META ANALYSIS OF VIDEO MODELING INTERVENTIONS

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Using Behavior Principles to Improve Quality of Services: Increasing Time-on-Task and Quality of Interactions in Ten Classrooms Serving Children with Low.
Advertisements

Evaluation of Special Education Teachers
Gifted Education at the Middle School Level Gifted support is a service, not a place!
Effects of Self-Directed Summary of Performance on Students’ Participation in Person Centered Planning Meetings For additional information, please contact:
+ Evidence Based Practice University of Utah Presented by Will Backner December 2009 Training School Psychologists to be Experts in Evidence Based Practices.
Teaching Children With Autism To Follow Activity Schedules on an iPad 3 Using Manual Prompts and Edible Reinforcement Mark Mautone 1, Kenneth F. Reeve.
How do you know it worked
Single-Subject Designs
Catherine Taylor Caldwell College Graduate Programs in Applied Behavior Analysis.
Reviewing the Literature on: Social Stories Presented by Ira Rinn.
Response to Intervention in The Social Domain. Response to Intervention (RTI) Response to evidence-based interventions (Elliott, Witt, Kratchowill, &
Social Skill Instruction as Tier II Intervention Tim Lewis, Ph.D. University of Missouri OSEP Center on Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports.
Carly Roberts Reading Instruction for Students with Significant Cognitive Disabilities.
ALICE RHODES VICTORIA SLOCUM UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY Applications of a Changing Curricular Focus on the Ecological Curricular Framework.
Non-Overlap Methods in Single Case Research Methodology Erin E. Barton, PhD, BCBA-D.
Single Subject Research (Richards et al.) Chapter 8.
Printed by INTRODUCTION PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING Ann F. Filer, M/Ed., BCBA John Ward-Horner, Ph.D., BCBA-D Robert K Ross, EdD., BCBA-D.
Question: Is video modeling an effective physical therapy treatment in children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)? History of Modeling.
Video Workshop Emotion Flashcards Teacher Resources Social Skills For Pre K- 3 rd HomeQuitNextPrevious VIDEO AND PICTURE MODELING OF SOCIAL SKILLS Click.
The Effects of Strategy Instruction on Written Expression of Students With Disabilities Leigh Ann Sutton Ronald H. Pannell April 15, Alternative.
Current Methodological Issues in Single Case Research David Rindskopf, City University of New York Rob Horner, University of Oregon.
Single-Subject Experimental Research
Training Individuals to Implement a Brief Experimental Analysis of Oral Reading Fluency Amber Zank, M.S.E & Michael Axelrod, Ph.D. Human Development Center.
Self-Regulated Strategy Development for Students with Asperger Syndrome: A Discussion May 13, 2011 Min-Chi Yan.
Chapter 7: High Leverage Practice 2: Techniques to Teach Students with Learning Disabilities.
Overlap Methods derived from Visual Analysis in Single Case Research Methodology In collaboration with Brian Reichow and Mark Wolery.
IES Single-Case Research Institute: Training Visual Analysis Rob Horner University of Oregon
Yvonne Moreno, Ph.D..   According to the CDC, 1out of every 68 children is diagnosed with an ASD  The number of children with ASD’s receiving special.
Oklahoma State University Can Mathematics State Test Scores Improve in Four Minutes a Day? Justine Celoni, M.S., Carrol Smith, M.S., and Katye Perry, Ph.D.
Peer Modeling Intervention:
Video Self-Modeling to Reduce Disruptive Behavior in Children Significantly Impacted by ASD Kate M. Sadler, M.Ed. Introduction Participants & Setting Results.
IES Advanced Training Institute on Single-Case Research Methods
DAY 2 Visual Analysis of Single-Case Intervention Data Tom Kratochwill
A systematic literature review of empirical evidence on computer games and serious games Wakana Ishimaru Leo Liang.
Single-Case Effect Size and Meta-Analytic Measures
For more information contact:
Ε.Ε.Ε.Ε.Κ School of Special Education & Training
Agenda What is a high probability (high-p) request sequence?
Evaluating Student-Teachers Using Student Outcomes
DEVELOPING EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE IN CHAPLAINCY:
Grace Eckojojo and Isabel Leon
Partnership for Practice
Video Self-Modeling: Effectiveness in School Populations Krystal Franco, B. I. S., Christopher Carter, SSP & Wendi Johnson, Ph.D. Texas Woman’s University,
Special Education Today
Video Modeling as an Intervention
Research in action project SEDP 651
DAY 1.
Single Subject Research
MUHC Innovation Model.
Fidelity of Implementation Fidelity 6-8 weeks following live workshop
New Goal Clarity Coach Training October 27, 2017
Evidence-based Predictors and Practices for Promoting Positive Outcomes for Transition Age Youth with Disabilities. I have worked in a professional capacity.
A Meta-Analysis of Video Modeling Interventions that Teach Employment Related Skills to Individuals with Autism Carol Sparber, M.Ed. Intervention Specialist.
Non Diploma Secondary Services
University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA (USA)
Rachel McMahan Queen, Ph. D.
Examining the Content Validity for a Preschool Mathematics Assessment Carol Sparber M.Ed., Kent State University Pam Elwood M. Ed., Kent State University.
2015 PARCC Results for R.I: Work to do, focus on teaching and learning
Stephanie Shire University of California Los Angeles
Gifted Behaviors Rating Scale
Kathy Hebbeler, ECO at SRI International AUCD Meeting Washington, DC
New IPS Research Findings
Kavitha N Krishnan MS OTR/L Dec 2nd, 2016
Improving the Use of Effective Practices Through Coaching
Examination of Parent Understanding of YETI Evidence Based Practices
ABAB Design Ethical considerations
Consortium of State Organizations for Texas Teacher Education
Non-Overlap Measures PND PEM ECL (PEM-T) NAP TauU TauUadj.
Single Subject/Small-N Designs
Wiki, Wiki Sanden, S., & Darragh, J. (2011). Wiki use in the 21st-century literacy classroom: A framework for evaluation. Contemporary Issues in Technology.
Presentation transcript:

META ANALYSIS OF VIDEO MODELING INTERVENTIONS ON THE SOCIAL SKILLS OF CHILDREN WITH AUTISM Carol Sparber, M.Ed. Special Education/Transition, Kent State University Video Modeling Defined: ANALYSIS OF VIDEO MODELING INTERVENTIONS: Is there a difference in the effectiveness in types of video modeling? Strength of Intervention: An intervention method that uses video recording to provide a visual model of target behaviors by reviewing the recording (Maione & Mirenda, 2006) and involves the participant watching a video that depicts someone performing a task targeted for acquisition (Marcus & Wilder, 2009). Criterion Measures Defined: 6-7 pts. effective, 5 or less ineffective Percentage of Non-overlapping Data (PND) Calculation of non-overlap between baseline and successive intervention phases . (Scruggs, Mastropieri, & Casto, 1987) PND > 90% highly effective (3pts) PND >70% effective (2pts) PND 50% - 70% questionable effectiveness (1pt) PNE < 50% reflects unreliable treatment (0pts) Percentage of All Non-Overlapping Data (PAND) Calculation of total number of data points that do not overlap between baseline and intervention phases (Parker, Hagan-Burke,& Vannest, 2007) PAND >88% effective (2pts) PAND 79% to 88% questionable effectiveness (1pt) PAND < 79% unreliable treatment (0pts) Percentage of Data Points Exceeding the Median (PEM) Calculation of percentage of data points exceeding the median of baseline phase (Ma, 2006) PEM .9 to 1, highly effective (2pts) PEM .7 to .9 moderately effective (1pt) PEM Less than .7 questionable or not effective (0pt) Citation Type of Intervention PND PAND PEM Overall Strength of intervention (max points possible: 7) Apple, Billingsley & Schwartz (2005) Video Modeling 67% (1pt) 86% .75   3 VM with feedback 100% (3pts) (2pts) 1.00 7 Buggey (2005) Video self modeling 94% 91% .88 6 Charlop-Christy, Le, & Freeman (2000) Video modeling 88% 95% .85 5 In-vivo modeling 70% 89% .79 4 Hine & Wolery (2006) Point- of- view video modeling  73% 78% .64 (0pts) Maione & Mirenda (2006)  79% 74% .72  91% .98 Marcus &Wilder (2009) Peer video modeling  82% 83% self-video modeling  80% 87% .78 Nikopoulos & Keenan (2007)  96% 98% .97 Nikopoulos & Keenan (2004)  98% .77 Reagon, Higbee & Endicott (2006) .93 Tetreault & Lerman (2010) Point of view video modeling  77% 51% .63 2 Significance: Video Modeling (VM) is a promising and effective practice for teaching social behaviors to students with autism (Marcus & Wilder, 2009; Apple, Billingsley & Schwartz, 2005; Nikopoulos and Keenan, 2004; Buggey, 2005) Incorporates visual and auditory features relevant to the learner (Maione & Mirenda, 2006; Hine & Wolery, 2006) Can be employed effectively to teach social skills to children with autism in a wide range of environments (Apple, Billingsley & Schwartz, 2005; Marcus & Wilder, 2009) Easy to implement, cost and time effective, provides prompt feedback (Reagan, Higbee, Endicott, 2006) Effective in generalizing and maintaining behaviors (Charlop-Christy, Loc Le, Freeman, 2000; Hine & Wolery, 2006) Single subject VM studies are usually interpreted by visually inspecting graphed data (Reynhout and Carter, 2006) There is a need for supporting evidence-based interventions with an “effect size” with more objective and reliable measures (Kazdin, 2008) Results: Graphical displays of all studies indicate positive effects across participants, behaviors and settings. An evaluation of PND, PAND and PEM across all studies show the strength of intervention was not equally strong. 43% of the studies were rated moderately to highly effective but 57% of the studies received ratings of unreliable or not effective Results indicate video modeling with feedback is the most effective form of intervention with average nonparametric ratings of 97% Search Strategies: An electronic search was conducted for studies from 2000 to 2010 using the Educational Resources Information Center (ERIC), Google Scholar and PsycINFO. Search terms included: ‘video modeling’, ‘autism’, ‘social skills’, social initiations and ‘single subject design’ Ten studies that met the criteria were reviewed Inclusion Criteria: Single case research with a multiple baseline design that demonstrated experimental control (Horner, et al., 2005) Participants had a diagnosis of autism according to DSM-IV Focus on improving social and communication skills The independent variable was a form of video modeling, with the video created by the instructor or researcher The study used a multiple baseline design Practical Implications & Future Studies: Effective implementation of Video Modeling should include the use of multiple methods of feedback such as: additional practice, social praise, prompting and role play. Future single subject design studies should report non-overlapping calculations to allow researchers and special educators to understand relative strength or effectiveness of the intervention method. Nonparametric measures should be used to examine the effectiveness of maintenance and generalization. Future studies should consider use of newer technology, such as apps for Ipads, Ipods and Iphones as a form of a video intervention. Methods: Graphs for each study were calculated and analyzed for Percentage of Non-overlapping Data (PND), Percentage of All Non-Overlapping Data (PAND) as well as Percentage of Data Points Exceeding the Mean (PEM) resulting in 92 calculations across 10 studies with 29 participants. The basic data unit of analysis was the comparison between baseline and intervention Nonparametric data for each study was rated for effectiveness based on predetermined criteria (Parker, Vannest & Davis, 2011) Ratings were recorded and analyzed to determine the most effective form of VM intervention

14th International Conference on Autism, Intellectual disability & developmental Disabilities   Presenter Name: Carol Sparber, M.Ed. Intervention Specialist Affiliation: Kent State University, Doctoral Candidate, Special Education 100% of the Research project was done by the researcher Title: A Meta-Analysis of Video Modeling Interventions on the Social and Communication Skills of Children with Autism Abstract: Due to increasing demands in educational research for improved rigor to support evidence-based interventions, this meta-analysis examines video modeling practices used in social and communication skills training for “effect size”. More specifically it examines the effectiveness of four methods of video modeling interventions using three nonparametric measures. Summary: Video modeling is an evidence-based intervention that presents a variety of visual examples to facilitate acquisition of new behaviors and subsequently support maintenance and generalization of the learned behavior. It can be effectively employed to develop and strengthen communication skills, academic performance, social, and self-help skills. Video modeling interventions are typically recorded using a single case design and effectiveness is determined by visual inspection of the graphed data. There is a need for supporting evidence-based interventions with an “effect size” with more objective and reliable measures (Kazdin, 2008). Three indices of non-overlapping data were used to examine each study. Calculations of Percentage of Non-overlapping data (PND), Percentage of all Non-overlapping Data (PAND) and Percentage of Data Points Exceeding the Median (PEM) resulted in 92 calculations across ten studies with 29 participants. The overall analysis reports non-overlapping calculations of the relative strength or effectiveness of each video modeling intervention method. Results indicate that video modeling with feedback provides the most effective method of video modeling interventions. Although Video Modeling is typically used for students with Autism, it has also been used as an intervention to improve the social skills of students with Multiple High-Incidence Disabilities, students with Intellectual Disabilities as well as students with Emotional and Behavioral Disorders. With trends in special education moving toward inclusion, there is a need to provide general educators with practical and effective evidence based inclusive instructional practices. Video modeling is an instructional strategy that can serve as a method for designing a learning environment that supports a wide range of learners. It offers individualized instruction, provides control of content and is applicable in a variety of settings. With advances in technology, video modeling can serve as an efficient and effective method in addressing the needs of diverse students. Learning outcomes for Video Modeling Intervention Poster Presentation After attending this poster session, attendees will be able to: Understand the significance for using video modeling as an intervention Examine three nonparametric measures for overall “effect size” of each type of video modeling intervention Acknowledge the importance of supporting evidence-based interventions with objective and reliable measures.