What are reporting guidelines The EQUATOR Network workshop

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Research article structure: Where can reporting guidelines help? Iveta Simera The EQUATOR Network workshop.
Advertisements

Critical Reading VTS 22/04/09. “How to Read a Paper”. Series of articles by Trisha Greenhalgh - published in the BMJ - also available as a book from BMJ.
Doug Altman Centre for Statistics in Medicine, Oxford, UK
Reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses: PRISMA
3. STARE-HI - Guidelines for authors of IT evaluation studies a) Why STARE-HI (Jan Talmon) b) STARE-HI: Guidelines for authors.
Critical Appraisal Dr Samira Alsenany Dr SA 2012 Dr Samira alsenany.
Statistical Editor, Health & Social Care in the Community
Identifying evidence for decision-analytic models Suzy Paisley DoH Research Scientist in Evidence Synthesis Consensus Working Group on the Use of Evidence.
HOW TO ACCESS EBSCO DATABASES “FREE TRIAL” 1. VISIT LIBRARY WEBSITE: library.uplb.edu.ph/ 2. AT THE LIBRARY HOMEPAGE, PRESS – Journal Subscriptions – UNDER.
STrengthening the Reporting of OBservational Studies in Epidemiology
HRB Centre for Primary Care Research Department of General Practice RCSI Medical School Developing an International Register of CPRs for Primary Care:
The EQUATOR Network Library for Health Research Reporting Iveta Simera The EQUATOR Network workshop 10 October 2012, Freiburg, Germany.
CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE
How your submission will be evaluated by European Urology reviewers: Reviewer template and Publication guidelines Jim Catto Associate Editor European Urology.
Introduction to MAST Kristian Kidholm Odense University Hospital, Denmark.
Transparent and accurate reporting increases reliability, utility and impact of your research: Reporting guidelines and the EQUATOR Network Iveta Simera.
CONSORT: Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials Evidence-based, minimum set of recommendations for reporting clinical trials Rennie (JAMA) urged the.
Plymouth Health Community NICE Guidance Implementation Group Workshop Two: Debriding agents and specialist wound care clinics. Pressure ulcer risk assessment.
2nd Concertation Meeting Brussels, September 8, 2011 Reinhard Prior, Scientific Coordinator, HIM Evidence in telemedicine: a literature review.
Systematic Approaches to Literature Reviewing Dr Tamara O’Connor Student Learning Development
Trusted evidence. Informed decisions. Better health. Cochrane_QuickRefBooklet.indd 114/8/15 5:41 pm.
Implementing a new drug or technique (APA Cambridge 21. June 2013) Tom G. Hansen, MD, PhD, Department of Anaesthesia & Intensive Care Odense University.
Research article structure: Where can reporting guidelines help? Iveta Simera The EQUATOR Network workshop 10 October 2012, Freiburg, Germany.
Introducing… …..from the BMJ Evidence Centre. BestPractice is a new concept for health information delivered at the point-of-care Diagnosis PrognosisTreatmentPrevention.
LITERATURE REVIEW ARCHELLE JANE C. CALLEJO, PTRP,MSPH.
John N. Lavis, MD, PhD Professor and Canada Research Chair in Knowledge Transfer and Exchange McMaster University Program in Policy Decision-Making McMaster.
From the initial page of the Cochrane Library, we have clicked on the Cochrane Reviews: By Topic hyperlink. This has displayed the Topics for Cochrane.
Evidence Based Practice (EBP) Riphah College of Rehabilitation Sciences(RCRS) Riphah International University Islamabad.
CONSORT 2010 Balakrishnan S, Pondicherry Institute of Medical Sciences.
Evidence-Based Public Health Practice: Using Research and Data to Improve Your Programs Week 2, Part 1: Step 3 of 6--Use the research literature to guide.
Lisa Hussey Associate Publisher, Clinical Medicine 4 th March 2016 Born open access – a new approach to publishing and science.
Evaluation Requirements for MSP and Characteristics of Designs to Estimate Impacts with Confidence Ellen Bobronnikov March 23, 2011.
Academic Writing Skills
Reporting guidelines: current status
ACOEM Council on Education and Academic Affairs
Interprofessional Online Learning for Primary Health Care:
Society for Yoga Research — Health Research Reporting Guidelines —
The DELTA2 Study: Summary of Methodology and Results
How to read a paper D. Singh-Ranger.
How to write a project plan Ove Karlsson
Planning your Dissertation
Supplementary Table 1. PRISMA checklist
Key guidelines for reporting health research studies
Scientific journal editor core competencies
STROBE Statement revision
Critical Reading of Clinical Study Results
Alison Day Lead Librarian Grand Round
Investigation of the shortcomings of the CONSORT 2010 statement for the reporting of group sequential randomised controlled trials Munya Dimairo Acknowledgements.
Uses of STROBE in real life Questionnaire results
Touring the World of Evidence
Second Edition Chapter 3 Critically reviewing the literature
Janna Friedly M.D. Assistant Professor University of Washington
Measuring Data Quality and Compilation of Metadata
Using The Troy Library for Academic Research
An activity-based journal club to help staff & students improve confidence at reading scientific papers Cornwall Health Library: Katy Oak Catriona Organ.
Correspondence: Standards for Reporting of Digital Health Education Intervention Trials (STEDI) statement: an extension of the CONSORT.
Journal evaluation and selection journal
Research & scholarship
Dr. Maryam Tajvar Department of Health Management and Economics
Writing a literature review
(HINARI) PubMed Conduct systematic reviews of the literature
Critically reviewing the literature
PRISMA flow diagram for peer-reviewed literature search and included studies. PRISMA flow diagram for peer-reviewed literature search and included studies.
STROBE Statement revision
Main recommendations & conclusions (1)
Table of Contents – Part B
PHARM Library Orientation
MANUSCRIPT WRITING TIPS, TRICKS, & INFORMATION Madison Hedrick, MA
ISSUES RELATED TO PUBLICATION OF health system-based investigations
Critically reviewing the literature
Presentation transcript:

What are reporting guidelines The EQUATOR Network workshop Iveta Simera The EQUATOR Network workshop 7 September 2013, Chicago, USA I

Reporting guidelines (RGs) Focus on scientific content of the article Definition: Specify a minimum set of items required for a clear and transparent account of what was done and what was found in a research study, reflecting in particular issues that might introduce bias into the research Form: structured advice, often as a checklist (perhaps also a flow diagram) Most internationally accepted RGs Based on evidence Consensus of relevant stakeholders (multidisciplinary group) Moher et al. PLoS Med 2010

“Hierarchy” of reporting guidelines Recommendations RGs Broad GENERIC Narrow SPECIFIC

“Hierarchy” of reporting guidelines Recommendations RGs Frequency of RGs Broad GENERIC Few RGs Narrow SPECIFIC Many RGs

Different focus of RG (1) STUDY DESIGN / METHODOLOGY Generally applicable, key methodology features, no details specific to diseases, etc. Generic framework for reporting key aspects of: Main study designs / types (generic guidelines) More specialised designs Specific methods, evaluations, analyses Core RG (“Must”) Generally applicable, key methodology features, no details specific to diseases, etc. Generic framework for reporting key aspects of: Main study designs / types (generic guidelines) Framework for a complete research paper (examples: CONSORT, STARD, STROBE) Framework for only a part of research study / paper (examples: CONSORT for abstracts) More specialised designs Often extending the generic guidelines Examples: CONSORT for cluster trials Specific methods, evaluations, analyses Generic statistical guidelines Cost-effectiveness analysis Quality of life assessment

Examples: main study design

Examples: specialised design

Examples: methods

Different focus of RG (2) SPECIFIC DISCIPLINE / CLINICAL AREA Different ‘degree’ of specificity May or may not address general methodology items May focus on a complete research study / paper or only on a part Should be used with relevant generic methodology guidelines as they often focus only on content specifics Key focus is on discipline / clinical area specific issues Different ‘degree’ of specificity May or may not address general methodology items May focus on a complete research study / paper or only on a part Examples RCTs in leukaemia; longitudinal studies in rheumatology Economic evaluations in obstetrics

Examples

Examples

EQUATOR website

Library for health research reporting

Reporting guidelines database Browse – 3 options Search – free text RG catalogue

For more visit: www.equator-network.org