Initial States and Global Dynamics versus Fluctuations

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
M. Oldenburg Probing QCD with High Energy Nuclear Collisions, Hirschegg, Austria, January Directed Flow in Au+Au Collisions Markus D. Oldenburg.
Advertisements

PID v2 and v4 from Au+Au Collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV at RHIC
Mass, Quark-number, Energy Dependence of v 2 and v 4 in Relativistic Nucleus- Nucleus Collisions Yan Lu University of Science and Technology of China Many.
Marcus Bleicher, Berkeley, Oct Elliptic Flow in High Energetic Nuclear Collisions Marcus Bleicher & Xianglei Zhu FIAS & Institut für Theoretische.
Elliptic flow of thermal photons in Au+Au collisions at 200GeV QNP2009 Beijing, Sep , 2009 F.M. Liu Central China Normal University, China T. Hirano.
Supported by DOE 11/22/2011 QGP viscosity at RHIC and LHC energies 1 Huichao Song 宋慧超 Seminar at the Interdisciplinary Center for Theoretical Study, USTC.
LP. Csernai, Sept. 4, 2001, Palaiseau FR 1 L.P. Csernai, C. Anderlik, V. Magas, D. Strottman.
In relativistic heavy ion collisions a high energy density matter Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP) may be formed. Various signals have been proposed which probe.
Norway. 3-dim. QGP Fluid Dynamics and Flow Observables László Csernai (Bergen Computational Physics Lab., Univ. of Bergen)
The speed of sound in a magnetized hot Quark-Gluon-Plasma Based on: Neda Sadooghi Department of Physics Sharif University of Technology Tehran-Iran.
Julia VelkovskaMoriond QCD, March 27, 2015 Geometry and Collective Behavior in Small Systems from PHENIX Julia Velkovska for the PHENIX Collaboration Moriond.
Properties of the Quantum Fluid at RHIC Strangeness in Quark Matter March 26-31, 2006.
Flow Vorticity and Rotation in Peripheral HIC Dujuan Wang CBCOS, Wuhan, 11/05/2014 University of Bergen, Norway.
ATLAS measurement of dipolar flow (v 1 ) in Pb-Pb collisions Jiangyong Jia for the ATLAS Collaboration WWND 2012 April 7 th - 14 rd Based on results in.
Collective Flow in Heavy-Ion Collisions Kirill Filimonov (LBNL)
Λ Polarization in an Exact rotating and expanding model for peripheral heavy ion reactions Yilong Xie NorSAC-2015 Department of Physics and Technology,
Csörgő, T. 1 Observables and initial conditions from exact rotational hydro solutions T. Csörgő 1, I. Barna 1 and M.I. Nagy 1,3 1 MTA Wigner Research Center.
Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model LongGang Pang 1, Victor Roy 1,, Guang-You Qin 1, & Xin-Nian.
Longitudinal de-correlation of anisotropic flow in Pb+Pb collisions Victor Roy ITP Goethe University Frankfurt In collaboration with L-G Pang, G-Y Qin,
Two particle correlation method to Detect rotation in HIC Dujuan Wang University of Bergen Supervisor: Laszlo P. Csernai.
QM 年 11 月 日 Shanghai, China 梁作堂 (Liang Zuo-tang) 山东大学 1 For The 19th International Conference on Ultra-Relativistic Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions.
STRING PERCOLATION AND THE GLASMA C.Pajares Dept Particle Physics and IGFAE University Santiago de Compostela CERN The first heavy ion collisions at the.
L.P. Csernai 1 Laszlo P. Csernai, University of Bergen, Norway Differential HBT method to detect rotation Wigner - CCNU mini Workshop, Budapest, Apr. 7-8,
Csörgő, T. 1 Observables and initial conditions from exact rotational hydro solutions T. Csörgő 1, I. Barna 1 and M.I. Nagy 1,3 1 MTA Wigner Research Center.
Roy A. Lacey (SUNY Stony Brook ) C ompressed B aryonic at the AGS: A Review !! C ompressed B aryonic M atter at the AGS: A Review !!
Zagreb, Croatia, 2015/04/20 Csörgő, T. 1 New exact solutions of hydrodynamcs and search for the QCD Critical Point T. Csörgő 1,2 with I.Barna 1 and M.
Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider and Ultra-Dense Matter.
1 Jeffery T. Mitchell – Quark Matter /17/12 The RHIC Beam Energy Scan Program: Results from the PHENIX Experiment Jeffery T. Mitchell Brookhaven.
Energy Scan of Hadron (  0 ) Suppression and Flow in Au+Au Collisions at PHENIX Norbert Novitzky for PHENIX collaboration University of Jyväskylä, Finland.
LP. Csernai, NWE'2001, Bergen1 Part II Relativistic Hydrodynamics For Modeling Ultra-Relativistic Heavy Ion Reactions.
Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model Victor Roy Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China Collaborators.
Hadron Collider Physics 2012, 12/Nov/2012, KyotoShinIchi Esumi, Univ. of Tsukuba1 Heavy Ion results from RHIC-BNL ShinIchi Esumi Univ. of Tsukuba Contents.
Robert Pak (BNL) 2012 RHIC & AGS Annual Users' Meeting 0 Energy Ro Robert Pak for PHENIX Collaboration.
Heavy-Ion Physics - Hydrodynamic Approach Introduction Hydrodynamic aspect Observables explained Recombination model Summary 전남대 이강석 HIM
Relativistic Theory of Hydrodynamic Fluctuations Joe Kapusta University of Minnesota Nuclear Physics Seminar October 21, 2011 Collaborators: Berndt Muller.
Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook, ISMD, Kromĕříž, Roy A. Lacey What do we learn from Correlation measurements at RHIC.
Hyperon Polarization in Heavy ion Collisions C. C. Barros Jr. Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina Brasil Strangeness in Quark Matter 2013 University.
Implications for LHC pA Run from RHIC Results CGC Glasma Initial Singularity Thermalized sQGP Hadron Gas sQGP Asymptotic.
JET Collaboration Meeting June 17-18, 2014, UC-Davis1/25 Flow and “Temperature” of the Parton Phase from AMPT Zi-Wei Lin Department of Physics East Carolina.
Soft physics in PbPb at the LHC Hadron Collider Physics 2011 P. Kuijer ALICECMSATLAS Necessarily incomplete.
PHENIX. Motivation Collaboration PHENIX Roy A. Lacey (SUNY Stony Brook) PHENIX Collaboration I N T E R N A T I O N A L W O R K S H O P O N T H E P H.
Fluctuations, Instabilities and Collective Dynamics L. P. Csernai 1 and H. Stöcker 2 1 Institute of Physics and Technology, University of Bergen, Allegaten.
Duke University 野中 千穂 Hadron production in heavy ion collision: Fragmentation and recombination in Collaboration with R. J. Fries (Duke), B. Muller (Duke),
Elliptic flow from initial states of fast nuclei. A.B. Kaidalov ITEP, Moscow (based on papers with K.Boreskov and O.Kancheli) K.Boreskov and O.Kancheli)
 Collision of heavy nuclei at relativistic energies leads to formation of Quark- Gluon Plasma (QGP).  Strong confirmation arises from the recent observation.
I. Correlations: PHOBOS Data, Flux Tubes and Causality II. Ridge: Transverse Flow, Blast Wave Long Range Correlations and Hydrodynamic Expansion Sean Gavin.
WPCF 2015, Warsaw, 2015/11/06 Csörgő, T. for Nagy, M 1 Observables and initial conditions for rotating and expanding fireballs T. Csörgő 1,2, I.Barna 1.
Chiral Magnet Effect, where are we?
Experiment Review in small system collectivity and thermalization in pp, pA/dA/HeA collisions Shengli Huang.
SQM,UC Berkeley 27 June- 1July 2016
Review of ALICE Experiments
PHENIX Measurements of Azimuthal Anisotropy at RHIC
クォークグルーオンプラズマと高エネルギー重イオン衝突反応
Directed Flow of Identified Particles
Heavy Quark Flow as Better Probes of QGP Properties
Phase transitions and critical fluctuations
Angular Momentum And Early Time Gluon Fields
Roy A. Lacey & Peifeng Liu Stony Brook University
ATLAS vn results vn from event plane method
Collective Dynamics at RHIC
Experimental Studies of Quark Gluon Plasma at RHIC
Maya Shimomura University of Tsukuba
Introduction Results Methods Conclusions
Directed Flow Measurements at STAR
LHC−ALICE実験におけるソフトな指針で見るQGP QGP through soft probes at LHC-ALICE
Differential HBT method to detect rotation
One PeV Collisions Very successful Heavy Ion run in 2015, with all new detectors in operation 16 GB/s readout/ 6GB/s on disk after HLT compression.
of Hadronization in Nuclei
Introduction of Heavy Ion Physics at RHIC
ShinIchi Esumi, Univ. of Tsukuba
Presentation transcript:

Initial States and Global Dynamics versus Fluctuations 8th International Workshop on High pT Physics at LHC (HPT2012) 21-24 October 2012, Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China Initial States and Global Dynamics versus Fluctuations For hard processes, from the most energetic initial stages we need to know the ST configuration of the background Laszlo P. Csernai, University of Bergen, Norway L.P. Csernai

Global Dynamics versus Fluctuations L.P. Csernai

Central Collisions (A+A) Global Symmetries One symmetry axis: z-axis – given by the beam direction Azimuthal symmetry Longitudinal, +/- z symmetry  rapidity – even Spherical or ellipsoidal flow, expansion Global v1, v2, v3, … vn = 0 !! Fluctuations Perfect conditions for fluctuation studies Azimuthal fluctuations - no interference - perfect, odd & even harmonics Longitudinal fluctuations - global rapidity-even flow interference  (slight) dominance for rapidity-even fluctuations Best for critical fluctuation studies : L.P. Csernai

This is a direct proof of low viscosity !

asymmetry could occur) ! Oct. 2011, p. 6 Flow originating from initial state fluctuations is significant and dominant in central and semi-central collisions (where from global symmetry no azimuthal asymmetry could occur) ! L.P. Csernai

~ spherical with many (16) nearly equal perturbations ~ like Elliptic flow, v2 L.P. Csernai

Longer tail on the negative ( low l ) side Longer tail on the negative ( low l ) side ! (see discussion of “Skewness” later)

Higher order moments can be obtained from fluctuations Skewness Higher order moments can be obtained from fluctuations around the critical point.  Skewness and Kurtosis are calculated for the QGP  HM phase transition Positive Skewness QGP HM Negative Skewness indicates Freeze-out mainly still on the QGP side. L.P. Csernai

Peripheral Collisions (A+A) Global Symmetries Symmetry axes in the global CM-frame: ( y  -y) ( x,z  -x,-z) Azimuthal symmetry: φ-even (cos nφ) Longitudinal z-odd, (rap.-odd) for v_odd Spherical or ellipsoidal flow, expansion Fluctuations Global flow and Fluctuations are simultaneously present  Ǝ interference Azimuth - Global: even harmonics - Fluctuations : odd & even harmonics Longitudinal – Global: v1, v3 y-odd - Fluctuations : odd & even harmonics The separation of Global & Fluctuating flow is a must !! (not done yet) L.P. Csernai

Analysis of Global Flow: and Fluctuating Flow: L.P. Csernai

Method to compensate for C.M. rapidity fluctuations Determining experimentally EbE the C.M. rapidity Shifting each event to its own C.M. and evaluate flow-harmonics there Determining the C.M. rapidity The rapidity acceptance of a central TPC is usually constrained (e.g for ALICE |η| < ηlim = 0.8, and so: |ηC.M.| << ηlim , so it is not adequate for determining the C.M. rapidity of participants. A Participant rapidity from spectators B C L.P. Csernai

Interplay between global collective flow and fluctuating flow ATLAS L.P. Csernai

Peripheral Collisions (A+A) Global Flow in Peripheral Collisions (A+A) Many interesting phenomena: Historically: Bounce off / Side splash; Squeeze out  pressure & EoS 3rd flow or Anti-flow (QGP), Rotation, KHI, Polarization, etc These occur only if viscosity is low!  viscosity With increasing energy flow becomes strongly F/B directed & v1 decreases L.P. Csernai

Fluctuating initial states [1] Gardim FG, Grassi F, Hama Y, Luzum M, Ollitraut PHYSICAL REVIEW C 83, 064901 (2011); (v1 also) [2] Qin GY, Petersen H, Bass SA, Mueller B PHYSICAL REVIEW C 82, 064903 (2010) Fluctuating initial states Cumulative event planes show weak correlation with the global collective reaction plane (RP). If the MEP is set to zero (by definition) then CM rapidity fluctuations do not appear, and v1 by definition is zero. In [2] v1(pt) is analyzed (for RHIC) and the effect is dominated by fluctuations. (Similar to later LHC measurements.) L.P. Csernai

V1 from Global Collective flow  v1(pt) = 0 !!!

Initial States L.P. Csernai

Collective flow There are alternative origins: (a) Global collective flow (RP from spectators) (b) Asymmetries from random I.S. fluctuations (c) Asymmetries from Critical Point fluctuations Goal is to separate the these  This provides more insight How can we see the flow of QGP?  Rapid hadronization and freeze-out L.P. Csernai

„Fire streak” picture – 3 dim. Myers, Gosset, Kapusta, Westfall Symmetry axis = z-axis. Transverse plane divided into streaks.

Flux – tubes ED or QED: Gluon self-interaction makes field lines attract each other.  QCD:  linear potential  confinement L.P. Csernai

String model of mesons / PYTHIA Light quarks connected by string  mesons have ‘yo-yo’ modes: t Gy.&A. Init. state The whole string moves Cs.M.&S. Init. state x String stopped: no Bjorken flow If mass is not zero [T. Sjostrand & H.U. Bengtsson, 1984-1987] PYTHIA L.P. Csernai

t Yo-yo in the fixed target frame  target recoil  density and energy density increase in the “fragmentation region” z L.P. Csernai

Initial stage: Coherent Yang-Mills model [Magas, Csernai, Strottman, Pys. Rev. C ‘2001] L.P. Csernai, Praha 2007

String rope --- Flux tube --- Coherent YM field

Initial State 3rd flow component This shape is confirmed by STAR HBT: PLB496 (2000) 1; & M.Lisa &al. PLB 489 (2000) 287. 3rd flow component L.P. Csernai

Initial state – reaching equilibrium Initial state by V. Magas, L.P. Csernai and D. Strottman Phys. Rev. C64 (01) 014901 Relativistic, 1D Riemann expansion is added to each stopped streak M1

3rd flow component Hydro [Csernai, HIPAGS’93] & [Csernai, Röhrich, 1999] L.P. Csernai, Praha 2007

v1(η): system-size dependence G. Wang / STAR QM 2006 : v1(η): system-size dependence System size doesn’t seem to influence v1(η). L.P. Csernai

Anti-flow (v1) at LHC Initial energy density [GeV/fm3] distribution in the reaction plane, [x,y] for a Pb+Pb reaction at 1.38 + 1.38 ATeV collision energy and impact parameter b = 0.5_bmax at time 4 fm/c after the first touch of the colliding nuclei, this is when the hydro stage begins. The calculations are performed according to the effective string rope model. This tilted initial state has a flow velocity distribution, qualitatively shown by the arrows. The dashed arrows indicate the direction of the largest pressure gradient at this given moment. L.P. Csernai

Anti-flow (v1) The energy density [GeV/fm3] distribution in the reaction plane, [x,z] for a Pb+Pb reaction at 1.38 + 1.38 A.TeV collision energy and impact parameter b = 0.5b_max at time 12 fm/c after the formation of the hydro initial state. The expected physical FO point is earlier but this post FO configuration illustrates the flow pattern. [ LP. Csernai, V.K. Magas, H. Stöcker, D. Strottman, Phys. Rev. C84 (2011) 02914 ] L.P. Csernai

Rotation F.O. The rotation is illustrated by dividing the upper / lower part (blue/red) of the initial state, and following the trajectories of the marker particles. L.P. Csernai

Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability (KHI) L.P. Csernai

Max = 3. c/fm [Du-Juan Wang, Bergen, et al.,] Relativistic Classical If is negligible Max = 3. c/fm L.P. Csernai

Onset of turbulence around the Bjorken flow S. Floerchinger & U. A. Wiedemann, JHEP 1111:100, 2011; arXiv: 1108.5535v1 y Max = 0.2 c/fm Initial state Event by Event vorticity and divergence fluctuations. Amplitude of random vorticity and divergence fluctuations are the same In dynamical development viscous corrections are negligible ( no damping) Initial transverse expansion in the middle (±3fm) is neglected ( no damping) High frequency, high wave number fluctuations may feed lower wave numbers L.P. Csernai

Typical I.S. model – scaling flow The same longitudinal expansion velocity profile in the whole [x,y]-plane ! No shear flow. Usually angular momentum is vanishing! X Zero vorticity & Zero shear! Z Such a re-arrangement of the matter density is dynamically not possible in a short time! L.P. Csernai

Adil & Gyulassy (2005) initial state x, y, η, τ coordinates  Bjorken scaling flow Considering a longitudinal “local relative rapidity slope”, based on observations in D+Au collisions:  L.P. Csernai

This is similar to our model, with several flux-tubes in each fire-streak, with different rapidities at their ends. This leads to a “diffuse nuclear geometry” : Here in a given streak on the projectile side, there is a distribution[1] of the ends of the flux tubes, so that the energy is shifter more to the positive rapidity side. [1: Wounded nucleon model, Brodsky etal. PRC (1977)] The consequence is that the energy is shifted forward on the projectile side  (RHIC - 200 A.GeV, - v1 is black !) v1 is opposite side then in the experiment. L.P. Csernai

Bozek, Wyskiel (2010): Directed flow x, y, η, τ coordinates Similarly to Adil & Gyulassy this is also based on the Wounded nucleon picture. η and x coordinates are used. The P & T distributions are given  Target Projectile Bjorken flow B F  Z Directed flow (v1) peaks at positive rapidities! (as A&D) Global collective coordinates Notice: the arrows are pressure gradients! The authors re-parametrized their initial state to a ‘tilted’ i.s. and with modified distributions, and this could reproduce the observations at RHIC  Not a dynamical model L.P. Csernai

3, Directed flow at different centralities ‘tilted’ i.s.

Summary The I.S. is decisive in causing global collective flow Consistent I.S. is needed based on a dynamical picture, satisfying causality, etc. Several I.S. models exist, some of these are oversimplified beyond physical principles. Experimental outcome strongly depends on the I.S. Thank you L.P. Csernai

L.P. Csernai

Kristian Birkeland 1867 - 1917 Assessment of the evaluation committee for Yara’s Birkeland prize 2012. Yara’s Birkeland prize for 2012 is awarded to dr. Yun Cheng for her thesis Hydrodynamics and Freeze Out Problems in Energetic Heavy Ion reactions, for which she was awarded the degree of Philosophiae Doctor at the University of Bergen in 2010. The work was carried out under the supervision of professor László Csernai the Department of Physics and Technology. … … … In her thesis, dr. Yun Cheng has investigated how theoretical models for the the various phases of a plasma-forming heavy ion collision can be fitted coherently together, and how well the resulting description agrees with experimental measurements. This represents a valuable contribution to our understanding of fundamental aspects of hot strongly interacting matter. Her work is pure basic research, aiming at understanding and testing the validity of quantum chromodynamics, one of the main components of the current Standard Model of elementary particles. L.P. Csernai