Results from surveys on peer review & peer feedback

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Academic Publishing is Evolving… Helping the world efficiently publish its knowledge Pete Binfield Co-Founder and Publisher PeerJ CRIStin Meeting, Norway.

Advertisements

NONFICTION Is prose that deals with real events and people, not with imagined events and imagined people.

Ref: Youth Peer Education toolkit: Standard of Peer Education Programmes, 2005.

OAPEN-UK Final Year Benchmarking Survey of Participants.

Sophistication in Research in Marketing Donald R. Lehmann Leigh McAlister Richard Staelin “Ideas that Matter” Pre-Conference Summer AMA 2010.

Career Field Research Project 3 points => Journal Articles Word document submitted on Moodle 1 Point => Independent Reflection Word document submitted.

MedEdPORTAL Reviewer Tutorial Contact MedEdPORTAL

Nutrition and Schools Rachel Bear Boise State University Writing Project Teacher Consultant.

Open Access & REF202*.  Green OA  Deposit of pre-print or post-print of accepted paper for publishing within a repository.  Gold OA  Published version.

Editor’s Viewpoint Jeff Craven Science and Operations Officer NWS Sullivan/Milwaukee WI WCM/SOO Conference Feb

Being a journal editor: scholar or secretary? Liz Todd Co-editor of International Journal of Research and Method in Education

A questionnaire is a document designed for the purpose of seeking specific information from the respondents.

Unit 5: Developing the Training Program 1 © SHRM 2009.

Agenda for Breakout Sessions 2/25/ Texas Tuning Oversight Council for Engineering and Science.

TAKEAWAYS WITH EVENT REGISTRATION SYSTEM KEY FEATURES WHICH MAKES THIS SYSTEMS A VALUABLE ASSETS.

Rationale In examining completion outcomes, student-level characteristics are key. Disaggregation of data by student groups are important for both intervention.

Training on Infection Prevention and Control

Writing for Professional Journals

10 steps to ‘Professional Clydebank High

Diversity and Inclusion Strategic Plan

ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE LEDGER AND GENERAL LEDGER CONTROLLING ACCOUNT

The final steps to the HDA project

What is Culturally Relevant teaching?

Creating Meaningful Information Literacy Assignments for an Introductory Agriculture Course Marianne Stowell Bracke Purdue University Libraries

"Being able to discuss with peers on research journey".

Communication & Safety

Publisher-Driven Preprints

How to Assess Common Reading Programs

Determining Discovery: How First-Year Students Use Primo

Uses of STROBE in real life Questionnaire results

Background Checking: Has the Use of Credit Background Checks Increased

University of Northern Colorado

Writing and Feedback.

Top 10 Suggestions on Publishing Journal Articles

ريكاوري (بازگشت به حالت اوليه)

5 Key features of Call Centre Design

Do Malaysians Trust Public Institutions?

ASAPbio/HHMI/Wellcome peer review meeting 8 Feb 2018

Scientific Publishing in the Digital Age

Scientific competence Communication and transparency

Helene Brinken Bootcamp – Day 1

e Stimuli images obtained from:

Course MT08 Perspectives on peer review

Submitting to a subscription-based journal

Strategic Human Resource Management

Presentation and Evaluation

P E S T Pest Analysis Political factors Economic factors

Building your ‘Top 5’ to help you complete your Evaluation

Jessica Polka Ron Vale Bodo Stern Boyana Konforti Robert Kiley

CS TA Spring 2007 Orientation

How the RDS can support your application

Jack L. Cronenwett, MD, Christos D. Liapis, MD

Local Control Accountability Plan Committee Meeting

Jeremy M. Berg Editor-in-Chief, Science family of journals

From results to submission

Peer Feedback More important than technology:

Computer Science The 6 Programming Steps.

3-2 Job Satisfaction.

How to make the most of your publications in the humanities?

Research ethics beyond the IRB

Business The test… The peer reviews….

Journal Club: Feasibility of Tobacco Interventions in Anesthesiology Practices Troy Tada, DO August 26, 2009.

What is Open Peer Review?

PEER SUPPORT IN TEACHING SURVEY RESULTS

Data + Research Elements What Publishers Can Do (and Are Doing) to Facilitate Data Integration and Attribution David Parsons – Lawrence, KS, 13th February.

Journal editor perspectives

Getting Your SoTL Research Published: An Editor’s Perspective

Self Assessment Arthur Chester Allen Suggs Troop Guides

Presentation transcript:

Results from surveys on peer review & peer feedback #bioPeerReview

Peer review survey demographics – 295 responses total #bioPeerReview

General attitudes toward peer review Ross-Hellauer T, Deppe A, Schmidt B (2017) Survey on open peer review: Attitudes and experience amongst editors, authors and reviewers. PLOS ONE 12(12): e0189311. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0189311 #bioPeerReview

#bioPeerReview

#bioPeerReview

#bioPeerReview

Credit and training for peer review #bioPeerReview From Peer Feedback survey

Efficiency in peer review Peer Review survey From Peer Feedback survey #bioPeerReview

Peer Feedback survey demographics – 370 responses total Questions relevant to authoring or reviewing experience were only asked of those with said experience. #bioPeerReview

Informal feedback #bioPeerReview

Finding an appropriate journal #bioPeerReview

Preprints & review transparency – author perspective #bioPeerReview

Transparency – reviewer perspective #bioPeerReview