TBay & OCUL Weeding Surveys Summary of 2009 and 2010 OCUL Member Survey Findings

Participation School Participating 2009 2010 Ryerson yes no Trent McMaster Brock Toronto Yes (UTM and UTL) UOIT Western RMC OCAD Windsor Queens York Lakehead Laurier Laurentian Nipissing Waterloo Participation Gold font = participated in both surveys

Weeding Activities Reported 2009 vs. 2010 2010 School 09 weeding 10 weeding Brock Weeded Plans to weed OCAD No plans to weed Lakehead Laurentian Laurier Plans to weed* McMaster Nippissing Queens RMC Ryerson Trent U of T U of T Mississauga UOIT Waterloo Western Windsor York *Two librarians were surveyed from Laurier. Both respondents indicated plans for weeding were in progress. Blanks indicate library was not surveyed in that year

# Schools Weeded by Publisher Now includes McMaster 2010 and additional Mac weeding from 09 not reflected in survey monkey. Blackwell and Elsevier added.

Publishers Weeded By School Products Weeded Brock Academic Press, Cambridge, Elsevier, JSTOR, Oxford University Press, Royal Society of Chemistry, Sage, Springer, Wiley Blackwell Laurentian Academic Press, American Chemical Society, American Mathematical Association, Berkeley Electronic Press, Cambridge, Elsevier, Emerald, JSTOR, Kluwer, Oxford University Press, PAO, Project Muse, Royal Society of Chemistry, Sage, Springer, Taylor & Francis, Wiley Blackwell McMaster Annual Reviews, Elsevier, Institute of Physics, JSTOR, NRC, Oxford University Press, PAO, Sage, Springer, Wiley Blackwell Nippissing JSTOR RMC American Chemical Society, Elsevier, Institute of Physics, Kluwer, Royal Society of Chemistry, Springer Ryerson Cambridge, Elsevier, JSTOR, Oxford University Press, Wiley Blackwell Trent American Chemical Society, Institute of Physics, JSTOR, Oxford University Press, Royal Society of Chemistry, Wiley Blackwell UOIT American Chemical Society, American Mathematical Association, Elsevier, Royal Society of Chemistry Waterloo Cambridge, Elsevier, Kluwer, Oxford University Press, Project Muse, Royal Society of Chemistry York Academic Press, American Chemical Society, American Institute of Physics, Cambridge, Elsevier, Institute of Physics, JSTOR, Kluwer, Oxford University Press, PAO, Royal Society of Chemistry, Sage, Springer, Taylor & Francis, Wiley Blackwell

Weeding By Publisher Titles Schools That Have Weeded Academic Press Brock, Laurentian, York American Chemical Society Laurentian, RMC, Trent, UOIT, York American Institute of Physics York American Mathematical Association Laurentian, UOIT Berkley Electronic Press Laurentian Cambridge Brock, Laurentian, Ryerson, Waterloo, York Elsevier Brock, Laurentian, RMC, Ryerson, UOIT, Waterloo, York Emerald Institute of Physics McMaster, RMC, Trent, York JSTOR Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, Nippissing, Ryerson, Trent, York Kluwer Laurentian, RMC, Waterloo, York Oxford University Press Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, Trent, Waterloo, York PAO Laurentian, McMaster, York Project Muse Laurentian, Waterloo Royal Society of Chemistry Brock, Laurentian, RMC, Trent, UOIT, Waterloo, York Sage Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, York Springer Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, RMC, York Taylor & Francis Laurentian, York Wiley Blackwell Brock, Laurentian, McMaster, Ryerson, Trent, York Plus Annual Reviews and NRC backfiles – McMaster

Publishers Weeded by School Titles B L M N RM C R T UOI T W Y Academic Press  American Chemical Society American Institute of Physics American Mathematical Association Berkley Electronic Press Cambridge Elsevier Emerald Institute of Physics JSTOR Kluwer Oxford University Press PAO Project Muse Royal Society of Chemistry Sage Springer Taylor & Francis Wiley Blackwell B = Brock L = Laurentian M = McMaster N = Nippissing R = Ryerson T = Trent W = Waterloo Y = York

2010 Reponses to Questions on Last Copies Do you intend to … …weed down to one copy? 2 libraries answered yes …retain a print copy if your location has the 2nd (or 3rd, or more) copy in Ontario? 5 libraries answered yes Out of the 5 libraries that intend retain a print copy, 0 will do so at the package level 4 will do so at the title level 1 will use a mixture of both How are you currently deciding whether you have the last print copy? Generalized Responses Response Count Checking against all OCUL members holdings. 3 Checking against some OCUL members’ holdings. Not currently checking. 2 If it is part of perpetual access only. 1 ISSN list from the vendor used to create a Cognos report of holdings that is manually compared to identify long runs that will be designated as the last print copy holder. Total # of Responses 10