TMAC Risuasis Nanminilgit Tukligikhat 2 Hope Bay Havanga TMAC Resources Inc.’s Phase 2 Hope Bay Project Nunavut Impact Review Board Pre-Hearing Conference Cambridge Bay June 15-16, 2017 TMAC Risuasis Nanminilgit Tukligikhat 2 Hope Bay Havanga Nunavut Avatiligiyit Katimayit Naalaktitiniahaqtitlugit Katimaniq Ikaluktutiak Juni 15-16, 2017

Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC)’s Role in the Nunavut Impact Review Board (NIRB) Review of the Proposed Phase 2 Hope Bay Project Nunaqaqaqtuligiyit Ukiurtaqtumilu Havaktit Kanata (INAC)-kut Havangi tapkunani Nunavut Avatiligiyit Katimayit (NIRB-kut) Naunaiyaqni tapkuat Uuktutit Tikligikhat 2 Hope Bay Havanga Responsible Minister: Has decision- making role under the Nunavut Agreement and Nunavut Project Planning and Assessment Act (NuPPAA) Intervenor: Provide expert advice Regulator: Administer Crown land, inspect and enforce conditions of the water licence Havalik Minihitauyuq: Ihumaliugutilik malikhugit tapkuat Nunavut Angigutit tapkuatlu Nunavut Havangi Parnaiyainiq Qauyihainiqlu Piquyat (NuPPAA) Pityutilik: Piqaqtitni ayuitnilgit uqautyinit Aulattiyi: Aulatai Quinguyup nunat, qauyihaqni atugiaqaqtitnilu atugiaqaqni tamna imaqmun laisa Photo: Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada

Nainaqhimayut tapkuat INAC-kut Piqatauni Naunaiyaqninut tapkuat Tukligikhat 2 Hope Bay Havanga Summary of INAC’s Participation in the Review of the Phase 2 Hope Bay Project Scoping Attended the NIRB community scoping meetings Comments on project scope to the NIRB NIRB Information Sessions Attended the NIRB community info sessions Information Requests (IRs) Fifty-one (51) IRs submitted to the NIRB Technical Review Comments (TRCs) Thirty-five (35) TRCs submitted to the NIRB Technical Meeting and Pre-Hearing Conference Havakhait Piqatauniq NIRB-kut nunalikni havakhai katimanit Uqauhit havanguyup havakhait NIRB-kutnut NIRB-kut Tuhagakhat Katimani Piqatauniq NIRB-kut nunalikni tuhagakhat katimani Tuhagakhat Tukhiqni (Irs-ngi) Avatik malguk qulitlu-tallimatlu (51) Irs-ngi tuniyauyut NIRB-kutnut Pitquhiliqutit Naunaiyaqni Uqauhit (TRCs- ngi) Avatit qulitlu-tallimatlu (35) TRCs-ngi tuniyauyut NIRB-kutnut Pitquhiliqutit Katimaniq Naalaktitiniahaqtitlugitluj Katimaniq

Nainaqhimayut tapkuat INAC-kut Piqatauni Naunaiyaqninut tapkuat Tukligikhat 2 Hope Bay Havanga Uuktut Avatiliqutit Aktuanit Uqauhit (DEIS) Summary of INAC’s Review of the Phase 2 Hope Bay Project Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) INAC provided expertise on the following: Biophysical Environment (19 TRCs) Surface Water Quality (6 TRCs) Surface Water Quantity/Hydrology (3 TRCs) Marine Water Quality (1 TRC) Tailings Management (3 TRCs) Waste Rock Management/ARD (4 TRCs) Closure Planning (2 TRCs) Socio-economics (16 TRCs) INAC-kut piqaqtitai ayuitnilgit tahapkununga : Uumatyutit Takukhauni Avatigiyai (19 TRCs-ngi) Maniqami Immap Nakuunia (6 TRCs-ngi) Maniqami Imaq Anginia/Imaliqut (3 TRCs) Tagiumi Imaq Nakuunia (1 TRC-ngi) Kuvittaqvit Aulatauni (3 TRCs-ngi) Iqakut Uyaqat Aulatauni/ARD-ngi (4 TRCs- ngi) Umiknianut Parnaut (2 TRCs-ngi) Inuliqutit-maniliugutit (16 TRCs)-ngi

Maniqami Imaq Nakuunia Surface Water Quality Modelling of mixing / stratification of water column near effluent discharge outlet in Aimaokatalok Lake Cryo-concentration ratios Predicted parameter concentration increases above baseline Incomplete data to assess Aimaokatalok Lake water quality impacts Maniqami Imaq Nakuunia Uuktugautit akutnit / allatqikni imaq kikliqaqni haniani halumailgut imait kuvigiaqvia talvani Aimaokatalok Lake Cryo-katyihimani avihimanit Nalautagat uuktugautai katihimani ilagiagutai qulaani huniumaitni ilitquhit Iniqhimaittut tuhagakhat tikittaqnianut Aimaokatalok Tahiq imaq nakuunia aktuanit

Maniqami Imaq Anginia / Imaliqut Atuinangitai piplugit tuhaqhitainiq tapkuatlu ihuaqhigiaqni kinittaqnit tuhagakhat Aallatqikni inai paniqpaliani aktilat Qauyihaqni amiakut aktuanit maniqami imaq anginia Tagiuqmi Imaq Nakuunia Atuqni nunavaluit tulitqtautit hanayauninut tamna Roberts Bay uhinut tulakvik Surface Water Quantity / Hydrology Inconsistent use of reported versus adjusted precipitation data Discrepancy in site lake evaporation amount Assessment of residual impacts on surface water quantity Marine Water Quality Use of silt curtains in construction of Roberts Bay cargo dock

Kuvittaqvik Aulataunia Tailings Management Analysis of the stability of Boston and Doris tailings management areas Characterization of risk of failure for Doris tailings management structures Waste Rock Management Characterization of potentially-acid generating and non-acid generating rock Storage of waste rock on surface Plans to segregate waste rock Annual monitoring of pollution from mine site at freshet Kuvittaqvik Aulataunia Qauyihaqni hunialaitni tamna Boston tamnalu Doris kuvittaqvik aulataunia nunai Ilitquhit hivuganaqni atuttiangitni taphumunga Doris kuvittaqvit aulatauni hanahimayut Iqakut Uyaqat Aulatauni Ilitquhit huguilaqnit huguilaitnitlu uyaqat Tutqumani iqakut uyaqat maniqami Parnautit hanivaqninut iqakut uyaqat Ukiumun munagini halumaiqtautit uyagakhiuqvikmin mahaktiqniani

Umikniani Parnaiyainiq Closure Planning Consideration of revegetation in closure planning Use of remediated soils for reclamation Umikniani Parnaiyainiq Ihumagiyauni nautialiqtutqikhaqni umikniani parnaiyainiq Atuqni halumaqhaqni nunat halumaqhainiqmun Photo: Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada

Inuliqutit-Maniliugutit Socio-Economics Incorporation of public concerns and preferences into alternatives assessment Spatial and temporal boundaries Baseline data: gaps and confidence Several valued socio-economic components excluded from CEA Mechanisms for reporting / communicating results of cumulative effects monitoring are unclear Inuliqutit-Maniliugutit Ilaliutyaqni inungnit ihumaalutit atugumaniqhailu ahiagugutaulanut qauyihaqni Inikhait atulaknilu kikligiyai Huniumaititlugu ilitquhi tuhagakhat : piilgut pilagahuguinilu Qaphit pinnagiyat inuliqutit-maniliugutit ilagiyai ilaungititni tapkunanga CEA Havagutai tuhaqhitainiqmun / tuhaumatyutit qanugitni katiqhuqninit aktuanit munagini naunapyaktut

Inuliqutit-Maniliugutit Socio-Economics Inugiaknit hiamaumanilu Iglumiutagit inuliqutit qanugitnit Akinahuagutauni nunalikni havaktikhat ahiilu nanminilgit piyaqaqnit Tikipkaqni / aulaqtitni imiqluit pittailiyauyutlu hunat Ilaliutyaqni tapkuat IQ-ngi munaqhityutinut havagutai Socio-Economics Population and demographics Household social structures Competition for local labour and other business needs Import / export of alcohol and prohibited substances Integration of IQ into monitoring programs

Iniqtigutit Conclusions Tuhagakhat, qauyihainiq hatqiqtitnilu hunat talvani DEIS-ngi tamaitnut naamagiyauyut Kihimik, ilai piplugit tapkuat havanguyuq qauyihaqpaligialgit/naunaittiaqni Aturniqhat ihumaalutit tugangayut ilainut tahapkuatut maniqami imaq nakuunia anginialu, tagiumi imaq nakuunia, kuvittaqvit iqakutlu uyaqat aulatauni, umikniani parnaiyainiq inuliqutitlu-maniliugutit INAC-kut tukhiqhimayai tapkuat ilagiagutit tuhagakhat qauyihaqnilu piqaqtitauni TMAC-kut atuqpiagahuaqni piqaqtitni ilagiagutit tuhagakhat tapkunani Kingulliqpaq Avatiliqutit Aktuani Uqauhit INAC-kut takuniaqtai ukuat tuhagakhat tukliani tukligikhat naunaiyaqni pityuhit Conclusions Information, analysis and presentation of material in DEIS is generally acceptable However, some aspects of the project require further assessment/validation Key concerns relate to aspects such as surface water quality and quantity, marine water quality, tailings and waste rock management, closure planning and socio-economics INAC has requested that additional information and assessment be provided TMAC has made commitments to provide additional information in the Final Environmental Impact Statement INAC will look at this information in the next phase of the review process

Merci Koana ᖁᔭᓐᓇᒦᒃ Thank you Photo: Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada