European Banking Supervision: The First 18 Months

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Resolution: National or European? Dirk Schoenmaker, dean 2 October 2012, EESC Hearing, Brussels.
Advertisements

Deposit insurance in the European Union José María Roldán | 13 Oct 2005.
The ECB vs. The Fed By: Kostas Konstantinou Rafael Vera Kanut Yang Shuo Zhang.
SUOMEN PANKKI | FINLANDS BANK | BANK OF FINLAND Banking union and financial integration in the European Union Erkki Liikanen Governor, Bank of Finland.
Banking Union and the single supervisory mechanism (SSM) Meeting of the ad-hoc working party on the banking supervision mechanism, September 2012.
Towards a Banking Union - Panel I: Are growth and stability compatible? - Steven Keuning Director General HR, Budget and Organisation 20 March 2013.
Presentation of the ECB Framework Regulation Organisational aspects
EMU and the euro... (for dummies?) Presentation by Nigel Nagarajan Faculty Orientation for the 2009 Euro Challenge New York, November 25 th 2008 The 2009.
EMU and the euro... (for dummies?) Presentation by Nigel Nagarajan Student Orientation – 2009 Euro Challenge Miami-Florida European Union Center of Excellence.
The European Union THE EUROPEAN UNION Lesson 6 How do individuals, businesses and economies benefit from using the Euro?
The European Union THE EUROPEAN UNION How do individuals, businesses and economies benefit from using the Euro?
Economic Experience and Crisis in the Euro Zone Carlos Hurtado* The Restructuring and Resolution of External Sovereign Debt World Bank. Annual Law, Justice.
Meeting of Budget and Economic Committees Chairpersons Prague, April 2009 Zdeněk Tůma Towards new European framework of financial regulation and.
Corporate Governance and Banking Union in a transatlantic perspective ECGI Brussels 17 December 2012 Implementing the Banking Union Patrick Bolton Columbia.
Cyprus’s road to euro adoption Presentations to secondary school students.
The Polish Banking Sector 2013/2014 The Polish Bank Association
M. Singer – The CNB‘s view of the banking union 1 M. Singer – Bankovní unie očima CNB 1 M. Singer – Recent Developments in the Czech Economy and CNB Forecast.
European integration 1www.ecb.europa.eu © Progress of European integration 1952ECSC European Coal and Steel Community 1958 EEC and EURATOM European Economic.
1 Cross-Border Deposit Insurance: Burden Sharing & System Design.
The Response of Europe to the Collapse of Bretton Woods
Divergent Graduates on the Single Market? Education and Work Relationship of Master’s Degree Graduates in 13 European Countries 1 − to explore the actual.
The Global Economy European Monetary Union. European Union Emerged from post-WWII Europe –ECSC meant to end wars between France and Germany Evolved into.
TO BE OR NOT TO BE EUROPEAN.
Financial Conglomerates, What are the Inherent Risks? 2006 CIAB Conference Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago November 16, 2006 Thordur Olafsson, CARTAC.
Chapter 4 Managing the Global Environment. LEARNING OUTLINE Follow this Learning Outline as you read and study this chapter. What’s Your Global Perspective?
Estonia and the European Union NGO Eurohouse Europe Direct Kuressaare inforelay 10A Tallinna str., Kuressaare Phone and fax:
Alexander Consulting Enterprise 10/16/2015 The European Union and the EURO.
Slovak University of Agriculture Faculty of Economics and Management History of the Economic and Monetary Union, ESCB and ECB 2007/2008 Class 2 MPA Ivana.
The Building Block Approach – A tool for regulatory and supervisory reforms for microfinance European MF week 2012, Luxembourg,
COLLEGE - LIMASSOL BUSINESS STUDIES European History Lecture 12.
3 rd Bank of Greece Workshop The Euro Area Sovereign Debt Crisis and Its Implications for the Economies of SEE The implications for the financial sector.
IRISH INSTITUTE OF PENSIONS MANAGERS SEMINAR ANNE MAHER Chief Executive19 February 2004 The Pensions Board WHAT IS HAPPENING IN EUROPE?
Monetary Policy of the European Central Bank and Its Consequences Mateusz Benedyk.
Tomasz Obal Basel, May 2007 Deposit Insurance Cross-Border Issues Burden-sharing.
Tomasz Obal Basel, May 2007 Deposit Insurance Cross-Border Issues Burden-sharing.
 Used by 17 of 27 countries  Used for all payments starting in 2002  Should be used by all countries once they join THE EURO.
The European Banking Union: where do we stand?
Cross-Border Supervisory Cooperation under Basel II and the Revised Basel Core Principles 6th Annual International Seminar on Policy Challenges for the.
European Union Established in accordance with Masstricht Treaty (1993) 27 countries –Motto: Unity in Diversity Four Freedoms –People –Goods –Services.
“Debt and Credit, Growth and Crises” Bank of Spain and the World Bank Madrid, Spain 19 June,
IAGS 2016 independent Annual Growth Survey Give Recovery a Chance 23rd meeting of the Europe 2020 Steering Committee press contact.
Part A: Global environment. Chart A.25 UK and euro-area banks’ equity prices have come under particular pressure Sources: SNL Financial, Thomson Reuters.
Uniting Europe: Origins of the EU. Europe today: Organized in different structures – –European Union (EU) –Council of Europe –NATO… EU is not a state,
Progress of European integration
Part A: Global Environment
IBRN conference « The international bank lending channel of monetary policy » Discussion Julien IDIER Macroprudential policy division.
Banking Union: Does It Work?
4/13/2018 Banking Regulation for stimulation of economic development: opportunities and limitations ACPR – SSM Coordination Division 26th International.
Banking union and financial integration in the European Union
Monetary Policy and Fiscal Soundness
1888 PressRelease - Mason Baxter: ECB to come up with new strategies to tackle existing.
Italy: emerging from the crisis
Participating countries
European Union Duy Trinh.
European Banking Supervision: The First 18 Months
European Economic and Monetary Union
Banking Union: Where Are We Now and Where Are We Going?
THE EUROPEAN UNION How do individuals, businesses and economies benefit from using the Euro?
Frank Moss (European Central Bank) Athens, 18 May 2012
EUROPEAN UNION the “EU”
THE EUROPEAN UNION How do individuals, businesses and economies benefit from using the Euro?
EESC Thematic discussion on the ESFS State of Play and Perspectives
EUROPEAN UNION the “EU”
European Banking Supervision: The First 18 Months
Role-play on EU decision-making
Governor Fullani, February 11, 2011
The European Union.
History, introduction and importance today
How fragile remains the euro area?
Banking Union: Where Are We Now and Where Are We Going?
Presentation transcript:

European Banking Supervision: The First 18 Months Dirk Schoenmaker Bank of Greece Athens, 14 July 2016

Agenda New system Assessment Functioning of SSM Euro area banking market Assessment 3 core criteria: effectiveness, toughness and fairness 2 other criteria: efficiency and market integration In sum: compelling start, lingering challenges 9 country reports show major differences The Netherlands

The new system

Governance of the 100 significant banks

What do non-performing loans tell us?

1. Effective Joint Supervisory Teams overcome previous home-host squabbles -> clear line of command But conflict of interest: loyal to ECB or NCA boss? Joined-up / consolidated view of banks at euro- area level So far: banking supervision not been softened by loose monetary policy

2. Tough More intrusive + less capture/political intervention Supervisory coordinator at a distance in Frankfurt Actions speak louder than words: more capital higher SREP scores (pillar 2) also tough with recap in Greece over summer 2015 but determination of SREP scores is black box

3. Fair No country- or institution specific pattern at ECB But differences in size systemic risk buffers applied by NCAs

4. Efficiency: areas for improvement Bureaucratic: all decisions in Supervisory Board Example: major delays for fit-and-proper tests Solution: more use of delegation Data driven: multiple and overlapping data requests Independence requires transparency and accountability Lack of transparancy over supervised banks Accountability: limited access European Court of Auditors

Work in progress

5. Single Banking Market? Aim of Banking Union to break bank-sovereign loop Decoupling should lead to integrated market Unrealistic to eliminate all bank-sov links in short term End geographical ring-fencing Both ECB and NCAs still impose intra-€A constraints Banks may convert subs into branches Prospects for cross-border M&A Need to complete Banking Union Risk sharing: European Deposit Insurance Scheme ‘‘Risk reduction’’: limits on sovereign exposures (and stop counting deferred tax credits as capital)

Country-level experience Diversity of structures/experiences/perceptions Examples Countries with many small banks (Austria, Germany, Italy) vs concentrated systems (e.g. France, NL) Home (e.g. France, Germany, Italy, Spain) vs Host (e.g. Belgium, possibly Greece & Portugal in near future) Ongoing sector-wide fragility challenges especially Italy and Portugal

Thank you for your attention