Elaine Walklet1,2, Kate Muse2, Jane Meyrick1, Tim Moss1

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Authors and affiliation Research, University of Sheffield, 3 East Midlands Ambulance Service Study flow Conclusion In addition to measures relating to.
Advertisements

Accessing Sources Of Evidence For Practice Introduction To Databases Karen Smith Department of Health Sciences University of York.
Developing Research Proposal Systematic Review Mohammed TA, Omar Ph.D. PT Rehabilitation Health Science.
Progress with the literature reviews for the CHOICE programme Chris Dickens.
Results  81 papers were reviewed 55 papers psychoeducational interventions 19 papers educational interventions 14 papers multicomponent interventions.
O Type 2 diabetes has traditionally been managed as a single chronic disease state but it can commonly exist with co-morbidities such as depression. o.
What is the Evidence for Social Care Intervention in the Emergency Department? Introduction  The current health and social care delivery system is not.
Systematic Reviews.
Identifying the evidence Laura Macdonald Health Protection Scotland
EBM Conference (Day 2). Funding Bias “He who pays, Calls the Tune” Some Facts (& Myths) Is industry research more likely to be published No Is industry.
According to the MECIR conduct standards, item 41, it is now mandatory for authors to provide a PRISMA study flow diagram in their reviews. It is essential.
Can Web-based Interventions Increase Physical Activity Levels in People with MS? A Systematic Review Protocol Rachel Dennett 1* Kim Algie 1 Elaine Coulter.
Systematic Review Krit Pongpirul, MD, MPH. Johns Hopkins University.
LITERATURE REVIEW ARCHELLE JANE C. CALLEJO, PTRP,MSPH.
 Bullying is a significant problem for ~ 20% of youths › Numerous associated issues:  Internal & external psychological disorders  Physical and psychosomatic.
Psychodynamic Psychotherapy: A Systematic Review of Techniques, Indications and Empirical Evidence Falk Leichsenring & Eric Leibing University of Goettingen,
Depression Screening in Primary Care and Impact on Suicide Prevention Anne-Marie T. Mann, BSN, RN, DNP Candidate Diane Kay Boyle, PhD, RN, FAAN.
Non-pharmacological interventions to reduce psychological sequelae of mild traumatic brain injury: A systematic review Dr Nikola Creasey Paediatric Emergency.
Effects of Alcohol on U.S. Adolescent Sleep Patterns: A Systematic Review Nancy Carballo, MSIV Shahrzad Bazargan-Hejazi, PhD 2015 DIDARP 10 th Annual Drug.
Members of Eastern Health: Angliss Hospital, Box Hill Hospital, Healesville & District Hospital, Maroondah Hospital, Peter James Centre, Turning Point.
LITERATURE REVIEW OF DECISION MODELS FOR DISEASES WITH SHORT-TERM FLUCTUATIONS/EPISODES: The Case of COPD Dr. Orpah Nasimiyu Wavomba
A1 & A2 The aim: (separate) Critique a Qualitative study on “Telemonitoring of blood glucose and blood pressure in type 2 diabetes.” Critique a Quantitative.
Adverse Effects of Single Dose Gentamicin in Adults - A Systematic Review Hayward R S, Harding J, Molloy R, Land L, Longcroft-Neal K, Moore D, Ross J D.
CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE
What are the most effective treatment approaches to use to reduce fatigue for people with Multiple Sclerosis? A critical appraisal of the literature Samantha.
Discussion & Conclusion
FIGURE 3. FOREST PLOT AFTER CONTROLLING FOR NETWORK INCONSISTENCY
Effectiveness of yoga for hypertension: Systematic review and meta-analysis Marshall Hagins, PT, PhD1, Rebecca States,
Jones, Amy1; Anderson, S2; Murphy, T1 and Martino, D3.
Hamlet C1, Williamson H1, Moss T1, Meyrick, J2
Mediators and moderators of physical activity maintenance: a systematic review. Jennifer Murray1, Dr. Sarah Brennan1, Prof David French2, Prof Chris Patterson1,
Life expectancy and causes of death of people with
Works in progress The needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans* people (LGBT) who are affected by dementia: A comprehensive scoping review. Joanna Semlyen,
METHODS AND MATERIALS: SCIENTIFIC/CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE:
Kinship care for the safety, permanency, and well-being of children removed from the home for maltreatment: A Summary of a Systematic Review Erin Geary.
Presented by Renee Harrison, MSW University of Utah 2012
NURS3030H NURSING RESEARCH IN PRACTICE MODULE 7 ‘Systematic Reviews’’
TJTS505: Master's Thesis Seminar
Interprofessional Online Learning for Primary Health Care:
Jones, Amy1; Anderson, S2; Murphy, T1 and Martino, D3.
Complex abdominal wall reconstruction in the setting of contamination and active infection: a systematic review of fistula and hernia recurrence rates.
HEALTH PROMOTION, INTEGRAL CARE AND SOCIAL INCLUSION
Rachel Morell1, Simon Rosenbaum1,2 and Belinda J Parmenter1
The efficacy of interventions to improve psychosocial outcomes following surgical treatment for breast cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis Hannah.
Alessandro Andreucci, Paul Campbell, Kate Dunn
Supplementary Table 1. PRISMA checklist
The impact of transition on health
Literature review Dr.Rehab F Gwada.
Y W Liao1, S Shaman1, C S Chean1, S S Poon1, A Soltan1
Xiaoqi Sun, Suzanne H. So, Chen Zhu, Patrick W. Leung Background
Prognostic factors for musculoskeletal injury identified through medical screening and training load monitoring in professional football (soccer): a systematic.
Review of the Literature
Foroutan N1,2, Muratov S1,2, Levine M1,2
Lifestyle factors in the development of diabetes among African immigrants in the UK: A systematic review Alloh T. Folashade Faculty of Health and Social.
Finding the Literature for Systematic Reviews
Understanding methods for the assessment of patient adherence: a case study in removable devices for the improvement of trial outcome data Zoe Tolkien,
Preliminary results of a systematic review.
Wayne State University
Is performing a scoping review useful after recent Cochrane review?
Primary care healthcare professionals’ knowledge, attitudes and practices towards promoting the reduction of children’s secondhand smoke exposure Jaidev.
Therapeutic writing for eating disorders: A systematic review
Genevieve Young-Southward1 Christopher Philo2 Sally-Ann Cooper3
Complementary Art Interventions for Children Coping with Cancer:
Performing literature searches and using EndNote Online
Patient reported outcome measures for facial skin cancer: a systematic review and evaluation of the quality of their measurement properties Tom Dobbs,
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Trent Regional SAPC Conference 19 March 2019
How effective are primary care-led models of post-diagnostic dementia care? A systematic review Rachael Frost1, Kate Walters1, Su Aw2, Greta Brunskill3,
Systematic Review & Meta-analysis
Presentation transcript:

Elaine Walklet1,2, Kate Muse2, Jane Meyrick1, Tim Moss1 Do Psychosocial Interventions Improve Quality of Life and Wellbeing in Adults with Neuromuscular Disorders? A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis. Elaine Walklet1,2, Kate Muse2, Jane Meyrick1, Tim Moss1 1University of the West of England; 2University of Worcester Background and Aim Neuromuscular disorders (NMDs) are a heterogeneous group of acquired and inherited conditions affecting the neuromuscular system1. Most NMDS are progressive and incurable and are associated with many adverse psychosocial outcomes, such as reduced quality of life (QoL) and well-being2. Previous research has consistently found that psychosocial factors are better predictors of QoL than physical impairment in adults with NMDs3,4. A systematic review on the effectiveness of psychosocial interventions for improving QoL and well-being is therefore required. Aim – To systematically review the literature on the impact of psychosocial interventions on QoL and wellbeing in adults with neuromuscular disorders 2. Method Search strategy - PsycInfo, PsycArticles, Medline, CINAHL, AMED , Web of Science, CENTRAL, Conference Papers Index, Open Grey, hand searching, citation tracking, contacting experts. Inclusion/exclusion - (1) RCTs, CTs or cohort study, (2) 18+ with NMD diagnosis, (3) Psychosocial intervention, (4) QoL and/or well-being assessed as quantitative outcome, (5) Publication in English Study identification - Primary and secondary screening by EW and KM Appraisal of study quality - The Effective Public Health Practice Project (EPHPP) Quality Assessment Tool for Quantitative Studies4 Study synthesis – Narrative synthesis 3. Study selection Records identified through online databases (n = 4,130) Records identified through other sources (n = 5) Records screened after duplicates removed (n = 3136) Records excluded from title/abstract (n = 3,117) Full-text articles assessed for eligibility (n = 19) Studies included in narrative synthesis (n = 10) Full-text articles excluded (n = 9) Ineligible intervention (n = 4) Ineligible outcomes (n = 2) Data duplication/ no results (n = 2) Ineligible conditions (n = 1) Figure 1: PRISMA flow diagram 4. Results 50% of studies were for patients with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS). The remainder were for patients with post-polio syndrome (n = 1), muscular dystrophies (n = 1) and mixed groups of NMDs (n = 3). The range of interventions included: cognitive behavioural therapy (n = 3), dignity therapy (n = 1), hypnosis (n = 2), expressive disclosure (n = 1) , gratitude lists (n = 1), group psychoeducation (n = 1) and psychologically informed rehabilitation (n = 1). Across varied interventions and NMDs, 7 studies reported a short-term beneficial effect of intervention on QoL & well-being. However there were widespread issues with study quality, contrasting definitions/assessment of Qol/well-being, a lack of long-term follow-ups and limited consideration of moderators. Figure 2: EPHPP Quality Assessment Tool4 ratings for all included studies 6. References Hilton-Jones D, Freebody J, Stein J. Neuromuscular disorders in the adult: a practical manual. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press;2011. Piccininni M, Falsini C, Pizzi A. Quality of life in hereditary neuromuscular diseases. Acta Neurol Scand. 2004;109:113–9. Simmons Z, Bremer BA, Robbins RA, Walsh SM, Fischer S. Quality of life in ALS depends on factors other than strength and physical function. Neurol. 2000; 55(3):388–92. Graham CD, Weinman J, Sadjadi R, Chalder T, Petty R, Hanna MG, et al. A multicentre postal survey investigating the contribution of illness perceptions, coping and optimism to quality of life and mood in adults with muscle disease. Clin Rehabil. 2014;28(5):508–19. Contact: e.walklet@worc.ac.uk 5. Discussion and Conclusion There is currently no strong evidence to determine whether psychosocial interventions improve QoL and well-being in adults with NMD. Although some benefits were identified, they were almost exclusively short-term and subject to bias. The paucity of high quality research and confusion surrounding measurement of QoL and well-being impeded meaningful interpretation of findings. Further research with a strong emphasis on study quality, clearly defined outcomes and consideration of moderator variables is required to progress current understanding and inform recommendations for practice.