1999 Mastio Natural Gas Pipeline Survey

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
OptiShip ® Multi-carrier Shipping System. OptiShip ® customers save on average 13.6% of parcel shipping costs… OptiShip ® is a comprehensive system that.
Advertisements

Total Utility Management Services, LLC is committed to helping your organization make the best informed energy decisions with decades of cost-proven results.
3/16/20001 BPA’s traditional revenue stream varies with water supply (higher water conditions, higher revenues) BPA’s revenues from Slice are independent.
Evaluating and Managing Performance …..it’s not just about Vendors Yukon Procurement Conference February 16, 2015.
Loads Acting as a Resource Relationships with QSEs and LSEs
ECO 436 Natural Gas. ECO 436 David Loomis Natural Gas Unbundling in IL for Small Customers 1What are benefits to unbundling? 1What are the.
G 200 L 200 ISO NEW ENGLAND T H E P E O P L E B E H I N D N E W E N G L A N D ’ S P O W E R. COLD SNAP Overview of Proposed Options for Winter 2004/2005.
Total Quality, Competitive Advantage, and Strategic Management
5 Creating Customer Value, Satisfaction, and Loyalty
Regulatory Update Questar Gas Company Annual Account Management Customer Meeting Barrie L McKay September 16, 2014.
The Evolving Roles and Responsibilities of Gas Utilities In Today’s Markets Presented by: Hank Linginfelter Executive Vice President, Utility Operations.
Limited Proceedings Water & Wastewater Reference Manual1.
2013 Calendar Year Customer Survey Results
California’s Renewable Energy Credits (REC) Market Update
El Paso Corporation Nominations and Scheduling Customer Advisory Group Update May 14, 2009 Colorado Interstate Gas Company Wyoming Interstate Company Cheyenne.
1 New Mexico State University Santa Fe Conference 2005 Steve Rodgers Office of Markets, Tariffs & Rates—South Federal Energy Regulatory Commission March.
Prepared by Opinion Dynamics Corporation May 2006.
APPA Marketing Coalition A cooperative effort for APPA member utilities offering voice, video and/or Internet services APPA Broadband Conference San Francisco,
1 Is there LNG in California’s Future? “LNG: When East Meets West” Zeus Development Conference Long Beach, CA by David Maul Manager, Natural Gas Office.
© 2002 J.D. Power and Associates. All Rights Reserved 2002 Electric Utility Residential Customer Satisfaction Study Cedar Rapids, Iowa August 7, 2002 Presented.
Measurements Jaremilleta M. Arawiran January 22, 2010 Library Multifunction Room.
CEC Workshop January 24, 2003 January 24, 2003 Chris Price Market Development Wild Goose Storage Inc.
California Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee Oversight Hearing May 10, 2016 Southern California Edison Colin Cushnie Vice President,
September 25, 2001 Maryland Public Service Commission Retail Gas Market Conference Timothy S. Sherwood Department Head, Energy Acquisition.
. com Page 1 ENRON.COM Sketches for New Services Area May 18, 2000 *This presentation includes sample content from the Energy Transportation Services area.
ENRON TRANSPORTATION SERVICES Customer Service Review ETS Gas Logistics.
Sourcing Evaluation Life Cycle Go/No Go decision points Competition Alignment Discovery Con tract Modification Project Initiation Vendor Capabilities Contract.
Connecting the Dots in New England: NEPOOL’s IMAPP Initiative
Aligning the Gas and Electric Markets: EDF Solutions
Overview of Post-Project Evaluation in NEDO
A Business Leader’s Expectations of HR
California Product Offerings
Exceptional Fuel Costs in LMP
Cloud University Live: 8 Steps to Build Your Cloud Go to Market Plan
Operations Directors Conference October 9, 2001
“An Opportunity to Communicate”
Well Trained International
Light Rail Transit Project
Privileged and Confidential
Energy Enterprise Trading and Risk Management Industry Study
Operations Management
Transmission Pricing Options
The External Environment: Opportunities, Threats, Industry Competition, and Competitor Analysis 1.
Energy Day Strawman Proposal
Product Definition Chapter 4 Paul King.
Supply Chain Management Principles
NERSA presentation at the PPC meeting held on 24 May 2006
Transmission Outage Coordination
Privileged and Confidential
ETS eCommerce & eBusiness DRAFT.
SCANA Energy Marketing
Customer Service Review
ENRON TRANSPORTATION SERVICES BUSINESS REVIEW November 15, 2001
ALBUQUERQUE TEAM MEETING November 7, 2001
A Real Business Example Questions for Discussion
January 2014 Mutual Assistance Drill
Pseudo-tie business procedure
Chapter 14 Pricing Strategies and Tactics
Gas-Electric Coordination Can New Services Bridge the Divide?
December 9, 2005 Allison DiGrande, External Affairs Department, ISO/NE
Chapter 14 Sourcing Decisions in a Supply Chain
Strategy, Balanced Scorecard and Strategic Profitability Analysis
About LCRA LCRA is a conservation and reclamation district created by the Texas Legislature in It has no taxing authority and operates solely on.
Chapter 8 The Marketing Plan
Chapter 14 Sourcing Decisions in a Supply Chain
IBM Data Center Tech Support Survey Results
Pseudo-tie business procedure
4 FEASIBILITY STUDY KEY ACTIONS
1. 2 Operational Efficiency and Business process Performance Operational Efficiency and Business process Performance Just in Time Systems (J I T) Reductions.
How To Conduct Market Research For A Startup Idea?
Presentation transcript:

1999 Mastio Natural Gas Pipeline Survey Results for Transwestern Pipeline Company March 30, 2000

Mastio Index Rankings for Interstate Pipelines* High Score 100 The industry mean increased 2.2% from 1998 to 1999 Transwestern’s average score decreased .2% 90 80 70 NBPL TW NNG FGT All others 60 Transwestern’s overall ranking fell slightly, from 9th out of 46 to 11th out of 50. 50 40 30 20 10 Low Score *Includes all 50 interstate pipelines surveyed

Mastio Index The Mastio Index is a composite of the overall service, overall performance, overall preference and the 40 customer service attributes measured, weighted by the customer needs as defined by all 1,257 customers surveyed. The overall scores are converted to a 100 point scale with a higher score being preferable. “Overall service” 25% “Overall pipeline company performance” 25% “Rank in order of preference” 25% Need weighted composite of the 40 attributes 25% 100%

Glossary of Terms Mean - The average score of the information extracted from the number of respondents - thus, the mean can vary depending upon the data extracted Industry group - Industry respondents Focus Group - Customer list TW provided Mastio Industry mean - The average score from all 1,257 industry respondents Focus Group mean - The average score from all 23 focus group respondents Commercial - Marketing Commercial support - Market services Attributes - Mastio provided statements ranked by respondents on a scale of 1 to 5 Score/Rating - The respondents used a scoring system of 1 to 5 Rating Scale 1=Excellent 4=Below Average 2=Good 5=Poor 3=Average

Attributes Top 15 Attributes ranked in order of importance by all industry respondents in 1998 1. Transportation pricing is competitive 2. Dependability in agreements and commitments 3. Timely notifications before initiating restrictions 4. Accuracy in scheduled gas volumes 5. Accurate measurement of volumes 6. Reliability of primary firm gas transportation 7. Gas metering systems are accurate 8. Ability to negotiate discounts 9. Attitude of continuous improvement 10. Reps who listen well 11. Availability of capacity 12. Simple and straightforward scheduling 13. Responsive sales and service personnel 14. Pipeline understands your needs 15. Real-time pipeline operations information New Attributes added in 1999 and not yet ranked by industry 1. Trustworthiness of pipelines 2. Internet/EBB access to pipeline information

TW FOCUS GROUP

Customers in TW Focus Group* * PG&E (LDC) was a part of the TW Focus Group, but they did not respond to the survey. PG&E makes up 13.14% of TW’s revenue.

Customer Focus Group (cont’d) The following focus group customers were identified based on available data SoCal USGT Duke Energy Agave PNM Williams Energy None of TW’s Focus Group customers planning to switch pipelines within the next two years.

Transwestern Areas of Strength & Areas Needing Improvement* Areas of Strengths Areas Needing Improvement** Ability to negotiate discounts Storage service Reliability of primary firm gas transportation Competitive transport pricing Availability of capacity Timely notifications before initiating restrictions TW - 2.00 Mean - 1.89 Reps communicate clear tariff information TW - 2.20 Mean - 2.11 Responsiveness of voicemail systems TW - 2.06 Mean - 1.98 Gas pooling and aggregation service TW - 2.17 Mean - 2.12 Accurate, concise, & understandable contracts Mean - 2.17 * This is a list of TW’s top 5 strengths and the 5 areas that need to see the most improvement. It is based on an average of all 40 attributes rated by TW’s Focus Group. ** Even though these are below the mean, TW received a good to excellent rating.

COMPETITION

Overall Performance Scores By Industry Pipeline TW El Paso PGT Kern River NW Overall Performance Preference Service Needs Weighted Composite of 40 Attributes 2.17 2.49 2.16 2.47 3.09 2.44 2.38 2.19 2.80 2.13 2.23 25% 2.00 2.52 2.03 2.21 2.15 2.96 2.28 2.27 Average 2.25 2.60 2.34 2.42 Mean 2.95 2.24 Ranking 1 2 3 4 5

ACTION PLAN

Transwestern Action Plan Item Action 1. Timely notifications before initiating restrictions. 1. Evaluate sending e-mail notices on outages. Re-evaluate simplification of current outage posting format. Currently, gas control coordinators call customers and post notices on EBB. Proposed elimination of the SoCal Window through the SoCal Gas Industry Restructuring proceeding (summer of 2000). Validate EPSQ up front in the nomination process (11/99). E-mail scheduled cut notices to customers (10/99).

Transwestern Action Plan (cont’d) Item Action 2. Pooling and balancing services 3. Reps communicate clear tariff info 2. Implementation of the PG&E Market Center. Evaluate the implementation of similar market center services with other parties e.g. SoCal. Investigate the potential offering of SBS on TW. Evaluate delivery into a pool from IT and FT services. 3. Marketing will utilize face to face customer meetings to communicate tariff changes and new services. Increase the regulatory review of tariff changes with Market Services and Marketing from once per year to twice per year. Continue recently implemented Marketing and Market Services monthly meetings to facilitate consistent communications.

Transwestern Action Plan (cont’d) Item Action 4. Responsive voicemail systems 5. Accurate, concise, & understandable contracts 6. General 4. Implementation of telephone pick groups and backups in Marketing Group. Market Services monitor voicemail responsiveness through weekly random checking. 5. Initiate Document Control Project for 2000 implementation. Review of contract terms with new hire representatives on an on-going basis. 6. Marketing to implement scorecard with top revenue customers e.g. defining what is customer service. Follow-up on Mercer?

Transwestern Action Plan (cont’d) Item Action 7. Mastio Study 7. Follow up with Mastio on our feedback for enhancements for 2000 survey: Weight of the 40 attributes and overall questions. Further clarifications of attribute questions e.g. “Trustworthiness of pipeline”. Industry respondents re-rank attribute questions in order of importance for 2000.