WSI-FS II: Validation of Squamous Cell Carcinoma Frozen Section Whole Slide Image Diagnosis in Surgical Pathology Vamsi Parimi MD1; Ryba Dominika, Ewa.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY PATHOPHYSIOLOGY w DEFINED Involves the study of function that results from disease processes.
Advertisements

International Telecommunication Union Workshop on Standardization in E-health Geneva, May 2003 Digital Imaging in Pathology for Standardization Yukako.
The Impact of Gynecologic Pathology Diagnostic Errors on Patient Care Dana Marie Grzybicki MD, PhD Colleen M. Vrbin, BA Danielle Pirain, BS Stephen S.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Robotic Telepathology vs
James E. Madory, D.O. Assistant Professor Medical Director of Pathology Informatics Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine Medical University.
…and that the right diagnosis is critical to your patients’ outcomes. UW Ocular Pathology Laboratory Because you know ocular tissue is different …
Milwaukee Pathology Hub and Spoke Model Bruce E. Dunn, M.D. Milwaukee VA Medical Center
The Laval University (Québec) virtual slide telepathology project; A structured patient-oriented network involving 21 sites Bernard Têtu MD, Medical director.
A re-audit of Prostate biopsies from January to December 2010 and Dr. M S Siddiqui Consultant Histopathologist University Hospital of North Tees.
Measuring diagnostic accuracy of using digital slides in routine histopathology and analyzing sources of diagnostic errors László FÓNYAD 1st. Dept. of.
Procedures used by CHTN
Ronald S. Weinstein, M.D. Professor, Pathology Head, Pathology 1990 – 2007 Director, Arizona Telemedicine Program.
1 CLINICAL TRIALS Digital Pathology in the Era of Global Clinical Trials: Improving Quality and Consistency Ron Luff, MD, MPH.
Diagnostic Assays to Plan Specific Drug Treatment Elizabeth Hammond MD.
High Volume Slide Scanning Architecture and Applications
PATHOLOGY: A Career in Medicine
Audit of oropharyngeal cancer reporting and frequency of p16 testing at Derriford Hospital. Cost and clinical implications Miss S J Edwards ENT StR Dr.
Development of CAP Standards for Digital Pathology That Would be Important for CAP Accreditation of Pathology Labs as We Transition Into a Digital Era.
Background Sentinel lymph node biopsy has been recently introduced in the clinical setting because it is highly accurate in predicting the lymph node status.
Practical Issues on Clinical Validation of Digital Imaging Applications in Routine Surgical Pathology FDA Hematology and Pathology Devices Panel Meeting.
Image Quality in Digital Pathology (from a pathologist’s perspective) Jonhan Ho, MD, MS.
Real-Time Telepathology for Subspecialty Consultation Nikolaj Lagwinski, MD September 10 th, 2007.
Unknown Primary Tumors: Newer Concepts and Approches “ 10 years experience of a Comprehensive Cancer Center” Valerio Ramazzotti S.C. Epidemiologia Roma.
Operational Considerations in Implementing Digital Pathology Pathology Visions 2009 Walter H. Henricks, M.D. Cleveland Clinic.
1 CAP Audio Conference on the CMS 2009 Physician Quality Reporting Initiative Jonathan Myles, MD, FCAP College of American Pathologists December 17, 2008.
Developing a Validated Tool For Evaluating Whole Slide Images.
Changes in Breast Cancer Reports After Second Opinion Dr. Vicente Marco Department of Pathology Hospital Quiron Barcelona. Spain.
Diagnostic Challenge Pathology for Neurosurgery & Neurology Residents Department of Pathology University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City,
The Results of Automated Image Analysis Workshop at the 10th European Congress on Telepathology and 4th International Congress on Virtual Microscopy Arvydas.
INCREASED EXPRESSION OF PROTEIN KINASE CK2  SUBUNIT IN HUMAN GASTRIC CARCINOMA Kai-Yuan Lin 1 and Yih-Huei Uen 1,2,3 1 Department of Medical Research,
Challenges of Cancer Diagnosis in Resource Limited Settings Optimizing Pathology Support Ann Marie Nelson, M.D. AIDS and Infectious Disease Pathology Joint.
Wednesday August 16, 2006 APIII 2006 Vancouver Breakout Session A2 Integrating whole slide images into clinical workflow Jonhan Ho, MD Dermatopathology.
Grading And Staging Grading is based on the microscopic features of the cells which compose a tumor and is specific for the tumor type. Staging is based.
Issues in Validation of Whole Slide Digital Images for Frozen Section Interpretation Lewis A. Hassell, MD Pathology Visions October 2010.
W. Scott Campbell, Ph.D., MBA University of Nebraska Medical Center
Assessing Quality of Pathology Reporting: The Case of Tongue Cancer Lihua Liu 1, PhD Wesley Y. Naritoku 2, MD, PhD Juanjuan Zhang 1, MS Lenard Berglund.
CLINICAL ASPECT OF GRADING AND STAGING Hanggoro Tri Rinonce, MD, PhD Department of Anatomical Pathology Faculty of Medicine, Gadjah Mada University.
Critical Appraisal Course for Emergency Medicine Trainees Module 5 Evaluation of a Diagnostic Test.
R2 김재민 / Prof. 정재헌 Journal conference 1.
Digital Pathology, An Introduction From glass slides to digital files and there after.
Introduction to Quality Assurance. Quality assurance vs. Quality control.
Pathophysiology.
Tissue Collection & Banking Facility
Comprised of Blood Agar and CHROMagarTM Orientation using WASPLabTM
W. Scott Campbell, MBA, PhD James R. Campbell, MD
Careers in Biomedical Technology Objective 1
CORRELATION OF PHYSICAL EVALUATION AND MRI OF CERVICAL LYMPH NODE WITH HISTOPATHOLOGICAL FINDINGS IN ORAL SQUAMOUS CELL CARCINOMA: AN AMBIDIRECTIONAL STUDY.
Pathophysiology.
Hematology and Pathology Devices Panel Meeting October 22-23, 2009
The Royal Brompton & Harefield Hospitals’ Experience
FDA Hematology and Pathology Devices Panel Meeting October 22-23, 2009
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY.
A diagnostic challenge: an incidental lung nodule in a 48-year-old nonsmoker Blake Christianson1, Smeet Patel MD1, Supriya Gupta MD1, Shikhar Vyas MD2,
Undiagnosed primary Hepatocellular carcinoma
W. Scott Campbell, MBA, PhD University of Nebraska Medical Center
Fadeel H. Mahmood1, Jeffrey A. Strakowski1,2, Marcie A
W. Scott Campbell, MBA, PhD University of Nebraska Medical Center
Prof.S.M.Haider Faisal Hameed Wahab Kadri
MORE THAN JUST INFLAMMATION: INITIAL DIAGNOSIS OF CHRONIC LYMPHOCYTIC LYMPHOMA FOUND IN A ROUTINE EXCISION OF SQUAMOUS CELL CARCINOMA Andrew LJ Dunn,
Digital Pathology Early Adoption Douglas J
Digital Pathology Devices Panel Meeting
An Audit on Complex hyperplasia reporting at Derriford Hospital
Pathophysiology.
Measuring Accuracy in Digital Pathology Ole Eichhorn Chief Technology Officer, Aperio FDA panel discussion, Oct 22-23, 2009.
Digital Pathology Devices Panel Meeting
Digital Pathology Devices Panel Meeting
A specialty review made by residents for medical students
UPDATEs IN GASTROINTESTINAL PATHOLOGY
Trends in survival from metastatic lung cancer in California,
New Provider and Reappointment Training
Presentation transcript:

WSI-FS II: Validation of Squamous Cell Carcinoma Frozen Section Whole Slide Image Diagnosis in Surgical Pathology Vamsi Parimi MD1; Ryba Dominika, Ewa Borys, MD1; Vijayalakshmi Ananthanarayanan, MD1; Swati Mehrotra, MD1; Xianzhong Ding, MD1; Maria M. Picken, MD PhD1; Dariusz Borys, MD1 1Department of Pathology, Loyola University Medical Center, Maywood, Illinois INTRODUCTION RESULTS The utility of Whole Slide Imaging for Frozen Section (WSI-FS) slides is garnering increasing interest in anatomic pathology for primary diagnostic and consultation purposes. The College of American Pathologists (CAP) as part of its proficiency testing introduced WSI checklist (GEN. 52920) to ensure the diagnostic performance of digitized slides on par to that of glass slides light microscopy for clinical use. In addition to technical issues, regulatory and validation requirements related to WSI-FS have yet to be adequately addressed. Our objective was to examine the results of a WSI-FS validation study performed using WSI clinical validation guidelines recently released by the CAP in a community/academic setting. Our study was the first to specifically looking at different tumor subtypes encountered in anatomic pathology frozen section diagnosis. The current study report results of validation of whole slide imaging for frozen section Squamous Cell Carcinoma (SCC) diagnosis to that of original glass slide (G-FS) interpretation. We have shared our previous WSI-FS I Adenocarcinoma study data at USCAP-2016 Among 246 specimens, 135 were positive for SCC, 104 negative for SCC and 7 lymph nodes positive for metastatic SCC. FS specimens include slides with primary SCC neoplasms, margins of surgical resections and lymph nodes The average scan times per slide was 2 minutes 30 seconds and average interpretation time per specimen was 2 minutes 30 seconds which included evaluation of superficial and deep frozen sections. The wash-out interval was greater than 300 days. Interobserver agreement between G-FS and WSI-FS ranged from 84-93% Average false negative and false positive diagnosis on WSI-FS was 8.3% and 2.28% respectively The sensitivity and specificity of WSI-FS diagnosis ranged from 85-96% and 93-100% respectively.   The ratio of the odds of the WSI-FS being positive if the GS has a SCC relative to the odds of the WSI-FS being positive if the GS does not have the SCC (Diagnostic Odds Ratio) was 817 (average). Inter-rater reliability between G-FS and WSI-FS; Cohen's Kappa Statistic ranged from 0.83 to 0.94 among the pathologists and demonstrated an overall excellent reliability for the observer agreement. Pathologist Specialization   Bone/Soft tissue Neuropathology Genitourinary HNT-1 HNT-2 Gastrointestinal Total specimens (n=246) G-FS WSI-FS (A) WSI-FS (B) WSI-FS (C) WSI-FS (D) WSI-FS (E) WSI-FS (F) Positive for SCC 135 61% 61.30% 50.30% 58% 53% 57% Negative for SCC 104 39% 38.70% 49.70% 42% 47% 43% Suspicious for SCC LN/ Mets Concordance 7 85% 80% 60% 100% Overall Concordance 90% (208) 87% (193) 84% (176) 91% (185) 92% (162) 93% (234) p value <0.05 False +ve (Type I error) 4.70% 6.70% 0% 0.90% 1.40% PPV 95% 96% 99% False -ve (Type II error) 2.50% 6.60% 16.80% 8.90% 6% NPV 97% 90% 83% 91% Sensitivity (95% CI) 98.28 93.22 85.29 93.81 92.31 96.35 Specificity (%) 92.59 94.59 100 98.61 97.92 Positive likelihood ratio 13.26 17.24 N/A 67.54 46.248 Negative likelihood ratio 0.02 0.07 0.15 0.06 0.08 0.04 Diagnostic-OR (95%CI) 712 241 1075 1241 Cohen's Kappa Statistic 0.92 0.87 0.83 0.91 0.94 METHODS A total of 108 FS SCC cases (246 specimens and 463 glass microscope slides) from random anatomic sites from 2013 and 2014 were identified (search word “squamous”) and scanned by Aperio CS2 slide scanner (Leica Biosystems, San Diego, CA, USA) with 20x/0.75NA Plan Apo objective lens The digital images were visualized at 1916 × 1072 pixel resolution with eSlide Manager (Leica Biosystems) software. In our study, 6 surgical pathologists specializing in neuropathology, head, neck & thorax pathology, bone and soft tissue pathology, genitourinary pathology and gastrointestinal pathology independently evaluated WSI-FS slides necessary to make a final diagnosis (presence or absence of SCC). No clinical or prior diagnostic information (age, sex, clinical history, location, presence or absence of tumor) were provided to the pathologist in aiding diagnosis. Pathologists reviewed the WSI-FS cases, without the knowledge of primary pathologist’s readout on G-FS. CONCLUSION We established diagnostic concordance between digital and glass slides by CAP-PLQC recommended guidelines for the SCC tumor subtype in an institutional laboratory system at ×20 magnification among pathologists sub-specialized in surgical pathology. This study was the first to specifically evaluate WSI-FS diagnosis of SCC.  REFERENCES Pantanowitz L, Sinard JH, Henricks WH, Fatheree LA, Carter AB, Contis L, Beckwith BA, Evans AJ, Lal A, Parwani AV. “Validating whole slide imaging for diagnostic purposes in pathology: guideline from the College of American Pathologists Pathology and Laboratory Quality Center.” Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2013 Dec;137(12):1710   Têtu B, Evans A. Canadian licensure for the use of digital pathology for routine diagnoses: one more step toward a new era of pathology practice without borders. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2014 Mar;138(3):302-4