A New Operating Paradigm

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Booz Allen Hamilton Leading strategy and technology consulting firm
Advertisements

Airline Cost Categorization. Administrative vs. Functional Cost Categories One approach to airline cost categorization makes use of administrative cost.
Operations Management
SYST 660 Airline Operating Costs and Airline Productivity
M I T I n t e r n a t i o n a l C e n t e r f o r A i r T r a n s p o r t a t i o n Impact of Air Transportation on Regional Economic and Social Connectivity.
CABI TOURISM TEXTS Introduction to Tourism Transport SVEN GROSS LOUISA KLEMMER COMPLIMENTARY TEACHING MATERIALS CABI TOURISM TEXTS Introduction to Tourism.
STRATEGIC CHECK FOR AIRLINES Avconet in cooperation with Strategic Partners.
Business-Level Strategy: How do we compete? Business-Level Strategy: How do we compete?
The Strategy of International Business
Industry and Competitive Analysis
Strategic Planning and the Marketing Management Process
Air Transportation A Management Perspective
Low Cost Carriers within an Evolving Industry - Growth and Challenge With special thanks to: Raymond James and Associates, Inc. (RJ&A) and GCW Consulting.
The Strategy of International Business
Textbook Reviews By Aj.Weerawit Lertthaitrakul Logistics & Supply chain management Business Administration Air Transportation A Management Perspective.
JetBlue Cost and Productivity Analysis Greg Koch HW for OR 750.
Continental Airlines: The Competitive Arena
United Airlines Cost and Productivity Analysis Nahid Boustani Spring 2013.
Small Community Service Prospects Faye Malarkey Regional Airline Association Federal Aviation Administration 30th Annual Aviation Forecast Conference March.
Continental Airlines Customer Analysis
Airline Operating Costs & Airline Productivity - US Airways - Seungwon Noh (Apr )
Route Planning and Evaluation
Innovation & Cost Leadership, 15. November © 1 Innovation & Cost Leadership Wolfgang Kurth 15. November 2004.
EATS 2007 Maintenance Conference Aviation Maintenance Market Outlook Berlin October 17, © All rights reserved. VZM Management Services.
1-1 Strategic Planning and the Marketing Management Process Chapter 1 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights.
Transport in Europe The search for mobility. Importance of transport in Europe 1 million transport-related enterprises Over 7million jobs Value-added.
European Low Fares Airlines Association European Low Fares Airline Association Low fares airlines: business model and impact on regional airports John.
The Strategy of International Business
IAS Financial results Efficiency increase in 2002.
Introduction to Network Planning Concepts and Practice Course Outline Dynaston Inc.
TEAM 1 – Airbus AXX Future of Air Transportation and Possible Air Response.
By: Nan Shellabarger Date: February 28, 2006 Federal Aviation Administration FAA Forecast.
Airline Deregulation and Airline Economics. Airports you have known?
Route and Network Planning
BPSM Types of Strategies. Classification of Strategies Once a company completes its mission formulation, environment scan & internal appraisal, it has.
Value of a Nonstop William Swan Chief Economist Boeing Commercial Airplanes Marketing April 2004.
01/07/05, Titel © 1 Low Fare Model: How basic should it be? LARA: The Low Fare and Regional Aviation Summit Wolfgang Kurth London, 08.
COMPANY PRESENTATION May 2016 Confident for Growth.
Why Hubs Work Revenue Benefits for Hubbing Spring 2005 Research Working Paper.
Yinuo Zhu.
Biography for William Swan
Milano-Malpensa Airport
MSP: Outcomes of the Delta / Northwest Merger
Profitability Analysis
MARKETING THE INDUSTRY SEGMENTS
Alaska Air Carrier Association
Strategy Implementation
Strategic Planning and the Marketing Management Process
Προκλήσεις και προοπτικές αεροπορικών εταιρειών
Introduction First established as Federal Express, today’s FedEx Corporation is one of the most recognized brands for their express delivery system, FedEx.
Wolfgang Kurth 1. February 2005
2015: In Rarefied Air According to US Bureau of Transportation statistics, the 25 US scheduled service passenger airlines, which are the basis of the.
A Relatively Smooth Ride
Organizational Structure and Controls
Booz Allen Hamilton Standard Colors
AIRLINE MANAGEMENT AERO 4100 / 5100
Analyzing the Current Situation
DOA Facilities Management Airline Industry Growth Trends
Government Travel Advisory Committee September 23, 2014
Qualitative Scenarios
American Airlines Value Pricing
Airline Deregulation and Airline Economics
AIRLINE INDUSTRY ANALYSIS
مقالات إدارية حبيبات القهوة!!!! مبيعات قطاع الأعمال - الأحساء
Forestry and Agriculture Greenhouse Gas Modelling Forum
A New Operating Paradigm
Chapter 14 Marketing.
Industry Analysis: American Airlines
Competitive Analysis: American Airlines
Presentation transcript:

A New Operating Paradigm Booz Allen Hamilton Standard Colors Colors should be used in the color pairs whenever possible. Do not mix and match colors, use pairs together as shown. Black, White and Gray can be used with any of the other colors. Purple Pantone 2765 R 12 G 4 B 79 Green Pantone 357 R 15 G 67 B 24 Blue Pantone 2 88 R 11 G 31 B 101 Pantone Cool Gray 6 R 158 G 158 B 158 Black Red Pantone 485 R 252 G 5 B 14 Yellow Pantone 3965 R 232 G 244 B 4 Aqua Pantone 319 R 126 G 204 B 189 White

Booz Allen Hamilton Leading strategy and technology consulting firm 11,000 employees, $2.2B Founded in 1914 Our clients in air transportation: Governments, airports, air navigation providers Airlines, logistics, GDSs, travel agencies, equipment and service providers A global team: USA, Europe, Asia, Latin America, Africa Breadth: Strategy, operational restructuring, organizational design Systems design and implementation support Policy and regulatory advice RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

Unit Revenue and Cost Trend Cents Per Available Seat Mile(c/ASM) Airline crisis is unprecedented – current price levels appear consistent with long term trends Unit Revenue and Cost Trend (U.S. Industry) Unprecedented cost-revenue gap, started before 9-11 Unit Revenue (RASM) Unit Cost (CASM) Cents Per Available Seat Mile(c/ASM) (Adjusted To 2001 Dollars) CASM decline: RASM decline: 1979–1992: 1.5%pa 1979–1992: 1.8%pa CASM increase: RASM increase: 1993–1998: -1.0%pa 1993–1998: +0.6%pa Risk that revenues will revert to “old” trend line Note: CASM reduction Q3 2002 somewhat overstated due to accounting effects Source: Company Financial Statements, Back Associates, BAH Analysis RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

The paradigm shift between point-to-point and network business models is far from over U.S. Domestic Market Structure (O&D Passenger Trips Y2000) Low Cost Carrier Potential Low Cost Carriers (LCCs) can conservatively participate in 70% of the US market LCCs now participate in 43% of O&D market Significant growth potential remains Eastern U.S. Increased breadth in existing strongholds Increased depth in O&Ds currently served Non-Stop Service Available Non-Stop Service Not Available Total Major Hub Cities 44% 6% 50% Minor Hub Cities 7% 2% 9% Large Non-Hub 10% 3% 13% SWA Connection 6% 2% 8% Other 9% 7% 16% Total 78% 22% 100% ~ 10% Over 2,000 Miles ~ 16-18% Small City Markets RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

Average Yield(1) in Hub Markets The fundamental threat to hub and spoke carriers lies in price realization Average Yield(1) in Hub Markets 60 OA Yield No SWA preserve 50 OA Yield SWA conn SWA non-stop competition reduces OA yields 25%-35% SWA one-stop competition reduces OA yields 15-20% 40 OA Yield SWA direct competition C/ASM 30 SWA Yield connect 20 SWA Yield non-stop 10 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 RANGE Note: (1) Revenue per revenue passenger mile, including PFC and taxes (2) OA: Other Airline Source: DOT Y.2000 data, BAH Analysis RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

The situation is complicated by an excess of hub capacity Current Travel Structure (Passenger Trips, Y2000) Connect In USA 30% ~110 M O&D PAX International ~70% Do Not Connect in US ~60% of Domestic Trips Are Non-Stop ~410 M O&D PAX Domestic Other Connections 9% Inadequate Non-Stop Service 10% Current Domestic Connections ~40% No Non-Stop Service Available 22% Source: U.S. DOT, BAH analysis RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

…resulting in an unsustainable revenue positions at hub-and-spoke carriers Competitive Composition: Typical Mainline Carrier, Pre-Crash Degree Of Price Sensitivity Non-Stop Passenger Flight Connecting Passenger Flight Low: Individual chooses airline, travels on business or rich personal travel 20% - 30% revenue 20% - 25% of revenue Medium: Corporation is principal decision maker, drives bargain 10% - 15% revenue 10% - 15% revenue High: Mostly leisure travel and price sensitive business 15% revenue 10% - 15% revenue Generally Product Advantage Significantly Higher Yields (Without LCC Price Impact) Moderately Vulnerable Product Parity Or Disadvantage Vulnerable RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

Network carriers have a huge cost gap vs LCCs CASM Versus Stage Length 2000 SK AZ AF US LH BA KL Cents / ASM EasyJet IB AS AA UA NW TW AirT CO Ryanair DL AWA SWA ATA Britannia Average Stage Length (miles) Source: BAH Analysis RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

Note: Average Airline based on Delta, United, and US Airways Much of this cost differential is a result of production model choices, not frills Drivers Of Unit Cost Differences U.S. Network Carriers and SWA (737-300: Stage Length, Seat Density and Factor Cost Adjusted, Y2000) 7.2 12% c/ASM Other 15% G&A Sales and Res 70% Schedule Pax, Bag, Cargo Handling -50% Process & Pace Ownership Costs Onboard Costs Distribution Maintenance Costs Fuel Costs Frills 3% Other Pilot Costs Baseline (SWA) Note: Average Airline based on Delta, United, and US Airways RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

A new business model may emerge that closes 70-80% of the cost gap and re-establishes product differentiation Random hubbing Improved asset productivity Reduce TAT and handling complexity Alter trade-off between efficient operation and optimum connectivity Restructure Network / Hub Operations to Remove Scheduling Constraints (“Below the Wing Processes”) Separate simple from complicated tasks; apply tailored process streams Reduce low-value interactions with staff Simplify reservation, ticketing, check-in Simplify Customer Interface at the Airport and in Distribution (“Above the Wing Processes”) Reduce complexity, increase pace Lower Cost Differentiated Services Viability Provide specialized services and appropriate schedule qualities Achieve pure business streams High service levels where needed or expected (local vs. connectivity) Low-cost service levels where possible (high-value vs. low-value customers) Create Separate Business Systems for Distinct Customer Segments (“Product Differentiation”) RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt

Incremental Evolution A new industry structure may emerge – or the next crisis will be a repeat on steroids New Business Model Incremental Evolution 2-3 new network based carriers emerge by continent 1 or 2 random hubs each Many centers of mass a la SWA Greater focus on non-stop services 1-2 low costs carriers by continent Regional carriers that perform two missions Feed for limited number of random hubs Point to point flying in business and smaller markets Network carriers stick to current business model Continued share loss to LCCs Low cost subs fail again Regional operators take over larger proportions of network 1-2 low cost carriers succeed by continent Regional carriers pick up failing routes, remain more focused on feed Next crisis is an amplification of current one RPUS1747-0126-011303v1.ppt