Debunking and Responding to Science Denial

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Citizen response to attacks on science education Josh Rosenau National Center for Science Education or… Help, there’s science denial in my schools!
Advertisements

Science and Creationism 23. Education © Colin Frayn,
What Do You Think about Your Future? Plan of Our Lesson 1.Warming up (revision words, answering the questions) 2. Reading different opinions about future.
By: Sarah Sproul and Alex Waggoner SCIENCE AND REALISM.
Unit 2: The God Question. Meeting the Living God by William J. O’Malley, S.J. The Second Question: Does God Exist? The Great Debate God vs. Science by.
Research 7.3 (D) Relate the impact of research on scientific thought and society, including the history of science and contributions of scientists as.
Christianity: Use of Human Embryos Religious Viewpoint 1 LI: I have learned about Christian views on use of human embryos. I have evaluated Christian views.
Evolution and Natural Selection. Here’s Hank! C_M C_M.
The Great DebateThe Great Debate  CREATION  EVOLUTION.
The Importance of Teaching Evolution in Public Schools By: Angie Bicher.
Global Warming: What are the Questions?. Question 1: There is scientific evidence to show that the Earth’s surface temperature is increasing. Other evidence.
Pure Science vs. Applied Science
Relationship between Science and Religion. Conflict Model Science and Religion are ‘at war’ – they have different methods of examining the same evidence,
Nicholas Copernicus & Galileo Galilei
Everyday Practice of Science Where Intuition and Passion Meet Objectivity and Logic By Frederick Grinnell.
Teaching Evolution Across the Curriculum Irene Anne Eckstrand, National Institutes of Health Ida Chow, Society for Developmental Biology.
Creation / Evolution Debate Workshop #3 Beyond the Terms.
Science, Society, and You
1 Level 1 Biology: Chapter 1 Science as a Way of Learning: A Guide to the Natural World.
Teaching and Communicating Controversial Topics in Science: Ongoing Challenges & Opportunities THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES National Academy of Sciences National.
Assessment.  Introduction… “Billions of people around the world are religious, following faiths such as Islam, Christianity and Buddhism…” “Why is it.
Mark McCaffrey & Josh Rosenau Programs and Policy Directors NCSE’s New Climate Change Education Initiative.
Principles of Media Advocacy Barbara Martin February 20, 2008 February 20,
Saving the Best for Last Addressing Subjects of Public Controversy by Answering Questions First and Placing Conclusions in Scientific Context Mike Phillips.
The Nature of Science Section 1.2 Pages
 It helps you understand what life has evolved into over the years.  Provides a foundation for modern biology  Explains the diversity of all the life.
By: Deanna Jones.  The discovery of evolution is one of the most powerful scientific achievements of all time.  Evolution explains why Earth is so diverse.
The Role of Journalism in Scientific Research
© Colin Frayn, Learning leads to Atheism Learning leads to knowledge If kids have been brainwashed and isolated –This can be a traumatic.
On Eschewing a Policy-Prescriptive Role for Science in Environmental Controversies Johnny Lin Physics Department North Park University Chicago, Ill.
CHECK YOUR CLICKERS. About Clickers You may discuss all of your answers with your neighbors before you enter your answer into the clicker program. You.
Coalition of Scientific Societies Evolution in Science Education Survey Highlights Developed by Jennifer A. Hobin, Ph.D. FASEB Office of Public Affairs.
EVOLUTIONARY THEORY AS A TEACHING TOOL IN UNDERGRADUATE SCIENCE COURSES FOR ELEMENTARY EDUCATION MAJORS: SCIENTIFIC INQUIRY VERSUS INTELLIGNET DESIGN “THEORY”
Biology Spring Semester Review Evolution Natural Selection FossilsBiodiversity Ecology Q $100 Q $200 Q $300 Q $400 Q $500 Q $100 Q $200 Q $300 Q $400.
 Express ideas about a difficult topic  Convince audience members your opinion is correct  Practice research skills  Build communication skills.
Michigan Employability Skills Teamwork Skills are needed to be successful in the jobs these days.
Chapter 1 What is Biology? 1.1 Science and the Natural World.
Challenges of Teaching Evolution Rachel Fisher June 19, 2014.
Why is Evolution Important? Lydia A. & Daniela H. Block 2 Unit 7 Project.
An Introduction to Scientific Ocean Drilling and the JOIDES Resolution.
Philosophy and God. Theism – the assertion that there is a God theos = God (Greek) –Implications: o Life here on earth has an eternal dimension. o Purpose.
© 2006 David A. DeWitt 6/9/2016 Comparison of Worldview Learning Outcomes in DLP vs. Residential Creation Course David A. DeWitt Center for Creation Studies.
God and Science A study of the compatibility between the bible and science “We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth, and.
LESSON 1: PowerPoint slides to accompany Using Bioinformatics: Genetic Testing.
Media attention does not just happen Prepare for your 15 seconds of fame! Fred Balvert & Souad Zgaoui Erasmus MC, Communications Dept. Erice International.
Evolution and Biodiversity Chapter 4. Core Case Study: Life on Earth Uniquely suited for life –Temperature range –Liquid water –Gravitational mass –Oxygen.
What is Physical Science?
On a new page, leave the top two lines blank and…
Comparing the Opinions of the Science Community and the General Public in Ireland An Amárach Briefing to Science Foundation Ireland November 2017.
Theory of Knowledge Review
On a new page, leave the top two lines blank and…
History of Vaccine Research
Mixed Messages: Climate change in America’s classrooms
1.1- Introduction to Engineering
BIOENGINEER ADRIENNE R. MINERICK, PhD
What is Scientific Argumentation?
The Nature of Science Ms. Gravette.
OES Science Fair January 24
WHAT IS MODERN BIOLOGY?.
Introduction to Engineering
Nature V. Nurture.
Pellagra 7th Grade Science.
Department of Earth and Biological Sciences
Views on scientists’ role in shaping policy vary based on the issue
Key Ideas How do scientists explore the world?
The Nature of Science Section 1.1.
Evolution Change Over Time.
Chapter 21 the Enlightenment and Revolutions
3 main categories that ask questions about different kinds of systems.
Creation Theories Focus.
Presentation transcript:

Debunking and Responding to Science Denial Josh Rosenau National Center for Science Education rosenau@ncse.com @JoshRosenau

ALCOHOL HOMOSEX GENETIC ENGINEERING MOM/CHILD LIB HARD ROCK TERRORISM

Education doesn’t matter alone > Education doesn’t matter

Audience Research Selected Findings Strongest messages in both rounds of research Invoke the role of evolution in making advances in medicine and curing diseases The compatibility of religious faith and acceptance of evolution One’s personal religious viewpoints should not be imposed on public school students A key framing point Science class should help students to understand how science works and how scientists do their jobs. Evolution is a core scientific principle that is foundational to many areas of science and helps scientists make technological developments, like curing disease. Courtesy of Jay Labov, National Academy of Sciences

Make political controversy political Separate science and nonscience Make political controversy political Make religious controversy religious

Don’t be afraid of emotion

Opinions don’t differ on the shape of the Earth.

Shift to a real scientific debate (Were dinosaurs warm-blooded, not evolution vs. creationism)

Science is a process http://understandingscience.org