CERN-ITER Workshop CERN Procurement Anders Unnervik 16 Jan 2017

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Public Private Partnership Investment and Construction Armando R. Araujo Cairo 2003.
Advertisements

Best Value For Money adjudications for Industrial Services C. Lara/CERN 14 November 2013.
Design-Build: RISKS OR REWARDS for the Consulting Engineer?
WINNING PUBLIC SECTOR CONTRACTS 20/11/2014 Meet West, Galway Bay Hotel John Maughan (on behalf of Galway City, Galway County & Roscommon) 20/11/2014.
Liabilities and Risk Sharing RA Dirk Hoffmann MBA all rights reserved Best practices – a European perspective Dirk Hoffmann, MBA, Lawyer (Germany)
Jeff Delmon FEU Financial Solutions World Bank. Why PPP? Procurement efficiency Lifecycle management Design/construction/operation management Monetizing.
Procurement Presentation Alan Brett Contracts Officer HSE.
> taking best practice to the world International Experience with Performance Based Maintenance Contracts.
REPLACEMENT AND MAINTENANCE OF LIFTS GIVING ACCESS TO LHC UNDERGROUND AREAS TENDERING PROCEDURE IT-4056/EN 105 December 2014 Floris Bonthond.
Diploma in Procurement & Supply
Drafting the Request for Tender Offers: Important Terms and Conditions – Charles Rumbaugh Guest Lecturer Naval Postgraduate School IDARM International.
INVITATION TO TENDER PROCEDURE INVITATION TO TENDER PROCEDURE IT – 3972/EN PROVISION OF MAINTENANCE SERVICES ON INDUSTRIAL TRUCKS ON THE CERN SITE Insert.
1 Smart Public and Private Procurement Lukáš Klee for BCC in CR Procurement in the construction sector and the use of FIDIC contracts British Chamber of.
H11.pE-3.0 Welcome Master of Project Management / International project contracts - r 1.1 – slide 1 International project contracts E.S.C.T
TENDERING PROCEDURE IT- 3927/EN
Doing business with CERN Anders Unnervik 3 November 2014.
Purchasing Supplies at CERN
Session 3: Project Development Agenda The Voice of a Technologist Utility Project Development Reliability Concepts Residential Project Development Homework.
Purchasing supplies at CERN Procurement Strategy Dante Gregorio FP-PI.
Doing business with CERN Anders Unnervik Ankara 5 October 2015.
Generic Documents for the Design, Build, Operate Contract for a Solid Waste Facility.
2 ESS ERIC High Level Advisory Meeting – 15 July 2014.
Office of Procurement Services.  Vendor Application Website: 
Doing business with CERN Anders Unnervik 20 May 2014.
Purchasing supplies at CERN Procurement Rules Someone FP-PI.
PROCUREMENT RULES FOR EXPERIMENTS AT CERN Dante Gregorio CERN Procurement Service.
Building Capacity of SMEs for Participation in Public Procurement Draft Presentation for Training of Trainers June 2014.
How to succeed in International Tenders Ing. Miloš TKÁČ MTC – Engineering / Consulting / Sales Južná trieda 93 – P.c. Strojár, Košice tel.: 055 / 6808.
Technical External Management Requirements Technology Complexity Interfaces Reliability / Performance Quality Planning Controlling Funding / Resources.
Scope of PCP Phase 1: Solution Design of Q4 First-of-a-kind prototype QUACO Bid Conference, CERN, 07 th July 2016 Arnaud Foussat, CERN TE MSC-LMF Helene.
CERN Procurement Procedures for the HL-LHC project Civil Engineering work London, 24 June 2016 Lisa Bellini-Devictor, CERN/IPT-PI.
CERN Procurement Procedures Rome, 28 th June 2016 Adam Horridge.
2016 Floris Bonthond 31 May Agenda – Procurement at CERN 2 What does CERN buy? Procurement budget Industrial Return and Return Coefficients.
Construction Tender Process Tender steps between Client, Contractor and Subcontractor Dr A Kimmance.
Introduction to Sustainable Procurement Principles for Building Efficiency Building Efficiency Accelerator 19 July 2016.
Project Management – PTM712S
Treatment of Key Risks under EPC Contracts
Doing business with CERN Anders Unnervik
Agenda Procurement organization and budget What does CERN buy?
CERN-ITER Workshop Magnet installation Some critical assembly and installation contracts Anders Unnervik 17 Jan 2017.
Doing business with CERN Anders Unnervik
BOT LAW (R.A. No. 6957, as amended by R.A. No. 7718)
Doing business with CERN Dante Gregorio (dante.
Purchasing supplies at CERN
Contract Award Procedures
Purchasing supplies at CERN
12.2 Conduct Procurements The process of obtaining seller responses, selecting a seller and awarding the contract The team applies selection criteria.
Ch 11 - Procurement Management Learning Objectives
Purchasing supplies at CERN
Cooperation between CERN and Ukrainian Industries 2017
Workshop Activity 1 (in groups – 4 students in each) – 15 minutes
TENDERING PROCEDURE IT-3981/EN
Ways to industry participation in CLIC 24th October, 2017
PRE-BID MEETING ITB UNDP Design and Construction of a new medical warehouse in Bissau, Guinea Bissau 15th August 2017 Presented by Antoine Fadoul UNDP-
Simplification and reduction of administrative burden.
Lockheed Martin Canada’s SMB Mentoring Program
2016 Procurement Framework Contract Management
Speaker: Sarah Chambers, Esq. Claims Counsel| Professional Liability
LEASING.
Design-Build Acquisition and Contract Incentives July 19, 2018
Steps during and after a Pre-commercial Procurement
Steps during and after a Pre-commercial Procurement
Proposal submission and evaluation
Training module EPC facilitators A role to play Add date.
Cofindustria OVERVIEW OF THE WORLD BANK PROGRAM IN SERBIA
Proportion of total R&D expenditure by function in 2005
Steps during and after a Pre-commercial Procurement
Steps during and after a Pre-commercial Procurement
Design-Build Acquisition and Contract Incentives May 9, 2019
How Small Developers and EPC Contractors Can Add PPA Financing to their Arsenals John Langhus, VP Business Development Midwest Solar Expo 2019 New Energy.
Presentation transcript:

CERN-ITER Workshop CERN Procurement Anders Unnervik 16 Jan 2017

Legal framework CERN, an Intergovernmental Organization, was established in July 1953, by the “Convention for the establishment of a European Organization for Nuclear Research”. As an Intergovernmental Organization, CERN is not a legal entity under national law but governed by public international law. CERN benefits from immunity from national jurisdiction and execution. Thus, legal disputes between CERN and its suppliers and contractors are not submitted to national courts but solved via international arbitration. CERN is thus entitled to establish its own internal rules necessary for its proper functioning, such as the rules under which it purchases equipment and services. 2

Standard or Non-Standard? What do we buy ? Standard or Non-Standard? Off-the-shelf or products which can be produced with existing manufacturing techniques and/or technologies => functional specification Non-standard products where industry has neither the required know-how nor the immediate interest to develop and design the products for its existing markets => built to print Prototypes and/or pre-series needed?

Basis of Award – Supply contracts Supply contracts shall be awarded on FCA price, «Lowest compliant bid » basis…. ….and….

Lowest cost ……? Takes into account: Initial investment Operating costs: Energy consumption Spares Maintenance Training, etc. Disposal costs

Basis of Award – Service contracts Service contracts are awarded on a «Best Value for Money» basis to the bidder submitting the most economically advantageous bid

Best Value For Money The following criteria and weights will be applied by CERN to evaluate the bids for Service contracts: Criterion Weight Price (inc. all relevant costs) XX Quality Experience of the key personnel Stability of the personnel External references Technical know-how Technical training Quality of the bid Tests Etc. TOTAL 100

Some contractual conditions Performance (bank) guarantee; Two years warranty; Except in case of gross negligence or wilful misconduct, no liability for any indirect or consequential loss or damage; Penalties for late delivery, and often for some contract breaches; Changes of sub-contractors to be approved by CERN; Step-in rights in case of problems with sub-contractors; New IPR vested in CERN; Arbitration.

Some contractual cases, LHC Civil engineering FIDIC Red book (modified, e.g. dispute resolution board); CERN-Engineer-Contractor; Unforeseeable ground conditions; Late building permit->changed contract Dipole cold masses and components CERN design (build-to-print); CERN supplied all major components and tooling -> CERN supplier and client; Initially: one sector, target price with incentive fees and on open-book principles; Instead, firm and fixed prices for 30 cold masses each, thereafter new tender for the rest; Insolvency.

Some contractual cases, LHC Cryogenic distribution line Functional specification; Stage 1: Design, pre-series 110 m test cell (ceiling price for series), three contractors; Stage 2: New fixed-firm prices for series; Issues; change of sub-contractor, insolvency, corrosion, bad components; CERN decided to take over resp. for a faulty sector, pay extra for acceleration of components.

Some contractual cases, LHC Assembly of LHC cryomagnets on the CERN site (see WS-3, presentations); Assembly of LHC interconnections on the CERN site (see WS-3, presentations).

Lessons learned, LHC Different contracts require different tendering and contracting strategies; Technical risk to be borne by the owner of the technology, i.e. the party who knows most about the risks concerned; Flexibility and innovation in the procurement process. If a strategy does not work as planned ->change it; There is no “one-size-fits-all” specification: from “build-to-print” to functional specifications; Plan for variations; Price break-downs.

13

14