Debris Discs in Binaries

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Resonant Structures due to Planets Mark Wyatt UK Astronomy Technology Centre Royal Observatory Edinburgh.
Advertisements

Dust Growth in Transitional Disks Paola Pinilla PhD student Heidelberg University ZAH/ITA 1st ITA-MPIA/Heidelberg-IPAG Colloquium "Signs of planetary formation.
Planetary Migration and Extrasolar Planets in the 2:1 Mean-Motion Resonance (short review) Renate Zechner im Rahmen des Astrodynamischen Seminars basierend.
Signatures of Planets in Debris Disks A. Moro-Martin 1,2,3, S. Wolf 2, R. Malhotra 4 & G. Rieke 1 1. Steward Observatory (University of Arizona); 2. MPIA.
Unt4: asteroid part 2. Comets Comet Ikeya-Seki in the dawn sky in 1965.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris Disks Stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) ( 1) Observatorio Nacional.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris disks stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) (1) Observatorio Nacional.
INTRODUCTION Dust is usually observed in the  m to mm range. In many discs, simple estimations show that this dust cannot be primordial and has to produced.
A numerical check of the Collisional Resurfacing scenario Philippe Thébault & Alain Doressoundiram Observatoire de Meudon.
Dust Dynamics in Debris Gaseous Disks Taku Takeuchi (Kobe Univ., Japan) 1.Dynamics of Dust - gas drag - radiation 2. Estimate of Gas Mass 3. Dust Disk.
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
High-resolution Imaging of Debris Disks Jane Greaves St Andrews University, Scotland.
Image: ISAS/JAXA Christopher Stark University of Maryland NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Collisional Grooming: Including Collisions in (Prohibitively.
SN 1987A the excitement continues Bruno Leibundgut ESO.
1 Why exoplanets have so high eccentricities - By Line Drube - November 2004.
Spitzer Space Telescope Observations of the Fomalhaut Debris Disk Michael Werner, Karl Stapelfeldt, Chas Beichman (JPL); Kate Su, George Rieke, John Stansberry,
Origin of the Solar System
The formation of stars and planets
Sculpting Circumstellar Disks Feb 2008 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
Debris disc modelling Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory/Stockholm Observatory.
2006 SQ 372 : A Planetary Interloper from the Inner Oort Cloud N. Kaib, A. Becker, L. Jones University of Washington.
« Debris » discs A crash course in numerical methods Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory/Stockholm Observatory.
Susan CartwrightOur Evolving Universe1 Galaxy evolution n Why do galaxies come in such a wide variety of shapes and sizes? n How are they formed? n How.
Planetesimal Accretion in Binary Systems Philippe Thébault Stockholm/Paris Observatory(ies) Marzari, Scholl,2000, ApJ Thébault, Marzari, Scholl, 2002,
Zodiacal Cloud: The Local Circumstellar Disk Sumita Jayaraman.
A new class of warm debris disks? Rachel Smith, Institute for Astronomy; Mark Wyatt, Abstract.
Chapter 19 Star Formation (Birth) Chapter 20 Stellar Evolution (Life) Chapter 21 Stellar Explosions (Death) Few issues in astronomy are more basic than.
Decoding Dusty Debris Disks AAAS, Februrary 2014 David J Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.
Chaotic Case Studies: Sensitive dependence on initial conditions in star/planet formation Fred C. Adams Physics Department University of Michigan With:
Molecular Hydrogen Emission from Protoplanetary Disks Hideko Nomura (Kobe Univ.), Tom Millar (UMIST) Modeling the structure, chemistry and appearance of.
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
Planets in Debris Disks Renu Malhotra University of Arizona Planet-Debris co-evolution Where can debris exist? Cases: Solar system, upsilon Andromedae,
Infrared Signatures of Planetary Systems Amaya Moro-Martin Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University.
Modeling Planetary Systems Around Sun-like Stars Paper: Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems: Cold Outer Disks Associated with Sun-like Stars,
Disk Instability Models: What Works and What Does Not Work Disk Instability Models: What Works and What Does Not Work The Formation of Planetary Systems.
HERschel Observations of Edge-on Spirals (HEROES) Joris Verstappen (UGent) for the HEROES team (UGent, Cardiff University, INAF-Arcetri, KU Leuven, VUB,
October 20, 2005 Nearly Resolved Debris Disks STScI, Baltimore Hervé Beust Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Grenoble, France FOST group The origin of the.
Alice Quillen University of Rochester Department of Physics and Astronomy Oct, 2005 Submillimet er imaging by Greaves and collaborato rs.
ALMA Observations of proto-planetary disks I HD – P.I. Casassus 2013 Nature 493, 191 Herbig Ae star 140 pc, 2 Myr, 1.9 M , disk mass 0.1 M  Left:
The PSI Planet-building Code: Multi-zone, Multi-use S. J. Weidenschilling PSI Retreat August 20, 2007.
The AU Mic Debris Ring Density profiles & Dust Dynamics J.-C. Augereau & H. Beust Grenoble Observatory (LAOG)
Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory Planet formation in binaries.
Are transition discs much commoner in M stars? Recent claim that 50% of discs around M stars are in transition (Sicilia-Aguilar et al 2008) CAREFUL! For.
Using the Inner Oort Cloud to Explore the History of the Earth and Sun Nathan Kaib Advisor: Tom Quinn Collaborators: Andrew Becker, Lynne Jones University.
Processes in Protoplanetary Disks Phil Armitage Colorado.
Millimeter Observations of the  Pic and AU Mic Debris Disks David J. Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle S.Andrews,
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?  Pic, A5V star AU Mic, M1Ve star.
Pinpointing Planets in Circumstellar Disks Mar 2009 Alice Quillen University of Rochester.
Collision Enhancement due to Planetesimal Binary Formation Planetesimal Binary Formation Junko Kominami Jun Makino (Earth-Life-Science Institute, Tokyo.
Theoretical difficulties with standard models Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge.
Kate Su, George Rieke, Karl Misselt, John Stansberry, Amaya Moro-Martin, David Trilling… etc. (U. of A) Karl Stapelfeldt, Michael Werner (NASA JPL) Mark.
The prolate shape of the Galactic halo Amina Helmi Kapteyn Astronomical Institute.
Philippe Thébault Planet formation in binaries. Planet formation in binaries why bother? a majority of solar-type stars in multiple systems >90 detected.
Circumstellar Disks at 5-20 Myr: Observations of the Sco-Cen OB Association Marty Bitner.
© 2017 Pearson Education, Inc.
Extended debris discs around nearby, Sun-like stars as a probe of disc-planet interactions Astronomical Society of Australia ASM 5th July 2016 Dr. Jonty.
Young planetary systems
Gas! Very few debris disks have detected gas, and it is generally only found around the youngest systems. So why should we consider gas here?
Dynamical trapping (pile-up) of grains near the sublimation radius
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?
What (exo)-planetary science can be done with microlensing?
Planetesimal formation in self-gravitating accretion discs
Who was here? How can you tell? This is called indirect evidence!
The scenario for the formation of galaxies is very reminiscent of the formation process for solar systems. Giant cloud of gas and dust, shrinks under its.
Debris disks Basic properties Observational methods & constraints
Planets in binaries Sergei popov.
The Planet Forming Region Around a Young Star
The scenario for the formation of galaxies is very reminiscent of the formation process for solar systems. Giant cloud of gas and dust, shrinks under its.
Resonance Capture generalization to non-adiabatic regime
Presentation transcript:

Debris Discs in Binaries Numerical modelling Philippe Thébault Thebault, Marzari & Augereau, 2010, A&A Thebault, P., 2011 (submitted)

Debris Discs in binaries why bother? a majority of stars in multiple systems >80 detected exoplanets in binaries Planet formation in binaries is a very fashionable topic right now debris discs are the most easily observable components of an extrasolar planetary system

They rather look like this They rarely look like this Imaged debris discs show pronounced structures They rather look like this They rarely look like this ”something” is shaping them: planets? ...or planets? ...or maybe planets? What about a companion star?

imaged discs in binaries HD141569 (Krist et al.) HR4796A (Schneider et al.)

In principle, it’s simple: (Holman&Wiegert, 1999) acrit …N-body code but... steady collisional production of small grains placed on high-e orbits by radiation pressure reaching far beyond rcrit need to model the coupled dynamical & collisional evolution of the disc (Krivov, 2010)

a new code to study the collisional and dynamical evolution of perturbed discs at steady state Set up Parent Body Ring  = 10-3 (~ Pic)

3 steps 1) Parent Body run: for =0 particles, until dynamical steady state is reached. Save10 PB disc profiles for 10 ≠ positions of the companion on its orbit separated by dtsav=torb/10 2) Collisional Runs: From each of the10 PB discs, 105 small grains are released following dN s-3.5ds. They are assigned a collision destruction probability as a function of size and location. All particle positions are recorded at each dtsav. Runs are stopped when all particles have been removed by ejection or collisions 3) Recombining: Use all collisional runs to reconstruct the dust distribution, at steady state, for each orbital position of the perturber.

Azimuthally averaged radial profiles Always small grains in the ”forbidden” region. Amount of matter beyond rcrit increases with increasing eB. Only very diffuse discs can present sharp outer edges. unstable region (Thebault et al. 2010)

Spatial Structures: density maps at steady state acrit eB=0.2 precessing spirals for half the orbit eB=0 precessing spiral structures eB=0.75 Invariant asymmetric disc eB=0.5 spiral at periastron passages (Thebault, 2011)

Radial cuts Azimuthal cuts eB=0 eB=0.2 eB=0.75

Depletion of small >0.15 grains Size distribution within < rcrit Depletion of small >0.15 grains

Synthetic SEDs

(not) fitting the HR4796A disc Observational constraints on the companion: eB>0.45 in order to truncate a PB disc at 70AU r>510AU

SUMMARY New model to study the combined effects of Dynamical Perturbations, Collisions and Radiation Pressure in collisionally active perturbed debris discs A binary can never fully truncate a debris disc: Circumprimary discs extend far outside the limit for orbital stability Small grains are underabundant within the orbital stability limit Discs can appear colder than what they should Depending on eB, precessing, transient (spirals) or fixed asymmetries can develop in the dynamically “forbidden” regions