‘It's raining cats and dogs’

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 12: Is There a God?.
Advertisements

Philosophy and the proof of God's existence
Introduction to A2 Philosophy Homework: Background reading – ‘Questions about God.’ – Chapter 4 – God and Language, by Patrick J. Clarke.
Religious Language Speaking about God Part 1. Why Religious language? The concept of a God is: Something other Something timeless We talk of things using.
The Cosmological and Teleological Arguments ARGUMENTS FOR THE EXISTENCE OF GOD.
OCR training programme Get Ahead - improving delivery and assessment of Units G581: Analogy Question.
Religious Language Symbol and analogy.
The Cosmological Argument (Causation or ‘first cause’ theory)
LO: I will know about Wittgenstein’s views on religious language Hmk: Prepare for tracker assessed presentations Due next Wednesday 1 st There won’t be.
LO: I will know how thinkers have solved the problem of speaking meaningfully about God by making negative statements of what God is not.
St. Thomas AquinasSt. Thomas Aquinas  CE  Naples, Italy  Benedictine then Dominican monk  Primary Works:  Summa contra Gentiles  Summa.
The Design or Teleological Argument for the Existence of God.
Lesson Objective: Lesson Outcomes: Lesson Objective: Lesson Outcomes: Mr M Banner 2016 Grade 12 th May 2016 Starter: What does Cosmology mean to you? Title:
The Cosmological Argument
The Cosmological Argument for God’s Existence
Religious Studies Part 1 : Download a Specification A Level
The design argument.
Switch on 2 learning Get Creative Starter Challenge:
The Teleological Argument
Religious Language.
Religious responses to the verification principle
Pioneers of Critical Thinking (Socrates, Plato Aristotle) / Thomas Aquinas and Critical Thinking Objectives: To trace the intellectual legacy of the pioneers.
The Cosmological Argument
Religious Language.
Think, pair, share A: Privation B: The Fall of Man A:Seminally B: Free will.
Rapid Recall! Fill in the table with what you remember from memory! Prizes for the first correctly filled in one! 1) What are William James’ four qualities.
Reading material Articles: Tillich on symbols & Aquinas on analogy questions 1. What is art? 2. Does it open up new levels of reality for you? 3. Does.
Recap task Think of fifteen key terms associated with analogy Choose nine and add to the bingo grid Play bingo.
What was AJ Ayer’s book called?
Starter Activity Rejecting the use of univocal language
Recap: William Paley Qua Regularity Socrates Classical Philosophy
Using Analogy to Understand God
RECAP Odd one out Match them up 1. Hare 4. Hick 7. Flew 2. Swinburne
How do the pictures link to last lesson?
A: What would Anselm say. B: What would Gaunilo say
The Via Negativa Starter: What is it?
The analogy of the Arrow
Think pair share What type of argument is the cosmological argument?
Is Religion Reasonable?
The Anthropic Principle
What is the difference between a sign and a symbol?
Which is the odd one out?.
What does it mean to be eternal?
In pairs, attempt to describe an object in the room by saying what it is not…. It is not red…..
RELIGIOUS LANGUAGE.
How did we prove that the world was not flat?
What did I google to find this picture?
What are the four causes of the Universe?
2) Who said ‘you can’t cross the same river twice?’
The Cosmological argument
Describe this object: Does it help describe it further by saying it exists?
2) Who said ‘Ex nihilo, nihil fit’?
Teleological Argument
What is the difference between a cabbage and a machine?
OCR training programme Get Ahead - improving delivery and assessment of Units G581: Analogy Question.
Is the jigsaw task a fair analogy?
Rapid Recall! Fill in the table with what you remember from memory! Prizes for the first correctly filled in one! 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6)
What makes these things different?
‘A triangle has three sides’
RECAP Odd one out Match them up 1. Hare 3. Hick 5. Flew 2. Swinburne
Omnipotent Deity Atheist Agnostic Omnibenevolent Polytheist Analogy
Think, pair, Share The paradox of the stone Can God make a stone that is too heavy for him to lift? Discuss in pairs.
Do these phrases describe: Meta or Normative ethics?
Revision Beliefs about God
Science can offer us explanations of things that are within the universe, but does the universe as a whole have an explanation? Think, pair, share.
By the end of today’s lesson you will
Religious Language.
Recap task Think of fifteen key terms associated with analogy Choose nine and add to the bingo grid Play bingo.
Explore the key ideas of the cosmological argument. (8 marks)
The Teleological Argument
Presentation transcript:

‘It's raining cats and dogs’ Analogy: useful? ‘It's raining cats and dogs’

Analogy

Learning outcomes To be able to explain why analogies are important in the topic of religious language. To be able to evaluate the ideas of Aquinas on analogies.

Aquinas: Why Analogy? A famous analogy is William Paley’s watchmaker analogy (we studied this last year). He explains the teleology (purpose) of the universe by comparing its design to an intricate mechanism. So, he argued, God is a bit like a watchmaker. For Aquinas, such comparisons were needed for all talk of God. Thomas Aquinas was concerned by the problem of explaining God in human language; God is supposedly perfect and infinite, so he might defy description. Aquinas stated that we could not speak of God ‘univocally’ (with our language being applied to him with the same meaning), but nor could we speak of him ‘equivocally’ (with our language being applied with a different meaning). This left Aquinas needing to find a way of using language as an indirect description of God. For this he turned to ‘analogy’. An analogy is an attempt to explain the meaning of something by comparison with an example more familiar to us.

Language meaning exactly the same thing in all situations. UNIVOCAL LANGUAGE Language meaning exactly the same thing in all situations. EQUIVOCAL LANGUAGE Language meaning different things in different situations. The term ‘bat’ could also be seen as an equivocal term. You could be talking about a ‘cricket bat’ or a ‘flying bat’ (the animal). Problem: If we say that ‘God is good’ means something completely different from any other ‘good’ then God would be unintelligible (we couldn’t understand him). So, Aquinas argues, we cannot speak of God equivocally. Black cat, black hat, black mat: for all these, ‘black’ means the same thing. Problem: If we say ‘that lesson was good’ then ‘good’ means something different from saying ‘God is good’, since God is perfect and infinite. So, Aquinas argues, we cannot speak of God univocally.

Aquinas thought that analogy would be a good compromise, because it would avoid the difficulties of univocal and equivocal language. To make an analogy (a comparison), we would be saying that God is not just like us, but nor is he nothing like us and our world. By finding appropriate analogical language, Aquinas thought we could say broadly what God is like. This would give us partial but justifiable knowledge of God. To understand this theory, though, we must realise that it works within theism. In other words, Aquinas assumes that God exists; his theory is only helpful if we take that for granted.

The cataphatic way or via positiva Read through the article on Aquinas’ views on talking about God… Answer this question in your notes: Does Aquinas follow the via negativa or the via postivia? Top Philosopher: What are, the modern philosopher, Mark Vernon’s views on the via negativa? Stretch yourself: Have you explained the term via eminentiae?

Think, Pair, Share A: Univocal language B: Equivocal language A: Analogy B: What does Aquinas say about religious language?

In depth: Aquinas and Analogy Search around the room to complete the worksheet! What else does he say? Top Philosopher: What does are the modern philosopher Mark Vernon’s views on the via negativa? Stretch yourself: Research Aquinas’ 4th way…

Analogy: In your words What is analogy of attribution? What is Analogy of Proportionality? What is the difference between the two? 4) Explain two criticisms of Aquinas’ view. Top philosopher task: What synoptic links could you make with Aquinas’ ideas? Stretch yourself: Write a response to Aquinas’ ideas from point of view of Anthony Flew.

Fourth Way - The Argument From Degrees And Perfection St. Thomas formulated this Way from a very interesting observation about the qualities of things. For example one may say that of two marble sculptures one is more beautiful than the other. So for these two objects, one has a greater degree of beauty than the next. This is referred to as degrees or gradation of a quality. From this fact Aquinas concluded that for any given quality (e.g. goodness, beauty, knowledge) there must be a perfect standard by which all such qualities are measured. These perfections are contained in God.

How many can you think of? You must remember to explain the meanings. Keywords! How many can you think of? You must remember to explain the meanings.

Ramsey, models and qualifiers A twentieth-century version of the idea of speaking of God analogically comes from the philosopher Ian Ramsey, who explained his ideas in his book Religious Language. He tried to explain the way in which religious language could usefully describe God by using the terms ‘models’ and ‘qualifiers’. What does Ramsey mean by the terms models and qualifiers? Write an explanation for he means in your notes… e.g. Models: Qualifiers: