With Some Reflections on Practical Implications

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Poverty Traps, Resilience and Resource Dynamics Among the Extreme Rural Poor Chris Barrett Cornell University Seminar at James Cook University (Townsville,
Advertisements

Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University Seminar to Harvard University Sustainability Science Program October 24, 2012 Resilience Against Chronic Poverty:
Christopher B. Barrett and Mark A. Constas Cornell University Presentation at the International Food Policy Research Institute August 2, 2013 Toward A.
1 Risk and Asset Management in the Presence of Poverty Traps: Implications for Growth and Social Protection Christopher B. BarrettMichael R. Carter Cornell.
Poverty Traps, Safety Nets and Sustainability Chris Barrett Robin Hill Seminar Cornell University April 28, 2005.
Christopher B. Barrett and Michael R. Carter Seminar at University of California at Riverside May 24, 2012 T HE E CONOMICS OF P OVERTY T RAPS AND P ERSISTENT.
Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University James Cook University SIS group meeting July 8, 2013 Chronic Rural Poverty and Resilience: Some Reflections and.
Why IBLI? On Poverty Traps, Catastrophic Risk and Index Insurance Christopher B. Barrett Index Based Livestock Insurance Mini Workshop International Livestock.
Christopher B. Barrett and Mark A. Constas Cornell University December 11, 2012 presentation at CARE USA’s Washington, DC, Roundtable on Resilience Resilience.
LRAP: Lessons for the Region Scott Drimie. Introduction Deriving lessons from LRAP for the region: An example of “good practice” Engages vulnerability.
RURAL MARKETS, NATURAL CAPITAL AND DYNAMIC POVERTY TRAPS IN EAST AFRICA Discussion of Prototype CLASSES* Model Presently Under Development: A Work in Progress.
Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University May 22, 2013 remarks at panel discussion on Risk & Vulnerability Monash Centre for Development Economics Resilience.
Finding Meaning in Our Measures: Overcoming Challenges to Quantitative Food Security USDA Economic Research Service February 9, 2015 Food Security As Resilience:
Screen 1 of 16 Vulnerability What is Vulnerability? LEARNING OBJECTIVES Understand the concept of vulnerability. Appreciate the difference between vulnerability.
Adapting Index-based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) for Ethiopia: Logic and Design Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University Workshop at International Livestock.
May 5Advanced Institute on Vulnerability Vulnerability of coupled human-environment systems Jill Jäger Co-Director, Advanced Institute on Vulnerability.
Improving targeting and delivery Group 4: Making Social Protection Work for Pro-Poor Disaster Risk Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation.
Defining Vulnerability, resilience, risk Presentation outline Dr. Arjumand Nizami Photo: Intercooperation Pakistan by Tahir Saleem.
Logo Add Your Company Slogan Vulnerability (W. Neil Adger, 2006) Fanlin Meng Oct 7, 2013 Resilience Adaptation.
On Climate Variability And Resource- Dependent Wealth Dynamics: The Case of Ethiopian Pastoralists Paulo Santos University of Sydney Christopher B. Barrett.
THE LINKS BETWEEN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL POLICIES JOSÉ ANTONIO OCAMPO UNDER-SECRETARY GENERAL ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS.
Food Security As Resilience: Reconciling Definition and Measurement
Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University Monash University Workshop on “Ecologists and Economists: scope for collaboration?” March 13, 2013 Chronic Rural.
Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University Lecture at the University of Notre Dame September 8, 2015 Development Resilience: Theory, Measurement & Implications.
Dynamic Effects of Index Based Livestock Insurance on Household Intertemporal Behavior and Welfare Munenobu Ikegami, Christopher B. Barrett, and Sommarat.
Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University Presentation at the National Socio-Environmental Synthesis Center (SESYNC), Annapolis, Maryland March 24, 2015.
Poverty Traps, Resilience and Coupled Human-Natural Systems Chris Barrett, Cornell University May 20, th Annual Conference on Economics and Catholic.
Weather index insurance, climate variability and change and adoption of improved production technology among smallholder farmers in Ghana Francis Hypolite.
How Shocking! The Challenges of Shocks, Variability, and Resilience in Evaluating Impact in Adaptation Projects Marc D Shapiro, Ph.D. Project Leader, Global.
Access to Health Services OIYP Kaleidoscope Workshop October 2007.
Traditional Knowledge
Article by Caroline Moser
DISASTER VULNERABILITY, RISK AND CAPACITY
CaLP Asia Cash Transfer Programming and Persons of Concern Workshop
Resilience Concepts and Measurement Workshop
Microfinance and small holder farmers productivity
Measuring development process resilience: A test from northern Kenya
Classification of Research
Comments: Emergent Properties of Human-Environment Systems
Group 1 Issues of highest importance Foci for discussion/action
Resilience Concepts and Measurement Workshop
Evaluating Community Change
ALTER WP1 IMPACT PATHWAYS
MOIS 508 Spring 2006 Dr. Dina Rateb
Hazards Planning and Risk Management Risk Analysis and Assessment
EXECUTIVE – LEGISLATIVE AGENDA FORMULATION
Analyzing Reliability and Validity in Outcomes Assessment Part 1
Measuring Estimating Resilience
Engaging and Empowering People and Communities
Session Situation Analysis Step 5 Chronic & Transitory Food Insecurity
Poverty Traps, Resilience and Coupled Human-Natural Systems
Fostering Dialogue to Support Community Resilience
Chris Barrett presentation, 6 Oct 2014
Building Changes’ Strategic Business Planning Process
Anchoring Growth and Employment:
The Development Resilience Approach
Human Capabilities and Poverty Dynamics in the Face of Agro-Ecological Shocks Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University USAID/NBER event on “Resilience.
Societal resilience analysis
Considerations in Development of the SBSTA Five Year Programme of Work on Adaptation Thank Mr. Chairman. Canada appreciates this opportunity to share.
Foundation module 3 Programme design.
CONVERGENCE AND CONSENSUS ON A HRBA TO DEVELOPMENT
Human Capabilities and Poverty Dynamics in the Face of Agro-Ecological Shocks Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University World Bank seminar “Resilience.
The Compelling Case for Integrated Community Care: Setting the Scene
Analyzing Reliability and Validity in Outcomes Assessment
Poverty Traps, Safety Nets and Sustainability
Michael R. Carter University of Wisconsin Christopher B. Barrett
Christopher B. Barrett, Cornell University
Community mobilisation
Disaster Preparedness and Resilience
Caroline Burnley, Ph.D. Director, Resilience Research Lab
Presentation transcript:

With Some Reflections on Practical Implications Toward A Theory of Resilience for International Development Applications: With Some Reflections on Practical Implications Christopher B. Barrett Cornell University Presentation at the International Livestock Research Institute July 4, 2014

Motivation “Resilience” has rapidly become a ubiquitous buzzword, but ill-defined concept within the development and humanitarian communities

Motivation Why development and humanitarian communities’ current fascination with “resilience”? Risk perceived increasing in both frequency and intensity Recurring crises lay bare the longstanding difficulty of reconciling humanitarian response to disasters with longer-term development efforts. Increasingly recognize interdependence of biophysical and socioeconomic systems. Tap ecological work on resilience. But we lack a theory-measurement-and-evidence-based understanding of what resilience is with respect to poverty and hunger, how to measure it, and how to effectively promote it so as to sustainably reduce chronic poverty/food insecurity.

Motivation At the same time, much ambivalence (even cynicism) about the ‘rise of resilience’ Seen as too imprecise and malleable a concept/term Not pro-poor as commonly formulated Often ignores issues of agency/power/rights Barrett & Constas (in review) advances a simple theory of resilience with the objective of sharpening thinking, facilitating theory-based, precise measurement and evaluation, and anchoring resilience in broader efforts to reduce poverty and food insecurity.

Resilience: Need to Adapt Close parallels to multiple other literatures : System-focused About the capacity to absorb, and adapt to, disturbances/ shocks w/o changing state But must adapt concept to be useful for development: We care about individual well-being — the system has instrumental rather than intrinsic importance Must be pro-poor, and hence explicitly normative Stability not always good; may instead seek productive disruption Need to adapt ecological resilience lit using existing tools of development studies/economics concerning the stochastic dynamics of individual and collective human well-being.

Toward a Theory Resilience of whom to what? Subject of interest: quality of life, ~ Sen’s ‘capabilities’. Focus further on minimizing the human experience of chronic poverty. This implies: focus on individuals’ (and groups’) well-being within a system, not the state of a system itself. consider the stochastic dynamics of well-being do not focus on specific sources of risk b/c problem is uninsured exposure to many stressors (ex ante risk) and shocks (ex post, adverse realizations) to which resilience implies adaptability while staying/becoming non-poor.

Toward a Theory Concept of Resilience for Development Development resilience is the capacity over time of a person, household or other aggregate unit to avoid poverty in the face of various stressors and in the wake of myriad shocks. If and only if that capacity is and remains high, then the unit is resilient. Key Elements: focus on stochastic dynamics of (aggregable) individual standards of living Normative implication: prioritize avoidance of and escape from chronic poverty and minimize within the population and over time the experience of low standards of living.

Toward a Theory Stochastic Well-Being Dynamics Consider the moment function for conditional well-being: mk(Wt+s | Wt, εt) where mk represents the kth moment (e.g., mean (k=1), variance (k =2) or skewness (k =3) Wt is well-being at time t εt is an exogenous disturbance (scalar or vector) at time t These moment functions describe quite generally, albeit in reduced form, the stochastic conditional dynamics of well-being.

Toward a Theory Ex: Nonlinear expected well-being dynamics with multiple stable states (m1(Wt+s | Wt, εt) ) Noncontroversially: NPZ >> CPZ >> HEZ Those ∈{CPZ,HEZ} are chronically poor in expectation(m1(W|Wt, εt)<p) The CEF reflects indiv/collective behaviors (agency/power) w/n system

Toward a Theory The development ambition is to move people into the non-poor zone and keep them there. The humanitarian ambition is to keep people from falling into HEZ … offers foundation of a rights-based approach to resilience. For the current non-poor, seek resilience/resistance against shocks in the ecological sense: no shift to either of the lower, less desirable zones. But for the current poor, those in HEZ/CPZ, the objective is productive disruption, to shift states to the NPZ. Asymmetry is therefore a fundamental property of resilience against chronic poverty. Thus stability ≠ resilience.

Toward a Theory Explicitly incorporate risk by integrating broader set of moment functions to move from CEF to CTDs: Note: Transitory shocks (- or +) can have persistent effects Risk endogenous to system state CTDs reflect both natural and socioeconomic contexts

Programming implications Objective: minimize the duration, intensity and likelihood of people’s experience of poverty Three options: Shift people’s current state – i.e., increase Wt. Ex: transfers of cash, education, land or other assets. Alter CTDs directly through risk reduction/transfer (∆s system too) – i.e., truncate εt . Ex: social protection - EGS, insurance, improved policing, drought-resistant varieties. Change the underlying system structure (mk(.) – techs/ institutions – induces ∆ in behaviors and CTDs. Prob: multi-scalar reinforcement – ‘fractal poverty traps’ Must explore the feedback within broader system to identify possible intervention points behind univariate dynamics.

Programming implications The role of social institutions, power, exclusion and solidarity “A tale of two widows” And would the widower’s dynamic = the widow’s?

Toward Systems Integration Feedback between sub-systems can be crucial Generalize to admit the role of the natural resource state, Rt: mk(Wt+s | Wt, Rt, εt) And recognize that parallel dynamics exist for the resource: rmk(Rt+s | Rt,Wt, εt) Now feedback potentially arises between R and W (e.g., range conditions depend on herd size/stocking rate, disease reproduction depends on household incomes) Or at least correlation due to εt (e.g., climate). Then the resilience of the underlying resource base becomes instrumentally important to resilience against chronic poverty.

Coupled human and natural systems dynamics Toward Systems Integration Coupled human and natural systems dynamics Problem: Many candidate contemporaneous relationships between Rt and Wt (e.g., EKC vs. soil degradation thresholds) make prediction difficult at best.

Toward Measurement and Evaluation If agencies program around resilience goals, then we need to be able to measure it and evaluate program/project performance. Should use theory to guide measurement. Key measurement implications of this theory: Qual. work to better understand root relationships. Estimate mk(·) and rmk(·). Use estimated moments to estimate the probability of poverty in each of a sequence of time periods. Based on a normative assessment of an appropriate tolerance level for the likelihood of being poor over time, individuals, households, communities, etc. could be classified as resilient or not. Then do impact evaluation based on such measures.

Summary Resilience is a popular buzzword now. But little precision in its use, theoretically, methodologically or empirically. We aim to help facilitate rigorous, precise use of the concept to help identify how best to avoid and escape chronic poverty. This will require advances in theory, systems integration, measurement and empirical work in many different contexts and over time. Much to do in all areas … a massive research agenda, especially as agencies begin using resilience as a programming principle. But we must start with a firm theoretical foundation.

Thank you for your time, interest and comments!