Welcome. We are organizing initially by commentary authors

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Disproportionality in Special Education
Advertisements

A system of laws, policies, and practices that pushes students out of schools and into the juvenile and criminal systems An over-reliance on school.
ETHICS In Field Of Dental Hygiene BY Dr. Shahzadi Tayyaba Hashmi.
Andreal Davis, Kent Smith Wisconsin RtI Center/PBIS Network Exemplar presenters: Jessica Grandt-Turk, Lindsey Krueger Harrison Elementary School, Janesville,
Policing Juveniles Police typically encounter juveniles when responding to a call. Police try to treat minors with least restrictive alternative unless.
Ethical Considerations in Behavior Analysis and Autism Intervention Christine M. Holland, MS BCBA
1 Manifestation Determination. 2 Today’s Goals and Objectives…. Define Manifestation Determination Discuss when to complete a Manifestation Determination.
Analyzing National Board Standards Workshop #3 CERRA National Board Candidate Support Workshop Toolkit WS
ETHICS IN FIELD OF DENTAL HYGIENE Dr. Shahzadi Tayyaba Hashmi
Essential Questions How can the law impact our lives today? How do court decisions impact our lives today? What are the constitutional principles behind.
Ethical Justice HOW YOU DECIDE MAKES A DIFFERENCE 1 Texas Juvenile Justice Department Juvenile Justice Training Academy Metric Blvd., Bldg. H, Suite.
School Discipline Communication Plan Kierstyn Johnson ADMS 626 Summer 2015.
Semester Discipline Data Data Source: District Online Discipline System December 15,
Organizing Your Legal Analysis
Superintendents’ Network Welcome! Apprentice Facilitators And Coaches.
CIS 170 MART Teaching Effectively/cis170mart.com FOR MORE CLASSES VISIT HSM 210 GENIUS Inspiring Minds/hsm210genius.com FOR MORE CLASSES.
HSM 230 Entire Course HSM 230 Week 1 Assignment Ethics and Law Presentation  HSM 230 Week 1 Assignment Ethics and Law Presentation  HSM 230 Week 1 CheckPoint.
Unit 2 Consolidation Day Discuss/clarify upcoming writing assignments Answering a Case: Taking a Stand.
University of California, Irvine, School of Education
R.A.C.C.E. Radical Advocates for Cross Cultural Education
Youth Criminal Justice Act
CSCE 390 Professional Issues in Computer Science and Engineering Ch
FD Supporting Teaching and Learning
Breaking the School to Prison Pipeline
Equality and diversity – session 2
Name of my project My Name Silver Spring International Middle School
CSCE 390 Professional Issues in Computer Science and Engineering Ch
PROJECT LEGAL TIPS PROGRAM DR. JAMES CARROLL, DIRECTOR
Rational Perspectives on Decision Making Keys to Decision Making
Critical Theory or Literary Criticism
Principles of Health Care Ethics
Steps for solving problems in your community!
Hammurabi’s Code Was it just?.
Organizational Effectiveness
U.b.c. personal profile Produced by Ms D. Rose Queen Elizabeth Secondary Career Centre 2016/2017.
CJA 394 Competitive Success/snaptutorial.com
CJA 394 Enthusiastic Study/snaptutorial.com
CJA 394Competitive Success/tutorialrank.com
CJA 394 GUIDE Education Your Life-- cja394guide.com.
CJA 394 GUIDE Lessons in Excellence-- cja394guide.com.
CJA 394 Education for Service-- tutorialrank.com.
CJA 394 Education for Service/snaptutorial.com
CJA 394 GUIDE Education for Service-- cja394guide.com.
CJA 394 Teaching Effectively-- snaptutorial.com
Setting Actuarial Standards
Sexual Orientation in Education
The Framework for Teaching
Promote Children and Young People’s Positive Behaviour
Racial Disparities in Discipline Practices
Youth Criminal Justice Act
Chapter One Crime and Criminology
Methods of Legal Inquiry Writing a Legal Case Brief
#RETHINKDISCIPLINE 401 South Queen Street
Positionality: Using Self-Discovery to Enhance Pre-Service Teachers’
The HTS Law School Guide to
Preparing a Case Brief.
NAVIGATING SYSTEMS CHANGE
The Double Standard of Juvenile Justice
Chapter 8 Developing an Effective Ethics Program
Gwinnett Parent Coalition to Dismantle the School to Prison Pipeline
Consolidated district performance report (CDPR)
Crime and the Law The Prison System in Scotland
Parent-Teacher Partnerships for Student Success
Eloise Forster, Ed.D. Foundation for Educational Administration (FEA)
Applied Software Project Management
VIRGINIA BOARD OF EDUCATION Model Guidance for Positive and Preventive Code of Student Conduct Policy and Alternatives to Suspension
Steps for solving problems in your community!
Ethical, Professional and Legal Issues in Groups
Steps for solving problems in your community!
Unit 5: Working with Parents and Others in Early Years
Presentation transcript:

Welcome. We are organizing initially by commentary authors Welcome! We are organizing initially by commentary authors. Please choose the author group you’d like to start in.

Goals Identify, compare, and analyze various ethical, empirical, and practical considerations relevant to the Cell Phone Case. Draw upon these considerations to discuss the distinctions and intersections between educational injustice and other forms of social injustice. Evaluate the relevance of particular ethical, empirical, and practical considerations of educational and social injustice to specific agents/roles.

Agenda Written Reflection Abena: Mini-lecture on STPP Commentary Author small group discussions Jigsaw and Category Sorts Debrief/Ending Reflection

Written Reflection (private) Describe an experience in which you observed educational injustice and social justice intersect. What was the outcome? How did you feel? This might be an experience you observed in your work as a practitioner, as a student, as a parent, or as a community member.

What do we mean when we say “school to prison pipeline”?

What is the phenomenon that we are trying to explain? “For many young people, our schools are increasingly a gateway to the criminal justice system. This phenomenon is a consequence of a culture of zero tolerance that is widespread in our schools and is depriving many children of their fundamental right to an education.” Sen. Richard “Dick” Durbin D-Ill Source: (Elias, 2013, p. 39).

What evidence suggests that schools may be “gateways to the criminal justice system”? There are strong and persistent correlations between school outcomes and juvenile justice system contact. Rates of re-enrollment after contact with the juvenile justice system are estimated between 25-33% in one city. Source: (Wald & Losen 2003; Redfield & Nance, 2016).

What is the phenomenon that we are trying to explain? “For many young people, our schools are increasingly a gateway to the criminal justice system. This phenomenon is a consequence of a culture of zero tolerance that is widespread in our schools and is depriving many children of their fundamental right to an education.” Sen. Richard “Dick” Durbin D-Ill Source: (Elias, 2013, p. 39).

What policies are attributed to the “culture of zero tolerance”? School discipline policies that set mandatory consequences for violations of school rules. Increased presence of police in schools. Adoption of laws mandating referral of children to law enforcement authorities for a variety of school code violations. Source: (Wald & Losen, 2003).

Which students are most impacted by these policies? Black students are 3.3 times more likely to be suspended or expelled than their White counterparts.* Latino students are nearly twice as likely be suspended or expelled than their White counterparts.* Students with disabilities are 3.6 times more likely to suspended than other students in elementary school and 2.2 times higher in middle and high school. *These patterns hold for both male and female students, though disparities are somewhat attenuated between female students. Source: (Redfield &Nance, 2016).

Implicit biases influence discretionary decisions. What are the practices associated with schools being “gateways to the criminal justice system”? Schools serving students who are Black, Latino, or have a disability tends to have: Harsher disciplinary consequences. Lower expectations. Inexperienced or out-of-license teachers. High rates of retention. Restrictive special education programs. Implicit biases influence discretionary decisions. Source: (Wald & Losen 2003; Redfield & Nance, 2016).

What are the limits of a “pipeline”? Some suggest that the pipeline metaphor illuminates systemic processes, but hides individual actions. Rather than a pipeline, a bundle of risk factors? How does resilience fit in?

Commentator Groups What ethical, empirical, and/or practical considerations does your commentator raise in discussing the cell phone case? Record each consideration on a separate sticky Each member of your group should have a complete set of stickies to take with them for the next exercise

Jigsaw Group Task 1 Each group member shares the ethical, empirical, and practical considerations raised by their commentator What considerations were not raised by any commentator? What else needs to be taken into consideration in the cell phone case? Record these on new stickies—again, one consideration per sticky.

Jigsaw Group Task 2 As a group, come up with a new scheme to organize these considerations (i.e. no longer by author/source). What is the logic behind this new set of categories or organizational approach? Choose someone to explain it quickly to the class in a whip-around.

Jigsaw Group Task 3 Reorganize considerations by relevance to: Ms. Smith Mr. Jackson Other(s) (who?) Why did you make the choices you did? Choose someone new to explain it quickly to the class in a whip-around.

Debrief How do school-based versus non-school-based sources of injustice intersect in this case, in light of the various considerations at play? What principles and practices should guide educators and policy makers in responding to multiple sources and forms of injustice? To what extent, if at all, should educators/schools be responsible for addressing or ameliorating social injustices that arise from outside schools?

Reflection What are the ethical, empirical, and practical considerations relevant to the experience you wrote about at the beginning of class? What are the values and principles that guided the decision makers in your case? What are the values and principles that should guide decision-makers?