British Academy/Government Social Research Workshop on Evaluation.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Areas of Research Specific issues. Clinical Trials Phase I First use in humans of an experimental drug or treatment In a small group of healthy volunteers.
Advertisements

4th VRE Programme meeting July 2006, Manchester User engagement: five key challenges and strategies for addressing them Chris Ramsden and Kerstin.
Workforce Development Update - September Workforce Development – Messages from Cavendish Review In the wake of the Francis Inquiry; What can be.
Greater Involvement of People Living with HIV (GIPA)
Doheny M. 1, Richardson N. 1, Brennan L. 2, Lambe B. 3, Osborne A. 1, Carroll P. 3 1 Centre for Men’s Health, Institute of Technology Carlow 2 Men’s Development.
Information and Communication Technology Research Initiative Supporting the self management of obesity: The role of ICTs University.
Library manager Gruppo di discussione del Workshop.
Supporting the self management of obesity: The role of ICTs ICTRI2 seminar, Department of Health, Wellington House, London February 15 th 2007.
Modelling the impact of service innovation in Stroke Care Tanaka Business School: Imperial College. Lead researcher: Dr Benita Cox Background Stroke is.
What is DV-alert DV-alert (Domestic Violence Response Training) is a FREE nationally-run accredited training program that provides skills to: RECOGNISE.
Health Education NCEL (North Central and East London) Health Education NWL (North West London) Health Education SL (South London) The power of collaboration.
Concept To develop a low cost, consistent end of life care programme, available to all care homes. It will support the development of nominated staff.
+ Year 11 Health and Physical Education H.P.E courses for year 11? VET Certificate Courses  Certificate II Sport and Rec. – Coaching  Certificate.
MOVING FROM “WHAT’S THE MATTER WITH YOU” MEDICINE TO “WHAT MATTERS TO YOU”: A PARADIGM SHIFT IN PHILOSOPHY OF CARE.
18 th to 21 st June 2013 Primary Care Sciences Keele University RUNNING RANDOMISED CLINICAL TRIALS For further enquiries contact Debbie Cooke Tel: +44(0)1782.
Activity 1: My skills. Personal, learning and thinking skills How would you describe these kinds of people? What do you think they would be good at? –Independent.
Apprenticeships and Benefits Pocketfit Team. Apprenticeship Offer Instructing Fitness Studio Instructing Operational Services Management and Leadership.
Barriers & facilitators associated with initial and continued attendance at community-based interventions among families of overweight & obese children.
The role of The National Careers Service in Transforming Rehabilitation Emily Jones - Futures Advice, Skills and Employment Ray Plummer - Skills Funding.
WORKSHOP CAN EDUCATION AND LIFELONG LEARNING IMPROVE QUALITY OF LIFE IN RURAL AREAS? Introduction by Fouli Papageorgiou Summer Academy on “The Role of.
Presentation By L. M. Baird And Scottish Health Council Research & Public Involvement Knowledge Exchange Event 12 th March 2015.
Can an evidence based coaching intervention improve outcomes for older people with congestive heart failure (CHF) and their informal caregivers within.
Author Title Author Name Universal Credit Briefing.
Policy Research Programme Social Care Workforce Research Initiative Marie McNay and Hazel Qureshi.
Quality Education for a Healthier Scotland Improving Practice Elaine Kwiatek, Education Projects Manager, NES.
The health and wellbeing impacts of Active Labour Market Programmes (ALMPs) Dr Adam Coutts Public Policy Unit Department of Politics and International.
Facilitator: Step 4 1. Review / Recap Step 3 workshop review Review of ‘To Do’ List Reflection discussions 2.
1 Training Family Carers in the Implementation of Positive Behavioural Support Marie Thomson Depute Manager Positive Behaviour Support Team
Researching Innovation.  By definition, an innovation means that you are testing out something new to see how effective it is.  This also means that.
Monitoring and Evaluating Rural Advisory Services
Pruden Global Business Solutions Consulting, LLC (PGBSC)
Ambition School Leadership
Career Ready and Programme updates
Institute of Health and Society, Newcastle University
Skills for Care update Laura Anthony Locality Manager – SW London.
RUNNING RANDOMISED CLINICAL TRIALS
About us I would have about then Turas Nua logo.
ENTERPRISE FACULTY What is Enterprise?.
Developing Sustainable Behaviour Change Training
Poster 1. Leadership Development Programme : Leading Cultures of Research and Innovation in Clinical Teams Background The NHS Constitution is explicit.
Project Coordinator – Breaking the Cycle of Youth Violence
Elizabeth Cornish Career Development Service University of Leicester
The HEalthy Adolescent Relationships Training Study (HEARTS) is a project to evaluate the ArielTrust’s ‘FaceUp’ programme.
Competency Based Interviews
Final Draft for Approval – March 2016
Monitoring and Evaluating Rural Advisory Services
Strategic Planning Update Group 5
Connecting employee volunteers with school/college governing boards
ما الذي يريد صاحب العمل أن يعرفه؟
eInclusion Call 5 INFO DAY Brussels , 19th April 2005
Key Question WHY USE A NON-TRADITIONAL RCT DESIGN?
Smart & Health Aging Promoting Empowering Systems
“Effective professional development for teachers is a core
Social Cohesion & Inclusion Sub-group Proposal, May 2018 Chaired by
micro:bit Global Challenge
Diabetes Prevention Programme
Location: Staff Home Woodend Hospital
Takeyourplace.ac.uk Using data to address ethical challenges in RCTs: activity tracking and process focus Sonia Ilie & Silvia Lucato-Hadeler.
micro:bit Global Challenge
micro:bit Global Challenge
Get a Boost, Get Connected, Get Hired!
micro:bit Global Challenge
micro:bit Global Challenge
Are you ready? #carevalues
The National Professional Qualification (NPQ) An overview
NAME OF GOOD PRACTICE PRESENTERS NAME: CATEGORY: LOCAL GOVERNMENT COE
Community Engagement and Participation
Ciara Lynch, Medical Social Worker
Evaluation of Youth Employment Initiative
Advance Care Planning and Communication Skills
Presentation transcript:

British Academy/Government Social Research Workshop on Evaluation. Case Study 4: Group Work trial Date: 12th July 2017 Presenter: Mark Langdon

Why are we testing Group Work Group Work (JOBS II) Why are we testing Group Work JOBS Supports employment and inoculates against & Rejuvenates Psychological Distress Tested via RCT in the USA (twice) and Finland Found +ve impact on employment and Psychological State. Sustained differences up to 2 years following participation. Also ‘tested’ in Ireland and China But how does it work? Careful design; the facilitators behaviours, structure to claimant day, shared problem solving, shared group experiences, job search skills and resilience building.

What can sink your trial? Resentment Bias Recognise Recruit Intervention Control Randomise A simple Parallel Designed RCT Selection Bias Innovation and Reactance Bias Challenge to equipoise Volition Fit with operational process

Addressing some of these issues, but not all… Resentment Bias A simple Zelen Designed RCT Control Reactance Bias Recognise Randomise Decline Recruit Offered Intervention Accept Selection Bias Innovation Bias Challenge to equipoise Programme Fit with operational process Volition

Questions for discussion… What steps have you taken to ensure successful trial delivery? What other factors have emerged in live running that have risked trial failure; how were these managed? What is the role for active trial management? What are your views on the importance of qualitative process evaluation?