Intervention evidence gathering Julie Arnot ScotPHN Researcher

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Pan London Developments: Working with the Voluntary Sector Nicky Hill, Senior Programme Manager Lisa Bellis, Senior Programme Manager Safer London Foundation.

Advertisements

Improving outcomes for young people Jamie Callaghan & Fiona Muir Community Justice.

Fife Domestic & Sexual Abuse Partnership Strategy Sheila Noble.

Community Safety In Scotland September 2014

ACPOS Scottish Policing Assessment Setting the Strategy Research and Risk Assessment.

© Donald Findlater Where’s child sexual abuse gone? Have we fixed it?

Alcohol in Scotland a public health perspective Dr Lesley Graham Public Health Lead, Information Services Division, National Services Scotland Alcohol.

SAFER CITIES MODEL. SAFER CITIES TOOLS SAFER CITIES TRAINING MANUAL AND TOOLKIT Overall development objective is to facilitate effective strategy development.

Violence prevention – a public health priority Philip Conaglen Annette Gallimore ScotPHN is hosted by.

Community Safety Programme Board Priorities Stuart Priestley – Chief Community Safety Officer.

Children’s Wellbeing Stakeholder Event Thursday 14 th May 2015 ‘Shaping local priorities and supporting a responsive market’

A Mental Health Strategy for Scotland Emma Lyon Mental Health Improvement Programme Officer NHS Health Scotland.

Persistent Offender Project Persistent Offender Project Joint Partnership between Glasgow Addiction Service & Strathclyde Police Funded by Glasgow Community.

Needs Assessment: Young People’s Drug and Alcohol Services in Edinburgh City EADP Children, Young People and Families Network Event 7 th March 2012 Joanne.

Building Safer Communities National Community Safety Convention Lewis Ramsay Assistant Chief Officer Prevention & Protection Scottish Fire and Rescue Service.

Hazel Simmonds Assistant Director Safer Neighbourhoods COMMUNITY SAFETY BOARD 21 st February 2008.

Calderdale Safer & Stronger Communities Partnership Strategic Assessment Review June 2009 Calderdale. A great place to be safe.

Service Delivery to Vulnerable Groups Cape Town March 2009.

NHS Health Scotland – improving health and reducing health inequalities Wilma Reid Head of Learning & Workforce Development.

PoPP Edinburgh (Psychology of Parenting Project) Pat Southall EVOC Children, Young People and Families Network 3 September 2015.

Safer Communities Developing Local Plans, Joint Plans & the Connection to Safer and Stronger Local Scrutiny/Local Plans and Community Safety Cheryl Smith.

1 The Prevention, Treatment and Management of Conduct Problems in Childhood David M Fergusson Christchurch Health & Development Study Department of Psychological.

What’s the Harm? Self Harm Awareness & Skills Allison Murray Glasgow (South) Community Health Partnership.

Prevention of intimate partner and sexual violence against women Prof Rachel Jewkes Director, Gender & Health Research Unit, Medical Research Council,

Safe Newcastle Strategy Cllr Tony Rounthwaite.

Pathways to Recovery. About Us KIKIT Pathways to Recovery is a culturally specific service but not culturally exclusive. Most of Our Team are from the.

HASGA Tuesday 24 th November Strategy: No Need to Exclude ….work towards the position where the needs of all young people are addressed, and where.

Adult and Child Protection arrangements in Edinburgh Presentation to EVOC 2015 Kate Fennell, Adult Protection Lead Officer Sean Byrne, Child Protection.

Collaborative Effort of HIV, Domestic Violence and Homeless Service Organizations to Develop Integrated Services as Strategy for HIV Risk Reduction for.

… because safeguarding children is everyone’s responsibility Enfield Safeguarding Children Board (ESCB) Annual Report 2014/15 Geraldine Gavin – ESCB Independent.

“Integration & adult protection” 19 th November 2014 Wendy Harrington Social Work Scotland.

Hampshire Futures Safeguarding Update July 2017.

Child Sexual Exploitation & Modern Slavery

Rape and Sexual Violence Strategic Governance Group Standards

Surveillance of NCDs: Instruments and Data Sources

ESOL Family Learning Workshop

Youth Violence.

Communities Partnership

No More Suicide in Bolton How Can you make a difference

Introduction to Child Sexual Exploitation

SocialLink Emily Mason 19 October 2017

The Albert Kennedy Trust – No young person should have to

A UK perspective: Prevention of violence against Women and girls

OPEN presentation, October 2017 Dr Gemma McKibbin & Dr Nick Halfpenny

An understanding of complex anti-social behaviour cases, including cases presented at partner risk assessment conference (ASBRAC) Best use of community.

Kent Internet Risk Assessment Tool (KIRAT)

Violence against women and girls (VAWG) in East LOTHIAN strive - enterprising third sector conference, 7 November 2017 Veronica Campanile, VAWG Strategy.

Bullying including cyberbullying Female Genital Mutilation (FGM)

Youth Justice: Advancing the Whole System Approach

NHS Education for Scotland Always Event Project

Public Health Research Programme

A Violence Prevention Strategy for Scotland

Nottingham city dsl network October

Safeguarding: Security making people and places safer

Realising the Rights of Indigenous Children

Update from the Boards and Community Safety Partnership

Presented by David Erfani Project Officer

Blood borne viral hepatitis action in Wales

1. Reduce harms from the main preventable causes of poor health

National Child Sexual Exploitation Work Group Implementing the national plan… Moira McKinnon Chair National Work Group 2019.

National Child Sexual Exploitation and Trafficking Workshop – Intelligence Led Investigations I will come back to the scenario towards the end of this.

January 2019 ROSC Seminar.

IMPROVING SCOTLAND’S HEALTH Rights, Respect and Recovery

Hampshire Futures Safeguarding Update July 2017.

Shared Learning Workshops

Tackling the wider determinants of health: Health Improvement Domain

Neighbourhood Watch Engagement Event 11 February 2013

Domestic Abuse.

Getting Knowledge into Action for Healthcare Quality

Presentation transcript:

Intervention evidence gathering Julie Arnot ScotPHN Researcher

‘Evidence’ Extensive international evidence base (journal articles, reviews) - for some forms of violence prevention, less so for others Heavy focus on U.S. based interventions: Findings transferable to Scottish / U.K. context? Interventions might report positive changes in self-reported behaviour in the short-term: Do they always translate into longer-term violence prevention?

Scottish evidence Who is delivering interventions, where, to whom? Disparate range of orgs Local & national level, various sectors Breadth of violence types Limited articles / reports Pockets of published evidence: GBV on H.E. campuses, Medics Against Violence, Community Initiative to Reduce Violence, Mentors in Violence, sex work, gang violence……..

ScotPHN evidence gathering in lieu of ‘evidence’ ScotPHN identified c.60 Scottish interventions 2014* Update: developed short online q/naire Nov 2017 For completion / dissemination by: Strategy group of public sector partners 3rd sector (GBV/DV) / 3rd sector membership orgs Scottish Directors of Public Health Scottish Health Promotion Managers Community Planning Partnerships Several safety / violence related networks / partnerships. *See: Philip Conaglen & Annette Gallimore (2014) Violence prevention: a public health priority. https://www.scotphn.net/projects/violence-prevention-2/violence-prevention/

Q’s & Response Questionnaire asked: Primary, secondary, tertiary prevention? Targeting what & who? Setting? Evaluated? Response rate? Unknown no. received questionnaire 73 responses, overlap 2014, local offshoots of national programmes Good spread of interventions: Domestic abuse, sexual violence, non-sexual violence Scotland, Glasgow, Inverclyde, Renfrewshire, Edinburgh, S Lanarkshire, Highland Home / doorstep, schools, street, city centre Representative spread of organisations? Who’s missing? Growing bank of ‘evidence’ about interventions with brief info / contacts

Combine 2014 & 2017: c.100+ interventions (defunct?), 67+ evaluated: Gender based violence: 24 Domestic abuse: 23 Youths: 18, Gangs: 3 School based: 17 NTE / alcohol licensing / town centre / festive: 12 Ex-offenders / offenders: 13 Child abuse / corporal punishment: 6 Hate crime: 5 Anti-social behaviour: 4 Robberies / serious crime: 4 Alcohol / drugs: 4 Sex work: 3 Suicide / self-harm: 3 Knife violence: 2 Trafficking: 1 At risk adults: 2 MAPPA Unit: 1 FGM / Honor based violence: 1 Doorstep crime: 1 Oral / Maxillofacial: 1 Assault injury surveillance: 1 Social Norms: 1 H.E. medical/ dental student training: 1

How many interventions aimed at primary prevention? Crude estimate: 85 Q: quick, brief info on intervention, contact details: http://surveys.healthscotland.com/index.php/184454/lang-en Thank you (your time is appreciated).

Workshop 1 Discussion topic: What actions in your area of work are currently, successfully preventing or reducing violence? Setting? Targeting what & who? Impact? Can it be extended to other locales / domains? 40 mins. table discussion 20 mins. in plenary for each table to briefly summarise discussions.