Narratives of agency and exclusion amongst transgender female sex workers in Cape Town, South Africa Zoe Samudzi, MSc Department of Social Psychology,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Evidence to Support the Scale-up of Work with Men: The Men and Gender Equality Policy Project Margaret E. Greene,
Advertisements

Division: EIDD WTO TBT Workshop on Good Regulatory Practice March 2008 Focus on Transparency and Consultation.
Gender and Globalization Dr. Carl Davila The College at Brockport Gender, Power and Globalization S.U.N.Y. Global Workforce Project.
Panel II - Promoting the access of vulnerable groups to social services covering basic needs A synthesis of discussions Hugh Frazer.
WHO G UIDANCE FOR TRANSGENDER PEOPLE Melbourne, July 2014 Kate Montecarlo A ssociation of Transgender People in the Philippines.
Gendered Assumptions and HIV/AIDS in Armed Conflict and Humanitarian Emergencies Presenter: Henia Dakkak Date: 23/07/2014.
Giving us a global voice Cecilia Chung, USA On behalf of the Key Populations Living with HIV Advisory Group of GNP+
B ALANCING IMMEDIATE SAFETY WITH THE NEED FOR FAR REACHING, LONG - TERM SOCIAL CHANGE T OWARDS A C OHERENT S TRATEGY FOR C RIME R EDUCTION IN S OUTH A.
Key Populations: Making Them Matter in the Global HIV Response Inextricable Links: HIV and Human Rights Kevin Osborne, LINKAGES Project Director 2 March.
Evaluation of Community Mobilization and Empowerment in Relation to HIV Prevention Programming among Female Sex Workers in Karnataka State, South India.
“Global Injustices – The control, containment and punishment of PLHIV” “How South Africa’s legislative framework fails us time and again: Experiences of.
Lessons learned from Nairobi, and experiences from Serbia Mr.sci.prim.dr Dragan Ilić epidemiologist Република Србија МИНИСТАРСТВО ЗДРАВЉА 1.
WORLD AIDS DAY 2001 Male involvement in the fight against AIDS Marleen Temmerman, RUG.
Washington D.C., USA, July 2012www.aids2012.org Turning the Tide of the Impact of HIV in Black Diaspora Communities African and Black Women Moono.
“A VISION OF HOPE” EXPERIENCE OF SENEGAL IN THE FIGHT AGAINST AIDS AND REDUCING WOMEN’S VULNERABILITY Dr Khoudia Sow, CRCF, UMI 233 Dakar Sénégal.
Through the Global Gender Gap Report, the World Economic Forum quantifies the magnitude of gender-based disparities and tracks their progress over time.
‘More Than Just Lip Service: Scaling up sex work initiatives’ Making the Money Matter: Support for sex worker initiatives through the Global Fund for HIV,
Why? To Spend money well and achieve fair outcomes What?
BUILDING HOPE Changing Health System in El Salvador Eduardo Espinoza Deputy Minister for Health Policy.
 Examines the nature of culture and the diverse ways in which societies make meaning and are organized across time and space. Topics include cultural.
7 th European Feminist Research Conference Utrecht, 4-7 June 2009 GEMIC: A project on Gender, Migration and Intercultural Interactions in the Mediterranean.
Operational Plan for UNAIDS Action Framework: Addressing Women, Girls, Gender Equality and HIV February 3, 2010.
NETWORK PRESENTATION- Botswana Network on Ethics, Law and HIV/AIDS(BONELA) REGIONAL WORKSHOP ON HIV/AIDS and VULNERABLE GROUPS MARCH 11-13, 2009, CAPE.
African Centre for Statistics United Nations Economic Commission for Africa Towards a More Effective Production of Gender Sensitive Data in African Countries:
Behavioural Monitoring for an All of Society Approach to HIV / AIDS Risk Reduction in Mozambique Prof. Andrew E. Collins Department of Geography / Disaster.
LGBTI Networks in Addressing HIV/AIDS Issues in SA Cape Town March 2009.
Eunice Sinyemu, ICW February 2013, Zambia.  Why involve women living with HIV?  How? ◦ Delivering services ◦ Demand creation ◦ Advocating for an enabling.
WCC - EHAIA RESPONDING TO THE HIV / AIDS CRISIS IN AFRICA.
Resiliency among Urban Youth Newly Diagnosed with HIV in Kenya: Sources of Social Support and Active Coping Strategies Gary W. Harper 1,2, Elizabeth Ngugi.
With Financial Support from the DAPHNE III Programme of the European Union.
Regional Forum: Use of Gender Data in Sub-national Decision-making Kigali, Rwanda August 2012 Key Gender Terms and Concepts.
Gender Affirming Health Care Drawing from a Zambian, Zimbabwean & South African context Presenter: Ricky Nathanson - Sexual Rights Centre ICASA 2015 KEY.
PROMOTING THE HEALTH OF MEN WHO HAVE SEX WITH MEN WORLDWIDE A training curriculum for providers.
Gender, Diversity and Climate Change
IAS Satellite Session 25th July 2017 Daniel Were, PhD
All-Ukrainian Network of PLWH
The Qualitative Report 8th Annual Conference
TransIT The Transgender Implementation Tool for the WHO key population guidelines.
Measuring Social Inclusion
Trade Union Training on the Validation of the training manual entitled “Union Training on Occupational Safety and Health” HEALTH & HIV/AIDS.
A Network of community-based service providers and sex workers organisations, cooperating in 25 European countries. AIMS  Advocate for sex workers’ human.
LABOR EDUCATION AND GLOBAL SOLIDARITY
Protocol for Workplace Gender Transitioning
10.2 Qualitative research: Interviews
Unit 10 Safeguarding in HCS Unit 10 Safeguarding in Health and Social Care Aim The aim of this unit is to enable learners to develop an understanding of.
Lady: Evaluation of a High Impact Approach to Sexual Health Promotion and Advocacy Among African American Colligates Females Background Conclusion The.
Narratives of agency and exclusion among cisgender male and transgender female sex workers in Cape Town, South Africa: dominant gender constructs and implications.
Gender Gender refers to the socially constructed characteristics of women and men – such as norms, roles and relationships of and between groups of women.
Facilitator Notes: Explain that this presentation provides a brief introduction to the global framework of Positive Health, Dignity, and Prevention (PHDP)
Sexual Trichotomy model
An on-line course in critical mental health promotion: Teaching and learning at multiple spheres of influence Jakubec, S.L., Mascaro, P. (Mount Royal University,
Institutional Theory and Platform Labour in Developing Countries
Data collection on LGBTI people and the 2030 Agenda
Carla Sutherland, PhD Head of Programmes, the Other Foundation
What does it take to reach the people who need it most?
What can be the concrete input of Religion for the promotion of Gender Equality & Women‘s Rights?
Residence Life Coordinator – University of South Carolina
Rejections of Heteronormativity & Hegemonic Masculinity
Advancing the Human Condition
The Feminization of Hiv in Ecuador Patriarchy as a threat to Public health A transfeminist perspective Fabián Espinosa – Academic Director – SIT Study.
Community rehabilitation workers as change agents: ”bringing back respect and dignity to communities!” Presenter: Mrs Siphokazi Sompeta Disability Studies.
POLICY & Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender & Intersex students
Gender inequality The unequal treatment of individuals based on their gender where by men or usually women are denied the same rights and opportunities.
Rebecca Nash and Ashley Towne
GDLN Global Dialogues: Scaling Up Poverty Reduction
Diverse Women? Marginalised Women? Or unhappy men?
What are the main features of Late Career Reinvention Coaching?
EXERCISE – TWO SIDES OF THE SAME COIN
GENDER CONCEPTS AND DEFINITIONS Sex refers to biologically defined and genetically acquired differences between males and females, according to their physiology.
Concepts & Themes.
Presentation transcript:

Narratives of agency and exclusion amongst transgender female sex workers in Cape Town, South Africa Zoe Samudzi, MSc Department of Social Psychology, London School of Economics Background This qualitative study explored the dynamics of discrimination, exclusion, vulnerability, and empowerment and how they influence the identity creation of transgender female service users at the Sex Workers Education and Advocacy Taskforce (SWEAT) in Cape Town. The primary objective of this project was to locate how transgender women construct understandings of their own identities in contrast with the stigmatized occupational and gendered identities imposed upon them. Findings The women who were interviewed reported stigmatization, discrimination, and exclusion from a number of different spaces. The most notable findings, however, are the described opportunities for gender affirmation, coping, social networking, empowerment, and increased self-efficacy presented through the navigation of sex work and advocacy spaces. The findings indicate the ways in which these sex workers draw empowerment and agency from their work and gender identities, and through the reclamation of otherwise hostile spaces. Global Theme I: Identity as a means of exclusion Organizing themes Basic themes Discrimination in public service spaces Police/legal services; health services Discrimination in discursive spaces Gendered spaces; advocacy spaces Discrimination in physical spaces National identity; public/communal spaces; family homes Methods Fifteen women were interviewed: data from their semi-structured interviews was organized using thematic network analysis (see figure for a partial coding framework) then analyzed using a combined theoretical framework of Connell’s hegemonic masculinity and Morrell’s context-specific South African hegemonic masculinities. Global Theme II: Empowerment through identity Organizing themes Basic themes Positive identity as trans women Validation as women; reclamation/creation of spaces Positive identity as sex workers Community; conciliation of gendered and work identities Positive identity as sex worker-advocates Helping self and others promote health-enabling behavior; helping self and others develop ways of coping and bringing about change; liberation and support through sharing narratives Conclusion The study’s findings support the critical need for civil society and other [public] spaces to be more deeply inclusive of all gendered identities in order to decrease incidences of violence against transgender female sex workers and improve their access to health-enabling/enhancing opportunities. Understanding mechanisms of stigma and exclusion is crucial in creating safe spaces for transgender women more widely, and also in developing a holistic conceptualization of gender and sexuality that more accurately reflects the lived experiences of gender variant and non-conforming individuals.