Achievable Penetration Rates

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Comments for Workshop on EEU Budget for August 6, 2008.
Advertisements

Reporting and Evaluating DSM Performance Staff Workshop – April 28, 2011.
Grenada Sustainable Energy Plan Stakeholders Meeting April 5, 2002.
The Energy Efficiency Commitment overall progress and emerging issues Charles Hargreaves 4 September 2007.
Will CO2 Change What We Do?
The Demand Forecast and Conservation Analysis Interface May PNREC Massoud Jourabchi & Tom Eckman.
Statewide Measure Cost Update Overview & Discussion.
à 2007, Pacific Gas and Electric Company Energy Efficiency Emerging Technologies to Mitigate Climate Change Duane Larson AB 32 Economic & Technical Advancement.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Review of Draft Commercial Sector Conservation Assessment February 3, 2009.
Regulatory View of DSM/EE David Drooz Public Staff – N.C. Utilities Commission April 2015.
Overview of Federal Appliance Standards and Their Impact on Regional Loads Tom Eckman Northwest Power and Conservation Council BPA Utility Brown Bag September.
SEEA Presentation to SEES March 2006 SEEA Presentation to SEES February 2006 SOUTHEAST ENERGY EFFICIENCY ALLIANCE.
Vermont Electric Energy Efficiency Potential Study – Draft Findings April 10, 2006.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Deemed Energy Savings and Cost-Effectiveness of 80-Plus Power Supplies RTF January 2007.
Rooftop Solar Photovoltaic Seventh Plan Approach to Analysis CRAC November 13, 2014.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Draft 6 th Plan’s Assessment of Regional Conservation Potential Conservation Resource Cost and Availability April.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Achievability Issues Conservation Resources Advisory Committee March 12, 2009.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Model Conservation Standards Economic Analysis for for New Single Family and Manufactured Home Construction June.
1 NORTHWEST ENERGY EFFICIENCY ALLIANCE Emerging Technology Appraisal Presented to the NW Power Council – Conservation Resource Advisory Committee Meeting.
Technical Group - ECMs.  Benton PUD  BPA  Chelan PUD  Clallam County PUD  Clark County PUD  Cowlitz PUD  Energy Trust of Oregon  Franklin PUD.
Phoenix Convention Center Phoenix, Arizona The Energy Opportunity in Windows & Envelope Technologies Energy Technologies Windows & Building Envelope Karma.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council The Northwest Energy Efficiency Market 2007 NAESCO Northwest Regional Meeting June 15, 2007 Tom Eckman Northwest.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Draft Plan Proposed Regional Conservation Targets for Power Committee June 10, 2009 Updated for CRAC.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Draft Plan Proposed Regional Conservation Targets for June 9, 2009.
Results from the California Energy Efficiency Potential Study – Existing Residential and Commercial Jean Shelton July 27, 2006 San Francisco, California.
Energy Reduction In setting the energy target, three factors are considered: –Local climate. –Locally available energy sources. –Size of the home. We Consider.
Expanding Energy Efficiency for BC Hydro: Lessons from Industry Leaders June 19, 2012 Prepared for the BC Sustainable Energy Association.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Review of Draft Commercial Sector Conservation Assessment 28 April, 2009.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Slide 1 Accelerating Energy Efficiency To Reduce the PNW Power System's Carbon Footprint Tom Eckman Manager, Conservation.
Northwest Power Planning Council The Fifth Plan’s Draft Conservation Resource Assessment Summary of Results To Date April 8, 2003.
Adequacy Assessment for the 2017 Pacific Northwest Power Supply Steering Committee Meeting October 26, 2012 Portland, Oregon 1.
September 30, 2003Conservation Resources Advisonry Committee 1 Commercial Sector Measure Quest Sources & Findings.
DRAFT Preliminary: BPA Summary of 6 th Plan Supply Curves May 15, 2009 Lauren Gage
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Residential Conservation Resource Assessment Overview of Analytical Process and Major Assumptions April 21, 2009.
NWPPA NIC Conference: Indoor Ag & Implications for Utilities John Morris- Policy & Regulatory Affairs Director.
Regional Conservation Progress Review of Regional Savings from September 21, 2010.
Emerging Technologies Presented by Mark Rehley, Emerging Technology Operations Manager Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance.
11/23/ Residential Sector Load Forecast Impacts of Codes, Standards and Market Changes Preliminary Estimates June 19, 2002.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council 1 Distribution System Efficiency Potential & Conservation Voltage Reduction Power Committee April 2009.
UGI Utilities – Electric Division Energy Efficiency & Conservation Collaborative Meeting July 21, 2010.
Conservation Resources Draft Seventh Power Plan Conservation Potential Assessment.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council A Look At The Council’s Conservation Planning Methodology and Assumptions A Look At The Council’s Conservation.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council The Role of Energy Efficiency in Could (and Should) Play in Montana’s Future Insights from the 5 th Northwest.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council The Role of Energy Efficiency in the Northwest Power and Conservation Plan Tom Eckman Manager, Conservation Resources.
1 Proposed Input Assumptions to RTF Cost-Effectiveness Determinations February 2, 2010.
2014 Enhanced RCP Jennifer Light & Lakin Garth Regional Technical Forum December 8, 2015.
Sixth Power Plan A Public Utility Point of View Bill Gaines, Director, Tacoma Public Utilities Craig Smith, Assistant General Manager, Snohomish PUD Northwest.
Process for Review of 6 th Plan Supply Curves June 19, 2009 Lauren Gage
Contribution of Federal Standards Toward 6 th Plan Efficiency Goals Conservation Resources Advisory Committee Meeting June 4,
Slide 1 B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Variable Capacity Heat Pump Sub-Committee Road-Mapping Session BPA Energy Efficiency.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Conservation Resources in the (Draft) 5 th Northwest Power Plan Tom Eckman Manager, Conservation Resources Northwest.
3/12/ Regional Conservation Resource Supply Assessment Who Wants It & Why How We Propose to Do It And Whose to Blame If We Fail.
DISTRICT HEATING District heating is an infrastructure which allows heat generated in a centralized location to be distributed to residential homes and.
Slide 1 Overview of Conservation in the Pacific Northwest Energy Efficiency Options in the Northwest Post-2011Meeting March 4, 2008.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Small Office Savings Analysis RTF August 30, 2007.
Seventh Plan Update RETAC September 23, Final Plan Update Review of Past Program Results Emerging Tech & New Measures Finance, Admin Cost, Line.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council Slide 1 Heat Pump Water Heaters Tom Eckman Manager, Conservation Resources Northwest Power and Conservation Council.
PLACE IMAGE HERE Energy efficiency policy in New Zealand Country Report to the APEC Expert Group Energy Efficiency and Conservation September 2010 Sendai.
PRELIMINARY DRAFT EXCERPT RECOMMENDATIONS ON MEASUREMENT AND VERIFICATION METHODS IN THE FRAMEWORK OF DIRECTIVE 2006/32/EC ON ENERGY END-USE EFFICIENCY.
What’s Next in Lighting? Overview of Seventh Power Plan Findings on Commercial Lighting Conservation Potential.
Northwest Power and Conservation Council The Role of Electric Energy Efficiency in Reducing PNW Carbon Emissions Tom Eckman Manager, Conservation Resources.
PSE Conservation Resource Potential Assessment: Consistency with Power Council’s Methodology November 17 th, 2009.
WSU Support for Regional Emerging Technologies Cris Love WSU Energy Program Regional Emerging Technologies Advisory Committee - RETAC March 2, 2016.
WSU Support for Regional Emerging Technologies
Potomac Edison Preliminary Energy Efficiency and Conservation Programs
A New Approach to Emerging Technology
Potential and Goals Primer
Sixth Power Plan Setting Conservation Targets and Implementation Strategies Jill Steiner, Snohomish Public Utility District Northwest Power and Conservation.
The Northwest Energy Efficiency Market
Demand Side Management Potential Study Measure List Overview
Presentation transcript:

Achievable Penetration Rates The Pace of Conservation Acquisition April 17, 2009 Conservation Resources Advisory Committee

Outline in Two Parts Part 1 Part 2 Revisions to Ramp Rate Assumptions Sensitivity Testing slide 2

Revisions: Tamping Down Max Annual Rates Based on Comments & Further Thought slide 3

Revisions: Industrial Slowed down two important new measures: From New Measure - Fast to New Measure - Medium Energy Project Management Integrated Plant Energy Management Represent about 20% of industrial savings slide 4

Revisions: Distribution Efficiency Formerly All at “New Measure - Medium” Now: Split by Measure Bundle System Voltage by LDC method at New Measure - Fast System Voltage EOL method at New Measure - Slow Light System Improvements at New Measure - Slow Major System Improvements at New Measure - Slow slide 5

Revisions: Commercial Measure 30-Mar Previous LPD Package-New LO 20Fast LO Fast LPD Package-NR LO 20Fast LO Fast Lighting Controls Interior-New LO Medium LO Fast Lighting Controls Interior-NR LO Medium LO Fast Glass-Retro Retro in 20 Retro in 10 Demand Control Ventilation-NR LO Slow LO Medium Roof Insulation-NR LO Fast Retro in 10 Computer Servers and IT-Retro LO Slow LO Medium Street and Roadway Lighting-NR LO Slow LO Medium slide 6

Residential Consumer Electronics Heat Pump Water Heater New analysis adds 1000 MWa Potential over 20 years LO Medium Ramp Rate ~ 30 MWa per year by 2014 Heat Pump Water Heater Emerging Technology Ramp Rate slide 7

Results slide 8

Lost-Opportunity slide 9

Retrofit slide 10

Comparative Max Rates 6th PLAN 2010 2014 2019 Lost-Opportunity @ $100/MWh 35 120 200 Retrofit @ $60/MWh 140 160 Total 175 280 360 5th PLAN 2005 2009 2014 Lost-Opportunity @ $100/MWh 15 40 85 Retrofit @ $60/MWh 120 Total 135 160 205 slide 11

slide 12

Reality Check Achieved over 200 MWa in 2007 Expect higher in 2008 Most programs exceed 2007 & NEEA too Of the 200 MWa about 70 MWa was CFLs But CFL savings not in 6th Plan targets Many New Measures Higher Avoided Costs Federal Standards Push State Code Revisions in the Works slide 13

5th Plan Targets Seemed Daunting (130 to 150 MWa) Historic Performance slide 14

Part 2: Ramp Rate Sensitivity Testing Purpose: What is the Value of Going Faster? What is the Cost of Going Slower? What are the Resource Consequences? What are the Revenue Requirements? Tool: Portfolio Model Test Slow & Fast Achievable Penetration Issue: What Ranges? slide 15

Ramp Rate Sensitivity Testing Staff Proposal Lost-Opportunity SLOW: Up to $60 / MWh levelized cost FAST: Up to $120 / MWh levelized cost Non-Lost-Opportunity SLOW: 5th Plan Rate FAST: Washington I-937 rate All Cost-Effective in 10 years – evenly paced slide 16

Test Slow & Fast Deployment Rates Proposed Annual Maximum Limits on Deployment in MWa 2010 2014 2019 Lost-Opportunity SLOW Up to $60/MWh 29 100 168 Lost-Opportunity FAST Up to $120/MWh 36 123 206 Non-Lost Opportunity SLOW 5th Plan Maximum 120 Non-Lost Opportunity FAST All Cost-Effective @$60/MWh in 10 years (I-937) 160 slide 17

Annual Deployment Rates for Non-Lost Opportunity Resources slide 18

Annual Deployment Rate for Lost Opportunity Resources slide 19

Annual Deployment Rates for All Conservation Resources slide 20

Cumulative Deployment Rate for Non-Lost Opportunity Resources slide 21

Cumulative Deployment Rate for Lost Opportunity Resources slide 22

Cumulative Deployment Rate for All Resources slide 23

End slide 24