A Test of Ecological Character Displacement between the Larvae of Two Cryptic, Sympatric Species of Two-lined Salamander, Eurycea wilderae and Eurycea.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Aquatic Ecologic Factors Effecting Salamander Population Growth in Five Falls Creek Lindsey Fraites Daniel Keeton Jason Mulvaney.
Advertisements

Intraspecific Competition in Viola Tricolor ABSTRACT Intraspecific competition is competition between members of the same species. In this experiment intraspecific.
Factors that Affect Productivity in Wintering Lakes: An Analysis of Lake Zones and Snow Depth Kristen Kernan Winter Ecology- Spring 2012.
Populations Widely separated populations have less opportunity to share gene pools Observable differences among populations occur and are maintained Groups.
Character Displacement. Brown & Wilson’s Definition: Two closely related species have overlapping ranges. In the parts of the ranges where one species.
Movement Patterns and Microhabitat of Red-Backed Salamanders (Plethodon cinereus) Introduction Studying movements and microhabitat of a common, widespread.
Lecture 10 Community Ecology. Today’s topics What is community ecology? Interspecific relationships Community Structure and Function Exam 1 review.
Size Ratios. The analysis of size ratios has been of interest to ecologists and evolutionary biologists Dyar (1890) described a constant increment of.
Systematics, Genetics and Speciation Fundamentals of Fish Biology September 10, 2008.
BIOE 109 Summer 2009 Lecture 11-Part II Speciation.
What does penis’ size matter? Evolution of male genitalia in Thermosphaeroma isopods Veijo Jormalainen 1 & Stephen Shuster 2 Hair density Penes shape Bodysize.
Mercury Bioaccumulation in Bluegill and Largemouth Bass from a Hunting and Fishing Site in South Carolina, USA Brandy Bossle* and Virginia Shervette, University.
True or False 1. Speciation can be observed only over millions of years. 2. Some features (such as the human eye) are too complex to evolve by natural.
A Study of the Red-Bellied Turtle (Pseudemys rubriventris) Population in Lake Marburg Located in Codorus Park,Hanover (PA) INTRODUCTION A population of.
Speciation SJCHS. Evolution Microevolution: Change in a population ’ s gene pool from generation to generation Speciation: When one or more new species.
Comparison of barn owl (Tyto alba) sex ratios between northeastern and southeastern regions of Pennsylvania Kaitlyn M. Pontuti* & Karl Kleiner Department.
Salamanders of Idaho Ambystomatidae Mole Salamanders Long-toed Salamander Long-toed Salamander Barred Tiger Salamander Idaho Giant Salamander Plethodontidae.
Chapter 13 Competition. Modes of Competition Interference vs. exploitation: –Direct aggressive interaction between individuals –Using up resource Intraspecific:
Option G: Ecology and Conservation Chpt. 18: pages
Evolution of the Mexican Axolotl 
Effects of Competition on Ambystoma Salamander Larvae Erica Reed April 17, 2006 BIO 299.
Figure 1. Map depicting the supposed evolutionary history of terrestrial leeches in North America. Shaded area represents the Appalachian Range. (●) Haemopis.
Species boundaries, phylogeography and conservation genetics of the red- legged frog (Rana aurora/drytonii) complex Presented by: Chris Burton & Matt Meyer.
Geography of Speciation Allopatric – Peripatric Parapatric Sympatric.
The geography of speciation
Fecal DNA typing to determine the fine scale population structure and sex-biased dispersal pattern of Eurasian otter (Lutra lutra) in Kinmen CHUAN-CHIN.
Integrative taxonomy Gustav Paulay Florida Museum of Natural History University of Florida.
© File copyright Colin Purrington. You may use for making your poster, of course, but please do not plagiarize, adapt, or put on your own site. Also, do.
Speciation and hybridization Where do species come from and where are they going? Darwin’s “Origin of Species” said little about how new species arise.
Ecological Speciation- Sticklebacks
Quadrat Sampling Chi-squared Test
By: Jessica Browne and Alanna MacDonald
All interactions between biotic factors that can impact an ecosystem
Comparison of Two Artificial Cover Object Grid Densities for Sampling Terrestrial Salamanders JohnRyan A. Polascik and Brian P. Mangan King’s College,
Metapopulations are groups of populations linked by immigration and emigration. High levels of immigration combined with higher survival can result in.
Aquatic, Watershed, and Earth Resources
MACROEVOLUTION AND THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES
What is a Species? Biological species = A population or group of populations whose members have the potential to interbreed with one another in nature.
Ecology -Communities (Part 2)-
WRITING PAPERS General Comments Structure and Scope of a Review Paper Structure of a Primary Research Paper A. Abstract B. Introduction C. Methods.
Claudia Tan Li Ying, Zeng Yiwen, Darren Yeo Chong Jinn
Scales of Ecological Organization
James Barry University of Glasgow Introduction
Speciation Changes in allele frequency are so great that a new species is formed Can be slow and gradual or in “bursts” Extinction rates can be rapid and.
Aquatic Macroinvertebrate Composition Over an Elevation Gradient
Development of New Species by Evolution
Scales of Ecological Organization
Ryan FitzGerald Morgan Tarleton State University Abstract Methods
The Fall Diet of Cave Salamanders (Eurycea lucifuga) from Pigeon Mountain Examined Using Non-Lethal Gastric Lavage Techniques Jacob Hutton, Kate Donlon.
A Contradiction in Genes: Phylogeography of the Black Mountain Salamander (Desmognathus welteri Barbour 1950) Jessica A. Wooten1, Zachary I. Felix2, and.
Gene-sequence analysis reveals at least three species hidden in Zausodes arenicolus Erin Easton November 13, 2008.
Biotic Interactions.
Plant Ecology - Chapter 6
COLLECTION SITE MYEIK, MYANMAR
Diversity of life form Ecological niche.
A Comparison of Riparian Vegetation Structures
COMMUNITY ECOLOGY I pp
COMMUNITY ECOLOGY PP
Speciation Changes in allele frequency are so great that a new species is formed Can be slow and gradual or in “bursts” Extinction rates can be rapid and.
Interactions in Ecosystems
Ecosystems.
Speciation Hyla chrysoscelis Hyla versicolor.
Learning Objectives To recognize and identify biotic and abiotic influences on ecosystems To be able to interpret and analyze population data of predator.
Macroevolution Speciation.
Unit 1: Diversity in Ecosystems
Lecture 3 Evolution.
Understanding Ecology and Ecosystems
Unit 1: 1.7 Evolution - Speciation
Sampling locations and IDs for accessions sequenced in this study.
Presentation transcript:

A Test of Ecological Character Displacement between the Larvae of Two Cryptic, Sympatric Species of Two-lined Salamander, Eurycea wilderae and Eurycea cirrigera Results Mean temperature for E. lucifuga = 11.81 C Stephen Owensby Kristina Coggins Carlos Camp Introduction We took head measurements associated with feeding (Adams, 2000) from specimens from all sampled populations: Snout-vent length (SVL), head length, head width, eye-to-nostril distance, head depth, gape width, and jaw length. Comparisons were made between species in allopatry and between species at each sympatric site (NC & PC) using MANCOVA, with SVL set as covariate. Discriminant function analysis (DFA) was used to classify species. Character displacement occurs when differences between similar species are amplified in areas of sympatry due to competition (ecological character displacement) or hybridization (reproductive character displacement). Ecological character displacement has been demonstrated in terrestrial salamanders of the genus Plethodon (Adams & Rohlf 2000). Two species of the Two-lined Salamander (Eurycea bislineata) species complex, the Southern Two-lined Salamander (E. cirrigera) and the Blue Ridge Two-lined Salamander (E. wilderae), are parapatrically distributed. The former species occurs in the Piedmont of the southeastern US, and the latter is located in the southern Appalachian Mountains (Lannoo 2005). Abstract Competition has been hypothesized to represent a powerful force in determining the interactions between similar species. One possible result of interspecific competition is resource partitioning, which in turn may result in ecological character displacement. Character displacement is a pattern in which two species with overlapping ecological requirements differ more when they co-occur than when they do not. This pattern has been demonstrated in terrestrial, lungless salamander species that compete for food resources. Because the aquatic larval stages of biphasic species often occur in high densities, competition between sympatric species may be more likely between larvae than between adults. However, the ecology of larval lungless salamanders has not received the research attention as post-metamorphic salamanders. We studied two cryptic species of salamander, Eurycea wilderae (Blue Ridge Two-lined Salamander) and E. cirrigera (Southern Two-lined Salamander), which occur in two different types of environment – the Blue Ridge versus the Piedmont physiographic provinces – in the southeastern US. These two species occur in a narrow zone of sympatry in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains of northeastern Georgia. We tested for food partitioning in the larvae by determining prey items (to order) from specimens collected from allopatric and sympatric localities and comparing them with the available invertebrate fauna within each stream. We similarly tested for character displacement in head measurements known to be associated with feeding dynamics. Larvae at the sympatric sites were identified genetically. Chi-square analyses indicated no significant difference between species in prey items taken in sympatry. Moreover, MANCOVA indicated no consistent interspecific differences in head measurements in sympatric populations. Therefore, we concluded that there is evidence for neither food partitioning nor ecological character displacement between the larvae of these two species. Results MtDNA IDs and nDNA IDs matched for both PC & NC, indicating no hybridization. In each allopatric population, there was a highly significant difference between prey eaten and prey available (FC, Χ2 = 129.4; CC, Χ2 = 992.0). For NC, there was a significant difference between stream fauna and prey of E. wilderae (Χ2 = 157.6) but not of E. cirrigera (Χ2 = 12.0). There was no significance between the prey of E. wilderae and E. cirrigera (Χ2 = 7.8). E. wilderae E. cirrigera These two species occur sympatrically in northeastern Georgia (Camp et al. 2000). The larvae of both species have similar ecologies and may occur in high densities (up to 27 m-2; Milanovich et al., 2015).. Competition between larvae may be a contributing factor maintaining the parapatric distribution of the two species (Cunningham et al., 2009).. Purpose We tested for competition and ecological character displacement between the larvae of E. cirrigera and E. wilderae in an area of sympatry in northeastern Georgia. MANCOVA showed a significant difference between the species in allopatry (F = 3.09, P = 0.008). DFA classified 86.8% of E. wilderae and 78.3% of E. cirrigera correctly for allopatric populations. There was no significant difference between the species at either PC (F = 1.12, P = 0.325) or NC (F = 0.74, P = 0.618). At PC DFA correctly classified 80.6% of E. wilderae but only 55.2% of E. cirrigera correctly. At NC DFA correctly classified 56.7% of E. wilderae and 64.1% of E. cirrigera. Materials & Methods Literature Cited Salamanders were collected from four allopatric sites (two for each species) and from two sympatric sites. MC = Madison Co (E. cirrigera) FC = Fulton Co (E. cirrigera) SC = Union Co, Sosebee Cove (E. wilderae) CC = Union Co, Cooper Creek (E. wilderae) NC = Habersham Co, Nancytown Creek (both) PC = Habersham Co, Piedmont College (both) Three specimens from each allopatric site and all specimens from sympatric sites were genotyped based on a mtDNA gene (cyt-b) and a nDNA gene (POMC).   SC & CC MC FC PC & NC Adams. 2000. Pp 383—394, In Bruce, Jaeger & Houck. The Biology of Plethodontid Salamanders. Plenum Press. Adams & Rohlf. 2000. PNAS 97:4106—4111. Camp, Marshall, Landau, Austin & Tilley..Copeia 2000:572—578. Cunningham, Rissler & Apodaca. 2009. Journal of Animal Ecology 78:52—-62. Keller & Seehausen. 2012. Molecular Ecology 21:782—799. Lannoo. 2005. Amphibian Declines: The Conservation Status of United States Species. Univ. Calif. Press. Milanovich, Maerz & Rosemond. 2015. Freshwater Biology 16:1340—1353.   Discussion While there was a significant difference between E. wilderae prey and the stream fauna at NC, this difference was driven by only a single taxon (Megaloptera). In addition, there was no difference in foods between the species in sympatry. We concluded that there is no food partitioning between in larvae. Moreover, we found no evidence of ecological character displacement in larvae. Therefore, we concluded that competition does not occur between the larvae of the two species. Alternative explanations for the maintetance of parapatry include adaptation to different thermal environments (Keller and Seehausen, 2012) or competition between adults. We collected samples of invertebrates from CC, FC, and NC by sweeping 5 arbitrarily chosen sites, each measuring 10 x 12.5 cm. We dissected salamander stomachs to retrieve prey items. We identified all prey items and stream invertebrates to taxon (usually order) using Pennak (1978). We compared prey eaten to available stream fauna using chi square. For the sympatric site (NC), we also compared the prey items of the two species, adjusting the α level to 0.025.