A Reviewer’s Perspective

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Publishing Academic Articles: a way through the maze

Advertisements

Getting published in academic publications Tips to Help you Publish Successfully June 2004.

Giving Feedback. The right and the wrong. >> giving feedback

1 Publishing in European Journal of Teacher Education 28th August 2010 Kay Livingston, Editor, EJTE Geri Smyth, Co-Editor, EJTE Katie Peace, Publisher,

Publishing in Academic Journals Tips to Help you Succeed

Publishing in Academic Journals Tips to help you succeed

Professor Ian Richards University of South Australia.

ALEC 604: Writing for Professional Publication Week 11: Addressing Reviews/Revisions.

Qualitative Proposals and Reports

How to write a publishable qualitative article

BEST PRACTICES FOR GETTING PUBLISHED. Dr. Graham Parker  Storyboard your paper as the work develops; projects change, even your hypothesis might change.

Getting published (during your PhD studies) Professor Jennifer Rowley Department of Information and Communications Manchester Metropolitan University.

Understanding the *GHSWT *Georgia High School Writing Test.

Ian White, Routledge and Professor Ian McNay University of Greenwich July 2nd, 2014.

Research Hypothesis Dr. Abraham So far Theoretical –Thesis Algorithm that solve real problems Evaluation by mathematical proof Experimental –Project.

Publishing in Academic Journals Tips to help you succeed.

How to write clear, readable and enjoyable text Dr John Lockley Deputy Chair SOMW © 2015 John Lockley.

Ginny Smith Managing Editor: Planning and Urban Studies Taylor & Francis Ltd.

School of Human Services & Social Work Getting published Clare Tilbury Life Without Barriers Carol Peltola Research Chair.

Paul-François Tremlett, Lecturer in Religious Studies & Director of Research Degrees, Arts.

Ian White Publisher, Journals (Education) Routledge/Taylor & Francis

BEST PRACTICES FOR GETTING PUBLISHED. Dr. Graham Parker  Storyboard your paper as the work develops; projects change, even your hypothesis might change.

Research to Publication MARLA MULCAHY. Introduction Are you planning on sending your work to journals for possible publication? What is stopping you?

2 Why publish? 1. To exchange ideas 2. To build reputation 3. To disseminate work on a global scale Remember: Your research is not registered until it.

Lesson 1: English Composition 1 Review Topics Significance of Reading Reading Strategies The Relationship between Reading and Writing Purposes of Writing.

RSC-LONDON 21 June 2006

How to publish paper in journal. Step 1.Familiarize yourself with potential publications.

Publishing in Journals: Some Tips Dr Felix B Tan Professor and Head Business Information Systems Faculty of Business & Law Auckland U of Technology, New.

Publishing Educational Research Articles Dr. David Kaufman Faculty of Education Simon Fraser University Presented at Universitas Terbuka March 4, 2011.

Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management Editor: Greg W. Marshall Crummer Graduate School of Business Rollins College

Taylor & Francis Journals & How to get published? Biplob Kamrujjaman Journals Area Sales Manager Middle East & North Africa and Turkey.

How to write an essay.

How to write a publishable qualitative article

It’s more difficult than it seems

Aristotle on practical wisdom

GUST 1270 College and Career Planning

Writing An Annotated Bibliography

Effective Presentations

Chapter 22: Research and Ethos

From Revising to Editing: Working with Peer Groups

Academic Writing Whether you’re a student, teacher, or businessperson, academic writing skills are necessary in today’s world. Essays, reports, presentations.

Improving Meredith Student Writing Everyday in Every Class

Writing for Academic Journals

From PhD chapter to article

(working) Title of thesis: progress report

Center for Professional Communication

Essay Feedback.

How to proofread your Research Paper 1. If a paper is not proofread meticulously before it is submitted, it will earn poor marks due to careless mistakes.

Reaching a wider audience: From conference paper to journal article, avoiding rejection Liz Marr, Open University.

Usability Testing: An Overview

RESEARCH PAPER REDO.

Academic Writing and Publishing

BHS Methods in Behavioral Sciences I

ACADEMIC WRITING IN ENGLISH: AN OVERVIEW

Writing An Annotated Bibliography

How to Write a Scientific Paper

Needs analysis (ESP) Communicative language needs for your job ?

Chapter 14 Writing and presenting your project report

Topics, Rules, Issues, Evaluation

“The Right To Fail” In paragraph 3 it says: “the right to fail is one of the few freedoms that this country does not grant its citizens.” What does this.

Getting published Frances Gardner.

Essay Writing Skills Tips and Suggestions

TOK Presentations What do you need to do?.

LITERATURE REVIEW Moazzam Ali Assistant Professor

Introduction to the Research Essay

Class Introduction Prof. Aaron Jones

Instructor’s Resource Manual The Writer’s World: Paragraphs and Essays

The 6 Traits of Writing Definitions and suggestions from:

Presentation transcript:

A Reviewer’s Perspective Dr Pat Sikes Professor of Qualitative Inquiry University of Sheffield

Reviewers are human too

What’s going on when a reviewer reviews?

What do you do when you get feedback?

TOP 10 REASONS FOR REJECTION Sent to the wrong journal Not a proper article (e.g. clearly a thesis chapter or consultancy report) Too long or too short for specific journal Poor regard to conventions of journal (failure to consult Notes to Contributors or conventions of academic writing generally Bad style, grammar, punctuation Fails to say anything of significance or states the obvious at tedious length Not properly contextualized (e.g. concentrates on parochial interests and ignores needs of wider audience) No theoretical framework Scrappily presented and clearly not proofread Libellous, unethical, rude