The view that mind and body are distinct and separate entities.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Dualism. The reading for today is Ch. 1 of Philosophy of Mind: A Beginner’s Guide.
Advertisements

Metaphysics Part II. Thought Experiment: Physical & Mental Properties A1. 2 more objects: quarters, books, grass… A2. 2 more physical descriptors: green,
I move, therefore I am Physical Literacy June 2013 Jens E. Birch Oslo University College
LECTURE 24 THE NATURE OF PERSONS PHYSICALISM AND DUALISM (“WHAT AM I?)
Substance dualism: do Descartes’ arguments work? Michael Lacewing
Descartes argument for dualism
HUMAN NATURE AND MODERN PHILOSOPHY DESCARTES PHILOSOPHY 224.
Amy Dandron Helen Burkett
Philosophy of Mind Week 3: Objections to Dualism Logical Behaviorism
Epistemology Revision
Life and Death Philosophical Perspectives. Two problems To discuss whether life after death is possible we need to understand two related philosophical.
Metaphysics.
The Scientific Method. iSkylab Went really well! Data 10, Form 3, Questions 7, explain ½, wrt, etc. Type and repeat questions! Moon phases are NOT due.
Mind-Body Dualism. The Mind-Body Problem The problem of explaining how a mind is connected to and interacts with a body whose mind it is, or the problem.
Human Nature 2.3 The Mind-Body Problem: How Do Mind and Body Relate?
© Michael Lacewing Doubt in Descartes’ Meditations Michael Lacewing
René Descartes ( AD) Meditations on First Philosophy (1641) (Text, pp )
Learning objective: To be able to explain the claim that the mind is ontologically distinct from the body; To understand Descartes’ conceivability argument.
“ta meta ta physika biblia” Literally: the books that come after the physics Today: subjects transcending, i.e., going beyond, the physical, e.g. the supernatural.
 Doubt- to be uncertain about something, to hesitate to believe  Dualism- the belief that the mind and body are separate (but interact). Mind is a kind.
Rene DescartesRene Descartes  1596 – 1650 CE  La Haye (now Descartes), France  Lived mostly in Holland, died in Sweden.  “The Father of Modern Philosophy”
© Michael Lacewing Substance and Property Dualism Michael Lacewing
L ECTURE 6: D ESCARTES. L ECTURE O UTLINE In today’s lecture we will: 1.Become introduced to Rene Descartes 2.Begin our investigation into Descartes’
Descartes’ Interactionist Dualism. Overview Descartes’ general project Descartes’ general project Argument for dualism Argument for dualism Explanation.
Substance dualism Michael Lacewing
Philosophy of Mind: Theories of self / personal identity: REVISION Body & Soul - what makes you you?
Lesson 4: Descartes; a dualist view
Descartes’ divisibility argument
The argument for the existence of bodies (Meditation 6) 1.Nature provided me with a strong propensity to believe there are bodies. 2.The only way I could.
Rene Descartes ( ) The Father of Modern Philosophy
René Descartes (1596–1650) Cartesian Substance Dualism.
COGITO ERGO SUM.
The Mind And Body Problem Mr. DeZilva.  Humans are characterised by the body (physical) and the mind (consciousness) These are the fundamental properties.
Rene Descartes and Rationalism Lecturer: Dr. F. Budi Hardiman.
Criticisms of Dualism. Descartes argument for dualism I can clearly and distinctly conceive of the mind without the body and the body without the mind.
René Descartes Brandon Lee Block D.
An Outline of Descartes's Meditations on First Philosophy
Rene Descartes The Father of Modern Philosophy
Substance and Property Dualism Quick task: Fill in the gaps activity Quick task: Fill in the gaps activity ?v=sT41wRA67PA.
METAPHYSICS The study of the nature of reality. POPEYE STUDIES DESCARTES.
DUALISM. Dualism Monism Traditional Religion Experience Our bodies may be damaged whilst our minds are active Our mental experience is private Science.
René Descartes ( ) The Father of Modern Philosophy.
1. I exist, because I think. 2. I am a thinking thing 3
Dualism LO: Consider the concept of dualism
Substance and Property Dualism
Intuition and deduction thesis (rationalism)
The Trademark Argument and Cogito Criticisms
Minds and Bodies.
Issues with Concept Empiricism: Is the concept of God innate
Descartes’ conceivability argument for substance dualism
What is the relationship between body and soul.
Life After Death: The Soul (Aristotle)
Body and Soul Key Words! In your group, write as many key words and definitions on this topic as possible!
Describing Mental States
Michael Lacewing The zombie argument Michael Lacewing
The Mind Body Problem Our minds seem to be non-physical and different from our bodies. Our bodies seem to be something different from our minds. Are they.
Does this person’s activity have any value?
Think, Pair, Share Beauty is understood by Plato as a separate thing even if no beautiful things existed. For Aristotle, beauty is a property of beautiful.
What does this mean? The SOS distress call literally means ‘save our souls’. When someone makes such a call, they are not asking for some invisible ghost-like.
Get Yourself Thinking…
Think, Pair, Share A: What does Plato say about reality? B: Explain the analogy Plato uses to explain reality. A: What is a form? B: What is a particular.
Describe this object: Does it help describe it further by saying it exists?
Think, pair, Share Is this the same person?.
The study of the nature of reality
What is good / bad about this answer?
What makes these things different?
Dualism.
Проф. С. Молор-Эрдэнэ Тархи ба Оюун \Brain and Mind\
The Mind Body Problem Our minds seem to be non-physical and different from our bodies. Our bodies seem to be something different from our minds. Are they.
A Course on Consciousness
Presentation transcript:

The view that mind and body are distinct and separate entities. Match the definitions.... Property dualism Substance dualism This is a compromise position between _________ dualism and materialism. This suggests that while there exists only one kind of substance, there are fundamental differences in the properties of mind and matter. The view that mind and body are distinct and separate entities.

Descartes' Dualism

Learning Outcomes To able to describe the difference between property dualism and substance dualism. To be able to explain Descartes’ dualism.

Descartes’ Dualism Rene Descartes (1596-1650) can be considered the heir of Platonic thought on the soul. Descartes realised that it was logically possible to doubt all things including the existence of the body (like the matrix!) However it is not possible to doubt that ‘I’ exist as a ‘thinking thing’. When I think there must be something doing the thinking. Descartes calls this the mind or soul. Therefore, if the body can be doubted the soul proved. I am more than just a body.

Mind and Body Our body is spatial but not conscious, while the mind is not spatial but is conscious. Even though this mind and body were separate, they interact within the brain. The state of the body will affect the mind and visa versa. When people die their body is left behind although their soul is able to continue with God.

Read through Descartes’ mediations and complete the worksheet… Stretch yourself: Read through the summaries of mediations 1 and 2 and add to your notes. Top Philosopher: In your notes, explain why Descartes is a substance dualist.

Principles of Philosophy Principles of Philosophy (Latin: Principia philosophiae) is a book by René Descartes. In essence it is a synthesis of the Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy It was written in Latin and published in 1644. Read through the article and summarise his argument in 5 points. Stretch yourself: What are Friedrich Nietzsche criticisms of cogito ergo sum?

Is he correct? Answer this question in your notes: ‘Descartes has proved that Dualism is true’ Discuss. Next steps: Research what other philosophers have said about Descartes and add it to your answer. Stretch yourself: What are Friedrich Nietzsche criticisms of cogito ergo sum?

Write a question based on this lesson’s learning for the hotseater.