P I N P Two Photon Exchange in elastic electron-proton scattering: QCD factorization approach Nikolai Kivel in collaboration with M. Vanderhaeghen DSPIN-09.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
A Measurement of the Target Single-Spin Asymmetry in Quasi-Elastic 3 He (e, e) Joe Katich for E and the Hall A Collaboration Two-Photon Physics World.
Advertisements

11 Contribution of Two-Photon Exchange with Excitation to ep Scattering Revisited Shin Nan Yang National Taiwan University Contribution of Two-Photon Exchange.
1 The and -Z Exchange Corrections to Parity Violating Elastic Scattering 周海清 / 东南大学物理系 based on PRL99,262001(2007) in collaboration with C.W.Kao, S.N.Yang.
Onset of Scaling in Exclusive Processes Marco Mirazita Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati First Workshop on Quark-Hadron.
Jefferson Lab/Hampton U
DESY PRC May 10, Beyond the One Photon Approximation in Lepton Scattering: A Definitive Experiment at DESY for J. Arrington (Argonne) D. Hasell,
Marc Vanderhaeghen Johannes Gutenberg Universität, Mainz Olympus Coll. Meeting, DESY, February 23-24, 2010 TexPoint fonts used in EMF. Read the TexPoint.
Two-photon exchange: experimental tests Studying the QED expansion for elastic electron-proton scattering Motivation The Three Experiments Summary With.
Richard MilnerDESY April 6, OLYMPUS Overview Motivation for the experiment Progress to date on the experiment The path forward.
CEA DSM Dapnia Egle Tomasi-Gustafsson Frascati, 20 Gennaio Model independent properties of two photon exchange Egle Tomasi-Gustafsson Saclay, France.
Andrei Afanasev, Trento workshop, 31 October 2012 Radiative Corrections for Elastic Scattering of Muons and Electrons on a Proton Andrei Afanasev The George.
LEPTON PAIR PRODUCTION AS A PROBE OF TWO PHOTON EFFECTS IN EXCLUSIVE PHOTON-HADRON SCATTERING Pervez Hoodbhoy Quaid-e-Azam University Islamabad.
Real Compton Scattering from the Proton in the Hard Scattering Regime Alan M. Nathan SLAC Experimental Seminar December 2, 2003 I. Compton Scattering from.
Possibilities to perform DVCS measurement at COMPASS E. Burtin CEA-Saclay Irfu/SPhN On Behalf of the COMPASS Collaboration DIS Madrid - 29 April,
Quark Helicity Distribution at large-x Collaborators: H. Avakian, S. Brodsky, A. Deur, arXiv: [hep-ph] Feng Yuan Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.
CEA DSM Dapnia Egle TOMASI-GUSTAFSSONAugust 5, High order radiative corrections in Electron-Proton scattering Egle Tomasi-Gustafsson Saclay, France.
Duality: Recent and Future Results Ioana Niculescu James Madison University Hall C “Summer” Workshop.
Эксперимент OLYMPUS и форм факторы протона С.Белостоцкий.
Two-photon Exchange John Arrington Argonne National Lab International Workshop on Positrons at Jefferson Lab, Mar 25-27, 2009.
Single-Spin Asymmetries at CLAS  Transverse momentum of quarks and spin-azimuthal asymmetries  Target single-spin asymmetries  Beam single-spin asymmetries.
Two-photon physics in hadronic processes Marc Vanderhaeghen College of William & Mary / Jefferson Lab PPP7 workshop, Taipei, June , 2007.
Chung-Wen Kao Chung-Yuan Christian University, Taiwan
Search for two-photon effects in charge asymmetry measurements from electron and positron scattering on nucleon and nuclei E. Tomasi-Gustafsson 1,2, M.
Andrei Afanasev, JLab Users Workshop, 6/22/05 Operated by the Southeastern Universities Research Association for the U.S. Dept. of Energy Two-Photon Exchange.
Measuring the Spin Structure of 3 He and the Neutron at Low Q 2 Timothy Holmstrom College of William and Mary For the Jefferson Lab Hall A Collaboration.
GEp-III in Hall C Andrew Puckett, MIT On behalf of the Jefferson Lab Hall C GEp-III Collaboration April 15, 2008.
Chung-Wen Kao Chung-Yuan Christian University, Taiwan National Taiwan University, Lattice QCD Journal Club Two is too many: A personal review.
Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility PAC-25, January 17, 2004, 1 Baldin Sum Rule Hall C: E Q 2 -evolution of GDH integral Hall A: E94-010,
DIS Conference, Madison WI, 28 th April 2005Jeff Standage, York University Theoretical Motivations DIS Cross Sections and pQCD The Breit Frame Physics.
Nucleon Elastic Form Factors: An Experimentalist’s Perspective Outline: The Fib and the Questions EM FF Strangeness Glen Warren Battelle & Jefferson Lab.
Chung-Wen Kao Chung-Yuan Christian University Taiwan TBE effects for both parity-conserving and parity-violating ep elastic scattering 12th International.
Jets and α S in DIS Maxime GOUZEVITCH Laboratoire Leprince-Ringuet Ecole Polytechnique – CNRS/IN2P3, France On behalf of the collaboration On behalf of.
JLab, October 31, 2008 WACS in 12 GeV era 1 GPDs Wide-Angle Compton Scattering pi-0 photo-production in 12 GeV era B. Wojtsekhowski Outline WACS and other.
Proton Form Factor Measurements with Polarization Method L.Pentchev The College of William and Mary For the GEp-2  and GEp-III collaborations JLab, June.
Nucleon spin physics with CLAS at Jlab Fifth International Conference on PERSPECTIVES IN HADRONIC PHYSICS Particle-Nucleus and Nucleus-Nucleus Scattering.
JLab PAC33, January 16, 2008 Polarization transfer in WACS 1  p   p Polarization transfer in Wide-Angle Compton Scattering Proposal D. Hamilton,
1 Nucleon Form Factors 99% of the content of this talk is courtesy of Mark Jones (JLab)
Envisioned PbWO4 detector Wide-Angle Compton Scattering at JLab-12 GeV with a neutral-particle detector With much input from B. Wojtsekhowski and P. Kroll.
DVCS Radiative Corrections C. Hyde Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA (and update to come) Hall A DVCS Collaboration.
TPE Contributions to Proton EM Properties in TL Region Dian-Yong Chen Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing
Bryan Moffit PAC32 Dry Run Precision Measurement of the Proton Elastic Cross Section at High Q 2 PAC32 12 GeV Proposal : PR Spokespersons:Bryan.
Status report of Hermes Status report of Hermes Delia Hasch Physics Research Committee, DESY Oct 27/ Spin physics:  finalised and new results on:
Timelike Compton Scattering at JLab
Flavor decomposition at LO
5/18/2018 Extracting the proton charge radius from low-Q2 electron/muon scattering Graphic by Joshua Rubin, ANL (Guy Ron – HUJI - giving the talk for)
Experimental Probes of Two-Photon Exchange*
Precision Measurement of the Proton Elastic Cross Section at High Q2
QCD CORRECTIONS TO bb →h h
Andrei Afanasev The George Washington University, Washington, DC
Theory : phenomenology support 12 GeV
James Johnson Northwestern University & Argonne National Lab
Charge-Asymmetric Lepton Scattering as a Probe of Hadronic Structure
The College of William and Mary Charlottesville, October 9, 2008
Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering at HERMES
Wide Angle Compton Scattering
Measurement of GPDs at JLab and in Future at Colliders
Hadron Form Factors Rolf Ent Jefferson Lab
DIS 2004 XII International Workshop
Exciting Hadrons Vladimir Pascalutsa
Unique Description for SSAs in DIS and Hadronic Collisions
Two-photon physics in elastic electron-nucleon scattering
Searching for intrinsic motion effects in SIDIS
Duality in Pion Electroproduction (E00-108) …
Unique Description for Single Transverse Spin Asymmetries
Egle TOMASI-GUSTAFSSON
Scaling Study of the L-T Separated p(e,e’π+)n Cross Section at Large Q2 Tanja Horn Jefferson Lab APS/DNP meeting 2007 DNP07 October 2007.
Motivation: See recent talk by Braun at Jlab 12 GeV upgrade Workshop
Two-photon exchange in p-p collisions
GEp-2γ experiment (E04-019) UPDATE
Measurement of Parity-Violation in the N→△ Transition During Qweak
Presentation transcript:

P I N P Two Photon Exchange in elastic electron-proton scattering: QCD factorization approach Nikolai Kivel in collaboration with M. Vanderhaeghen DSPIN-09

Missing radiative corrections Radiative correction at electron side: well understood and taken care of Box diagrams involve photons of all wavelength long wavelength (soft photon) is included in radiative correction (IR divergence is cancelled with electron proton brems- strahlung interference) Soft bremsstrahlung involves long-wavelength photons compositeness of the nucleon only enters through on-shell ff Maximon, Tjon PRC62, 2000

Large Q2 asymptotic of the TPE contribution: motivation Chen, Afanasev et al PRL93(2004) partonic or GPD-model Blunden Melnitchouk Tjon PRL91(2003) hadronic-model TPE is responsible for the discrepancy in FF extraction ? pQCD in TPE Future JLab Hall A/C PR-07-109/09-001 pol GE/GM Q2=6-14.8GeV2 JLab Hall A PR-07-108 unpol Q2=7-17.5GeV2 , stat. err. < 1%

Guichon Vanderhaeghen PRL91(2003) TPE contribution: theory Guichon Vanderhaeghen PRL91(2003) ep ep k k’ ( ) p p’

( ) TPE contribution: theory ep ep Form factors k k’ p p’ 1γ exch ( ) p p’ 1γ exch Form factors 2γ exch

( ) TPE contribution: theory ep ep Form factors k k’ p p’ 1γ exch ( ) p p’ 1γ exch Form factors Large Q2 asymptotic (pQCD) 2γ exch

TPE at large-Q2: QCD factorization approach both photons have large virtualities + crossed Breit frame - n=(1,0,0,1) n=(1,0,0,-1)

TPE at large-Q2: QCD factorization approach + others 23 graphs + crossed = Lowest order graphs to turn 3 collinear quarks into 3 collinear quarks moving in opposite direction

TPE at large-Q2: QCD factorization approach + others 23 graphs + crossed = Lowest order graphs to turn 3 collinear quarks into 3 collinear quarks moving in opposite direction

TPE at large-Q2: QCD factorization approach + others 23 graphs + crossed = Breit frame:

TPE at large-Q2: QCD factorization approach + others 23 graphs + crossed = Nucleon DA

TPE at large-Q2: QCD factorization approach + others 23 graphs + crossed = Hard subprocess * *

( ) TPE contribution: theory ep ep Form factors k k’ p p’ 1γ exch ( ) p p’ 1γ exch Form factors Large Q2 asymptotic (pQCD) 2γ exch helicity flip suppressed

TPE at large-Q: QCD factorization approach Form factors: all integrals are IR-finite pole ⇒ Im part ! NK, Vanderhaeghen, 2009 Borisyuk, Kobushkin, 2008 normalization is not computed, only the ratio to nucleon pQCD FF’s

TPE at large-Q: QCD factorization approach Nucleon DA assumption: drop the highest conformal moments theor. uncertainties: renorm. scale (NLO) helicity flip FF: 3 non-perturbative parameters Models for DA : QCD SR (1988), COZ QCD LCSR (2006), BLW Lattice (2006), QCDSF

Guichon Vanderhaeghen PRL91(2003) Reduced cross section with TPE correction Guichon Vanderhaeghen PRL91(2003) Born app Re part of TPE Empirical fit for the ratio and form factor: JLab Hall A, 2002 Brash, Kozlov, Li, Huber 2002

Reduced cross section with TPE correction NK, Vanderhaeghen, 2009 1-γ pol BLW QCDSF COZ Data set SLAC NE11, 1994

Golden mode: e+p vs. e-p elastic scattering JLab Class PR-07-005 Q2=.5-2.5 GeV2 ε=.1-.9 Future experiments: VEPP-3 Novosibirsk Q2=1.6 GeV2 ε=.44, .92 Olympus@Desy Q2=.8-4.5 GeV2 ε=.4-.9 pQCD estimate COZ Expected accuracy <2% BLW QCDSF

Polarized observables with TPE: test of ε-dependence Pl Pt μpGE/GM Born Pl/Pl COZ BLW BLW COZ

Polarized observables with TPE: test of ε-dependence Pl Pt JLab Hall C E-04-119 completed, new preliminary Q2=2.5 GeV2 ε=.14,.63,.785 Pre li mi na ry !!! BLW COZ GPD

Target Normal Spin Asymmetry Asymmetries related to absorptive part Target Normal Spin Asymmetry E-02-013 Hall-C prelimin μnGE/GM ≃0.35 Elab= 4.8 GeV GM ≃μnGD CLASS, 2009 Q2= 1.-4.5GeV2 COZ PR-05-015 Hall-A Elab= 3.3, 5.3 GeV Q2= 1.0, 2.5GeV2 BLW

Conclusions ☺ TPE is responsible for the discrepancy in FF extraction. This can be determined experimentally (GE/GM, non-linearity of Rosenbluth plot, ratio e+p/e-p, asymmetries sensitive to Im part of TPE) ☺ Hard QCD contribution in TPE at large Q2 can be large and must be considered accurately ☺ TPE at large Q2 depends on the structure of target and can provide us information about nucleon DA ☺ Experiments at higher Q2 where the theory works better is a good opportunity to check pQCD predictions ☹ Large power corrections and/or NLO can change optimistic picture.