Postmodernity vs postmodernism

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Structuralism Semiotic. Definition Semiotic / semiology => The study of sign and sign-using behavior a domain of investigation that explores the nature.
Advertisements

We’ll play Name That Critical Approach game at the end, so be ready!
Between Gazes Camelia Elias. postfeminism in cultural studies  encompasses the intersection of feminism with postmodernism, poststructuralism, and post-colonialism.
Sociological Imagination and Investigation Lecture 2: What can we know and how do we know it? The philosophical presuppositions of sociological thinking.
Biographical and Historical Criticism P37 Critical Approaches.
Warm Up #9 Write a short poem in the style of Romanticism (remember: not romance, but the ideas of the Romantic Movement) about any topic you want.
INTRODUCTION TO LITERARY CRITICISM LITERARY CRITICISM Literary criticism is the art of judging and commenting on the qualities and character of literary.
Post-structuralism and deconstruction
The French Lieutenant’s Woman. Published:1969 Set: between 1867 and 1869 Historiographic Metafiction Linda Hutcheon “ well-known and popular novels which.
POSTMODERNISM Vincenzo D’Angelo 5°A. HYSTORICAL BACKGROUND After the World War II general rethinking over the function of literature and arts characterized.
LITERARY THEORY 101.
Warm Up Examine the ink blot on the slide. What do you see in the image? Write down a short explanation of what you see in the space provided. Be prepared.
Frames of Analysis of Heritage Tourism Critical Discourse Analysis.
“Old” Historicism vs. New Historicism
A definition of postmodernism that I found is: a late 20th-century style and concept in the arts, architecture, and criticism, which represents a departure.
Dr. Fernando de Toro Metafiction The Theory and Practice of Self-Conscious Fiction.
BOOK CIRCLES ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES. Discussion Director ***This is the only required role. Job Description: Your job is to develop a list of questions.
There is no absolute truth.  Post WWII literature  Reaction against enlightenment ideas in Modernist literature.
Lecture 1/Term 3: Postmodernity/Postmodernism Dr Claudia Stein.
An Introduction, as adapted from the Bedford Reader Critical Approaches to Literature.
AN OVERVIEW OF SOME 'CRITICAL APPROACHES' FOR LITERARY ESSAYS How do we think about what we read?
Ways of Conceiving of the Relationship Between History and Literature The “Old” Extrinsic View (“Old” Historicism) History is “objective”; i.e., history.
INSTRUCTOR: Eileen Wade, Ed.D. POSTMODERNISM 3-1.
Critical Approaches to Literature
Introduction to Criticism
Literary Postmodernism
Literary Analysis Writing Today Johnson-Sheehan, Paine Chapter 8
Introduction to Criticism
Notes on “shape” of a story
DEFINITION CDA is an analytical research methodology that proposes a study of the relations between discourse, power, dominance and social inequality Accordingly,
Postmodernism and Deconstructionism
Today’s goals Essay 2 Machiavelli Group Passage Work and Presentation
Introduction to Critical Lenses
Analyzing Literature.
The Elements of Fiction
Literary Analysis Writing Today Johnson-Sheehan, Paine Chapter 8
A film by Spike Jonze Written by Charlie (and Donald Kaufman)
Reading Interests of Adults
What is the novel? E.M. Forster in Aspects of the Novel cites the definition of a Frenchman named Abel Chevalley: "a fiction in prose of a certain extent"
Definitions, Important Concepts, Major Figures, and Uses
Introduction to the Humanities
Ambiguities & epistemology (ways to know and produce knowledge): documentary as organized ethnographic texts SM6324 Dr. Linda C.H. LAI.
What we know so far in English!
A film by Spike Jonze Written by Charlie (and Donald Kaufman)
Literary Criticism An Introduction.
A Tale of two cities Honors English 9
Postmodernism Aims of Lesson:
Postmodernism English 230B.
DAY 2 No text without context.
NEW HISTORICISM/ CULTURAL STUDIES
LITERARY THEORIES ENG4U.
NEW HISTORICISM/ CULTURAL STUDIES
Section A: Question 1 B: Theoretical Evaluation of Production
Formal Features of Literature
Connections and Cultural experiences (What is quality literature?)
Semiotics Structuralism.
Independent Reading Project
Return to Text Anton Pokrivčák University of Trnava
What is Stylistics? Stylistics is the science which explores how readers interact with the language of (mainly literary) texts in order to explain how.
Issues of Subjectivity and Identity
What is a New Wave? The term ‘New Wave’ exists across different a range of forms. There are new waves in painting, music, fashion, literature and theatre.
Media.
Feminist stylistics.
Comment on Students’ Stories, And A Guide to Literary Criticism
Standards RL Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the.
Being Brilliant in English
Postmodernity/Postmodernism Dr Claudia Stein
Module C REPRESENTATION AND TEXT
INTERTEXTUALITY To learn about the concept of intertextuality and how it works.
Haroun Essay—Advice for 2019
Presentation transcript:

Postmodernity vs postmodernism The former she understands to mean "the designation of a social and philosophical period or 'condition'" (Politics 23), specifically the period or "condition" in which we now live. The latter she associates with cultural expressions of various sorts, including "architecture, literature, photography, film, painting, video, dance, music" (Politics 1)

 highlights the importance of crossing borders between disciplines, media, and nations, as well as of positioning oneself as a reader and critic. Other topics included her own intellectual background in comparative literature, in Canadian Studies, and in her more recent interdisciplinary projects on opera; recent developments in and since postmodernism; and the interconnections within her work on various practices of repetition with a difference, whether seen as postmodern, as parody, or as adaptation.

Postmodern Fiction Postmodernist representation Re-presenting the past What we tend to call postmodernism in literature today is usually characterized by intense self-reflexivity and overtly parodic intertextuality.(Hutcheon)

For linda Hutcheon the postmodern is much more an artistic style, recognisable by its self reflectivity and irony especially in its relations to the practices and objects of the surrounding culture and the cultural past. Postmodern work often takes the form of parody or pastiche , which has a highly divided and ambivalent(doubtful) relation to its objects of imitation.

Specifically, Hutcheon suggests that postmodernism works through parody to "both legitimize and subvert that which it parodies" (Politics, 101). "Through a double process of installing and ironizing, parody signals how present representations come from past ones and what ideological consequences derive from both continuity and difference" (Politics, 93). Thus, far from dehistoricizing the present or organizing history into an incoherent and detached pastiche, postmodernism can rethink history and shed light on new critical capacities.

Hutcheon coined the term historiographic metafiction to describe those literary texts that assert an interpretation of the past but are also intensely self-reflexive (critical of their own version of the truth as being partial, biased, incomplete, etc.) (Poetics, 122-123). Historiographic metafiction, therefore, allows us to speak constructively about the past in a way that acknowledges the falsity and violence of the "objective" historian's past without leaving us in a totally bewildered and isolated present.

Her approach to transtextuality… Transtextuality can be seen as a “first degree of metafictional devices(Perez Bovie,, Hornby). “Second Degree”: Diegetic narcissism” and “linguistic narcissm” (Linda Hutchinson, breaking the “realistic contract” in the realm of the diegesis or the discourse)

Though conscious of the many terms used to describe metafictional narratives, some with pejorative bias, Hutcheon suggests a figurative adjective, ‘narcissistic’, to name this kind of fiction, mainly for its descriptive and suggestive character. Indeed, it is an “ironic allegorical reading of the Ovidian Narcissus myth” (p.1), elaborated as an answer to the ‘Ovidian’ mourners of the novel’s death.

Hutcheon says that The Narcissus myth was first used by Freud to refer to the “universal original condition” of man. When transposed to the metafictional context, narcissistic narrative “is process made visible” (p. 6); in other words, a process-oriented mode of self-reflexive and autorepresentational narrative.

It is the sort of narrative that contains its own critical commentary in itself, what determines, according to Hutcheon, the theoretical framework of reference for its investigation. Hutcheon argues that metafiction moves the focus from the reader and the author as individual historical agents to the processes of reception and production of language (1984, p. xiv).

parody “Bad” by Michael Jackson >> “Fat” by Weird Al http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-oQBBLT9E4 “I’m Elmo and I Know It” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWF86D_UNxc

Postmodernist Representation Anti-realism “ . . . Many postmodern strategies are openly premised on a challenge to the realist notion of representation that presumes the transparency of the medium and thus the direct and natural link between sign and referent or between words and world” (Hutcheon, Politics, 34).

Postmodernist Representation Metafiction Fiction about fiction; Narcissistic narrative “Fiction that includes within itself a commentary a commentary on its own narrative and/or linguistic identity” (Hutcheon, Narcissistic Narrative, 1)

Re-presenting the past Intertextuality Nostalgia or Transgression? Pastiche or parody?

Parody (Linda Hutcheon) Postmodern fiction = historiographic metafiction = narratives of double-coded politics

Parody (Linda Hutcheon) “The prevailing interpretation is that postmodernism offers a value-free, decorative, de-historicized quotation of past forms and that this is a most apt mode for a culture like our own that is oversaturated with images. Instead, I would want to argue that postmodernist parody is a value-problematizing, denaturalizing form of acknowledging the history (and through irony, the politics) of representations.” (Hutcheon, Politics, 94)

Parody (Linda Hutcheon) “What I mean by ‘parody’ . . . is not the ridiculing imitation of the standard theories and definitions . . . . The collective weight of parodic practice suggests a redefinition of parody as repetition with critical distance that allows ironic signalling of difference at the heart of similarity. In historiographic metafiction . . . This parody paradoxically enacts both change and cultural continuity” (Hutcheon, Poetics, 26)

Linda Hutcheon, cites “The French Lieutenant’s Woman” as an example of postmodern historiographic metafiction, that it is an “example of doubled narrative” (Hutcheon, 1995, p. 84). She writes about the novel” “…the specificity of Victorian social and literary theory is evoked (in tandem with both the fictional narrative and the metafictional commentary).

Through footnotes which explain details of Victorian habits, vocabulary, politics, or social practices. Sometimes a note is used to offer a translation for modern readers, who just might not be able to translate Latin quite as easily as their Victorian forebears could.

Obviously, part of the function of these postmodern notes is extra-textual, referring us to a world outside the novel, but there is something else going on too: most of the notes refer explicitly to other texts, other representations first, and to the external world only indirectly through them” (Hutcheon, 1993, p. 84).

Hutcheon also speaks about another role of footnotes: they function “as self-reflexive signals to assure the reader as to the historical credibility of the particular witness or authority cited, while at the same time they also disrupt our reading – that is, our creating – of a coherent, totalizing fictive narrative” (Hutcheon, 1993, p. 85).