Paul Williams, Jonathan Mort Inc. The Legal Parameters of ESG:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 An overview of responsible investing and integration of environmental, social and governance factors Sam Collin EIRIS Foundation.
Advertisements

ESG Screening of Fund Managers Date: 10 th September 2013 Presented by: Kelly Christodoulou ESG Manager, Investments.
Performing a Fiduciary Review of Trust Administration FIRMA April 2009 Independent Fiduciary Services ® Independent Fiduciary Services, Inc.  th.
4 July 2005 Global Research of Investment Managers with Increasing Focus on SRI 13th Australian Colloquium of Superannuation Researchers Bruce Gregor.
Internal Control and Internal Audit
Brought to you by the Nationwide ® Advanced Consulting Group Best Practices When Working With Your 401(k) Clients.
Legal Structures for Social Enterprise Nicola Dickins Make it Happen Consultancy.
III Member Question Results “Being an UNPRI Signatory” November 14, 2014.
UNEP Training Resource Manual Topic 10 Slide 1. UNEP Training Resource Manual Topic 10 Slide 2 EIA is a process to: F gather information necessary for.
BUILDING TRUST IN YOUR COMMUNITY AROUND SCHOOL FINANCE ISSUES David Carlson, Director School Financial Services Team May 3, 2007.
Presentation Audit Committee Institute Ireland Conrad Hotel, Dublin 2 7 September 2004.
Pension Fund Forum Africa Presentation: Re-analysing Regulation 28: 12 Months Later – How Has It Changed the Playing Field Speaker: Jonathan Mort Company:
ESOPs: It’s More Than a Matter of Trust Presented by: Dan Reser President; Fiduciary Services, Inc
How to deal with the implications of New Regulation 28 Magda Wierzycka CEO SYGNIA ASSET MANAGEMENT.
IRF WORKSHOP PRESENTATION: THE CRISA CODE, RESPONSIBLE INVESTING AND ESG MARCH / APRIL 2012 Brandon Furstenburg Chief Operating Officer Mergence Investment.
Spelling Out a Strategy for Observing Good Governance in Managing Retirement Fund Faith Letlala 19 August 2013.
The most appropriate context for triple bottom line (or PPP/SRI) in South Africa F Makwetla RisCura.
Financial Management & Internal Control for Utility Companies Julia Barber, CPA and Sherman, Barber & Mullikin, CPAs Madison, IN
Supporting Solihull’s Voluntary Sector Effective Planning.
Paul Williams, Jonathan Mort Inc. The Legal Parameters of ESG: Do’s and don’ts for trustees.
Ray Ward Estate planning involving persons with a disability.
“The Role of CPSB and CASB in the Transformation and Growth of Counties” By CS Peterson Mwangi.
Welcome to the board Samantha LawryManager, Guidance and Education Manori GuntilakeCommunications Officer 9 March 2016.
Chapter 9 Mutual Funds as Institutional Investors.
The Malverns District.
In between two societal actors The responsibilities of SWFs towards human rights and climate change -- Eva van der Zee LLB PRI/Mistra Academic Conference.
Does pension funds' fiduciary duty prohibit the integration of environmental responsibility criteria in investment processes? A realistic prudent investment.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF ACTUARIES Copyright © 2016 American Academy of Actuaries. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced without express permission. PAGE.
The Illinois Secure Choice Savings Program
PENSION LAWYERS ASSOCIATION SEMINAR
Ethics: Guides for Professional Engagement
Introduction to the planning system for elected members​
An introduction to CIOs for Students’ Unions
PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY & QUALITY CONTROL
PRI – Service Provider Reporting 2017
District of innovation
What is responsible investment?
Providing assurance on risk management and controls
Engaging Trustees in Financial Management
UNEP FI has been talking about fiduciary duty and ESG integration for a long time.   Fiduciary duty may well be two of the most important words in finance.
Fiduciary Duty: Risk, Liability and Reward in a Changing Fiduciary Environment TUC Conference Paul Watchman 5 JUNE 2006.
Implications of Pension Reform (Governance) on Members and their Dependents Samantha Davidson 19 August 2013.
Auditing & Investigations II
Enhancing employers’ involvement in Social Protection policy debates
Pension funds and sustainable investment
Workers’ Capital Stewardship International Trade Union Perspectives
Accounting for superannuation plans
World Bank Land and Poverty Conference Mar 21, 2017
An Institutional Solution to Client Fund Management
TRUST ADMINISTRATION Paul B Davis, Higgs & Johnson
DTAS Annual Conference 2013 TRADING AND CHARITABLE STATUS
Introduction to GDPR 09/11/2018.
Costs, Fees, and Trustee Decision Making
The Public Sector Equality Duty
Communication and Consultation with Interested Parties by the RB
Using the EFQM Excellence Model to support the role of a trustee
IAEA General Conference Regulatory Cooperation Forum Regulatory Approach Prescriptive vs Performance Based David Senior Executive Director -
Investor protection and MIFID
Cost transparency of pension funds Dutch experiences
Accountability Issues in Proposal Writing
Governance and Audit Oversight for Capital Market
Fundraising with commercial partners
The Public Sector Equality Duty
Jonathan Mort Rowan Burger
Catholic School Councils: Making a Difference 1.1
Appointing a Management Agent
Duty of Loyalty.
Trustee.
Good Governance and an Effective Board of Trustees
CalPERS Update & Discussion
Presentation transcript:

Paul Williams, Jonathan Mort Inc. The Legal Parameters of ESG: Do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Introduction Why focus on the law? What does the law require? What are the parameters? How to work within the legal parameters? Conclusion: key messages The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Why focus on the law? Forms parameters of investment decision-making process Perspective: refer back to those parameters The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Legal requirements (1) – the common law Take account of, and weigh up, all relevant factors in pursuance of the purpose of the fund Cowan v Scargill: “when the purpose of the trust is to provide financial benefits…the best interests of beneficiaries are normally their best financial interests” UNEP-FI 2005 report (Freshfields opinion): “integrating ESG considerations into an investment analysis so as to more reliably predict financial performance is clearly permissible and arguably required....” ESG considerations relevant factors insofar as they affect performance The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Legal requirements (2) – Regulation 28 “A fund and its board must at all times apply the following principles…. Before making an investment in and while invested in an asset consider any factor which may materially affect the sustainable long term performance of the asset including, but not limited to, those of an environmental, social and governance character” Arguably goes no further than the common law Significant, as removes (at least some) uncertainty The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Trustees must not ignore ESG factors In theory permissible not to take ESG factors into account if have good reasons for it Primary goal must be performance/financial interests If not detrimental to financial interests, can arguably take ESG considerations into account for non-financial reasons The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Working within the parameters One size does not fit all Cost benefit analysis You cannot be an ostrich about this Pick the low hanging fruit The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Some practical steps Use your consultant’s expertise Devise a policy and include in your IPS Engage with your investment managers & custodians Extent to which they include ESG considerations in analysis What strategies do they adopt? PRI (Principles of Responsible) signatory? Voting policy and engagement with management – and do the two correspond? Include in tenders for new IMs and investment consultants Legally binding obligation in IMA Structure fees to incentivise long term performance Training Sign up to PRI – benefits of membership The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Conclusions – key messages Ignoring ESG a breach of trustee duty Financial interests still paramount One size does not fit all The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees Thank you for listening Any questions? The legal parameters of ESG: do’s and don’ts for trustees

Graph goes here