Work stream II: Perpetrators’ Trial Gene Feder, Helen Cramer, Karen Morgan, Jayne Bailey, Neil Blacklock, Marianne Hester, William Turner & Chris Newman.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Domestic Abuse - Workplace Policy Can it make a difference? February 2011.
Advertisements

Barnardos Registered Charity Nos and SC Barnardos Domestic violence: Risk Assessment Model.
Barnardos Domestic violence: Risk Assessment Model
Young People in Secure Settings- Feedback Dr Inyang Takon Consultant Paediatrician QEII Hospital, Welwyn Garden City, Herts.
Activ* 8 Background: National: 1 in 4 women will be victims of Domestic Violence in their life time. 2 women per week are killed by their former partners.
Domestic Abuse & Child Contact Part 1: Understanding the issues (Speaker: Nel Whiting, Scottish Women’s Aid)
Parents as Partners A GROUPWORK PROGRAMME WITH A COUPLE APPROACH DFE funded.
Violence Against Women and Their Children Professor Marianne Hester.
'Women with Mental Health Issues in the Criminal Justice System in Northern Ireland- A Misunderstood and Victimised Group'. Elizabeth Craig-PhD Student.
MODULE ONE Understanding Marginalized Populations.
What can we learn? -Analysing child deaths and serious injury through abuse and neglect A summary of the biennial analysis of SCRs Brandon et al.
NSPCC: Programmes for children living in high risk families
Domestic Violence and the Workplace Deborah McIlveen Policy & Services Manager Women’s Aid England.
Tackling Domestic Violence Professor Marianne Hester University of Bristol.
National Pacific Fono  Tupu Services  Pacific Alcohol, Drugs and Gambling Interventions Service  Regional Service under WDHB  Consists of 16.
ETherapy for Dual Diagnosis Leanne Chisnall. Self Help Services Established in 1995 Independent user-led mental health charity based in Manchester Provide.
Bracknell Forest Council: Evaluation of the Domestic Abuse Perpetrator Service (DAPS) Liz Phillips.
Women with drug and alcohol problems: What works? Gemma Lousley Policy and Engagement Officer, DrugScope.
Neil Blacklock, Acting Director Acting
Domestic Violence and Mental Health Judith Fitzsimons Domestic Violence Co-ordinator Hackney Domestic Violence Team.
Health care responses to domestic violence: end of the beginning? Gene Feder Mental Health in the Context of Domestic Abuse Conference September 15 th.
IRIS Identification and Referral to Improve Safety “If they ask I would answer” Judy Barber Islington IRIS Advocate Educator © Bristol University 2007.
The Effects of Imprisonment on Female Offenders Annetta Bennett Consultant Safeguarding Specialist.
Factors in Domestic Abuse Men’s risks Women’s and children’s vulnerabilities Service generated risks (SGRs)
The Dark Side of the Family. Domestic Abuse When a family member, partner or ex-partner attempts to physically, or psychologically dominate another.
Sally Johnson, Head of Service (Maternal health) Identifying vulnerability and enabling access to services.
The Caledonian System An integrated approach to address men's domestic abuse and to improve the lives of women, children and men. Developed for the Effective.
Housing and Social Work Services/ Social Work Service Caring Dad’s, Safer Children.
Young Person’s substance misuse service in Hampshire Julie Poling – Team Leader.
Scrutiny Commission on Domestic Violence Amanda Bradley, Head of Children and Families Social Care 24 th November 2011.
An Introduction to Specialist CAMHS in Somerset Mark Conway Schools Link Pilot Manager and Specialist CAMHS Clinician.
Bristol Mental Health update Will Hall System Clinical Leader.
Safeguarding: A shared approach. Overlapping factors ‘The prevalence of domestic violence, misuse of alcohol/drugs and parental mental health problems.
Depression and Anxiety Service Decision Tree for GPs and other referrers Person presents with depression and/or anxiety: Generalised Anxiety Disorder,
Young people experiencing intimate partner abuse
A real life example of intervention retention and follow up in the community: problem solving for self-harm in prisons.
Thresholds Conference
Young people, substance misuse and PHE
Rape and Sexual Violence Strategic Governance Group Standards
Consultation on proposals to change services for people at risk of violence and abuse 19 September 2016 Jessica Timmins, Strategic Improvement and Development.
An evaluation of the online universal COPING parent programme:
A need to belong: what leads girls to join gangs?
Randomized Controlled Trial of a Multi-pronged Intervention to Address Prevention of Violence in Zambia Serenity Harm Reduction Programme Zambia And Applied.
Presented by Renee Harrison, MSW University of Utah 2012
Gangs/SYV Forum Tues 3rd May 2016 MoJ 10.00am am
Module 9 Designing and using EFGR-responsive evaluation indicators
Counselling for the Whole Community
No More Suicide in Bolton How Can you make a difference
What is Golden Key and who is involved?
Victims of Sexual Assault and
IRIS – IDENTIFICATION AND REFERRAL TO IMPROVE SAFETY
IRIS – IDENTIFICATION AND REFERRAL TO IMPROVE SAFETY Addressing the health and wellbeing of victims and survivors of domestic abuse and violence Presenter:
domestic abuse & complex needs
ADDACTION FAMILY OFFER
Presented by Renee Harrison, MSW University of Utah 2012
Trilogy of Risk PowerPoint – Tips on how to use it
Locality Working & Family Well Being – the way forward March 2018
Professor Stephen Pilling PhD
Welcome Acknowledge the difficulty and the emotions around a service transferring. Explain have been on both sides of this before – was really pleased.
Parent-Child Assistance Program (PCAP) 1991-present An intensive 3-year home visitation intervention for pregnant and parenting, alcohol/drug abusing.
Assessment skills Carla Middleton-Ross and Laura Green- Priority Families Accredited Practitioners.
Unidentified Adults : Think Family.
Research benefits of NHS IT Programmes
What is CSE Sexual Exploitation of children and young people under the age of 18 involves exploitative situations where the young person receives ‘something’
Making the Case for Health and Work Champions
BSAB Self-Neglect Conference
Welcome Acknowledge the difficulty and the emotions around a service transferring. Explain have been on both sides of this before – was really pleased.
Working together to improve the health outcomes of the 0-5s
Southwest Domestic Abuse Local Action Group
The Rapid Assessment Pilot
Presentation transcript:

Work stream II: Perpetrators’ Trial Gene Feder, Helen Cramer, Karen Morgan, Jayne Bailey, Neil Blacklock, Marianne Hester, William Turner & Chris Newman al

Questions Do perpetrator groups (working with male perpetrators) reduce domestic violence & abuse? And do female ex/partners & the men themselves think perpetrator groups reduce abuse?

Background Need not only to support victim/survivors but also address perpetrators’ behaviour – largely heterosexual men Best models for addressing perpetration are groups Group models used widely in UK and elsewhere – but need stronger evidence that groups really work ie a trial Past research group trials on mandated populations eg prison populations measures not adequately capturing change

Stages of development Identifying a ‘best bet’ perpetrator group by looking at the literature and getting opinions from experts Making decisions on the measurements we can use that will capture meaningful outcomes? Setting up a small pilot trial (to be run by Splitz Wiltshire) in Bristol / N. Somerset / S.Glos If the pilot trial works, we will run a full trial in at least two geographical locations  

Methods addressing research question: Randomised controlled trial Treatment - 26 week group programme Control - usual care Randomised controlled trial – some men get group intervention, some men get phone call once a month (control)

Study inclusion 48 men (24 to intervention and 24 to control arm) AND as far as possible their women partner/ex partners 12 month follow-up. Data collected at regular intervals throughout trial. Male heterosexual groups only (opportunities for wider inclusion) Community-based - recruitment from multiple sources + WS1 advocate. Partners/ex-partners offered support irrespective of whether male is allocated to intervention or control arm. Most important outcome: are partners / ex partners of men safer and do they feel safer?  

(Some) key concerns   Can we get a small pilot trial to run successfully that makes us think a full trial might work? Can we recruit enough men & retain them? Can we recruit and retain female ex/partners? Is our intervention acceptable to all involved? Are there any safeguarding issues? If a pilot trial works can we run a full trial to answer our key research question: Are perpetrator groups effective at reducing domestic violence?

Outcomes using to answer question: Do perpetrator groups reduce domestic violence & abuse? Relevant outcome measures – currently under consideration Abuse measures Mental health measures Health Substance abuse Socio-demographic measures Cost data   Abuse measures e.g. Composite Abuse Scale, COHSAR scale for men, Child abuse measure + police reports Mental health measures e.g. CORE-OM, PHQ-9 (depression), GAD-7 (anxiety), Post-Traumatic Stress measure + self report on problems & treatment Health e.g. Short Form-12 & EQ-5D (general health & quality of life) Substance abuse e.g. AUDIT (alcohol), DUDIT (drugs) Socio-demographic measures e.g. age, number of children at home, ethnicity, income, occupation Cost data

Referral routes for male perpetrators Male advocate from IRIS+ DVA advocacy hub – ie workstream I Children's services Social services Other health practitioners? Health visitors? Probation & prisons – (men on short term sentences)* Mental health services Addiction services Self referral Police *However we do not want to recruit men who have been ordered to attend a DVPP.

Other referral routes? We are looking for all referral pathways in the B/NS/SG area – does anyone come across men concerned about their behaviour in relationships? Where do you refer them at the moment? Would your service be a potential referral pathway for reprovide?

Contact Karen Morgan Research Fellow, reprovide Email: Karen.morgan@bristol.ac.uk Tel: 0117 3314588 http://www.bristol.ac.uk/primaryhealthcare/researchthemes/reprovide/