ISMRM 2011 E-Poster #4643 mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone J.Su1, H.H.Kitzler2, M.Zeineh1,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Corpus Callosum Damage Predicts Disability Progression and Cognitive Dysfunction in Primary-Progressive MS After Five Years.
Advertisements

VBM Voxel-based morphometry
NON-EXPONENTIAL T 2 * DECAY IN WHITE MATTER P. van Gelderen 1, J. A. de Zwart 1, J. Lee 1,3, P. Sati 1, D. S. Reich 1, and J. H. Duyn 1. 1 Advanced MRI.
Journal Club: mcDESPOT with B0 & B1 Inhomogeneity.
Clinical Evaluation of Fast T2-Corrected MR Spectroscopy Compared to Multi-Point 3D Dixon for Hepatic Lipid and Iron Quantification Puneet Sharma 1, Xiaodong.
OverviewOverview Motion correction Smoothing kernel Spatial normalisation Standard template fMRI time-series Statistical Parametric Map General Linear.
A UTOMATIC S EGMENTATION OF T HALAMIC N UCLEI WITH STEPS L ABEL F USION J.Su 1, T. Tourdias 2, M.Saranathan 1, and B.K.Rutt 1 1 Department of Radiology,
Relaxometry & Image Processing Technical Update Clinical Findings/Product Need Competitive Info Recommendations T1 (DESPOT1 and LL) parameter fitting via.
MSmcDESPOT A look at the road behind and ahead October 30, 2009.
ISMRM 2010 Quantitative Imaging and MS. N. D. Gai and J. A. Butman, NIH T1 Error Analysis for Double Angle Technique and Comparison to Inversion Recovery.
Introduction: The lesion-centered view on MS __________________________________________________________________ RRI/TUD/StanU – HH Kitzler Specific Aims:
MSmcDESPOT: Follow-Ups November 1, Where We Are Baseline cross-section conclusions: – DVF is sensitive to early stages of MS where other measures.
Declaration of Conflict of Interest or Relationship I have no conflicts of interest to disclose with regard to the subject matter of this presentation.
Method for Determining Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Values for Cerebral Lesions from Diffusion Weighted Magnetic Resonance Imaging Examinations T.H.
Alzheimer’s Disease and Myelin February 2012 Jason Su.
Whole Brain Myelin Imaging with mcDESPOT in Multiple Sclerosis
MNTP Trainee: Georgina Vinyes Junque, Chi Hun Kim Prof. James T. Becker Cyrus Raji, Leonid Teverovskiy, and Robert Tamburo.
Diffusion-Tensor Imaging Tractography: Correlation with Processing Speed in Aging Stephen Correia 1, Stephanie Y. Lee 2, Song Zhang 2, Stephen P. Salloway.
September In Chapter 14: 14.1 Data 14.2 Scatterplots 14.3 Correlation 14.4 Regression.
7T Thalamus and MS Studies Jason Su Sep 16, 2013.
ISMRM2012 Review Jun 4, 2012 Jason Su. Outline Parametric Mapping – Kumar et al. A Bayesian Algorithm Using Spatial Priors for Multi-Exponential T2 Relaxometry.
Brain Mapping Unit The General Linear Model A Basic Introduction Roger Tait
References: [1]S.M. Smith et al. (2004) Advances in functional and structural MR image analysis and implementation in FSL. Neuroimage 23: [2]S.M.
J OURNAL C LUB : Lankford and Does. On the Inherent Precision of mcDESPOT. Jul 23, 2012 Jason Su.
A CCELERATED V ARIABLE F LIP A NGLE T 1 M APPING VIA V IEW S HARING OF P SEUDO -R ANDOM S AMPLED H IGHER O RDER K-S PACE J.Su 1, M.Saranathan 1, and B.K.Rutt.
MSmcDESPOT A Brief Summary April 2, The Technique mcDESPOT (multi-component driven equilibrium single pulse observation of T1/T2) is a quantitative.
J OURNAL C LUB : Deoni et al. One Component? Two Components? Three? The Effect of Including a Nonexchanging ‘‘Free’’ Water Component in mcDESPOT. Jan 14,
P025 MPRAGE Pre-Contrast. P025 MPRAGE w/ Z-Score < -4.
J OURNAL C LUB : S Magon, et al. University Hospital Basel, Switzerland “Label-Fusion-Segmentation and Deformation-Based Shape Analysis of Deep Gray Matter.
Interaction between chronic and acute pain: down- regulation of motivational value for relief from acute pain 589 OHBM 2009 INTRODUCTION Our recent fMRI.
Date of download: 5/28/2016 Copyright © 2016 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. From: Large, Nonplateauing Relationship Between Clinical.
A CCELERATED V ARIABLE F LIP A NGLE T 1 M APPING VIA V IEW S HARING OF P SEUDO -R ANDOM S AMPLED H IGHER O RDER K-S PACE J.Su 1, M.Saranathan 1, and B.K.Rutt.
Ovarian age is associated with gray matter volume and disability in women with MS independent of chronological age and disease duration Jennifer Graves,
Baseline and longitudinal patterns of brain atrophy in MCI patients, and their use in prediction of Short- term conversion to AD: Results from ADNI Xuejiao.
Date of download: 6/22/2016 Copyright © 2016 SPIE. All rights reserved. Schematic representation of the near-infrared (NIR) structured illumination instrument,
In The Name of God. Multiple Sclerosis and Normal MRI new modalities for problems solving.
Stats Methods at IC Lecture 3: Regression.
10/13/2017 1:36 PM CLINIQUE DU MAIL GRENOBLE, FRANCE
Axonal loss in the pathology of MS: consequences for understanding the progressive phase of the disease  C Bjartmar, J.R Wujek, B.D Trapp  Journal of.
Restriction Spectrum Imaging in Multiple Sclerosis
Metabolic Syndrome and Progression of Mild Cognitive Impairment
Comparison of cortical perfusion between relapse-remitting multiple sclerosis patients and healthy controls measured using Arterial Spin Labelling MRI.
GRAY MATTER ATROPHY IN PEDIATRIC MS PATIENTS
C. P. Loizou1, C. Papacharalambous1, G. Samaras1, E. Kyriakou2, T
Research Update Nov 18, 2016 Jason Su.
Brief Computerized Measures of Information Processing Speed are Sensitive to Multiple Sclerosis across the Lifespan M. Shaw1, C. Schwarz1, L.B. Krupp1,
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Bowden, Shores, & Mathias (2006): Failure to Replicate or Just Failure to Notice. Does Effort Still Account for More Variance in Neuropsychological Test.
Statistics in MSmcDESPOT
DIFFUSION ABNORMALITY OF CORPUS CALLOSUM IN ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE
What’s the Big Deal About Brain Atrophy and Neurodegeneration in RRMS?
Volume 60, Issue 4, Pages (November 2008)
Signal fluctuations in 2D and 3D fMRI at 7 Tesla
Volume 17, Issue 6, Pages (June 2010)
Figure 3 Associations of [11C](R)-PK11195 binding to disability and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) changes in patients with MS Associations of [11C](R)-PK11195.
A Network Diffusion Model of Disease Progression in Dementia
Volume 76, Issue 5, Pages (December 2012)
ISMRM 2012 Prelim. Abstracts Oct 17, 2011 – Jason Su
Basic Practice of Statistics - 3rd Edition Inference for Regression
Trajectory Encoding in the Hippocampus and Entorhinal Cortex
Extraocular Muscle Compartments in Superior Oblique Palsy
Motion-Based Analysis of Spatial Patterns by the Human Visual System
Figure 3 Anatomical distribution of all implanted electrodes
Anatomical Measures John Ashburner
Longitudinal Characterization of Cortical Lesion Development and Evolution in Multiple Sclerosis with 7.0-T MRI In patients with multiple sclerosis, 7.0-T.
Perceptual Classification in a Rapidly Changing Environment
Volume 76, Issue 5, Pages (December 2012)
Impact of approaches for clinical and radiological monitoring on predicting of short-term and long-term disability outcomes in multiple sclerosis Brian.
Atrophied Brain T2 Lesion Volume at MRI Is Associated with Disability Progression and Conversion to Secondary Progressive Multiple Sclerosis The rate.
Presentation transcript:

ISMRM 2011 E-Poster #4643 mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone J.Su1, H.H.Kitzler2, M.Zeineh1, S.C.Deoni3, C.Harper-Little2, A.Leung2, M.Kremenchutzky2, and B.K.Rutt1 1Stanford U, CA, USA, 2TU Dresden, SN, Germany, 2U of Western Ontario, ON, Canada, 3Brown U, RI, USA Title: I prefer the wording “Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone” over “Compared to Only Atrophy Measures” Are we allowed to change the title so that it’s different from the original abstract? Declaration of Conflict of Interest or Relationship I have no conflicts of interest to disclose with regard to the subject matter of this presentation.

mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Background Conventional MRI measures such as lesion load have been criticized with adding little new information on top of clinical scores for multiple sclerosis (MS) patients Measures that quantify the hidden burden of disease in white matter are urgently needed

mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Purpose To apply mcDESPOT, a whole-brain, myelin-selective, multi-component relaxometric imaging method, in a pilot MS study Assess if the method can explain differences in disease course and severity by uncovering the burden of disease in normal-appearing white matter (NAWM)

Study Demographic Data Healthy Controls All Patients CIS RRMS SPMS mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Study Demographic Data Healthy Controls All Patients CIS RRMS SPMS PPMS N 26 10 5 6 Mean age, yr (SD) 42 (13) 49 (12) 41 48 58 (7) 55 Male/Female ratio 10/16 7/19 3/7 0/5 0/6 4/1 Mean disease duration, yr — 14 2 (2) 15 (10) 28 (8) 20 Mean EDSS score 3.6 (2.4) 1.7 (0.9) 2.0 (1.7) 6.4 (1.1) 5.6

Scanning Methods 1.5T GE Signa HDx, 8-channel head RF coil mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Scanning Methods 1.5T GE Signa HDx, 8-channel head RF coil mcDESPOT: 2mm3 isotropic covering whole brain, about 15 min. SPGR: TE/TR = 2.1/6.7ms, α = {3,4,5,6,7,8,11,13,18}° bSSFP: TE/TR = 1.8/3.6ms, α = {11,14,20,24,28,34,41,51,67}° 2D T2 FLAIR: 0.86 mm2 in-plane and 3mm slice resolution 3D T1 IR-SPGR: 1mm3 resolution with pre/post Gd contrast

The Technique

Processing Methods: MWF mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Processing Methods: MWF Linearly coregister and brain extract mcDESPOT SPGR and SSFP images with FSL1 Find myelin water fraction maps using the established mcDESPOT fitting algorithm2 Myelin Water Fraction 1FMRIB Software Library. 2Deoni et al., Magn Reson Med. 2008 Dec;60(6):1372-87

mcDESPOT Maps in Normal T1single T1slow T1fast MWF 0 – 2345ms 0 – 1172ms 0 – 555ms 0 – 0.234 0 – 328ms 0 – 123ms 0 – 9.26ms 0 – 137ms T2single T2slow T2fast Residence Time

Processing Methods: Demyelination mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Processing Methods: Demyelination Non-linearly register mcDESPOT MWF maps to MNI152 standard space Combine normals together to form mean and standard deviation MWF volumes For each subject, calculate a z-score ([x – μ]/σ) at every voxel to determine if it is significantly demyelinated, i.e. MWF < -4σ below the mean Demyelinated Voxels

Processing Methods: WM mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Processing Methods: WM Brain extract MPRAGE images Segment white and gray matter with SPM83 Filter tissue masks to reduce noise then manually edit by a trained neuroradiologist Calculate parenchymal volume fraction (PVF) as WM+GM divided by the brain mask volume FLAIR WM 3Statistical Parametric Mapping software package.

Processing Methods: Lesions & DAWM mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Processing Methods: Lesions & DAWM Non-linearly register T2-FLAIR images to MNI152 standard space Combine normals together to form mean and standard deviation volumes Segment lesions as those voxels with z-score > +4 and diffusely abnormal white matter > +2 Edit masks by a trained neurologist DAWM Lesions

Processing Methods: NAWM & DVF mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Processing Methods: NAWM & DVF Segment normal-appearing white matter (NAWM) as WM – DAWM – lesions Find demyelinated volume fraction (DVF) Sum the volume of demyelinated voxels in each tissue compartment and normalize by the compartment’s volume # demy. voxels in compartment * voxel volume / compartment volume Normal-Appearing White Matter

Segmentations and DV FLAIR WM NAWM DAWM Lesions MWF Demyelinated mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Segmentations and DV FLAIR WM NAWM DAWM Lesions After all that processing, we can visualize the end result in a very intuitive way. MWF Demyelinated Voxels DV in NAWM DV in DAWM DV in Lesions

mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Statistical Methods Use rank sum tests to compare patient groups to normals along different measures Perform an exhaustive search to find the best multiple linear regression model for EDSS using Mallows’ Cp4 criterion among 21 possible image-derived predictors: PVF log-DVF in whole brain, log-DVF in WM, log-DVF in NAWM, log-DVF in lesions log-DV in those four compartments mean MWF in those four compartments volumes of those four compartments (lesion volume = T2 lesion load) volume fractions of those four compartments with respect to the whole brain mask volume 4Mallows C. Some comments on Cp. Technometrics. 1973;15(4):661-75.

Results: Mean MWF in Compartments mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Results: Mean MWF in Compartments Dotted line shows mean MWF in WM for normals. Rank sum testing was done for each bar against this Testing was also done for RRMS vs. SPMS and CIS vs. RRMS, any significant differences are shown with a connecting bracket Significance levels: * p < 0.05 ** p < 0.01 *** p < 0.001.

Results: DVF in Compartments mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Results: DVF in Compartments Dotted line shows demyelinated volume fraction in WM for healthy controls With DVF, all patient subclasses were significantly different from healthy controls PVF, however, fails to distinguish CIS and RR patients from normals

Results: Correlations with EDSS mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Results: Correlations with EDSS Lesion load correlates poorly with EDSS PVF and DVF are stronger indicators of decline

Results: Multiple Linear Regression mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Results: Multiple Linear Regression The best linear model for EDSS contains PVF (p < 0.001), mean MWF in whole brain (p < 0.001), and WM volume fraction (p < 0.01) Whole-brain MWF and WM volume fraction significantly improve the prediction of EDSS over that produced by PVF alone Explains 76% of the variance in EDSS (R2 = 0.76, adjusted R2 = 0.73) compared to 56% with only PVF

Discussion & Conclusions mcDESPOT-Derived MWF Improves EDSS Prediction in MS Patients Compared to Atrophy Measures Alone ISMRM 2011 #4643 Discussion & Conclusions DVF is able to differentiate CIS and RRMS patients from normals, whereas other measures such as PVF and mean MWF cannot The invisible burden of disease may be more important than lesions in determining disability, since we observe a higher correlation of EDSS with DVF in NAWM than lesion load A combination of established atrophy measures with new mcDESPOT-derived MWF are more capable in accurately estimating disability than either quantity alone

ISMRM 2011 E-Poster #7224 Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT J.Su1, H.H.Kitzler2, M.Zeineh1, S.C.Deoni3, C.Harper-Little2, A.Leung2, M.Kremenchutzky2, and B.K.Rutt1 1Stanford U, CA, USA, 2TU Dresden, SN, Germany, 2U of Western Ontario, ON, Canada, 3Brown U, RI, USA Declaration of Conflict of Interest or Relationship I have no conflicts of interest to disclose with regard to the subject matter of this presentation.

Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Purpose To apply mcDESPOT, a whole-brain, myelin-selective, multi-component relaxometric imaging method, in a 1-year longitudinal pilot MS study Assess the ability of the method to sense different rates of demyelination for different MS courses and compare it to changes in EDSS

Study Demographic Data Healthy Controls All Patients CIS RRMS SPMS Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Study Demographic Data Healthy Controls All Patients CIS RRMS SPMS PPMS N at baseline 26 10 5 6 N at 1-year 4 23 9 Mean age at baseline, yr (SD) 42 (13) 49 (12) 41 48 58 (7) 55 Mean disease duration at baseline, yr — 14 2 (2) 15 (10) 28 (8) 20 Mean EDSS score at baseline 3.6 (2.4) 1.7 (0.9) 2.0 (1.7) 6.4 (1.1) 5.6 N with EDSS change 3 1

Processing Methods: 1-year & DVF Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Processing Methods: 1-year & DVF At 1-year, demyelinated voxels are based on z-scores with respect to the combined baseline and 1-year normal group Find demyelinated volume fraction (DVF) Sum the volume of demyelinated voxels and normalize by brain mask volume # demy. voxels in compartment * voxel volume / compartment volume

Results: Mean MWF in Whole Brain Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Results: Mean MWF in Whole Brain Dotted line shows mean MWF for normals. Rank sum testing was done for each bar against this value Testing was also done for RRMS vs. SPMS and CIS vs. RRMS, any significant differences are shown with a connecting bracket Significance levels: * p < 0.05 ** p < 0.01 *** p < 0.001.

Results: DVF Change Colors denote subject type Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Results: DVF Change Colors denote subject type Arrowheads indicate the direction of change and the DVF at 1-year Dashed lines show subjects who also had a change in EDSS PPMS SPMS RRMS CIS Normals

Results: DVF in Whole Brain Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Results: DVF in Whole Brain Dotted line shows mean demyelinated volume fraction change for normals Definite MS patients are losing significantly more myelin than normals Progressive patients have a greater rate of demyelination In previous bar charts, you used connecting brackets to show significant differences, but here you aren’t. Any reason for that? There was no significance difference between CIS vs RR and RR vs SP despite the apparent visual differential in the bars.

Discussion & Conclusions Sensitive Detection of Myelination Change in Multiple Sclerosis by mcDESPOT ISMRM 2011 #7224 Discussion & Conclusions The normal pool at 1-year is currently too small to show significance for the changes in mean MWF DVF, however, is sensitive enough to show statistically significant changes in brain myelination over the study period Progressive patients show greater disease decline that are not reflected in their EDSS disability score EDSS and DVF measure different aspects of the disease. Patients with changes in EDSS did not actually have the largest demyelination changes