What is the difference between these two situations?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
What is a normative theory?
Advertisements

Utilitarianism.
Normative Ethics Metaethics ETHICS
Utilitarianism Guiding Principle 5.
Chapter Seven: Utilitarianism
UTILITARIANISM: A comparison of Bentham and Mill’s versions
Utilitarian Approach. Utilitarianism The founder of classical utilitarianism is Jeremy Bentham. According to Bentham human beings always try to avoid.
Consequentialist Theories of Ethics. Do Consequences make an action right? Many ethicists have argued that we should decide moral right and wrong by looking.
 The benefits of embryo research come mainly from stem cell usage  it is hoped that stem cells can be stimulated to develop any tissue or organ of the.
Utilitarianism Lesson # 4 Leadership and Ethics. Utilitarianism What is Utilitarianism?
The Morality of Consequences. Utilitarian Ethics We ought to perform actions which tend to produce the greatest overall happiness for the greatest number.
Ethics LL.B. STUDIES 2015 LECTURE 2. Part one Mapping ethics.
Ethics A look at the reasons behind decisions about what is right and wrong. What is the right thing to do?
Utilitarian approach to war and peace BY PHIL, ISAAC AND BAASIM.
Consequentialism Is it OK to inflict pain on someone else? Is it OK to inflict pain on someone else? What if it is a small amount of pain to prevent a.
Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism Learning Objectives:- (long term) 1. To understand the ‘greatest happiness principle’. 2. To understand the similarities.
Chapter 3: How Can I Know What is Right?
Utilitarianism is a theory about what we ought to do. It states that we should always choose actions which produce the greatest amount of happiness for.
‘UTILITARIANISM FROM BENTHAM & MILL’ THE GENERAL PRINCIPLES
LO: I will know about the Hedonic Calculus Hmk: Do some biographical work on John Stuart Mill Starter: Using your homework, what did you find out about.
Ethics A look at the reasons behind decisions about what is right and wrong. What is the right thing to do?
Consequentialism (utilitarism). General description 'Consequentialist theories regard the moral value of actions, rules of conduct, and so on, as dependent.
‘The New Testament principle of Agape is a better guide to ethical decision making than the Utilitarian principle of happiness.’ Discuss. Robert Brown.
Utilitarianism.
Tips for revision  Issues that have been asked about less:  Genetic Engineering  Embryo Research  Right to a Child  Theories that have been asked.
Religious Studies RELIGIOUS STUDIES OCR Specification 5. Religious ethics.
LO: I will explain Peter Singer’s approach to Utilitarianism H/W: Remember, assessment next lesson 10 th.
Hello Year 12!!! Welcome to AS Level Religious Studies
Utilitarianism Learning outcome:
Utilitarianism.
The Motivation of Human Beings
Rule Utilitarianism To understand later developments in Utilitarianism and the works of Mill and Singer.
Introduction to Ethics
Utilitarianism Learning Intention:
John Stuart Mill.
Introduction to Ethics
Lesson 1 – Introduction to ethics
Welcome Back! A2 Philosophy.
Recap on Ethical Theory
Utilitarianism - Introduction
Utilitarianism: Modern Applications of the theory
Industrial Revolution
Utilitarianism - Introduction
Utilitarianism: John Stuart Mill
Mill and Bentham’s Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism – John Stuart Mill
On your whiteboard: What is teleology? What is hedonism?
John Stuart Mill What do we know about him already?
Education for Justice (E4J)
Moral Reasoning  Ethical dilemmas in management are not simple choices between “right” and “wrong”.They are complex judgments on the balance between economic.
I think the principle of utility is…
Moral Reasoning  Ethical dilemmas in management are not simple choices between “right” and “wrong”.They are complex judgments on the balance between economic.
OBE 117 BUSINESS AND SOCIETY.
Something to think about…
Bentham’s Utilitarianism
20th century conflict day one
John Stuart Mill ( ).
Utilitarianism: Jeremy Bentham.
Agenda Warm Up Industrialization Project Fair or Unfair Candy
Ethical Language / Meta-Ethics
Ethical Language / Meta-Ethics
Moral Reasoning  Ethical dilemmas in management are not simple choices between “right” and “wrong”.They are complex judgments on the balance between economic.
Homework 1 Powerpoints.
Utilitarianism - Introduction
Utilitarianism – Bentham’s Classic Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism Consequential, i.e. Utilitarianism – a good moral decision is that which the consequences of the action produces the greatest good for the.
Theme 3 – Teleological Ethics – Situation Ethics
Moral Reasoning  Ethical dilemmas in management are not simple choices between “right” and “wrong”.They are complex judgments on the balance between economic.
On your whiteboard: List the strengths and weaknesses of act utilitarianism.
Utilitarianism – Bentham’s Classic Utilitarianism
Presentation transcript:

What is the difference between these two situations? Utilitarianism: An Introduction Can you think of an example where a desirable consequence justifies an ‘wrong’ action? Can you give an example where are desirable consequence does not justify a ‘wrong’ action? What is the difference between these two situations?

Introducing Utilitarianism: You have just moved to a new country. You like your new house and the weather is great. Everything is going well although this country has a Life Lottery. Every month, one person is picked at random and they are killed for their organs. Their organs are all used and can help 20 different people who need transplants. What would be the purpose of this type of system? Could it ever be theoretically justified? Bentham argues that humans are motivated by pleasure and pain. Bentham was a hedonist (greek for pleasure). They want to maximise pleasure and minimise pain.

Ethics Virtue Theory Normative ethics Meta- ethics Applied ethics Absolutist normative Ethics Relativist normative ethics Environment Teleological Sexual Ethics Deontological Virtue Theory War and Peace Situation ethics Equality Natural Moral Law Utilitarianism Kantian ethics Medical Ethics

Utilitarianism: Type of theory From the diagram above you need to complete the following sentences: Utilitarianism is a …………….ethical theory. This means that morality is derived from the potential …………….of actions. This is a branch of ……………..ethics, which means that the theory aims to determine how individuals should ……in different situations. Bentham argues that humans are motivated by pleasure and pain. Bentham was a hedonist (greek for pleasure). They want to maximise pleasure and minimise pain.

Utilitarianism: Type of theory From the diagram above you need to complete the following sentences: Utilitarianism is a Teleological Ethical theory. This means that morality is derived from the potential consequences of actions. This is a branch of Normative Ethics, which means that the theory aims to determine how individuals should act in different situations. Bentham argues that humans are motivated by pleasure and pain. Bentham was a hedonist (greek for pleasure). They want to maximise pleasure and minimise pain.

Utilitarianism: the basics In essence, Utilitarianism states that you should act in a way which will benefit the most amount of people in society. The rightness or wrongness is judged by it’s utility: the measure of how useful it is at producing goodness for the majority. THINK/ PAIR/ SHARE: Can you think of any examples of actions that might benefit the majority of people in society? Why do they benefit the majority? What is the good consequence they produce? Bentham argues that humans are motivated by pleasure and pain. Bentham was a hedonist (greek for pleasure). They want to maximise pleasure and minimise pain.

Social Context: Questions What did Robert Goodin mean when he claimed “Utilitarianism is whatever stripe is, first and foremost, a standard for judging public action”? For whom was Bentham’s act utilitarianism beneficial to and why? What was Bentham’s aim in society? What was Bentham’s views on religion?

The social and intellectual background to Utilitarianism When did the theory develop? Mid 18th Century Where was it developed? London By whom? Jeremy Bentham What had the greatest influence upon its development? The social impact of the Industrial Revolution

The Industrial Revolution: Began in Britain in the late 1700’s Prior to this manufacturing was often done in people’s homes, using hand tools and basic machinery Industrialisation marked a shift to powered, special-purpose machinery, factories and mass- production.

Advantages consequences of the Industrial Revolution Strengthened economy: higher production rates, higher quality and diversity of goods Improved systems of transportation Improved systems of communication and banking Raised standards of living for the middle and upper classes

1. The Motivation of Human Beings 2. The principle of Utility Jeremy Bentham 1. The Motivation of Human Beings 2. The principle of Utility 3. The Hedonic Calculus John Stuart Mill Rule Utilitarianism Act Utilitarianism Bentham argues that humans are motivated by pleasure and pain. Bentham was a hedonist (greek for pleasure). They want to maximise pleasure and minimise pain. Preference Utilitarianism Negative Utilitarianism Ideal Utilitarianism

Negative consequences of the Industrial Revolution Increased homelessness and poverty, especially in big cities Low wages and little job security for unskilled workers Poor working conditions Increased child labour Increased alcoholism and prostitution

Why Utilitarianism? THINK- PAIR- SHARE: How does the Bentham's classic act utilitarianism (perform actions which produce the most amount of good for the majority) address the social problems caused by the IR? Bentham's act utilitarianism addresses the problems caused by the Industrial Revolution because…

Social Context: Questions What did Robert Goodin mean when he claimed “Utilitarianism is whatever stripe is, first and foremost, a standard for judging public action”? For whom was Bentham’s act utilitarianism beneficial to and why? What was Bentham’s aim in society? What was Bentham’s views on religion?

Industrial revolution Recap plenary- pick at least 3 words from the selection below & explain them! Industrial revolution Consequentialist Jeremy Bentham Teleological Principle of Utility Relativist

HOMEWORK In preparation for next lesson, read through the information about Jeremy Bentham (the founder of classical act utilitarianism) and answer the questions below: When did Bentham develop his ideas of utility? What is the principle of utility? What is the role of governments, according to Bentham? How can happiness be attained according to Bentham?