Gravity from quantum entanglement Jae-Weon Lee (Jungwon univ.)

Outline Gravity is emergent Thermodynamics  Gravity (Jacobson, Padmanabhan) Entropy  gravity (Verlinde, 2010) Entanglement  Gravity (Lee, Lee, Kim, 2010) Spacetime is emergent Entanglement  Time (Page & Wooters) Entanglement  Spacetime (Raamsdonk) QM is emergent Information loss  QM (Lee, 2011)

The most beautiful physics formula (at leat for me) relativity thermodynamics Holographic principle Bekenstein-Hawking entropy quantum gravity BH Hawking radiation Entropy is proportional to area not to volume  Holographic principle

Black Hole Entropy mysteries Origin  Area law?  Entanglement Entropy? The information paradox  via Hawking Rad.? The infall problem  Firewall?

History BH thermodynamics (Bekenstein & Hawking 1972) dE=TdS Entanglement  Time (Page & Wooters 1983) Entanglement  BH entropy (Bombelli et al 1986) BH war (Hawking vs Susskind) Entanglement  Arrow of time (Llyod,1988) Holographic principle (t’Hooft & Susskind) Thermodynamics  Gravity (Jacobson, Padmanabhan) Entanglement  Dark energy (Lee, Lee, Kim, 2007) Entropy  Gravity (Verlinde, 2010) Entanglement  Gravity (Lee, Lee, Kim, 2010) Entanglement  Spacetime (Raamsdonk 2010) Holography  Entanglement (Takayhanagi, 2012) BH Firewall paradox Entanglement=Wormhole (ER=EPR, Maldacena) Experimental realization of PaW (Moreva et al, 2013) Entanglement  Gravity in AdS/CFT (Raamsdonk 2014) Entanglement  Gravity (Jacobson 2015)

Entanglement (nonlocal quantum correlation) entropy , Entanglement entropy A B If there is a causal horizon (information barrier), it is natural to divide the system by the horizon and consider entanglement entropy across the horizon.

Holography and Entanglement Entanglement has Area Law (in general) Nonlocality Relation to causality Something fundamental Observer dependency It reminds us of the Holographic principle! * Entanglement is faster than light! ( v > O(103)c )  Entanglement is more fundamental than anything with v <= c

How to calculate Entanglement entropy Hamiltonian Srednicki,PRL71,666 , R Vacuum=ground state of oscillators Reduced density matrix Eigenvalues entropy Calculable!

Entanglement entropy? Divergent Species problem Physics dependent l = UV cutoff Divergent Species problem Physics dependent

Dark energy from entanglement LLK:JCAP08, 005 Entanglement 1st law A black hole-like universe Hawking temperature Entanglement entropy Or Bekenstein-Hawking entropy Horizon Entanglement energy Expanding event horizonn d ~1 Holographic dark energy

Observation Zhang & Wu, astro-ph/0701405 The Hubble constant H0 predicted by the base ΛCDM model according to the Planck CMB data: 67.27 ± 0.66 km/s/Mpc But, H0 locally determined:73.02±1.79 km/s/Mpc,  One solution can be the dynamical DE arXiv:1604.01424 DE is not the Cosmological constant?

Jacobson’s Great idea Padmanabhan R x where Raychaudhuri equation using Bianchi identity Einstein equation is related to local Rindler observers!

Gravity from entanglement Lee, Lee, Kim, 1001.5445 dE A derivation of Entanglement 1st law

Thermofield doubled state Pure state (entangled) Thermal state Not directly related to gravity

Bisognano Wichmann theorem Density matrix is thermal (KMS state) with respect to the Hamiltonian generating time translation leaving the wedge invariant. KMS-condition describes precisely the thermal equilibrium states

Modern interpretation L R t x a

Perturbative QG Einstein Eq. + low energy QG  EE is SBH Bianchi 1211.0522 Einstein Eq. + low energy QG  EE is SBH Perturbative quantum gravity EOM

t AH Matter+gravity A0 L R thermal x Raychaudhuri equation

Verlinde’s entropic gravity 1001.0785 # of bits Equipartition Newton’s gravity! But has problems such as neutron interference exp.

Gravity from Information loss Lee FOP arXiv:1003.4464 Rindler horizon Information loss  Change of entanglement entropy  Entropic gravity

Return of the Jacobson M Confirmal mapping to Rindler wedge T. Jacobson 1505.04753 Causal diamond M Space-like slice Killing vector Confirmal mapping to Rindler wedge

continued C.C. T. Jacobson 1505.04753 The area variation at constant V for a maximally symmetric spacetime C.C.

Gravity from AdS/CFT 1405.2933 area of the bulk extremal surface

Eternal BH

Thermofield doubled state Pure state (entangled) Thermal state Maldacena’s proposal: the eternal black hole is dual to |TFD> of CFT

Holographic entanglement entropy Takayanagi 1204.2450 Strange connection btw Entanglement & holography

Spacetime from entanglement Israel: The two sides of the eternal BH are the entangled copies of a thermal system. Maldacena: The dual to the eternal BH is two entangled copies of a CFT (thermofield double formalism) Raamsdonk: Entangled sum of CFT state as an entangled sum of spacetime

Spacetime from entanglement Raamsdonk 1005.3035 Entanglement glue quantum superposition of disconnected spacetime = (connected) eternal AdS black hole spacetime

The Time problem Wave function of WDE is static. In QM time labels the dynamics but does not participate as a degree of freedom. In GR, time is just an arbitrary label- the theory is invariant under time reparameterizations. Wave function of WDE is static.  There is no time in canonical Q. Gravity

Page-Wooters Mechanism Stationary & entangled Clock and rest Conditional probability

where

Gravity as Quantum Entanglement Force. Lee Kim Lee arXiv:1002.4568 Total entanglement of the universe Arrow of time (Lyod) Entanglement force

EPR=ER Entanglement ~ worm hole 1 No Superluminal Signals Maldacena & Susskind 1306.0533 1 No Superluminal Signals 2 No Creation By LOCC 3 Restoring the thermo field state Entanglement ~ worm hole

f? QFT from information loss ??? f: field, some function of spacetime Maximize Shannon entropy Energy conservation Constraint Boltzmann distribution

Quantum Mechanics from information Lee FOP arXiv: 1005.2739,  rest observer accelerating observer Rindler observer will have no more information about fields crossing the horizon  What the observer can do is just to estimate the probability of the field configuration inside.

QFT from information J.Lee FOP 2011 Maximize Shannon entropy Boltzmann distribution For Rindler observer (continuous version + coord. Transf. ) Unruh showed that this is equivalent to Quantum partition function! (Unruh Eff.) Origin of QM and path integral! & Entropic gravity

Conclusion: Emergent universe? Gravity is emergent Thermodynamics  Gravity (Jacobson, Padmanabhan) Entropy  gravity (Verlinde, 2011) Entanglement  Gravity (Lee, Lee, Kim, 2011) Spacetime is emergent Entanglement  Time (Page & Wooters) Entanglement  Spacetime (Raamsdonk) QM is emergent Information loss  QM (Lee, 2011) Universe is emergent! from what??? Information! Information of what???

Verlinde’s Idea 1: Newton’s 2nd law JHEP04(2011)029 arXiv:1001.0785, Entropic force Newton’s 2nd law Holographic screen??

Lovelock Theorem in a 3+1D differentiable manifold, the Einstein tensor is the only tensorial and divergence-free function of the and at most their first and second partial derivatives.

Our works so far Dark energy from vacuum entanglement. JCAP 0708:005,2007.  dark energy from information 2) Does information rule the quantum black hole? arXiv:0709.3573 (MPLA)  Black hole mass from information 3) Is dark energy from cosmic Hawking radiation? Mod.Phys.Lett.A25:257-267,2010  Dark energy is cosmic Hawking radiation Verlinde’s paper: Gravity and mechanics from entropic force arXiv:1001.0785 Gravity from Quantum Information. 1001.5445 [hep-th]  gravity is related to quantum entanglement or information loss 2) Gravity as Quantum Entanglement Force. arXiv:1002.4568 [hep-th] 3) Zero Cosmological Constant and Nonzero Dark Energy from Holographic Principle. arXiv:1003.1878  (Lee) 4) On the Origin of Entropic Gravity and Inertia. arXiv:1003.4464 [hep-th] (Lee) Verlinde’s theory from quantum information model 5) Quantum mechanics emerges from information theory applied to causal horizons  arXiv:0041329 (Lee)

Black hole thermodynamics Bekenstein & Hawking The First Law The Second Law dE=THdS BH area always increases =entropy always increases Nobody knows the physical origin of these laws!

Holographic principle All of information in a volume can be described by physics on its boundary. The maximum entropy within the volume is proportional to its area not volume. R Scientific American August 2003