New Sources of Capital from Target Date Funds

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Michelle McGregor Smith CEO British Airways Pension Investment Management Limited Challenges in Pension Asset Liability Management.
Advertisements

Longevity Planning in Retirement Plans March 23,
CHAPTER 4: INVESTMENT COMPANIES.  Definition: financial intermediaries that collect funds from individual investors and invest those funds in a potentially.
New Sources of Capital from Target Date Funds October 16, 2012 National Association of Real Estate Investment Managers Moderator: Lennine Occhino Mayer.
Alternative Investments “Outlook for the Investment Management Industry” San Antonio October 17, 2007 Bank Depository User Group Meeting.
Essentials of Investments © 2001 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Fourth Edition Irwin / McGraw-Hill Bodie Kane Marcus 1 Chapters 4.
MODULE 14. REAL ESTATE SYNDICATION What is a Syndication? w Organizational Form of Ownership w Types of Syndicate Offerings w Reasons for Syndication.
© 2008 Thomson South-Western CHAPTER 13 INVESTING IN MUTUAL FUNDS.
By Michael Lawrance, CPA August 13,  The views in this presentation do not necessarily reflect that of KPMG LLP or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates.
June 1, 2010 Commercial Real Estate Fundamentals.
© 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or in part.
Mutual Fund Operations
Topic 5 Function, Purpose and Regulations of Financial Institutions.
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT FUNDS AND ERISA Marcia S. Wagner, Esq.
Investing in a low yield world David Irwin. 2 CTRL+ALT+DELETE.
Exploring Complementary Investment Opportunities: Real Estate Investment Trusts 1.
Investment Companies  What are they?  Financial intermediaries that invest the funds of individual investors in securities or other assets.
CHAPTER 20 Investment Companies. Copyright© 2003 John Wiley and Sons, Inc. Investment Funds Purchase direct, long term, capital market securities and.
New Ideas About the Distribution Phase Integrating Retirement Income & DC Plan Design Institutional Investor Institute Corporate Funds Roundtable March.
© 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved McGraw-Hill/Irwin Slide 1 CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUSTS (REITS)
Savings & Investment Vehicles Mike Meade. Saving vs. Investing Saving o Putting money away for safe-keeping o Emergency funds o Zero risk Investing o.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin©2007, The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved Essentials of Accounting for Governmental and Not-for-Profit Organizations Chapter.
Marcia S. Wagner, Esq. ERISA LANDSCAPE – PLAN SPONSOR ISSUES CARING FOR PARTICIPANTS.
Portfolio Management Unit – II Session No. 16 Topic: Managing Portfolios by Insurance Industry Unit – II Session No. 16 Topic: Managing Portfolios by Insurance.
Chapter 11 Stockholders’ Equity Using Financial Accounting Information: The Alternative to Debits and Credits, 6th by Gary A. Porter and Curtis L. Norton.
Unitized Managed Portfolios unitZXchange™ brings you.
Essentials of Accounting for Governmental and Not-for-Profit Organizations Chapter 7 Fiduciary Funds McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2008 by The McGraw-Hill.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin ©2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, All Rights Reserved Chapter Fourteen Investment Banking, Insurance, and Other Sources of Fee Income.
ESOPs: It’s More Than a Matter of Trust Presented by: Dan Reser President; Fiduciary Services, Inc
Qualified Plan Investments Chapter 11 Employee Benefit & Retirement Planning Copyright 2009, The National Underwriter Company1 Fiduciary Requirements of.
Financial Markets & Institutions
CITY OF DALLAS INVESTMENT POLICY ANNUAL REVIEW
Thinking Outside the Box: Is It Dangerous for You and Your Plan? Discussion Leader: Marcia S. Wagner The Wagner Law Group Defined Contribution Summit November.
TARGET-DATE FUNDS - A FIDUCIARY PERSPECTIVE Presented by: Jeff Hale, AIFA® Senior Consultant Pentegra Retirement Services June, 2011.
In-Plan Retirement Income Solutions: Offering a Defined Benefit solution in your 401(k) Plan Moderator: Rick Unser, AIF, QPFC, CRPS, Lockton Investment.
Stock Terminology (continued) Investors make money in stocks in two ways: –Dividends Companies may make payment to shareholders as part of the profits.
Non-Bank Financial Institutions Finance Companies, Insurance Companies, Pension Funds, Mutual Funds, and Real Estate Investment Trusts Chapter 5 Dr. BALAMURUGAN.
1 Copyright © 2001 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin CHAPTER 5 PRIMARY FORMS OF REAL ESTATE OWNERSHIP Sole Proprietorships.
Investors and the Investment Process Bodie, Kane and Marcus Essentials of Investments 9 th Global Edition 22.
DC Plan Investment Menu Best Practices Date Copyright T. Rowe Price. All rights reserved.
Treasury Market Risk Management. Treasury Management Treasury management is a broader concept than liquidity management Management of cash flows in terms.
Chapter Fourteen Investment Banking, Insurance, and Other Sources of Fee Income.
ESOP Repurchase Liability Management Solutions. The subject matter in this communication is provided with the understanding that The Principal® is not.
Mutual funds (see Ch. 16 Hirschey and Nofsinger)
1818 Society Annual Meeting Pension Plan Performance October 11, 2006
CIFs, Model Portfolios and 404a-5
WOMEN & INVESTMENT Sabah Almoayyed.
Annual Investment Report Presentation to City Council
The Fundamentals of Investing
Cleary / Jones Investments: Analysis and Management
Chapter 3 Jones, Investments: Analysis and Management
Investments.
Commercial Bank Operations
Be Your Own Bank: Leveraging Your Retirement Funds in Real Estate
The Fundamentals of Investing
Investors and the Investment Process
Resource Credit Income Fund
Risk Disclosures. Resource Real Estate Diversified Income Fund Access to Truly Diversified Real Estate Opportunities.
22 Investors and the Investment Process Bodie, Kane, and Marcus
Facing Retirement Risks
Qualified Retirement Plan Design For the Closely Held Company
Re-writing the rules on retirement plan investing
Tax-Exempt Insurance An opportunity for strategic diversification and distribution of your business and investment assets.
22 Investors and the Investment Process Bodie, Kane, and Marcus
Resource Credit Income Fund
Managing Defined Contribution Investments for Retirement Income
The Fundamentals of Investing
Investing in Mutual Funds, Exchange traded funds, and Real Estate
Financial Service Solutions
For broker and sponsor use only in the Emerging Markets Division.
Presentation transcript:

New Sources of Capital from Target Date Funds Steven Chudnow Prudential Real Estate Investors Steven Kapiloff UBS Realty Investors John Noell Mayer Brown Lennine Occhino October 17, 2012 National Association of Real Estate Investment Managers

What is a defined contribution (“DC”) plan? Participants fund contributions Risks of investment return on participants Participants direct investment of their own accounts

DC Terminology 401(k) – Internal Revenue Code § 401(k) 404(c) – Internal Revenue Code § 404(c) CIT – bank collective investment trust DB – defined benefit DC – defined contribution ISA – insurance company separate account QDIA – qualified default investment alternative RIC – registered investment company

Pension Trends and Drivers DB plans maturing and cash flow increasingly negative DB underfunding Disincentives to funding Investment losses Maturing participant population Accounting rule changes requiring pension liabilities to be reflected on corporate balance sheet

DB  DC Migration of Pension Assets DOL statistics indicate that between 1978 - 1997: Total private pension assets grew from $377 billion to $3.5 trillion The percentage attributable to DC plan assets increased from 27% to 51% Investment Company Institute: DC assets grew 6,100 percent over a ten-year period

2006 Pension Protection Act 2006 change in law to facilitate auto enrollment of employees in DC plan Established new fiduciary safe harbor for “QDIAs” as 401(k) default option QDIAs must be appropriately diversified (typically target date, balanced or lifestyle funds) QDIA managers include: External management firms Internal management professionals

Projected Growth of Target Date Funds in DC Plans Investment Company Institute: By the end of 2015, 35% of all DC assets in a target date type product Cerulli Associates: Target date funds in DC plans will grow from $426 billion in 2011 to $1.5 trillion in 2015 Casey, Quirk & Associates: Target date funds will swell to $2.6 trillion by 2018 from $311 billion in 2008

DC Real Estate Opportunity Through target date strategy, DC portfolios aligning with DB portfolios Callan Associates 2009 survey: 73% of target date fund managers had a dedicated real estate allocation PIMCO 2009 Defined Contribution Trends Survey: U.S. consulting firms promoting diversification and inflation hedging in DC plans Casey, Quirk DC plan sponsors concerned that current target date asset classes insufficient to address longevity, market volatility and inflation risks

DC Investor Categories Plan participant On behalf of 401(k) account Internally-managed portfolio On behalf of plan Externally-managed portfolio Externally-managed fund RIC CIT ISA Private DC fund of funds

Traditional DC Investment Vehicles Bank CITs JPMorgan Insurance company separate accounts Principal Life TIAA Public REITs Registered investment companies Limited to liquid assets

New Twist on DC Investment Vehicles DC Friendly Fund Investors RICs REITs CITs ISAs Externally-managed plan accounts Internally-managed plan accounts DC fund of funds GP Manager (RIA) Features Open-end Daily valuation Daily liquidity for participants Quarterly liquidity for plan LP Core funds Liquidity Cash Credit line Public REIT stocks Specialty funds Direct real estate

New Twist on DC Investment Vehicles DC Eligible Fund Investors CITs ISAs Externally-managed plan accounts Internally-managed plan accounts Participants Bank Trustee or Insurance Co Manager (RIA) Features Open-end Daily valuation Daily liquidity for participants Daily liquidity for plans CIT or ISA Core funds Liquidity Cash Credit line Public REIT stocks Specialty funds Direct real estate

New Twist on DC Investment Vehicles Parallel DC Friendly/DC Eligible GP Manager (RIA) Bank Trustee LP CIT Liquidity Cash Credit line Public REIT stocks Core funds Specialty funds Direct real estate

Limited Partnership Bank CIT Insurance Co. Separate Account Unlisted REIT Tax Status Partnership/flow-through 501(a) tax exempt bad income blocker Annuity converts bad income REIT ERISA Status ERISA plan assets Not ERISA plan assets Securities Law Exceptions Reg D under ‘33 Act 3(c)(7) ‘40 Act 3(a)(2) ‘33 Act 3(c)(11) ‘40 Act ‘33 Act/‘34 Act registered Falls outside definition Registration/Approvals None Must be approved by state insurance regulator Registered Investor Eligibility Externally-managed plan portfolios Internally-managed plan portfolios RIC CIT ISA DC fund of funds Plan participants Externally-managed portfolios Internally-managed portfolios Other Considerations Unit not transferrable – only redemption permitted Bank trustee must maintain overall investment control SEC focus on abuse Very inexpensive and easy to establish OCC mandates redemption payout within one year Investors hold annuity contract rather than direct fund interest Insurance company remains as intermediary with investors No parallel vehicles for other investor categories No “investor control” Expenses high due to registration Ongoing public reporting

DC Investment Issues Liquidity Daily pricing Plan participant driven – daily Event driven – reasonable accommodation RIFs Corporate transactions Plan design changes Plan fiduciary driven – quarterly Investment option changes Daily pricing

What to ask a Real Estate Manager Liquidity Management Managing cash flows and liquidity needs of TDF Managers and Plan Sponsors Plan TDF 15% to 40% of Plan Assets Real Estate 5% to 15% Allocation Private Direct Property 60-100% Cash/REITs 0-40% Credit Line 5-15% Factors to Consider TDF Cash Flow Rebalance methodology Events that may trigger a material change in cash flows; i.e., reenrollment, new participant enrollment, plan design changes What to ask a Real Estate Manager Are there liquidity queues to get in and/or out of private real estate? Does the manager deploy a multi- fund approach or single strategy? Utilize line of credit or back stop to guarantee liquidity

Liquidity Versus Optimal Allocations Liquidity Range 100% Publically Traded REITs 0% Private Direct Property Cash/REITs 20-40% Direct Private Property 60-80% Optimal allocation to produce desired outcome in TDF Trade off between liquidity and optimal allocation What is the real liquidity risk?

Daily Valuation: “30,000 Foot View” Record keeper determines NAV C-TDF DC RE Fund Overall Fund NAV determined by custodian NAV determined by RE Manager and/or 3rd Party NAV determined by fund(s) Private Real Estate Fund(s): 60-100% Liquidity Components: 0-40% (REITs and/or cash) +

Valuation Methodologies Range of Approaches Valued In-house Partially outsourced to 3rd Parties Valued by 3rd Parties Individual property appraisals Appraiser review process at Fund level Intra-quarter changes; capital deployed, extra-ordinary revenue/ expenses Net operating income and changes thereto Transparency Integrity of the internal model Frequency of change Conflicts of interest Organizational confidence in change notification process Materiality levels Frequency of change Strength of market database Organizational confidence in change notification process Access to accounting records of manager

DC Sponsor Considerations Liability for plan participant investment decisions 404(c) QDIA Participant education Fees/costs New participant-level disclosures of fees and expenses DOL, Congressional focus on excessive DC costs Zero UBTI tolerance Recordkeepers must add fund to platform DC Real Estate Council