Functionalism Eliminativism Prop Dualism MBIT Sub Dualism Behaviourism

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Cognitive Computing 2012 The computer and the mind DUALISM Professor Mark Bishop.
Advertisements

Frank Jackson: What Mary Didn't Know
Michael Lacewing Is the mind the brain? Michael Lacewing © Michael Lacewing.
Section 2.4 There Ain’t No Such Things as Ghosts Mind as Myth.
Philosophy 4610 Philosophy of Mind Week 7: Eliminative Materialism and Review.
Cognitive Computing 2012 The computer and the mind 6. IDENTITY THEORY Professor Mark Bishop.
20 th Century Views on Mind and Body Logical Behaviorism (Gilbert Ryle): “mind” refers simply to a way of speaking about behaviors ( ) Mind-Brain.
Mind, Body and Philosophy
Property dualism and mental causation Michael Lacewing
The Mind-Body Problem. Some Theories of Mind Dualism –Substance Dualism: mind and body are differerent substances. Mind is unextended and not subject.
The Mind-Brain Type Identity Theory
Logical behaviourism: objections
© Michael Lacewing Functionalism and the Mind- Body Problem Michael Lacewing
Michael Lacewing Logical behaviourism Michael Lacewing
Philosophy of Mind Week 3: Objections to Dualism Logical Behaviorism
Substance dualism and mental causation Michael Lacewing
Dualism: epiphenomenalism
This week’s aims: To set clear expectations regarding homework, organisation, etc. To re-introduce the debate concerning the mind-body problem To analyse.
Learning objective: To understand the threat of solipsism for substance dualists; To evaluate whether substance dualism can solve the ‘problem of other.
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 14 Minds and Bodies #3 (Jackson) By David Kelsey.
Eliminativism Philosophy of Mind Lecture 5 (Knowledge and Reality)
Learning objective: To understand what is meant by epiphenomenalism and issues with it. epiphenomenalist dualism Causal redundancy.
PHL 203 Theories of Reality Lecture for January 11 & 13, 2011 Prof. Borrowdale.
Eliminativism Philosophy of Mind. Today’s lecture plan: The ‘theory-theory’ of common sense psychology A Choice: Vindication or elimination (Isomorphic.
Philosophy of Mind Panpsychism: All is mind/conscousness.
Property dualism Key Words Learning objective:
Philosophy of Mind materialism.
Eliminative materialism
Descartes’ divisibility argument
Thought experiment Consider whether the person next to you might be a philosophical zombie. 1.List the evidence you have for thinking they have a mind.
Learning objective: To understand what Ryle thinks is a ‘category mistake’ To understand how he defends logical behaviourism.
DUALISM: CAUSAL INTERACTIONISM Philosophy of Mind.
Criticisms of Dualism. Descartes argument for dualism I can clearly and distinctly conceive of the mind without the body and the body without the mind.
The zombie argument: objections Michael Lacewing
Substance and Property Dualism Quick task: Fill in the gaps activity Quick task: Fill in the gaps activity ?v=sT41wRA67PA.
This week’s aims: To set two SMART targets based on formal assessment feedback and progress so far To understand basic ideas concerning each key theory.
This week’s aims  To test your understanding of substance dualism through an initial assessment task  To explain and analyse the philosophical zombies.
Mind body problem What is the relationship between mental states and the physical world? Zoltán Dienes, Philosophy of Psychology René Descartes ( )
Recap on your whiteboards
Philosophy of Mind Lecture II: Mind&behavior. Behaviorism
Philosophical behaviourism: two objections
Ryle’s philosophical behaviourism
Substance and Property Dualism
What is eliminative materialism?
The Mind-Body Problem.
ATS2840 Philosophy of Mind Semester 1, 2017
The Search for Ultimate Reality and the Mind/Body Problem
Property dualism: objections
The zombie argument: responses
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 14 Minds and Bodies #3 (Jackson)
What is the relationship between body and soul.
What does it mean to say mental states are reducible
Unscramble The Words What are these key terms from the current theory we’re looking at? Finicalmounts Callaroues Ipunt Optutu Relegatedgunkmown Nupmat.
Whiteboards! Briefly outline the theories of occasionalism and pre-established harmony. What is the key difference between the two? Identify one key issue.
Mind-Brain Type Identity Theory
Recap Questions What is interactionism?
PHL 203 Theories of Reality
Analytically or Ontologically Reducible?
Essay Writing – What makes a good philosophy essay?
Connection between body + mind
What keywords have we used so far
On your whiteboards: Summarise Mary’s Room / The Knowledge argument include the terms Qualia, Information and Physicalism in your answer. Make sure you.
The Mind Body Problem Our minds seem to be non-physical and different from our bodies. Our bodies seem to be something different from our minds. Are they.
True or False: Materialism and physicalism mean the same thing.
Functionalism Eliminativism Prop Dualism MBIT Sub Dualism Behaviourism
What is good / bad about this answer?
Recap: What were the issues and responses?
On your whiteboard: What is hard behaviourism? What are its strengths?
Which of these things are defined functionally? What function?
Recap: What is multiple realisability? Why is it an issue for MBTIT?
Presentation transcript:

Functionalism Eliminativism Prop Dualism MBIT Sub Dualism Behaviourism What did Ryle mean by a ‘disposition’? [3 marks] Briefly explain what Ryle means by a ‘category mistake’. [5 marks] Briefly explain why the conceivability of a mental state without behaviour is a problem for logical behaviourism. [5 marks] Outline the problem of circularity for Logical Behaviourism. [5 marks] Outline some of the advantages of Logical Behaviourism [12 marks] Assess the claim the mental states can be reduced to behaviour. [25 marks] What is meant by describing a mental state as having a ’causal role’? [3 marks] Briefly explain the inverted qualia argument against Functionalism. [5 marks] Briefly explain the Chinese Mind argument against Functionalism. [5 marks] Briefly explain one advantage Functionalism has over MiBIT [5] Compare and contrast Functionalism with MBTIT. [12 marks] Compare and contrast Functionalism with Substance Dualism. [12 marks] Explain how functionalism is a reductive account of the mind. [12] Outline the reasons why some philosophers reject a Functionalist account of pain. [12] Assess the claim that mental states can be reduced to their functional roles. [25 marks] What is meant by ‘folk psychology’? [3 marks] Why do eliminativist materialists claim that folk psychology is an empirical theory? [3 marks] Briefly explain why eliminativists prefer to eliminate mental descriptions rather than reduce them to physical descriptions. [5 marks] Briefly explain why eliminativists are critical of ‘folk psychology’. [5 marks] Outline some of the reasons why some philosophers object to the eliminativist position. [12 marks] Outline some of the reasons Churchland gives for eliminating ‘folk psychology’ [12 marks] Assess the claim that we should eliminate all talk of the mental and replace it with statements about the mind. [25 marks] Briefly explain the difference between an ontological and an analytical reduction. [5 marks] Outline one advantage of MBIT over other theories of mind [5 marks] Briefly explain the location problem [5 marks] What is meant by the term ‘multiple realisability?’ [5 marks] Outline some of the advantages MBTIT has over other physicalist theories [12 marks] Are brain states ontologically reducible to brain states? [25 marks] Assess the claim that reductive accounts of the mind in the end always fail [25 marks] What are qualia? [3 marks] What does ‘irreducible’ mean? [3 marks] What is meant by ‘interactionist property dualism’? [3 marks] What is meant by ‘epiphenomenalism’ [3] Briefly explain what it is for mental properties to be ‘emergent’ [5 marks] Briefly explain what is meant by describing mental properties as ‘irreducible’ [5 marks] Outline Frank Jackson’s ‘What Mary Never Knew’ thought experiment [12 marks] Outline the ‘Philosophical Zombie’ argument for property dualism [12 marks] Outline reasons why some philosophers do not accept Jackson’s Knowledge Argument [12 marks] Outline reasons why some philosophers do not agree that philosophical zombies prove property dualism [12 marks] Assess property dualism. [25] Assess the claim that non- reductive accounts of the mind fail to explain mental causation. [25] What is Leibniz’s Law? [3 marks] Briefly explain Descartes’ conceivability argument [5] Briefly explain Descartes’ indivisibility argument [5 marks] What are the similarities and differences between interactionist dualism and epiphenomenalist dualism? [12 marks] Outline some responses to the problem of other minds. [12 marks]