MANE-VU SIP Planning Meeting

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

RH Requirement for BART  §308 (e) contains BART requirements for regional haze visibility impairment…. The State must submit an implementation plan containing.

Advertisements

Modeling the New 1-Hour Nitrogen Dioxide (NO 2 ) and Sulfur Dioxide (SO 2 ) NAAQS Alan Dresser Research Scientist I October 14, 2011.

WRAP Stationary Source (SS) NOx and PM Report Lee Alter Western Governors’ Association WRAP IOC NOx Issues Meeting Denver, CO July 28, 2003.

Update: National Ambient Air Quality Standards Association of California Airports September 15, 2010 Phil DeVita.

Paul Wishinski VT DEC Presentation for: MARAMA-NESCAUM-OTC Regional Haze Workshop August 2-3, 2000 Gorham, New Hampshire LYE BROOK WILDERNESS CLASS I AREA.

PM 2.5 in the Upper Midwest Michael Koerber Lake Michigan Air Directors Consortium.

Natural Background Visibility Feb. 6, 2004 Presentation to VISTAS State Air Directors Mt. Cammerer, Great Smoky Mtn. National Park.

Substituting Sulfate for Sulfur Impact on the RHR metrics and control strategies Presented at the 2006 IMPROVE Steering Committee Meeting by B.A. Schichtel.

Meeting of the Southern Ute Indian Tribe/State of Colorado Environmental Commission and the Colorado Air Quality Control Commission 4/16/2015.

North Dakota’s Approach to a Periodic Review to Determine the Status of Consumption of PSD Class I Sulfur Dioxide Increments WESTAR Fall Technical Conference,

1 EPA’s Proposal for Nonroad Diesel Engines & Fuel May 2003 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Transportation and Air Quality Informal document.

Final Amendments to the Regional Haze Rule: BART Rule Making June 16, 2005.

Regional Haze Rule Best Available Retrofit Technology Government to Government Consultation Navajo Nation Environmental Protection Agency.

BART Control Analysis WESTAR August 31, 2005 EPA Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Todd Hawes

1 Summary of LADCO’s Regional Modeling in the Eastern U.S.: Preliminary Results April 27, 2009 MWAQC TAC June 15, 2009.

Application of Combined Mathematical and Meteorological Receptor Models (UNMIX & Residence Time Analysis) to IMPROVE Aerosol Data from Brigantine.

Climate, Air Quality and Noise Graham Latonas Gartner Lee Limited RWDI Air Inc.

Brief Description of CALPUFF Navajo Nation Environmental Protection Agency.

BART Guideline Overview WESTAR August 31, 2005 EPA Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Todd Hawes

REGIONAL HAZE BART – Key Issues For Consideration Eric Massey, Arizona DEQ Lee Alter, WGA SSJF Meeting June 3, 2004 Denver, Colorado.

Regional Haze SIP Development Overview AQCC Presentation July 2005.

Regional Modeling Center Workplan Fire/Carbon/Dust Workshop May 24, 2006.

WRAP States Four Factor Reasonable Progress Lee Gribovicz WRAP IWG Meeting March 10, 2009.

VISTAS Emissions Inventory Overview Nov 4, VISTAS is evaluating visibility and sources of fine particulate mass in the Southeastern US View NE from.

1 Projects:/WRAP_RMC/Presents/ADEQ_Feb ppt Western Regional Air Partnership (WRAP) Projection of Visibility Changes and Modeling Sensitivity Analysis.

Proposed Reasonable Progress Rule Workshop Brief Background and Procedure Public Workshop June 14, 2007.

FLMs, PSD Increment, and AQRVs: the Oregon experience WESTAR Fall Technical Conference Seattle September 2003 Philip Allen, Oregon DEQ.

Regional Modeling Joseph Cassmassi South Coast Air Quality Management District USA.

Regional Modeling for Stationary Source Control Strategy Evaluation WESTAR Conference on BART Guidelines and Trading September 1, 2005 Tom Moore -

Status of BART Analyses Implementation Workgroup Meeting April 17, 2007.

BART SIP Development: Example from Colorado Rocky Mountain National Park WRAP IWG Meeting, Denver, CO August 29, 2007 Presented by: Ray Mohr and Curt Taipale.

Reproposal of the Regional Haze Rule and BART Guidelines.

Summary of June 15, 2005 Revisions to RH BART and BART Guidelines.

Implementation Workgroup Meeting December 6, 2006 Attribution of Haze Workgroup’s Monitoring Metrics Document Status: 1)2018 Visibility Projections – Alternative.

BART Status of Other States AK, Bernalillo County, HI ND, SD, OR, WA.

WESTAR 2003 Fall Technical Conference Introduction to Class I Area Impact Analyses September 16, 2003 John Bunyak National Park Service.

2005 Progress on Emissions Inventories Attribution of Haze Workgroup Meeting January 24, 2006.

Summary of WRAP Stationary Source (SS) NOx and PM Report Lee Alter Western Governors’ Association WRAP Board Meeting Salt Lake City, UT October 15, 2003.

Proposed Amendments to the AB 32 Cost of Implementation Fee Regulation September 18, 2014 California Air Resources Board.

1 REMSAD VERSION 7.10 WITH SOURCE TAGGING Inter-RPO Modeling Meeting May 25, 2004 Shan He, Emily Savelli, Jung-Hun Woo, John Graham and Gary Kleiman, NESCAUM.

1 Recent MANE-VU Projections of Visibility for 2018 Gary Kleiman MANE-VU Stakeholder Briefing April 4, 2008 BWI.

EPA Region 10 Cumulative Effects Analysis Methodology Development Rob Wilson and Herman Wong WESTAR Fall Technical Conference September 16, 2003.

MANE-VU Technical Overview

National RPO Technical Meeting June 9, 2005 Gary Kleiman, NESCAUM

A Basis for Control of BART Eligible Sources

MANE-VU Emissions Inventory Update

Sulfate Attribution Methods

Attribution Of Haze Case Study for Nevada Jarbidge Wilderness Area

BART Overview Lee Alter Western Governors’ Association

Species Specific Reasonable Progress Analysis

Attribution Of Haze Case Study for Nevada Jarbidge Wilderness Area

Reasonable Progress: Chiricahua NM & Wilderness Area

MANE-VU Contribution Assessment Efforts: Trajectory Cluster Analysis

The four rules of number

John Bunyak National Park Service

PM2.5 NSR and Designations

Regional Modeling Update

Status of Regional Haze Rule

MONTANA REGIONAL HAZE VISIBILITY PROTECTION PLAN

TCEQ AMBIENT Air Monitors in Corpus christi

Who is BART in Idaho and how do we know?

62 – Sequences and Series Day 1 Calculator Required

CHALK? DATA: Interfering Variables: RESEARCH QUESTION: METHODS:

Status of the PM NAAQS Review

RHPWG – Control Measures Subcommittee Oil & Gas Source Coordination

Stationary Source NOx and PM Report: An Update Lee Alter Western Governors’ Association WRAP Market Trading Forum Meeting September 19-20, 2002 Snowbird,

WRAP Stationary Sources Forum Meeting November 14-15, 2006

RA BART Overview Deb Wolfe 8/9/2019.

Status of Preliminary Reasonable Progress Analysis

Acadia NP Size – 7.4 Horiz – 2.0 Vert – 0.1.

Presentation transcript:

MANE-VU SIP Planning Meeting BART Gary Kleiman NESCAUM/MANE-VU MANE-VU SIP Planning Meeting June 12, 2006

BART Resource Book Review of Regulations BART Eligible Source List (to the extent possible) MANE-VU BART Process and BART Workgroup Recommendations All eligible sources are subject to BART Presumptive levels of control BART Technology Assessment and Other Resources M-V Assessment (EGU/ICI/Cement/P&P) Industry Assessments BART Determinations (including visibility determinations!)

Visibility Determinations CALPUFF (MM5 driven meteorology) CALPUFF (NWS Observation driven met.) 2002 contribution and post-BART, if applicable Workgroup still investigating metrics, but 24-hour maximum impact at each Class I areas against natural conditions seems likely Sulfate, PM, and Nitrate will be calculated

Acadia 24-Hour Max Day Impact (relative to 20% worst natural and baseline conditions) 1.748 0.533 0.665 Wyman St. Acadia 0.905 0.186 0.324 0.220 WH Sammis Conesville 0.075 An example of CALPUFF, source specific modeling results (courtesy of VT DEC) at Acadia… Indian River Change in Visibility (Ddv) relative To Natural Background - Blue To Baseline - Red

BART Questions Presumptive Levels for Cement Plants Presumptive Sulfur Level for Fuel Oil Threshold for Visibility Impacts How to address engineering review versus visibility determination and other four factors Do we want to ask FLMs to express their opinion?