Why PJM? Presentation to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Midwest ISO from a Transmission Owner Perspective.
Advertisements

Quick, But Not Risky Ken Nickolai. START HERE Much of your discussion will be about money. Think both about money that will be spent… And money that.
Wholesale Restructuring 1.PURPA 2.Market based wholesale rates 3.Incentive rates 4.Energy Policy Act of 1992 Clarified power to order third party wheeling.
EMIG Electricity Market Investment Group Presentation to the Ontario Energy Board February 17, 2004.
Arizona Corporation Commission Arizona Independent Scheduling Administrator (AzISA) September 22,
Cost Ranges for the Development and Operation of a Day One Regional Transmission Organization PL
1 EMS User’s Group Meeting Deregulation Session Midwest ISO Status Update June 7, 1999 Findlay, Illinois Walter O.Stadlin KEMA Consulting, Horsham, PA.
Discussion of Inter-RTO Seams Issues Presented by: Midwest ISO and NYISO Independent Market Monitor David B. Patton, Ph.D. Potomac Economics October 7,
Jim Larranaga Men’s Basketball Head Coach, AP National Coach of the Year University of Miami Our Formula for Success: The Miami Way.
Regional Transmission Organizations: The Future of Transmission? Dave Edwards 4/17/2004.
1 Dale Osborn Midwest ISO February 27, Wisconsin Renewable Energy Summit Transmission Expansion Opportunities with Wind Energy.
The Continuing Evolution of U.S. Electricity Markets
Sue Sheridan President and Chief Counsel Coalition for Fair Transmission Policy EEI Transmission and Distribution Conference April 2012 TRANSMISSION PLANNING.
The Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator, Inc. An update By Jim Torgerson President and CEO Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator,
Infrastructure, Regulators and Utilities in the World of RTOs and Electricity Markets Steve Gaw, Commissioner, Missouri Public Service Commission President.
1 Enhancing the Role of Renewable Energy in California Robert A. Laurie Commissioner California Energy Commission Geothermal Resources Council Annual Meeting.
1 Transmission Development at Ameren and in the Midwest ISO Mid-America Regulatory Conference Maureen A. Borkowski June 8, 2010.
ISO New England Regional Update Wholesale Electricity Markets & State Energy Policy Seminar Connecticut Business & Industry Association December 14, 2010.
November 13, 2007 The Evolving Roles and Responsibilities of Gas Utilities In Today’s Markets: Giving Customers More Choices.
PacifiCorp Participation in the California ISO. 2 Full participation provides significant benefits beyond those of the Energy Imbalance Market EIM BenefitsFull.
The Value of Electric Transmission NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting June 25, 2012.
PJM © PJM Overview ARIPPA Valley Forge, PA November 8, 2007.
Spare Transformer Equipment Program (STEP) Public Service Commission of Utah – Technical Conference July 8, 2014.
1 New Mexico State University Santa Fe Conference 2005 Steve Rodgers Office of Markets, Tariffs & Rates—South Federal Energy Regulatory Commission March.
Powering Alberta AESO Annual General Meeting May 14, 2009 Reliable Power Reliable Markets Reliable People.
OSC Meeting April 27, Transmission Cost Allocation Overview.
1 WPL Regulatory Update Scott R. Smith Director, Regulatory Affairs.
Joseph L. Welch President and CEO, ITC Holdings Corp. July 16, 2007.
1 The Costs of Participating in Restructured Wholesale Markets American Public Power Association February 5, 2007 William M. Bateman Robert C. Smith.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Presentation by Nick Winser - Sr. Vice President Wednesday, 26 th June Washington, D.C.
PJM©2012www.pjm.com PJM’s Experience with Capacity Markets Terry Boston President & CEO PJM Interconnection Power Across Texas September 21, 2012.
Successful Restructuring: The Way Forward Mark Bennett Senior Manager of Policy Electric Power Supply Association Restructuring and the Wholesale Market.
Southern California Edison SM Southern California Edison Company Proposed AB920 Net Surplus Compensation Rate [NSCR] July 9, 2010.
Presentation to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Kathryn L. Patton, Sr. Vice President and General Counsel June 26, 2002 Why PJM?
1 Restructuring of the Midwest Wholesale Electricity Markets Michael D. Smith Constellation Power Source December 10, 2003.
Midwest ISO Discussion February 5, 2009 Greg Levesque Manager – Regional Relations & Policy.
Transmission Owner Sector Organization of PJM States, Inc. October 8, 2013.
NARUC/FERC COLLABORATIVE: DEMAND RESPONSE Paul Suskie, Chairman, Arkansas Public Service Commission July 15, 2007.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission MISO/Alliance Companies’ RTO Status Reports Presented by: Joseph Power Tony Ingram Rahim Amerkhail Patrick Clarey.
1 NAUSCA Summer Meeting Boston June 30, 3009 David W. Hadley Vice President State Regulatory Relations Midwest ISO.
Order 1000 Implementation in PJM – Challenges and Opportunities Jodi L. Moskowitz Senior Director – Transmission Development & Strategy October 13, 2015.
SAFIR WORKSHOP: MARKET DEVELOPMENT AND REGULATORY PROCESSES Craig Glazer Vice President—Governmental Policy PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. Washington, D.C.
1 Dr. Ahmed Kaloko Chief Economist Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Transition from Public Service to Competitive Markets.
Endless Possibilities RTO/Regulatory Update for East Origination September 18, 2001.
Alliance Update Illinois Commerce Commission Electric Policy Committee July 10, 2001.
The Midwest ISO – Platform to Meet Tomorrow’s Challenges Wisconsin Industrial Energy Group August 7, 2008.
2016 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
Mountain West Transmission Group
GAI History Based in Kokomo, IN since Full-time employees
Calculation of BGS-CIEP Hourly Energy Price Component Using PJM Hourly Data for the PSE&G Transmission Zone.
AES NewEnergy’s Initial View on the Proposed Alliance RTO
North American Markets Status
Achieving the Internal Gas Market The view of gas suppliers
Pseudo-tie business procedure
The Future of Demand Response in New England
The Illinois Model of Retail Competition
Calculation of BGS-CIEP Hourly Energy Price Component Using PJM Hourly Data for the PSE&G Transmission Zone.
20 YEARS AFTER – A CLOSER LOOK AT RTOs
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Westar Formula Rate and your bill
The Need for Compensatory Standby Rates
Benefits of New England’s Proposed Capacity Market
Preserving Competition and Promoting Clean Energy (for All)
2014 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
Generation Expansion Daniel Kirschen
2017 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
Mountain West Transmission Group Panel Discussion
2018 Annual Attachment O Stakeholder Meeting Ameren Missouri
Pseudo-tie business procedure
Calculation of BGS-CIEP Hourly Energy Price Component Using PJM Hourly Data for the PSE&G Transmission Zone.
Presentation transcript:

Why PJM? Presentation to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Kathryn L. Patton, Sr. Vice President and General Counsel June 26, 2002

Operational Reasons For IP Joining PJM IP has 345 kV Interconnections with 4 Utilities: Ameren, AEP, ComEd and TVA Imports for Native Load: 50% of Imports for Illinois Power’s Native Load Came from ComEd and AEP Exports: 60% of Exports were Delivered to the ComEd and AEP Systems 19% of Exports from IP System Served Load in PJM 25% of Exports from IP system Served Load in ComEd and AEP Service Territories

IP CE AEP TVA Interconnections Ameren MECS CILCo CWLP LGEE SIPC EEI 200 2812 IP CILCo AEP 572 937 287 CWLP 307 11250 280 230 409 LGEE Ameren TVA SIPC EEI

Imports for Native Load From Source Transmission System OTHER 3.0% CINERGY 1.9% WISCONSIN ELECTRIC 3.5% CILCO 2.1% AEP 17.0% TVA 24.5% COMMONWEALTH EDISON 33.1% AMEREN 10.4% LG&E 4.5% Based on Year 2000 Actuals

Exports From Illinois Power Transmission System by Transmission Ties AEP 41.1% COMMONWEALTH EDISON 19.0% AMEREN 18.7% TVA 14.6% MIDAMERICAN 3.8% SIPC 1.6% LG&E 0.3% CILCO 0.7% CWLP 0.2% Based on Year 2000 Actuals

Exports by Load Served (Ultimate Sink Transmission System) MIDAMERICAN 5.5% AMEREN 3.0% OTHER 13.9% SOUTHERN COMPANY 1.4% WISCONSIN ELECTRIC 3.1% ENTERGY 9.6% AEP 10.6% COMMONWEALTH EDISON 14.2% TVA 19.3% PJM 19.4% Based on Year 2000 Actuals

Customer Value of PJM Membership Liquid and Competitive Market Access to Diverse Supply from Historic Supply Sources Encourages New Generation Promotes Retail Access Lower Administration Charges in Long Term Timing of Start-Up Much Sooner Transmission Service By End of 2002 Full LMP/Market Implementation by End of 2003

Other Benefits to IP of Joining PJM Transparent and Robust Market Experienced Operator Has Been Up and Running for a Number of Years Already Worked through Start-Up Problems Efficient Stakeholder Process All Transmission Owners Offer Retail Choice Rate Design Doesn’t Shift Costs to Others Results in Greater Opportunity to Recover Transmission Revenue Requirement Quick Start-Up

Why Not MISO? Strands Illinois Power: IPs Only Strong Interconnection With MISO Is Ameren, and Ameren Has No ATC Either Into or Out of IP For This Summer Historic Supply Is Not Sourced From Ameren Generation Exports Don’t Serve Ameren Inefficient Stakeholder Process Few Transmission Owners Offer Retail Choice Rate Design Results in Cost Shift and Traps Generation in MISO (discouraging new generation) Market Start-Up Delayed Until Late 2004/Early 2005

Why Not MISO? Inexperienced Operator Numerous Start-up Problems Inaccurate ATC OASIS Frequently Down Slow Response to Service Requests Slow Response to Customer Inquiries Over 55 FERC Tariff Change Filings in Last 1 ½ Years Killed Liquidity at Cinergy Hub, which was One of the Most Liquid Trading Points in Industry Degradation of Service from Pre-MISO

Illinois Power’s Commitment Illinois Power is Fully Committed to Joining PJM Will Join as a Transmission Owner, or Part of Independent Transmission Company Illinois Power Does Not Intend to Spend Any More Money Toward Start-Up of an RTO Until FERC Issues a Final and Unequivocal Order. Illinois Power Already Spent $6.5 million to Leave MISO and $7.5 million to Develop ARTO. Annual Net Income for Transmission is Only ~ $7.9 Million/Year.