Presentation to the MA Electric Restructuring Roundtable

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Assessment of Peaking Gas Service for New Englands Quick Start Generators Planning Advisory Committee March 3, 2005 Herbert Rakebrand III Herbert Rakebrand.
Advertisements

NECPUC SYMPOSIUM Concurrent B Natural Gas Conditions Facing New England Mark R. Babula ISO New England Inc. Supervisor - Power Supply & Reliability June.
Rich Paglia Vice President
Yes, We Believe So, But New Capacity Will Be Needed (And Several Projects Are in the Pipeline) Massachusetts Electric Restructuring Roundtable February.
Al McBride MANAGER, AREA TRANSMISSION PLANNING Existing Import Interfaces: Transmission Transfer Capabilities and The Calculation of Tie Benefits DECEMBER.
Presentation to FERC’s Northeast Energy Infrastructure Conference Electricity Infrastructure in New England Stephen G. Whitley Sr. Vice President and Chief.
© 2008 ICF International. All rights reserved. NYSERDA Much Colder Than Normal Weather Combination Case Results December 2009 Contacts: Kevin R. Petak.
1 AEC October 31, To Chicago Western U.S. Gas Grid Northern Border Kern PGT Northwest El Paso CIG & WIC Trailblazer CIG KN Potential Connect to.
February 22, 2001 Alaskan Pipeline Meeting Agenda Introduction to Enron & El Paso Assessing the Alaskan Gas Impact Enron & El Paso Value Added.
NERC’s Long-Term Reliability Assessment (LTRA) Workshop: Natural Gas Dependency in New England Michael I. Henderson ISO New England Inc.
North American Natural Gas Infrastructure Needs Donald F. Santa, Jr. President Interstate Natural Gas Association of America The Independent Petroleum.
KERN RIVER GAS TRANSMISSION COMPANY Wyoming Pipeline Authority Casper, Wyoming August 21, 2007 John Dushinske Vice President of Marketing & Regulatory.
Outlook on Natural Gas and LNG. Fuel Diversity in New England Recent build-out ~10,700 MW Gas-fired generation (% Total NE GWh) –1999: 16% –2003: 41%
Connecticut’s Energy Future Connecticut Energy Advisory Board Conference Hartford, Connecticut December 2, 2004 Kevin Kirby Vice President, Market Operations.
Preliminary Analysis of the SEE Future Infrastructure Development Plan and REM Benefits.
SEPTEMBER 29, 2014 | CONCORD, NH Eric Johnson DIRECTOR, EXTERNAL AFFAIRS New Hampshire Energy Summit Lessons Learned from Winter 2014 and How the ISO Is.
© 2008 ICF International. All rights reserved. NYSERDA Much Colder Than Normal Weather Case Results November 2009 Contacts: Kevin R. Petak (
© 2008 ICF International. All rights reserved. NYSERDA Case 1 Results June 24, 2009 Contacts: Kevin R. Petak ( ) Vice President, Gas Market.
© 2008 ICF International. All rights reserved. New York Gas Market Overview Based on NYSERDA Case 1 (n0908) March 2009 Contacts: Kevin R. Petak (
Energy Risk Management – 3 October 2006 Increasing interactions with global energy markets - the impact on the GB gas market Jo Witters Wholesale Markets,
ENERGY MARKET PERSPECTIVE
Michael Dirrane Director, Northeast Marketing NASUCA 2012 Annual Meeting November 13, 2012.
Electric Energy Issues and the Region Connecticut Business and Industry Association Stamford, Connecticut December 2, 2004 Kevin Kirby Vice President,
Winter Past, Winter Future Role of LNG in New England Prepared for: New Hampshire Energy Summit Concord, NH October 5, Joe Dalton Director, Government.
New Hampshire Energy Summit Rich Paglia President, Maritimes & Northeast Pipeline Vice President, Marketing New England Pipeline Expansion Update.
Entrega Project Update Wyoming Natural Gas Pipeline Authority – August 30, 2005 Entrega Gas Pipeline Inc.
RGGI Workshop on Electricity Markets, Reliability and Planning Topic Session 3: RGGI Design, Markets and Reliability – Issues Relating to System Operations.
SERC Reliability Corporation 1 SERC RELIABILITY CORPORATION MID-AMERICA RELIABILITY CONFERENCE June 21, 2006 COLUMBUS, OHIO.
2015 NARUC Winter Meeting Nick Wagner – Iowa Utilities Board 1.
Bruce B. Henning Vice President, Energy Regulatory and Market Analysis Natural Gas in New England: Gas-Electric Interdependency.
WEFA Inc. Northeast Natural Gas Market Outlook Ron Denhardt Vice President, WEFA Energy Services September.
California Independent System Operator 1 Department of Market Analysis California Independent System Operator California ISO Creation Time: July,
1 Gas/Electric Coordination Meeting April, 2008 Bill Whaley Vice President Gas Control & Customer Service Bill Whaley Vice President Gas Control & Customer.
Aligning the Gas and Electric Markets: EDF Solutions
Exploring Pipeline Dynamics to Connect New Markets
Victorian Gas Declared Transmission System
Northern Border Partners (11.8%)
Winter Outlook Markets Matter
Northeast Natural Gas Market Outlook
Restructuring Roundtable March 24, 2017 Boston, MA
Natural Gas Infrastructure Assessment
Affordable Energy Production from Renewable Fuel
LNG: Reliable Gas Supply for the Northeast U.S.
APEx Conference 2016 October 12-14, Medellin Panel 1 – Value of Markets and Future Development Presenter: Restricted.
Massachusetts Electric Restructuring Roundtable
Natural Gas World Presentation T
The New England Restructuring Roundtable
Michael I. Henderson ISO New England Inc.
2018 Summer Outlook Markets Matter
December 9, 2005 Allison DiGrande, External Affairs Department, ISO/NE
ELECTRICITY RESTRUCTURING ROUNDTABLE
New England Resource Adequacy
Northeast Supply Dynamics
Mike Hachey Director, Power Marketing TransCanada Power Marketing Ltd
New England Gas Overview
Regional Natural Gas Supply & Deliverability
Market Design in New England
New England Electricity Restructuring Roundtable September 18, 2009
Alternative ICAP Proposal
Is New England Over-Reliant On Natural Gas?
CPES Meeting Cromwell, CT
Bringing Power from the North
New England Roundtable
Bringing Power from the North
Market Design Through a Period of Transition
Wholesale Electricity Costs
Natural Gas and Electricity Interface Challenges in New England
Winter Reliability Program Updated
New England Roundtable Gas Supply & Electricity Rates in New England
Manager, Resource Planning
Presentation transcript:

Steady-State Analysis of New England’s Interstate Pipeline Delivery Capability Presentation to the MA Electric Restructuring Roundtable February 16, 2001 Richard Levitan Levitan & Associates, Inc. rll@levitan.com

New England Natural Gas Supply Sources

New England Natural Gas Infrastructure New England’s Major Interstate Pipelines Iroquois • Portland Algonquin • Maritimes & Northeast Tennessee Existing pipeline delivery capacity = 3.8 Bcf/d. Daily LNG sendout capability at Everett = 0.450 Bcf/d. Expansion of 0.60 Bcf/d for 1,550 MW Sithe New Mystic Station, possibly Island End About 1.4 Bcf/d peak day deliverability behind the citygates Liquids via truck  0.1 Bcf/d

New England’s Interstate Pipelines Western Canadian Gas thru TCPL, Iroquois and PNGTS Eastern Canadian Gas thru M&N thru Tennessee Gulf Coast Gas thru Algonquin And Tennessee LNG from Algeria and Trinidad Tennessee Iroquois PNGTS M&N Algonquin

Primary Interstate Pipelines

Interstate Transportation Market Dynamics 14 pipeline projects placed in-service during 1999-’00 + 2.0 Bcf/d in the Greater Northeast New Pipelines in New England, M&N and PNGTS, result in + 615 MMcf/d (0.615 Bcf/d), or about 3800 MW Counterflow capability through Dracut  Tennessee Pressure and flow benefits improve network reliability New LNG supplies from Trinidad Commoditization of the “Supply Chain” Repackaged Btu services • Synthetics Increased liquidity • Risk management

Electric Assumptions - Reference Case Reference case load growth forecast thru 2005 7,500 MW (winter) of new capacity by 2005 200 MW of capacity attrition - 2000 CELT Report Net Interchange: firm contracts per 2000 CELT Report - (NY, NB, HQ) modeling of post-HQ FEC deliveries - (HQ Phase II) modeling of NEPOOL sales via proposed new interconnections (cross-sound cable)

Electric Assumptions - High Case High case load growth forecast thru 2005 11,500 MW (winter) of new capacity by 2005 4,000 MW (winter) of capacity attrition Net Interchange - Higher than Reference case: firm contracts per 2000 CELT Report - (NY, NB, HQ) modeling of post-HQ FEC deliveries - (HQ Phase II) modeling of NEPOOL sales via proposed new interconnections (cross-sound cable & Bridgeport cable)

Merchant Entry in New England (High Case)

Steady-State Highlights No pipeline delivery constraints on a peak day in Winter 2000-01 No summer peak day pipeline deliverability constraints through 2005 Delivery constraints are apparent in Winter 2003 Shortfall in gas requirements  1,755 MW out of 8,946 MW assumed There are 71 gas-fired units, 51 of which are dual fueled Delivery constraints intensify by Winter 2005 Shortfall in gas requirements  3,226 MW out of 11,579 MW assumed There are 75 gas-fired units, 54 of which are dual fueled Theoretical mitigation potential thru back-up fuel

Projected Shortfalls in Gas Requirements (MW)* 2001 2003 2005 * 6970 Btu/kWh

Summary of Peak Day Scenarios – Total Regional Demand vs Summary of Peak Day Scenarios – Total Regional Demand vs. System Capacity

Steady-State Modeling Results Year Scenario Forecast Pipeline Demand (MMcf/d) Unserved Merchant LDCs Merchant Generators Volumes (MMcf/d) Capacity (MW) 2001 Winter Peak Day High 2617 751 --- 2003 Reference 2837 872 189 1164 Winter 60-Day 804 72 443 880 285 1755 861 191 1176 2005 907 241 1484 782 76 468 906 524 3226 867 513 3159 Summer Peak Day 406 1501 Unserved merchant capacity does not take into account back-up fuel capabilities.

ISO Contingencies Loss of Major Gas-Fired Generating Unit No significant loss of pressure or flows Interstate pipelines have the ability to divert and/or re-route gas along the 1100-mile transportation path Loss of 2000 MW HydroQuebec Line Winter Peak Day - System cannot transport any additional gas Summer Peak Day - More than sufficient pipeline capacity to support replacement gas fueled generation

Gas Contingency Scenario 1 Increased horsepower requirements at other compressor stations Fall in delivery pressures to levels that could disrupt plant operations No observed impact on other pipelines Available compression capacity at Burrillville on Algonquin derated from 11,400 hp to 5,700 hp

Gas Contingency Scenario 2 Available compression capacity at Agawam on Tennessee derated from 9,760 hp to 3,253 hp Downstream compressor stations able to make-up for loss No unacceptably low delivery pressures for merchant plants observed No impact on other pipelines

Gas Contingency Scenario 3 7 miles of Tennessee’s 36-inch line at NY-MA border removed Downstream compressors able to compensate for pressure loss

Mitigation Potential Case New Entry (MW) Back-up Fuel Capability Peak Day Gas Available w/ Back-up Fuel Use (MMcf) Peak Day Transport Shortfall Excess or Shortfall w/ Back-up Fuel Use (MMcf/d) Reference 7,551 2,263 382.5 241.0 141.5 High 11,579 5,890 971.5 524.0 447.5

Recommendations Establish quality of interstate transportation arrangements Advocate the streamlining of FERC’s pipeline certification process Promote coordination of power and natural gas scheduling protocols Increase understanding of merchant generators’ fuel-switching capabilities

Levitan & Associates, Inc. www. levitan Levitan & Associates, Inc. www.levitan.com Tel: 617-531-2818 Email: rll@levitan.com