Within-Subjects Design

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ch 8: Experimental Design Ch 9: Conducting Experiments
Advertisements

Hypothesis Tests: Two Related Samples AKA Dependent Samples Tests
Chapter 9 Choosing the Right Research Design Chapter 9.
CHAPTER 8 EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN.
7/20/03Copyright Ed Lipinski and Mesa Community College, All rights reserved. 1 Research Methods Summer 2009 Using Between Subjects and Within.
Questions What is the relationship between ‘research designs’ and ‘research strategies’? Which method of experiments, within subjects or between subjects.
Slides to accompany Weathington, Cunningham & Pittenger (2010), Chapter 14: Correlated Groups Designs 1.
Questions  Is Exam 2 going to be cumulative or will it just cover the second part of the information?  Are cause-and-effect relationships the same as.
Chapter 9: Within Designs
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGNS Criteria for Experiments
CHAPTER 8 EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN.
Basics of Experimentation (1) Experimental Design: Which to Choose and Why?
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGNS What Is Required for a True Experiment? What Are the Independent and Dependent Variables? What Is a Confounding Variable? What Are.
Types of Group Designs _________-subject design. The experiment compares _____ group across different levels of the IV. e.g., behavior is studied in 1.
Using Between-Subjects and Within-Subjects Experimental Designs
Lecture 12 Psyc 300A. Review: Inferential Statistics We test our sample recognizing that differences we observe may be simply due to chance. Significance.
© 2001 Dr. Laura Snodgrass, Ph.D.1 Basic Experimental Design Common Problems Assigning Participants to Groups Single variable experiments –bivalent –multivalent.
Experimental Design: Between and within factors Psych 231: Research Methods in Psychology.
Major Points Formal Tests of Mean Differences Review of Concepts: Means, Standard Deviations, Standard Errors, Type I errors New Concepts: One and Two.
Experimental Group Designs
Chapter 8 Experimental Design.
1 Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences (5 th ed.) Gravetter & Wallnau Chapter 10 The t Test for Two Independent Samples University of Guelph Psychology.
Consumer Preference Test Level 1- “h” potato chip vs Level 2 - “g” potato chip 1. How would you rate chip “h” from 1 - 7? Don’t Delicious like.
Matched Pairs, Within-Subjects, and Mixed Designs
Chapter 14: Repeated-Measures Analysis of Variance.
Chapter 11 Hypothesis Tests: Two Related Samples.
Design Experimental Control. Experimental control allows causal inference (IV caused observed change in DV) Experiment has internal validity when it fulfills.
Chapter 10 Experimental Research: One-Way Designs.
Experimental Design: One-Way Correlated Samples Design
1 Experimental Design. 2  Single Factor - One treatment with several levels.  Multiple Factors - More than one treatment with several levels each. 
A Within-Subjects Experiment: Homophone Priming of Proper Names
Experimental Design. Threats to Internal Validity 1.No Control Group Known as a “one-shot case study” XOXO (IV)(DV)
@ 2012 Wadsworth, Cengage Learning Chapter 10 Extending the Logic of Experimentation: Within-Subjects and Matched-Subjects 2012 Wadsworth,
Experimental Research Strategy. Experiment Establish existence of a cause-and-effect relationship between two variables Demonstrating that changes in.
PRED 354 TEACH. PROBILITY & STATIS. FOR PRIMARY MATH Lesson 12 Repeated-Measures Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
Introduction section of article
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Using Between-Subjects and Within- Subjects Experimental Designs.
10 Experimental Research: One-Way Designs What types of evidence allow us to conclude that one variable causes another variable? How do experimental research.
The Psychologist as Detective, 4e by Smith/Davis © 2007 Pearson Education Chapter Six: The Basics of Experimentation I: Variables and Control Chapter Six:
Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin Using Specialized Research Designs.
Simple Experiments. Causal Claim Boldest claim a scientist can make Verbs such as “associated with” and “related to” replaced with “causes, influences,
Chapter 11 The t-Test for Two Related Samples
ITEC6310 Research Methods in Information Technology Instructor: Prof. Z. Yang Course Website: /itec6310.htm Office:
Experimental design – how Ps are allocated to each condition of the IV Repeated measures Independent measures Matched participants.
LECTURE 11 Chapter 11 Repeated Measures / Within Subs Design 1.Control error variance = individual diff. No diff. due to sampling error! 2. Fewer subjects.
Within-Subjects (Repeated Measures) Designs Each participant receives all conditions in the experiment Main advantage: increased power Since the number.
8 Experimental Research Design.
Repeated Measures Designs
Stats/Methods II JEOPARDY.
METHODS IN BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH
Research Methods: Concepts and Connections First Edition
Experimental Research Designs
Experimental Design-Chapter 8
Between-Subjects, within-subjects, and factorial Experimental Designs
Research design I: Experimental design and quasi-experimental research
Within- Subjects Design
Within- Subjects Design
Control error variance = individual diff.
Research Methods Experiments IV & DV
Between-Subjects Experimental Designs
Chapter 8 Experimental Design.
Repeated Measures Designs
1.2 Planning and Conducting Research
Chapter 13: Repeated-Measures Analysis of Variance
PSYA1: Cognitive Psychology Memory
Introduction to Between-Subjects Experiments
CHAPTER 8 EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN © 2012 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
Within-Subjects Experiments
Research Methods Experiments IV & DV
Bonus Slide!!! Things to “carefully consider”
Presentation transcript:

Within-Subjects Design Experimental Design

Between-Subjects Design (a. k. a., Independent Measures Design) A research strategy in which scores are obtained from separate groups of participants in different conditions EXPERIMENTAL GROUP CONTROL GROUP

Within-Subjects Design (a.k.a., Repeated Measures Design) Compares two or more conditions with scores obtained from the same group of participants CONDITION 1 CONDITION 2

Advantages of Within-Subjects Designs Eliminates Individual Differences*

CONDITION 1 CONDITION 2 John 20 Mary 30 Bill 40 Kate 50 MEAN 35 Sue 24 Tom 35 Dave 43 Ann 54 MEAN 39

CONDITION 1 CONDITION 2 John 20 Mary 30 Bill 40 Kate 50 MEAN 35 John 24 Mary 35 Bill 43 Kate 54 MEAN 39

Advantages of Within-Subjects Designs Eliminates individual differences * Fewer Participants

Disadvantages of Within-Subject Designs Environmental Variables Setting, Time of Day, Weather, etc.

Disadvantages of Within-Subject Designs Environmental Variables Experience Variables CARRYOVER EFFECTS Changes in behavior or performance caused by participating in earlier treatments PRACTICE EFFECTS FATIGUE EFFECTS

NO CARRYOVER EFFECTS CARRYOVER EFFECTS CONDITION 1 CONDITION 2 CONDITION 1 CONDITION 2 20 30 40 50 Mean = 35 19 25 41 55 Mean = 35 20 30 40 50 Mean = 35 25 35 45 55 Mean = 40 Some scores go up & some go down All scores are +5

Counterbalancing The order in which treatment conditions are administered from one participant to another are ordered to match with respect to time CONDITION 1 CONDITION 2 Half of Participants Half of Participants