Coef (change in ZAN from baseline) CONTACT and ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Upper Garden Villa Royal Cornhill Hospital
Advertisements

Creating a Therapeutic Milieu in an Acute Psychiatric Setting
Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence November–December 2014.
Conclusions and Implications
Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence May–June 2013.
Visit our websites: PhD Study: Evaluation of the Efficacy of the Incredible.
Journal Club Alcohol and Health: Current Evidence July–August 2005.
Psychology 3.3 Managing stress. Psychology Learning outcomes Understand the following three studies on managing stress: Cognitive (Meichenbaum, D. (1972)
The Community Perspective Dr Linda R Treliving Chair of SPDN.
Daniel Flynn 1, Mary Kells 1, Mary Joyce 1&2, Catalina Suarez 1&2 1. Health Service Executive 2. National Suicide Research Foundation The National Dialectical.
The cost-effectiveness of providing a DAFNE follow- up intervention to predicted non-responders J Kruger 1, A Brennan 1, P Thokala 1, S Heller 2 on behalf.
Day Hospital versus admission for acute psychiatric disorders Dr. Simon Benson ST2 General Practice.
Examination of the effects at one year of referral for brief intervention by an Alcohol Health Worker (AHW) on levels of alcohol consumption, psychiatric.
TRAP: A long term outcome and process study of a residential treatment for treatment refractory adolescents with personality disorders Dineke Feenstra.
The Effectiveness of Psychodynamic Therapy and Cognitive Behavior Therapy in the Treatment of Personality Disorders: A Meta-Analysis. By Falk Leichsenring,
Core Outcome Domains for Eczema – Results of a Delphi Consensus Project Introduction Eczema is a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory skin disorder that affects.
The SCIN (Skin care intervention in nurses) Trial: A Cluster Randomised Trial Dr I. Madan (Guy’s & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust), Dr V. Parsons (King’s.
Impact of transient and persistent personality disturbance on the outcome of anxiety and depressive disorders Professor Peter Tyrer (Imperial College,
Our experience of running a psycho education group for Borderline Personality Disorder (MBT-i). Chris Gray Specialist Nurse Practitioner in Psychotherapy.
1 Centre for Sport and Exercise Science, Sheffield Hallam University, U. K. 2 York Trials Unit, Department of Health Sciences, University of York, U. K.
Old fomrat. September 2013 Glasgow Conference.
London’s Mental Health Crisis Care Summit Workshop B: in the Emergency Department 25 th February 2016 Kia, Oval Dr Sean Cross and Dr Alex Thomson.
LifeCIT Development and pilot evaluation of a web-supported programme of Constraint Induced Therapy following stroke (LifeCIT) Meagher C 1, Conlon A 2,
Suicide and self-harm in people with bipolar disorder Better Care for People with Bipolar Disorder Manchester January 2015 Nav Kapur The Centre for Suicide.
By: Nashwa Ibrahim. The strengths-based approach is a person- centred approach to caring in mental health which supports commitment to human potential.
Association of Cognitive Outcomes and Response Status in Late Life Depression: A 12 Month Longitudinal Study David Bickford B.A., Alana Kivowitz B.A.,
Health Related Quality of Life after serious occupational injuries and long term disability Presenter: Ibishi Nazmie MD,PhD University Clinical Center.
Contact: Patrick Phillips,
Association of Body Mass Index (BMI) and Depression Severity
Wendy L. Wolfe, Kaitlyn Patterson, & Hannah Towhey
admissions in residents in care homes.
Kaitlyn Patterson & Wendy Wolfe
Caroline Clements Project lead, Professor Nav Kapur
A real life example of intervention retention and follow up in the community: problem solving for self-harm in prisons.
Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire McGill Pain Questionnaire
GENDER DIFFERENCES IN FIRST-TIME HOMELESS ADULTS*
Service-related research: Therapy outcomes audit
EXPERIENCES AND OUTCOMES OF PSYCHOTHERAPY IN PERSONALITY DISORDER: THE ROLE OF POST TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER Kirsten Barnicot,1 Mike Crawford,1 Stefan.
The mental health ‘stepped’ model of care
The Resource Pack Trial
ACT with Mindfulness: Piloting
An evaluation of the online universal COPING parent programme:
Emergency department pediatric psychiatric services
Eating Disorders Chapter 1.
Spiritual support in end stage heart failure (ESHF): a randomised controlled feasibility study  Linda Ross1, Jackie Austin2,Paul Jarvis1, Sara Pickett3 
Quality of Medical Care Received by Individuals with Mental Illnesses
Pharmacological and Behavioral
The DEPression in Visual Impairment Trial:
Presentations to an Irish Eating Disorder Service – who are they
Reducing bias in randomised controlled trials involving therapists:
Effect of centrally acting ACE inhibitors on Alzheimer’s disease progress: A retrospective longitudinal study using SLAM BRC Case register Dr Gayan Perera.
Neil Pearce Associate Medical Director for Safety
Miss Jacqueline Mansfield Dr Janet Parrott Professor Douglas MacInnes
Starting out on a clinical academic pathway: the experience of a newly- qualified nurse Sarah Lea Faculty of Health and Social Care, London South Bank.
The use of regular text messaging over one year to collect primary outcome data in an RCT Reuben Ogollah1,2, Martyn Lewis1,2, Kika Konstantinou1 Sarah.
Dr. Thomas Richardson Clinical Psychologist (1,2)
Dr Gayan Perera Epidemiologist
Development of an electronic personal assessment questionnaire to capture the impact of living with a vascular condition: ePAQ-VAS Patrick Phillips, Elizabeth.
The authors have no competing interests to declare.
Y.A. Westad, J. Vigfusdottìr, E. Jonsbu and K. Hagen
Sensory stimulation of the foot and ankle early post-stroke:
A2 unit 4 Clinical Psychology
INNOVATIVE, INTERPROFESSIONAL SIMULATION
Dr Kerry Woolfall Kerry_woolfall
Seasonal variation of incidence
An Innovative Joint Education initiative for Psychiatrists & GPs
JAMA Pediatrics Journal Club Slides: Effect of Attendance of the Child in Childhood Obesity Treatment Boutelle KN, Rhee KE, Liang J, et al. Effect of attendance.
Social prescribing: Less rhetoric and more reality
Mental Health and Emotional Wellbeing
Dr Coral Sirdifield Research Fellow
Presentation transcript:

Coef (change in ZAN from baseline) CONTACT and ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A Randomized Controlled Trial of Mentalization Based Therapy (ED) against Specialist Supportive Clinical Management (ED) in patients with both Eating Disorders and symptoms of Borderline Personality Disorder The NOURISHED Study *Paul Robinson 1,2, * Jennifer Hellier 4, Caroline Murphy 4, Barbara Barrett 4, Clare Rutterford 4, Fenella Lemonsky 5, Ulrike Schmidt 4, Nicola Kern 6, Daiva Barzdaitiene, 7, Az Hakeem 8, Alex Bogaardt 1, Ajay Clare 1, Anthony Bateman 1, 2, and Peter Fonagy 2, 3 Barnet Enfield and Haringey Mental Health Trust, 2. University College London, 3. Anna Freud Centre, 4. Kings College London, 5. Expert by experience, 6. South London and The Maudsley NHS Trust, 7. Kent and Medway NHS Trust, 8. Camden and Islington NHS Trust * Joint first authors ABSTRACT METHODS - continued Preliminary RESULTS RESULTS continued CONCLUSIONS Instruments used Eating Disorders Examination (EDE) (EDE-Q at 36 months) Reflective Function Questionnaire (RFQ) Reading the mind in the eyes test Object Relations Inventory (ORI) Acts of Deliberate Self Harm Inventory (ADSHI) MINI International Neuropsychiatric Schedule (MINI) Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis II Personality Disorders (SCID-II) Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) Zanarini-BPD (ZAN-BPD) Euroqol (EQ5D) Depression, Anxiety, Stress Scales -21 (DASS 21) Modified Social Adjustment Scale (SAS) Adult Service Use Schedule (AD-SUS) Big Five personality Inventory (BFI) Apart from the MINI and the SCID II which are only administered at baseline for diagnostic purposes, all instruments were repeated at 6, 12 and 18 months post randomization. At 36 months, the EDE-Q, the RFQ, the ZAN-BPD, and the DASS were used. The NOURISHED study: Nice OUtcomes for Referrals with Impulsivity, Self Harm and Eating Disorders. Eating Disorders (ED) and Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) are both difficult to treat and the combination presents particular challenges. Both are associated with vulnerability to loss of mentalization (awareness of one’s own and others’ emotional state). In BPD, Mentalization Based therapy (MBT) has been found effective in reducing symptoms. In this trial we investigate the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of MBT adapted for Eating disorders (Mentalization Based Therapy for Eating Disorders (MBT-ED)) compared to a standard comparison treatment, Specialist Supportive Clinical Management (SSCM-ED) in patients with a combination of an Eating Disorder and either a diagnosis of BPD or a history of self-harm and impulsivity in the previous 12 months. Primary outcome was the Global EDE score, compared between the two therapies. Interim results: Drop-out was high, with 37% attending for 12 month follow up and 22% at 18 months. However, using Linear Mixed Models analysis, up to 18 months, global EDE score, the primary outcome measure, had significantly improved in both treatment groups by a mean of 0.9 units. Analysis of subscales showed that the MBT-ED had significantly lower Shape Concern and Weight Concern scores compared to SSCM-ED. 36 month results and secondary outcomes are being analysed. Discussion: This is the first Randomised Controlled Trial of MBT-ED in patients with eating disorders and symptoms of BPD. During MBT-ED mentalization is encouraged, while in SSCM-ED it is not overtly addressed. Early indications are that both therapies appeared helpful, with MBT-ED perhaps having more influence on ED psychopathology. Adverse outcomes There were 10 adverse events including hospital admission for self harm and weight loss with no difference between groups. There was one death in a patient who was receiving MBT-ED. The inquest recorded a verdict of unexplained adult sudden death with no evidence (including toxicology) of self harm or other identifiable cause. Consort diagram A further (postal) follow up was performed at 36 months with 21 participants responding Changes in EDE scores (Eating Disorder symptoms) over time This study has now ended and analysis is continuing. However, certain tentative conclusions can be reached. The population treated was of high morbidity and this may have contributed to the drop out rate. Methodologies for implementing the two novel therapies MBT-ED and SSCM-ED have been established and manuals written. Recruitment was slower than anticipated mainly because of the training requirements for MBT-ED which delayed the onset of treatment. Participants were overwhelmingly suffering from Bulimia Nervosa and Borderline Personality Disorder. Both treatment groups showed a reduction of eating disorder symptoms comparable to that seen in other therapy trials and there was some evidence that MBT-ED might reduce eating disorder symptoms more that SSCM-ED. Both groups also showed a significant reduction in BPD symptoms. 3 year follow up results will be analysed together with the present result. Overall this trial should be seen as a feasibility and pilot study . The results encourage the use of both MBT-ED and SSCM-ED in further trials, for example in patients who have failed to respond to currently available evidence based approaches. EDE outcomes over 18 mth. The Global EDE score (top) declines significantly over time with no difference between treatments. Weight Concern (mid) and Shape Concern (below) show a significant treatment effect in favour of MBT-ED against SSCM-ED at 12 and 18 months. REFERENCES McIntosh, V. V., et al. (2006). "Specialist supportive clinical management for anorexia nervosa." The International journal of eating disorders 39(8): 625-632. Robinson, P., et al. (2014). "Study Protocol for a randomized controlled trial of mentalization based therapy against specialist supportive clinical management in patients with both eating disorders and symptoms of borderline personality disorder." BMC Psychiatry 14 (1): 51. Robinson P H (2013) Mentalization Based Therapy of non-suicidal self injury and eating disorders. In Non-suicidal self injury in eating disorders. Eds Claes, L, Muehelkamp. Publ: Springer Skårderud, F., Fonagy, P (2012). Eating Disorders. Handbook of mentalizing in Mental Health Practice. A. a. F. Bateman, P. Arlington, VA American Psychiatric Publishing Inc. 347-384. OBJECTIVES Primary objective To ascertain whether Mentalization Based Therapy (Skårderud et al 2012) is clinically effective at reducing observer rated symptoms of Eating Disorder, using an accepted measure, the Eating Disorders Examination, in patients with combined eating and borderline personality disorder symptoms up to 18 months post randomisation compared to Specialist Supportive Clinical Management (Mcintosh et al 2006). Secondary objectives To ascertain whether Mentalization Based Therapy is cost effective at reducing observer rated symptoms of Eating Disorder, using an accepted measure, the Eating Disorders Examination, in patients with combined eating and borderline personality disorder symptoms up to 18 months post randomisation compared to Specialist Supportive Clinical Management. To determine whether Mentalization Based Therapy is clinically effective at reducing symptoms of Borderline Personality Disorder as measured by the Zanarini-BPD scale, an accepted measure of BPD symptoms in patients with combined eating disorders and borderline personality disorder symptoms up to 18 months post randomisation compared to Specialist Supportive Clinical Management. To examine participant outcome at an average of 36 months post randomization. To ascertain whether adverse events in the two groups differ. To ascertain whether MBT is a cost-effective treatment for BPD compared to SSCM. 
   EDE diagnoses MBT-ED N=34 SSCM-ED Total N=68 AN 2 (6%) 4 (6%) BN 22 (65%) 21 (62%) 43 (63%) BED 0 (0%) 2 (3%) EDNOS 8 (24%) 11 (32%) 19 (28%) METHODS (see Robinson et al 2014) Changes in ZAN-BPD (Borderline PD symptoms) over time: Overall significant fall, but no difference between treatments. Data from whole group. This was a multi-centre study across three NHS Eating Disorder Units in three different NHS Trusts. The design is a single-blind (researchers being blind) randomised controlled trial of Mentalization Based Therapy for eating disorders (MBT-ED) (Robinson 2013), with an intensity of one individual and one group session per week for one year, compared to Specialist Supportive Clinical Management adapted for all eating disorders (SSCM-ED), a standard treatment for eating disorders, which comprises one session every 1 to 4 weeks for 20 to 26 sessions All trial participants had access to up to 5 hours of dietetic advice over the course of treatment. Participants were recruited from the participating clinics and included both new referrals and patients currently receiving care. Randomisation was remote to ensure researcher blindness to treatment allocation. Treatment began following randomization for 12 months (MBT-ED) or for up to 12 months (SSCM-ED). All participants were asked to complete assessment questionnaires and to participate in assessment interviews at 6, 12 and 18 months follow-up. A further postal follow up was conducted at 36 months.   Zan Global Coef (change in ZAN from baseline) Std. Err. P>z [95% Conf. Interval] 6 Months -2.418 0.745 0.001 -3.877 -0.958 12 Months -4.835 1.489 -7.754 -1.916 18 Months -7.253 2.234 -11.632 -2.875 Axis II diagnosis (SCID-II) MBT-ED N=32 SSCM-ED N=31 Total N=63 Avoidant Personality Disorder 2 (6.3%) 0 (0%) 2 (3.2%) Depressive Personality Disorder 5 (15.6%) 3 (9.7%) 8 (12.7%) Borderline Personality Disorder 23 (71.9%) 25 (80.7%) 48 (76.2%) No axis II Disorder 5 (7.9%) CONTACT and ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Dr Paul Robinson, Research Dept, St Ann’s Hospital, London N15 3TH p.robinson@ucl.ac.uk Development of the grant application was ably assisted by the North Central London Research Consortium to which organization we express our gratitude. This poster presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) under its Research for Patient Benefit (RfPB) Programme (Grant Reference Number PB-PG-0408-15183). The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NHS, the NIHR or the Department of Health. After the end of the NIHR grant, the trial was generously funded by Barnet Enfield and Haringey Mental Health Trust for a further year for which we are very grateful.