INVESTIGATING THE FALL AND ITS CONSEQUENCES Hamartiology (from Greek: ἁμαρτία, hamartia, "missing the mark, error" and -λογια, - logia, "study“) INVESTIGATING THE FALL AND ITS CONSEQUENCES

Audacity the Movie

THE DOCTRINE OF SIN

Hamartiology - OBJECTIVES After completing this segment, you will be able to: 1. Articulate the importance of Hamartiology. 2. Describe the basic terminology that relates to the topic under investigation. 3. Compare and contrast the various opinions on the topic of the Hamartiology. 4. Explain what the various sections of the Bible say about the Hamartiology. 5. Correlate the gathered biblical information to create scriptural conclusions. Also, you will use the formulated conclusions to assess the various perspectives and to identify the correct view. 6. Utilize the tool of apologetics to defend the biblical view of the Hamartiology. 7. Apply the acquired truths with the aim of glorifying God.

I. Preliminary Questions

II. Basic Terms Civil Righteousness Coram Deo (before God) Coram Mundo (before the world) Ability of Unbelievers

II. Basic Terms 2. Federal Headship A.K.A - Representative headship Belief - Adam was the covenantal or legal representative of the human race. Application - When Adam fell into sin, all of humanity fell into sin; the human race inherited Adam’s guilt and depravity.

II. Basic Terms 3. Immaculate Conception Not referring to the birth of Jesus Referring to the birth of Mary Mary was unaffected by sin during her conception Saint Anne, Mary’s mom, was supernaturally aided during birth to preserve Mary from the consequences of original sin. Celebrated on December 8th

II. Basic Terms 4. Natural Headship A.K.A. - The seminal view The perspective believes that traducianism is correct. Traducianism explains both … how the consequences of original sin were passed down from Adam to his posterity … and how all humanity, in seed form, was with Adam when he sinned.

II. Basic Terms 5. Original Sin – This theological concept describes the corrupt spiritual nature that is present within humanity BECAUSE OF Adam’s rebellion against God. G. K. Chesterton once noted that "Certain new theologians dispute original sin, which is the only part of Christian theology which can really be proved" (Orthodoxy, chap. 2). He saw original sin as the one Christian doctrine that is empirically verifiable and validated by 3500 years of human history.

Psalm 51:5 - Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, And in sin my mother conceived me.

Clarification Original Sin – This concept describes the corrupt spiritual nature that is present within in humanity from birth BECAUSE OF Adam’s rebellion against God. Why are we held accountable for Adam’s sin = FEDERAL HEADSHIP How is depravity passed down = NATURAL HEADSHIP

II. Basic Terms 6. Prevenient Grace – Arminian Doctrine on the nature of saving grace Saving Grace = Resistible Traditional Arminians Wesleyans

2 Perspectives on Salvation Arminian Calvinism 1. God Creates mankind 2. Allow the Fall 3. Sent Christ as the redeemer for all people 4. Decision to Redeem any who trust in Christ and condemn any who deny Christ (conditional election) - The Gospel Call goes forth - Prevenient grace enables every person to accept or reject the gospel call - Some freely accept the gospel - Their decision to accept the gospel makes them part of the elect. Election is not based upon God’s choice; it is conditional on man’s choice 5. Apply salvation to those who believe in Jesus (a.k.a. – the elect) 1. God Creates mankind 2. Allow the Fall 3. Decision to Redeem the elect and “pass over” others 4. Send Christ as the redeemer for the elect (unconditional election) - Every person deserves punishment - Total depravity ensures that every human will continuously and freely reject God (compatibilist freedom); prevenient grace is unbiblical; thus, no unsaved person will freely accept the gospel - It is entirely the work of God that enables certain unbelievers to accept Christ - Election is not conditional on man’s choice; it is entirely based upon God’s choice 5. Apply salvation to the elect

Arminians believe that humans are, in essence, radically depraved; however, God has released a supernatural help (prevenient grace) to all people that frees the will from birth. This grace is resistible. Natural Humanity (Totally Depravity) vs. Actual Humanity (Totally Depravity with Prevenient Grace)

III. Various Opinions PELAGIANISM HISTORY BELIEFS Pelagius *British Monk *4th Century *Optimistic View on Human Nature *Major Disagreement with Augustine *Ideas condemned at both the Synod of Carthage (418) and the Council of Ephesus (431). *Other Followers 16th Century Socinians Modernistic Theologians Humans are not born with a fallen nature or with depraved inclinations. Humans are born innocent. Original sin is a false doctrine. Evil actions = explained by bad examples.

III. Various Opinions SEMI-PELAGIANISM HISTORY BELIEFS Reaction to Augustine Revised the thoughts of Pelagius The dominant teaching of the Roman Catholic Church Original sin is true. Humans are born morally sick, not radically corrupt. Only Jesus and Mary escape this corruption. Humans are not held accountable for their wounded spiritual condition; they are held accountable for willfully breaking God’s law.

III. Various Opinions ARMINIANISM HISTORY BELIEFS Jacob Arminius (1560-1609) Studied at Geneva under Beza – A disciple of John Calvin 1603 – Arminius = professor of theology Revised John Calvin’s Views 1618 – Synod of Dort – Arminianism was condemned Original Sin is true Humans are radically depraved Prevenient grace (universal) offsets radical depravity, enabling the sinner to cooperate with God and accept (or reject) the Gospel. Conclusion: Because of prevenient grace, sinners are …. Technically Dead in Sins Practically Wounded

III. Various Opinions NEO-ORTHODOX VIEW HISTORY BELIEFS Karl Barth Neo-Orthodox Movement Humanity’s alienation from God is real; however, the Fall is not historical. Karl Barth and Emil Brunner denied the existence of Adam. Genesis is a non-literal story that every person re-enacts because of pride, not because of original sin. Sin is not primarily connected to history; it is connected to the limitations or finiteness of humanity.

III. Various Opinions REFORMED (Calvinistic) VIEW HISTORY BELIEFS Augustine Most Reformers Adam and Eve were on Probation Failure in the Garden = Led to Original Sin *Both Federal and Natural views are held Prevenient Grace is False Conclusion: Sinners are …. Technically Dead in Sins Practically Dead in Sins Unbelievers are spiritually dead towards God; thus, salvation is monergistic (God works alone).

The TWO Five Point Systems Brief Survey In groups of 2-3, look up and document (on 1 sheet of paper) the 5 articles of Remonstrance, a statement made by the followers of Arminius. Then, look up and document the 5 points of Calvinism. Compare and contrast these two theological systems. Do you tend to be more Arminian or Calvinistic in your theology?

Game Time This theological concept describes the corrupt spiritual nature that is present within humanity BECAUSE OF Adam’s rebellion against God. _______ ________- This term describes a supernatural grace that God pours out on all of humanity (since Calvary … or when the gospel is presented), although it is resistible. British monk in the 4th century who rejected original sin. _________ __________ - Mary was supernaturally protected from original sin during her birth. The ___________ ____________ view believes that humans are morally wounded (not totally depraved) because of the fall. This is the official perspective of the Roman Catholic Church. The ____________ view believes in totally depravity; however, prevenient grace softens the consequences of totally depravity, enabling one to accept Christ. This ______________ view does not believe in a historic fall. The _______________ view believes in totally depravity, and it rejects the doctrine of prevenient grace. The belief views Adam as the covenantal or legal representative of the human race. Coram Deo means righteousness in the presence of _____________.

IV. Biblical Survey The History of Fall The Effects of the Fall The Character of Sin The Prevalence of Sin The Consequences of Sin

Game Time Donum Superadditum – Latin for “added _____________. “ This theological concept describes the corrupt spiritual nature that is present within humanity BECAUSE OF Adam’s rebellion against God. _______ ________- This term describes a supernatural grace that God pours out on all of humanity (since Calvary … or when the gospel is presented), although it is resistible. British monk in the 4th century who rejected original sin. _________ __________ - Mary was supernaturally protected from original sin during her birth. The ___________ ____________ view believes that humans are morally wounded (not totally depraved) because of the fall. This is the official perspective of the Roman Catholic Church. The belief views Adam as the covenantal or legal representative of the human race. This view is also known as the seminal view. Coram Deo means righteousness in the presence of _____________. Coram Mundo means righteousness in the presence of the __________.

The History of Fall RC SPROUL The Narrative The Historic Nature of the Fall 1. It is more probable than not that Genesis 1-3 is essentially a historic narrative. 2. Later biblical writers attest to the historic realities of: Adam (Rom 5:14; 1 Cor 15:22; 1st Timothy 2:13-14) The Serpent (2 Cor 11:3; Rev 12:9) The Fall (1 Tim 2:14)

The Effects of the Fall Romans 5 – Death through Adam & Life through Christ ADAM JESUS (2nd Adam – 1 Cor 15:45) “just as sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, and in this way death came to all people, because all sinned” (12) “many died by the trespass of the one man” (15) “The judgment followed one sin and brought condemnation” (16) “one trespass resulted in condemnation for all people” (17) “by the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners” (19) “how much more did God’s grace and the gift that came by the grace of the one man, Jesus Christ, overflow to the many!” (15) “but the gift followed many trespasses and brought justification” (16) “how much more will those who receive God’s abundant provision of grace and of the gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man, Jesus Christ!” “through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous” (19) “The aorist [tense] points to one act, the act of Adam; we would expect the present or the imperfect [tense] if the Apostle were thinking of the continuing sins of all people.” Leon Morris

The Effects of the Fall Traducianism – Best Explains how Adam’s Corrupt Spiritual Natural Transfers Total Propagation of Species from Parents to Children = Implication of Scripture John 3:6 – “Born of Flesh is Flesh” = reference to spiritual realm Genesis 2:2-3 – God rested from all of His “creational” works.

Are we sinners because we sin? Or Do we sin because we are sinners? Federal Headship = Imputed Sin Natural Headship = Inherited Corruption (Traducianism) Personal Sin

The Character of Sin 1. Missing the Mark – A decision to make a mistake Ryder Smith – “The hundreds of examples of the word’s moral use required that the wicked man ‘misses the right mark because he chooses to aim at the wrong one’ – that is, there is no question of an innocent mistake or of the merely negative idea of ‘failure.’” 2. Irreligion – An irreverent or impious posture towards the things of God 3. Transgression – To cross over an established boundary 4. Iniquity – To deviate from the right course

The Character of Sin 5. Rebellion – To knowingly disobey Erickson: “All persons are assumed to be in contact with the truth of God, even the Gentiles, who do not have his special revelation. Failure to believe the message, particularly when openly and specially presented, is disobedience and rebellion. Anyone who disobeys a king is considered an enemy. Likewise the multitudes who disobey God’s Word.” 6. Treachery – A breach of trust … to be unfaithful to covenant expectations 7. Perversion – to bend or to twist 8. Abomination – An act that is reprehensible to God

The Prevalence of Sin Sin affects: A person’s relationship with God A person’s relationship with oneself A person’s relationship with others Guilt, Disfavor, Etc. Enslavement, Self-Denial, Deceit, Self-Centeredness , Etc. Ungodly Competition, Selfishness, Rejection of Authority, Etc. John 3:36, “He who believes in the Son has eternal life; he who does not obey the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God rests upon him.” Romans 3:10 – “There is none good, no not one.” Romans 6:17 – “we were once slaves to sin.” Ephesians 2:1 – “As for you, you were dead in your transgressions and sins.” James 4:1-2 - “What causes wars, and what causes fightings among you? Is it not your passions that are at war in your members? You desire and do not have; so you kill. And you covet and cannot obtain; so you fight and wage war”

The Prevalence of Sin DL 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 OBSTACELS OF LIFE Pre-Fall Man Post-Fall Man Reborn Man Glorified Man able to sin able to not sin unable to not sin unable to sin CAUSATION Proverbs 4:23 DL 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 OBSTACELS OF LIFE

The Consequence of Sin Spiritual Death (believers and unbelievers) Genesis 2:16-17: And the Lord God commanded the man, “You are free to eat from any tree of the garden, 17 but you must not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, for on the day you eat from it, you will certainly die.” Physical Death (believers and unbelievers) Hebrews 9:27: “It is appointed for men to die once, and after that comes judgment.” Eternal Death (unbelievers) Daniel 12:2: And many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt

V. Systematic Conclusions God’s initial Image Bearers were very good, both intrinsically and morally. Adam and Eve transgressed God’s law; the fall is a historic event. Adam serves as the initial (federal) representative for all humanity. His rebellious failure negatively affected his posterity (original sin). The depraved spiritual condition that Adam inherited, as a result of the fall, was and continues to be transferred to all persons via traducianism. The Scriptures go to great lengths to meticulously describe the character of sin. The severity of sin is especially noticed when compared to the holiness of God. Sin has radically affected every aspect of the human entity (moral, relational, functional, intellectual, spiritual, etc.). In fact, unbelievers are enemies of God and “spiritual dead” in their ability to makes things right with God. Rebellion or cosmic treason (sin) against God results in temporary and eternal consequences.

VI. Apologetics Question 1: Are All Sins equal? 1. All sins are equally competent in establishing human guilt before a holy God. 2. Some sins carry greater consequences than others. 3. Some sins are intrinsically worse than others.

VI. Apologetics Election-Based Theory Middle Knowledge Theory Question 2: What happens to babies that die? The Bible affirms that all babies are born in a sinful state. Therefore, each baby is in need of a second (spiritual) birth from the initial (physical) birth. There are examples in Scripture where babies seem to be saved before a profession of faith is made. However, this is not the norm, for "the wicked are estranged from the womb; they go astray from birth, speaking lies" (Psalm 58:3). There is an example in Scripture of a departed baby who seems to abide with God in heaven. The Scriptures do not answer this question exhaustively; there are three prominent theories. The Bible seems to suggest that humans are not accountable for sin (even though they are sinners) before they willfully disobey. This mercy does not apply to those who merely have access to General Revelation (Romans 1 – they are “without excuse”); however, it could easily apply to infants or persons with a life-long mental handicap. Ultimately, Christians should rest in the Lord, who is good and just. He will do what is right. Election-Based Theory Middle Knowledge Theory Age of Accountability

VI. Apologetics Question 3: Did God create evil? Logical Argument (1) God created all holistic things Evil is not a holistic thing Conclusion: God did not create evil   Logical Argument (2) The created holistic things can only be distorted by personal agents The created holistic things were distorted God, group 1 angels (unfallen), group 2 angels (fallen), and humans are personal agents God and the group 1 angels did not distort the holistic things Conclusion: Group 2 angels and humans distorted the holistic things VI. Apologetics Question 3: Did God create evil? The Bible affirms that God created all things. The Bible does not identify God as the author of evil. The Bible identifies Satan as the inventor of certain types of evil (lying); by implication, one could argue that Satan is the originator of all evil, or at least the first expression of evil. The Bible blames the human populace (via its representative) for the appearances and consequences of both natural evil (disasters, etc.) and moral evil (sin, etc.). Logically, Augustine argues that evil is not a holistic thing or original essence. Rather, evil is the privation, distortion, or perversion of a holistic thing. This philosophical understanding is consistent with the Hebrew word awah, which means to twist or bend something. For example, Proverbs 12:8 says, “A man is praised according to his wisdom, but men with warped (awah) minds are despised.” The despised men are not different species than the wise men; rather, they are distorted men.

VI. Apologetics Question 4: Is Ezekiel 18 consistent with the teaching of original sin? The Bible clearly affirms the doctrine of original sin; Adam’s sin affected his posterity. The Bible teaches that parental sins can, in some sense, practically influence children. Ezekiel 18 teaches, in some sense, that children can escape the guilt of their parents. The law of non-contradiction states that something cannot be (x) and non-(x) at the same time in the same way. The teachings of Ezekiel 18 and original sin are not contradictory. Necessary Contradictions Compatible Affirmations A + B B + C B + D A B C + D + E + F

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS You should seek discernment from the Bible in order to properly distinguish the good from the evil. Rob Bell on Oprah

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS 2. You should seek God for a righteous indignation or hatred towards evil.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS 3. You should fight every ungodly temptation before it becomes sin. Piper - Make War

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS 4. You should reject the current psychological consensus that removes moral accountability. Each individual is accountable for his or her own sins. Sam Harris Interview - Free Will (57-59:50).

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS 5. You should use the biblical teaching on sin to persuade others of their need for Jesus. Ray Comfort - Street Evangelism

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS 6. You should contemplate God’s holiness, your sins, and the redemptive works of Jesus in order to grow spiritually and to be driven missionally. Gospel-Centrality for the Believer