Report Cards & Reputational Incentives

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Pay-for-Performance Programs: the U.S. Experience Eric Schneider, M.D., M.Sc. Harvard School of Public Health Brigham and Womens Hospital Boston, MA.

Advertisements

PROCEED WITH CAUTION performance incentive programs and racial disparities Alyna Chien MD MS Marshall Chin MD MPH Andrew Davis MD Lawrence Casalino MD.

Healthcare Data Goals, Audiences, Difficulties Timothy A. Denton, M.D., F.A.C.C. High Desert Heart Institute Victorville, CA California Medical Association.

Screening: Doctors Paid for Heart Tests Order More NICHOLAS BAKALAR NY Times - November 14, 2011

Grinols and Mustard Impact of a casino opening on crime rates Concern: casinos are not random – opened in struggling areas Data at county/year level –

Low-Quality, High-Cost Hospitals, Mainly in South, Care for Sharply Higher Shares of Elderly Black, Hispanic, and Medicaid Patients Ashish K. Jha, E. John.

Rankings: What do they matter, what do they measure? Anne McFarlane August 18, 2010.

1 EPI235: Epi Methods in HSR May 3, 2007 L10 Outcomes and Effectiveness Research 4: HMO/Network (Dr. Schneeweiss) Methodologic issues in benchmarking physician.

1 Informational Strategies in Policy Design Organizational Report Cards By Dr. David L. Weimer.

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives  NYS cardiac surgery registry  Studies –In general: no impact –When impact was noted it was transient.

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives  Why fewer providers?  Medicare covers health services that are “reasonable and necessary.”  “In reality, many.

Does transparency improve quality? lessons learnt from cardiac surgery BCIS meeting 2006 Ben Bridgewater SMUHT.

Strengthening partnerships: A National Voluntary Health Agency’s initiatives in managed care Sarah L. Sampsel, MPH* Lisa M. Carlson, MPH, CHES* Michele.

Overview Public Reporting Cardiovascular Data Recommendations.

Decision Analysis. Real Case 63 year old housewife with 6 grown children. 10 year history of stable angina pectoris. 8 years ago she had total hip replacement.

1 IMPROVING HEALTH CARE QUALITY THE ROLE OF PAY-FOR-PERFOMANCE TOM DEAN M.D.

The potential impact of adherence to a guideline on the utilization of head CT scans in traumatic head injury patients. Frederick K. Korley M.D.

Patient-centered, Purposeful Public Reporting David Share, MD, MPH vice president, Value Partnerships Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan

Personalisation in the NHS Giles Wilmore Director NHS England

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives  Incentive to “volunteer” –0.4 – 2.0% CMS payments –Basically, a hospital’s profit margin  Currently, 95% of hospitals.

Cardiac Rehabilitation 2011 Update for Primary Care Providers Douglass A Morrison, MD, PhD Cardiac Rehabilitation, Medical Director Yakima Regional and.

Community Outreach to Reduce Disparities in Cardiovascular & Diabetes Morbidity & Mortality in the South Bronx Michael Alderman, MD Michelle Johnson, MD,

Changes in racial disparities under public reporting and pay for performance Rachel M. Werner.

Is Veteran User Status an Independent Risk Factor for Mortality After Private Sector CABG? William B. Weeks, MD, MBA Dorothy A. Bazos, Ph.D. David M. Bott,

A Comparison of Quality of Care in General Hospitals, Specialty Hospitals, and Ambulatory Surgery Centers Cheryl Fahlman, PhD Phil Kletke, PhD Chuck Wentworth,

Richard Siegrist Senior Vice President & General Manager HealthShare Technology, a WebMD company Adjunct Lecturer, Harvard School of Public Health Point-Counterpoint:

Mapping with ARCVIEW Aihua Pu. Outline Background Data sources Mapping with ARCVIEW Maps.

Date of download: 5/30/2016 Copyright © The American College of Cardiology. All rights reserved. From: Disparities in Cardiac Care: Rising to the Challenge.

Date of download: 5/30/2016 Copyright © 2016 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. From: Elective Intra-aortic Balloon Counterpulsation During.

Date of download: 6/21/2016 Copyright © The American College of Cardiology. All rights reserved. From: Cardiovascular Imaging Research at the Crossroads.

Date of download: 6/23/2016 Copyright © The American College of Cardiology. All rights reserved. From: When to stress patients after coronary artery bypass.

Date of download: 7/5/2016 From: Validation of the Appropriate Use Criteria for Coronary Angiography: A Cohort Study Ann Intern Med. 2015;162(8):

Healthy patients. Healthy hospitals. Early Results from the Premier-CMS Hospital Quality Incentive Demonstration Program Stephanie Alexander Senior Vice.

Date of download: 9/19/2016 Copyright © 2016 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. From: Association of Public Reporting for Percutaneous.

Efforts to Promote Use of HIT Suzanne Delbanco, CEO October 22, 2004 Founded by The Business Roundtable with support from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

Department of Family & Community Medicine

Vice President – Pediatric Population Health and Care Modeling

Department of Economics

Figure 1 A flow chart describing the systematic process followed for article selection. From: A systematic review of cost-effectiveness of percutaneous.

Jan L.Svennevig, MD,PhD Heart surgery in Norway 2005 Norwegian Association of Cardiothoracic Surgeons Jan L.Svennevig, MD,PhD.

Jan L.Svennevig, MD,PhD Heart surgery in Norway 2006 Norwegian Association of Cardiothoracic Surgeons Jan L.Svennevig, MD,PhD.

Figure 1 The flowchart depicts the total number of procedures in the Western Denmark Heart Registry (WDHR) and the exclusion of patients; NPR, National.

Successful CTO PCI Associated with Lower Mortality Risk

TCPI Data Management Webinar Eddie Fonner, Assistant Project Director

The Focus on Quality A Closer Look at a National Trend

The Society of Thoracic Surgeons

Influence of Cardiac Surgeon Report Cards on Patient Referral by Cardiologists in New York State After 20 Years of Public Reporting by David L. Brown,

Acute Kidney Injury and In-Hospital Mortality after Coronary Artery Bypass Graft versus Percutaneous Coronary Intervention: A Nationwide Study Shen et.

Frederick L. Grover, MD The Annals of Thoracic Surgery

Public Reporting of Cardiovascular Data

Fewer PCIs After Public Reporting Changes in NY

Alyna Chien MD MS Marshall Chin MD MPH Andrew Davis MD

Jan L.Svennevig, MD,PhD Heart surgery in Norway 2004 Norwegian Association of Cardiothoracic Surgeons Jan L.Svennevig, MD,PhD.

Effect of PCI on 1-year risk of all-cause mortality and major cardiovascular outcomes. CABG, coronary artery bypass grafting; CI, confidence interval (bars);

HOSPITAL READMISSION REDUCTION’S IMPACT ON ASSISTED LIVING

Defining operative mortality: Impact on outcome reporting

Kaplan-Meier curves: revascularisation rate (PCI or CABG) was significantly higher (p

Long-Term Survival After Coronary Arterial Grafts in Patients With End-Stage Renal Disease Taro Nakatsu, MD, Nobushige Tamura, MD, PhD, Yutaka Sakakibara,

Kaplan-Meier estimate of mortality in 1798 propensity score matched pairs with a propensity score >0.5 for the whole observational period. Kaplan-Meier.

Improved outcomes in coronary artery bypass grafting with beating-heart techniques Michael Mack, MD, Donna Bachand, RN, PhD, Tea Acuff, MD, James Edgerton,

(A) Multivariable Cox regressions showing the association of higher CHA2DS2-Vasc scores (≥6) and (B) R2CHA2DS2-Vasc scores (≥7) with 1-year mortality (CABG,

Cox regression of proportion mortality in the first 8 years for patients with three-vessel disease with a significant difference between the treatment.

Glenn N. Levine et al. JACC 2011;58:e44-e122

Leslee J. Shaw et al. JIMG 2010;3:

Effect of PCI on 3 to 5-year risk of all-cause mortality and major cardiovascular outcomes. CABG, coronary artery bypass grafting; CI, confidence interval.

Result of coronary angiogram among patients with and without diabetes admitted with first-time acute coronary syndrome (a significant stenosis was defined.

Expanding Access to Cardiac Rehab

Kaplan-Meier estimate of mortality in the two treatment strategies with significant difference between the two groups (log-rank test

Impact of Cardiothoracic Resident Turnover on Mortality After Cardiac Surgery: A Dynamic Human Factor Jeffrey H. Shuhaiber, MD, Kimberley Goldsmith,

The Assault on Specialty Medicine and the Modern Surgeon

Presentation transcript:

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives Moreover, Hospitals have RIs to obtain a (+) report cards “ Ranked among the top 10 hospitals in New York State for cardiac surgery and cardiac catheterization programs” (CMS discourages hospital from using its data for advertisement; and avoids ranking hospitals) http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.worldclassmedicine.com/images/heart/main_image.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.worldclassmedicine.com/homepage_heart.cfm%3Fid%3D21&usg=__aaZsK6rltIX6fx3iMcQ29-GaU8Y=&h=249&w=286&sz=15&hl=en&start=8&tbnid=y1zmptwLLVTdpM:&tbnh=100&tbnw=115&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dtop%2Bcardiac%2Bsurgeon%2Bnew%2Byork%2Brated%26gbv%3D2%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Dactive (accessed 11/25/08).

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives Disruptive Innovation & Physicians Market impact of a (-) report card is more clear cut http://www.hikingupward.com/OVH/SkyMeadows/images/122907/PC290099.jpg

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives NYS cardiac surgery registry 5% of surgeons with the lowest operative mortality exited the market 20% of surgeons with the highest operative mortality exited the market 2/3 of surgeons admitted to “cherry picking” patients Ashish K. Jha and Arnold M. Epstein. The predictive accuracy of the New York State coronary artery bypass surgery report-card system. 25 Health Aff 844, 844–55 (2006);

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives Objective evidence of cherry picking: Statistically significant reduction in the number of redo-CABGs being performed TR McLean, In New York State, do more percutaneous coronary interventions mean fewer or more complex referrals to cardiac surgeons? 6(1) Am Heart Hospital J 30, 30-36 (2008).

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives Just like hospitals, Physicians make use of (+) report cards “Dr. Ty Goletz is a top-rated orthopedic surgeon who has received numerous awards and accolades throughout the United States, including being chosen as one of San Antonio’s Top Doctors, and a Texas Super Doctor by Texas Monthly Magazine.” http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.drgoletz.com/images/goletz.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.drgoletz.com/about_goletz.html&usg=__Yggms_l5A8A2rDRBtqgrSiUKZZw=&h=285&w=244&sz=17&hl=en&start=3&tbnid=HyvJGfl4k_29tM:&tbnh=115&tbnw=98&prev=/images%3Fq%3D%2522surgeon%2522%2B%2522top%2Brated%2522%26gbv%3D2%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Dactive (accessed 11/15/08)

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives All I ever needed to know about report cards, I learned in 3rd grade: They change behavior The Key question is how is the government going to use (capitalize) on this information? McLean TR: Will reputational incentives stimulate a reversal of the physician brain drain?. J Health Serv Res Policy 2008; 13:50-52; Werner RM and Asch DA: The Unintended Consequences of Publicly Reporting Quality Information. JAMA 2005; 293:1239-1244

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives Answer: Two new CMS initiatives: Hospital Quality Initiative (HQI) Physician Quality Reporting Initiative (PQRI) Image URL on request

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives Common to both HQI & PQRI are paradigm shifts: Accountability shifts from structure (e.g. JC accreditation) to outcomes (e.g. SSI) Benchmarking for provider comparison Brett Elliott: Pay for Performance and the Hospital Quality Initiative. Del Med Jrl 2005, 77(8):288-96.

Report Cards & Reputational Incentives HQI MMA § 501b; Pub L 108-173 (117 Stat. 2066) But, CMS lacks statutory authority to collect provider specific data. “Voluntary” performance measurement reporting began 2004 Brett Elliott: Pay for Performance and the Hospital Quality Initiative. Del Med Jrl 2005, 77(8):288-96.