78 195.08 Pt Platinum 110 (281) Uun Ununnilium 42 95.94 Mo Molybdenum 24 51.996 Cr Chromium 74 183.84 W Tungsten 106 (271) Sg Seaborgium 43 (98) Tc Technetium 25 54.938 Mn Manganese 75 186.21 Re Rhenium 107 (272) Bh Bohrium 44 101.07 Ru Ruthenium 26 55.845 Fe Iron 76 190.23 Os Osmium 108 (277) Hs Hassium 41 92.906 Nb Niobium 23 50.942 V Vanadium Ta Tantalum Db Dubnium 112 (285) Uub Ununbium 40 91.224 Zr Zirconium 22 47.867 Ti Titanium 72 178.49 Hf Hafnium 104 (267) Rf Rutherfordium 39 88.906 Y Yttrium 21 44.956 Sc Scandium 57-71 La-Lu Lanthanides 103 (262) Lr Lawrencium 4 9.0122 Be Beryllium 40.078 Ca Calcium 12 24.035 Mg Magnesium 88 (226) Ra Radium 37 85.468 Rb Rubidium 19 39.098 K Potassium 55 132.91 Cs Caesium 38 87.62 Sr Strontium 556 137.33 Ba Barium 89-103 Ac-Lr Actinides 102 (259) No Nobelium 101 (258) Md Mendelevium 100 (257) Fm Fermium 99 (252) Es Einsteinium 98 (251) Cf Californium 97 (247) Bk Berkelium 89 (227) Ac Actinium 96 Cm Curium 95 (243) Am Americium 94 (244) Pu Plutonium 93 ((237)) Np Neptunium 92 238.03 U Uranium 91 231.04 Pa Proactinium 90 232.04 Th Thorium 71 174.97 Lu Lutetium 70 173.05 Yb Ytterbium 69 168.93 Tm Thulium 68 167.26 Er Erbium 67 (164.93 Ho Holmium 66 162.50 Dy Dysprosium 65 158.93 Tb Terbium 57 138.91 La Lanthan 64 157.25 Gd Gadolinium 63 151.96 Eu Europium 62 150.36 Sm Samarium 61 (145) Pm Promethium 60 144.24 Nd Neodym 59 140.91 Pr Praesodym 58 140.12 Ce Cer 2 4.0026 He Helium 54 131.29 Xe Xenon 10 20.180 Ne Neon 18 39.948 Ar Argon 36 83.798 Kr Krypton 86 (222) Rn Radon 53 126.90 I Iodine 9 18.998 F Fluor 17 35.453 Cl Chlor 35 79.94 Br Bromium 85 (210) At Astatine 8 15,999 O Oxygen 16 32.065 S Sulphur 34 78.96 Se Selenium 7 14.007 N Nitrogen 15 30.974 P Phosphorus 6 12.011 C Carbon + Natural Graphite + Fluorspar + Phosphate Rocks + Magnesite + Borates + Coking Coal Out of 52 investigated substances, there are 20 elements & element groups & substances with high economic importance & high supply risk

Is Nickel a critical raw material? PGM Nickel is not a “critical” raw material. But it is a host metal of critical raw materials occurring as by-products. This applies to many metals!

Criticality and raw materials Number of critical raw materials changes Close link between raw materials Challenging & misleading to limit measures to few raw materials Importance of & inter-linkages between all raw materials need to be recognized independent from status

2050 Global Challenges Ageing Society Food Energy supply Transport Population Growth Water Accomodation

All megatrends linked to significant raw materials demand 2050 Global Challenges Implications Access to (clean) water Safe & clean energy supply More & better food Accomodate >9 billion people Ensure Green transport Accomodate ageing society All megatrends linked to significant raw materials demand Raw materials demand linked to megatrends will affect criticality of raw materials

2050 EU vs. Global Challenges Priorities differ: Main population growth in Asia and Africa, outside EU Global scale Water Food Accomodation Energy supply Transport European Commission Flagship Initiatives be resource & energy efficient Promote innovation Ensure sustainable growth Be smart EU scale Energy supply Ageing society Green transport Water Food

Example: Energy & raw materials demand International Energy Agency Statistics online (2009) Different scenarios to address challenges around energy supply and climate change

Example: Energy & raw materials demand Publication of Leiden University investigated raw material demand linked to low carbon economy Various technologies were investigated Conclusion: demand of various base metals will significantly increase or multiply Kleijn et al: Metal requirements of low carbon power generation In: Energy (2011) Addressing global challenges will result in a significant raw materials demand and affect criticality of raw materials

Can improved recycling satisfy the increasing raw materials demand? Recycling for certain raw materials shows potential for improvement (e.g. REE) For many metals the recycling efficiencies are already high (Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Al, Pb...) Recycling is important but cannot satify the enormous raw materials demand Improving Recycling goes hand in hand with primary production but cannot replace it

Supply with raw materials is hampered by factors not being acknowledged in Criticality assessment Precautionary Principle Precautionary Principle EU Environmental legislation EU Chemicals Management Legislation EU value chains with high economic importance & relevance in addressing challenges EU Regulatory framework creates problems in satisfying raw materials demand of critical value chains

Raw materials supply: planning security is a key aspect Raw materials demand will increase in order to address global challenges Primary & secondary production will be needed Satisfying the demand requires significant long term investment Investment can only be taken if there is planning security Companies need to have planning security to invest into raw materials supply and to consequently satisfy demand

Our r Raw materials demand will increase in order to address global challenges Primary & secondary production will be needed Satisfying the demand requires significant long term investment Investment can only be taken if there is planning security Companies need to have planning security to invest into raw materials supply and to consequently satisfy demand

Our r Raw materials demand will increase in order to address global challenges Primary & secondary production will be needed Satisfying the demand requires significant long term investment Investment can only be taken if there is planning security Companies need to have planning security to invest into raw materials supply and to consequently satisfy demand