Paradise Threatened: Land Use and Erosion on St Paradise Threatened: Land Use and Erosion on St. John, US Virgin Islands Paper by: L.H. MacDonald, D.M. Anderson, and W.E. Dietrich. 1997. Environmental Management, 21(6): 851-863 Presented by Kelly Anderson, Environmental Studies, GEOG 370, March 1, 2010
Problem, Hypothesis, and Goal Problem: Development of new roads, businesses, and vacation homes are leading to increased erosion and sedimentation in nearby marine environments. Hypothesis: Erosion is most prevalent in areas of containing unpaved roads and parking areas. Goal: Identify sediment sources, construct model for predicting road surface erosion, evaluate erosion consequences, and recommend minimization methods.
Methods, Data, and Test Field observations Unpaved roads. Drainage channels clogged with sediment. 26 measurements at different road locations wide range of gradients Main focus: gradient and contributing area determine energy available for sediment transport Mapped road segments E = 0.00057A x S + 0.034 incorporated into GIS-based road surface erosion model (ROADMOD) Fish Bay and Lameshur Bay US Geological Survey (USGS) operated automated discharge and suspended sediment stations Fish Bay: rapid development Lameshur Bay: undisturbed, VINP
Results Fish Bay Lameshur Bay 16 km of roads total road surface erosion rate of 390 m³/yr. By assuming a sediment density of 1500 kg/m³, this converts to nearly 600 t/yr. Lameshur Bay 1.4 km of roads 65m³/yr or 100 t/yr Main issue: amount of sediment that reaches the coast mangroves, reefs, beaches.. Sediment delivery rate to water (scale 1-0). Use ROADMOD. Fish Bay: >60 tons/km²/yr (road surface erosion quadruples normal sediment yields) Lameshur Bay: 50 tons/km²/yr. Recommendations: erosion control measures, silt fences, road pavement regulations, waterbar installation, etc…
Map of St. John and USVI National Park, Contour Map of Lameshur Gut Contour map of sediment depth in the Lameshur Gut detention basin in January 1994. Shaded area represents area of sediment deposition; sediment depth contours are in centimeters. Map of St. John and Virgin Islands National Park. The USGS gauging stations are located near the mouth of the ephemeral streams (guts) flowing into Fish Bay and the eastern bight of Lameshur Bay.