Heat tolerance responses to different thermal selection scenarios in the invasive fly, Drosophila subobscura. Luis E. Castañeda*, Angélica Jaramillo &

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Disease emergence in immunocompromised populations Jamie Lloyd-Smith Penn State University.
Advertisements

A Comparison of Early Versus Late Initiation of Renal Replacement Therapy in Critically III Patients with Acute Kidney Injury: A Systematic Review and.
On board do traits fit B.M. model? can we use model fitting to answer evolutionary questions? pattern vs. process table.
Evolution of functional traits (Joel Kingsolver, Biology) Traits as functions: functional, function- valued, infinite-dimensional A primer in evolutionary.
Pearson & Dawson Quiz 1. What is a bioclimatic envelope? 2. How might bioclimatic envelope models be useful for invasive species management? 3. List and.
Discovery of a rare arboreal forest-dwelling flying reptile (Pterosauria, Pterodactyloidea) from China Wang et al. PNAS Feb. 11, 2008.
Evolution of Biodiversity
Fundamental Concepts in Behavioural Ecology. The relationship between behaviour, ecology, and evolution –Behaviour : The decisive processes by which individuals.
For example: Sickle Cell Anemia and Evolution Your name.
Chapter 51 Experiments, Good and Bad. Chapter 52 Experimentation u An experiment is the process of subjecting experimental units to treatments and observing.
Evolution Universals v. Diversity. Battle of Universals and Cultures Human universals: Search for unifying parameters of functioning –Emphasizes biology.
So you want to study marine biology?. Introduction to Marine Biology Physical Oceanography – Waves, Tides, Ocean Circulation, Seawater, and Surfing?
18 Species Diversity in Communities. 18 Species Diversity in Communities Resource Partitioning Nonequilibrium Theories The Consequences of Diversity Case.
Genetic control of plastic and evolutionary responses to the environment in Drosophila melanogaster Bregje Wertheim, Patrick Goymer, Alex Kraaijeveld,
Why do we sleep? – Evolutionary Theory BATs AO1 – Understand and recall the ecological theory of sleep A02 – Analyse information and relate it to psychological.
Impacts, uncertainties and non-linearities of extreme events (heavy precipitation and floods) in a changing climate Luis J. Mata Center for Development.
Rapid micro-evolution and loss of chromosomal diversity in Drosophila in response to climate warming A study by Francisco Rodriguez-Telles and Miguel A.
1 The Web of Life. Chapter 1 The Web of Life CONCEPT 1.1 Events in the natural world are interconnected. CONCEPT 1.2 Ecology is the scientific study of.
EVIDENCE ABOUT DIAGNOSTIC TESTS Min H. Huang, PT, PhD, NCS.
17.2 Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations
Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations. Learning Objectives  Explain how natural selection affects single-gene and polygenic traits.  Describe genetic.
Time series Model assessment. Tourist arrivals to NZ Period is quarterly.
Discovery of a rare arboreal forest-dwelling flying reptile (Pterosauria, Pterodactyloidea) from China Wang et al. PNAS Feb. 11, 2008.
An example of vertical profiles of temperature, salinity and density.
Adaptation for Survival L4: Environmental Changes Learning Objectives: 1.Describe different methods to monitor the environment. 2.Explain how living and.
Natural Selection Problem
Lab Report Guide IB.
Evolution of Biodiversity
Ichy Salmon: variation and adaptation Learning Goal: Students will understand the relationship between genetic variation and adaptation. Intended Learning.
Results Time mean SSTs display regions of large fronts but also thermostats associated with mode waters (Fig. 2, upper panel). Large fronts are typically.
CfE Advanced Higher Physics
October 1, 2013Computer Vision Lecture 9: From Edges to Contours 1 Canny Edge Detector However, usually there will still be noise in the array E[i, j],
A genetic polymorphism in the Drosophila insulin receptor suggests adaptation to climate variation across continents Annalise Paaby a, Mark Blacket b,
Chapter 5: Experimental Evolutionary Domestication Pedro Semōes, Josiane Santos, Margarida Matos Presentation by Priya Singha, UC, Irvine.
Lesson Overview 17.2 Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations Insect populations often contain a few individuals that are resistant to a particular pesticide.
Introduction 1 Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Montana State University, MT, US. 2 Départment de Biologie, Université Laval, Québec, Canada.
Chapter 8 Part I Answers The explanatory variable (x) is initial drop, measured in feet, and the response variable (y) is duration, measured in seconds.
Ecological Speciation- Sticklebacks
Haploid-Diploid Evolutionary Algorithms
The human eye - an evolutionary look.
17.2 Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations
پرتوهای غیریونساز دکتر میرشهرام حسینی پناه
* Facial thermal response to emotional stimulation
METABOLIC VARIATION OF JUVENILE PINK SHRIMP (Farfantepenaeus paulensis) DUE TO TEMPERATURE . Edison Barbieria; Aline Maria Zigiotto de Medeirosa; Marcelo.
MULTIPLE GENES AND QUANTITATIVE TRAITS
EFFECTS OF SEED STERILIZATION TREATMENTS ON SEEDLING VIGOR AND IN VITRO CALLUS INDUCTION OF FOUR MAIZE INBRED LINES Anita Dutta1, Juan Carlos Martinez2.
Fig. 1 Overview of model components to identify if hormonal pleiotropy constrains or facilitates phenotypic responses to selection. The environment imposes.
Aerial lakes photo.
Key research: Van Leeuwen et al
Haploid-Diploid Evolutionary Algorithms
Evolution of Biodiversity
Review of Research Types
The Chi Square Test A statistical method used to determine goodness of fit Goodness of fit refers to how close the observed data are to those predicted.
17-4 Patterns of Evolution
Thermal Tolerance in Aquatic Insects
MULTIPLE GENES AND QUANTITATIVE TRAITS
SSSELF-TALK AND PERCEIVED EXERTION IN PHYSICAL ACTIVITY
The Chi Square Test A statistical method used to determine goodness of fit Goodness of fit refers to how close the observed data are to those predicted.
Investigating Inheritance
17.2 Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations
17.2 Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations
Experiment Method:
Genetic modification of host acceptance by a seed beetle:
The Chi Square Test A statistical method used to determine goodness of fit Goodness of fit refers to how close the observed data are to those predicted.
DIRECTIONS Please take out a piece of paper for notes.
Risk Adjustment Network Meeting. The Hague. October 11-14, 2017
Electro-Thermal Analysis of Contact Resistance
-Short Talk- The soft X-ray characteristics of solar flares, both with and without associated CMEs Kay H.R.M., Harra L.K., Matthews S.A., Culhane J.L.,
17.2 Evolution as Genetic Change in Populations
Genomic determinants of coral heat tolerance across latitudes
Presentation transcript:

Heat tolerance responses to different thermal selection scenarios in the invasive fly, Drosophila subobscura. Luis E. Castañeda*, Angélica Jaramillo & Andres Mesas Instituto de Ciencias Ambientales y Evolutivas, Universidad Austral de Chile, Chile *E-mail: lecastane@gmail.com Funded by FONDECYT 1140066 Result 2. Correlated response of knockdown time Introduction Most of the evidence for low adaptive potential of heat tolerance comes from slow ramping assays. However, these assays increase the amount of experimental noise (e.g. resource depletion, stochasticity and measurement error), which might be explaining the low adaptive potential estimates for heat tolerance. In the present work, we evaluated the effect of the ramping rate on the evolutionary response of the heat tolerance in Drosophila subobscura. To accomplish this goals, artificial selection on heat tolerance was performed using slow (chronic thermal stress) and fast (acute thermal stress) ramping selection protocols. We also evaluated correlated responses of other heat tolerance estimates measured at four static assays. Using these data, we estimated the thermal death time (TDT) curves for each selection group. TDT curves (Fig. 1) give a more complete and reliable estimate of heat tolerance, and also an unified measurement of chronic and acute heat tolerance (Rezende et al. 2014). LRT: 2(2) = 1.33 p = 0.51 LRT: 2(2) = 25.66 p < 0.0001 Acute-Control: p < 0.001 Chronic-Control: p = 0.001 Acute-Chronic: p = 0.60 LRT: 2(2) = 52.69 Chronic-Control: p < 0.001 Acute-Chronic: p = 0.03 LRT: 2(2) = 4.59 p = 0.10 We found correlated responses of knockdown time for acute and chronic selection protocols. We found significant effect of selection protocol, except at 35 and 38ºC. Selected lines resisted for more time stressful temperatures than control lines. Interestingly, only at 37ºC, acute-selected lines showed longer knockdown times than chronic-selected lines. Figure 1. Thermal tolerance landscapes Thermal tolerance varies with the intensity and duration of a stress, and can be represented as a bivariate plot for a given survival probability (50% in the left panels) or as a landscape describing how survival probability is affected by both factors (below). CTmax z Result 3. Correlated response of TDT curves CTmax Selection: F2,12 = 6.0, p = 0.02 Sex: F1,12 = 0.5, p = 0.59 Interaction: F2,12 = 2.4, p = 0.13 Predicted CTmax for selected lines Predicted CTmax for control lines Thermal sensitivity (Z) Selection: F2,12 = 1.1, p = 0.37 Sex: F1,12 = 0.2, p = 0.66 Left: Correlated responses of CTmax for acute and chronic thermal selection. Significant differences in CTmax were for selected lines, but no for thermal sensitivity (Z). Non-differences were found between acute and chronic thermal selection. Below-left: Possible outcomes of changes in heat tolerance according to Castañeda et al. (2015): (A) only CTmax; (B) both CTmax and Z; and (C) only Z. Below-right: Correlated response of TDT in selected lines was only related to a change in CTmax as described in case w1. Methodology 1) Twelve D. subobscura lines were established and assigned to one of the selection protocols: Fast ramping (3), Control-Fast ramping (x3), Slow ramping (x3), and Control-Slow ramping (x3). 2) Selection was performed measuring heat tolerance with two ramping rates: 0.4 ºC/min (fast  30 min) and 0.08 ºC/min (slow  120 min). Flies within the 30% upper of knockdown temperature values were selected as parents of the next generation. For control lines parents were selected at random. 3) After 17 generations of artificial selection and 6 of relaxed selection, knockdown time was estimated at 35, 36, 37 and 38ºC for each selection protocol. Survival analyses at each temperature were performed to compare differences among selection protocols. 4) Using the TDT approach (Fig.1), we estimated the critical thermal limit (CTmax) and the thermal sensitivity (Z). These values were compared among selection protocols and sexes. Conclusions Heat tolerance evolved in an artificial selection experiment for knockdown temperature, increasing almost 1ºC regarding to control lines after 16 generations of selection. Evolutionary response of knockdown temperature was significantly higher for lines selected in acute than those selected in chronic thermal stress, suggesting that “ecologically relevant” protocols (i.e. slow ramping assays) are underestimating the evolutionary response of heat tolerance. Detection of differences in knockdown time among selection protocols depends on the static temperature assayed, which could unmasks correlated responses of thermal-related traits. TDT curves offer a straightforward approach for the study of thermal tolerance because unified heat resistance to chronic and stressful temperatures. Result 1: Evolutionary response of heat tolerance We found that evolutionary response of knockdown temperature was higher for flies selected in the acute than those selected in the chronic selection protocol. This result suggests that experimental noise related to long, slow ramping assays could be constrained evolutionary change of heat tolerance in lab conditions. For further reading Rezende, EL, LE Castañeda & M Santos (2014) Tolerance landscapes in thermal ecology. Functional Ecology 28: 799-809. Castañeda LE, EL Rezende & M Santos (2015) Heat tolerance in Drosophila subobscura along a latitudinal gradient: contrasting patterns between plastic and genetic responses. Evolution 69: 2721-2734.