Calculating commuting distance – a straight forward process?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Presented to GIS Committee presented by Eric Songer, URS Corporation 11/20/2008 Turnpike Enterprise Use of TeleAtlas GIS Data for Transportation Modeling.
Advertisements

CT Geospatial Information Systems Council Connecticut Geospatial Information Systems Council.
UP206A: Introduction to GIS. » The ArcGIS Network Analyst extension allows you to build a network dataset and perform analysis on a network dataset »
19 th Advanced Summer School in Regional Science Combining Vectors and Rasters in ArcGIS.
Spatial Statistics UP206A: Introduction to GIS. Central Feature.
Enabling a national road and street database in population statistics Pasi Piela ESRI UC San Diego 2014.
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe Statistical Division Applying the GSBPM to Business Register Management Steven Vale UNECE
Enabling a national road and street database in population statistics Pasi Piela Q2014 Vienna Conference.
James Palma Maryland State Data Center Maryland Department of Planning 301 West Preston Street, Suite 702 Baltimore, Maryland September 20, 2010.
Finland Sharing experience ESTP course on Geographic Information Systems (GIS): Use of GIS for making statistics in a production environment Statistics.
GIS in ISTAT (National Institute of Statistics) DCIQ – DIQR - INT ESTP course on Geographic Information Systems (GIS): Use of GIS for making statistics.
Creating a GIS Based Traffic Control Planning Tool for the Dallas District Andrew Karl Dr. Maidment CE 394K.3 GIS in Water Resources Term Project Due:
ArcGIS Network Analyst: Network Analysis with ArcGIS Online
Platform Data Extension PDE 1.4
Network Analysis with Python
Essential SNA Project being developed from 2011 to 2013.
ArcGIS Network Analyst: Automating Workflows with Geoprocessing
S T A T I S T I C S A U S T R I A May 13th – 15th Register Based Census “The Austrian Principles of Redundancy” UNECE/Eurostat.
FGDC Address Standard Update: What's Next? Address Standard Working Group Martha Wells, GISP Carl Anderson, GISP Sara Yurman, GISP Ed Wells, GISP Hilary.
Commuting time for every employed: combining traffic sensors and many other data sources for population statistics Pasi Piela EFGS Krakow.
UP206A: Introduction to GIS. » The ArcGIS Network Analyst extension allows you to build a network dataset and perform analysis on a network dataset.
Sharing experience Attribution (by) Licensees may copy, distribute, display and perform the work and make derivative works based on it only if they give.
Analytical Queries on Road Networks: An Experimental Evaluation of Two System Architectures Shangfu PengHanan Samet Department.
ITU Interactive Terrestrial Transmission Map | March 2015
Time Dependent Transportation Network Models Petko Bakalov, Erik Hoel, Wee-Liang Heng # Environmental Systems Research Institute (ESRI)
Enabling a national road and street database in population statistics: Commuting distances for all employed persons and other accessibility statistics.
Box Plots & Cumulative Frequency Graphs
Integration of Geography and Statistics in Europe – State of Progress Based on the GEOSTAT 2 survey Jerker Moström, Statistics Sweden Amelia Wardzińska-Sharif,
Integration of PASER & GIS WLIA March 4, 2004 Presentation Outline Road Centerlines –Overview –Creating –Attribute –Uses –Paser Geocoding Process –Overview.
URBDP 422 Urban and Regional Geo-Spatial Analysis Network Analysis Team Work Time VIII February 25, 2014.
Pasi Piela NTTS Conference, Brussels 14 March 2016
UNECE Seminar on New Frontiers for Statistical Data Collection, Geneva
Network Analysis with ArcGIS Online
Citilabs’ Sugar Analyst – Measuring Accessibility
Data Collection for Sub-national Statistics (Labour Market Areas)
Meeting of the Working Party
Microsoft Services Provider License Agreement Program reference card
Routing and Logistics with TransCAD
Rail transport statistics developments Agenda Item 4.1
SIRE and LAU Local Administrative Units
Country report - Portugal
Sub-regional workshop on integration of administrative data, big data
Country report - Finland
LAU, SIRE, postcodes
Calculation of commuting-distances in ArcView 3.x
1.3 Describing Quantitative Data with Numbers
Country report - Sweden
X-DIS/XBRL Phase 2 Kick-Off
Rail transport statistics developments: user’s perspective
ESS VIP ICT Project Task Force Meeting 5-6 March 2013.
Task Force on Passenger Mobility Statistics 11 October 2018
Contents Co-operation about one common register Public accessible
Defining Labour Market Areas (LMAs) in Bulgaria based on the EU method
Network Analysis using Python
Mapping Data Production Processes to the GSBPM
Local Administrative Units
Distances to primary schools in Austria
Perturbative methods for ESS census tables
Road Ahead – Analysis Capabilities (ArcGIS 10.1)
Data validation in Liechtenstein
SMALL AREA ESTIMATION FOR CITY STATISTICS
Recent spatial analysis work for the 4th Cohesion Report
Miryam Vahtra, State Budget Department, Ministry of Finance of Estonia
Geo-enabling the SDG indicators – experiences from the UN Global Geospatial Management and the GEOSTAT 3 project Agenda item 12 Ekkehard PETRI – Eurostat,
Geocoding of Population and Housing Census 2000: Lessons Learned
City and Functional Urban Area geometry creation
Ingrid Kaminger (and Sibylle Saul) GISCO Meeting Luxembourg
Geospatial data for cities and FUAs: state of play and opportunities
How to GEOSTAT census data?
Esri Roads and Highways An Introduction
Presentation transcript:

Calculating commuting distance – a straight forward process? Ingrid Kaminger GISCO meeting Luxemburg March 2nd 2015 Calculating commuting distance – a straight forward process?

Motivation 2011: change to the register based census Most commuting variables published in previous censuses are not included in administrative data sources (commuting time, commuting distance, commuting frequency, means of transport used for commuting) For the Census 2011 publications very coarse estimates for some of these variables were derived from a testing file of a LAU2-to-LAU2 matrix

Grant & Goal Eurostat Grant 2013: Merging statistics and geospatial information in Member States Title: Census 2011 - Enriching Commuter Statistics Goal 1: Model the variables road distance and commuting time using georeferenced register data and a road network .

Concept and functional possibilities Commuters: self-employed and employed persons as well as pupils or students, who have to travel between their place of residence and their place of work or educational institution Data source: register based census 2011, includes building ID of home and work resp. school for every resident Available for residents of Austria working resp. going to school in Austria Georeference for each building in the building and dwellings register Routing network (street classification, turning relations, speed, distance, …)

Working steps Prepare data and feed it into system (8.401.940 residents  4.270.049 routes) Georeference missing objects Create point layer of living and working addresses Add transit routes to street network Network Analyst – load points as locations Routing network – adapt necessary settings (speed, restrictions, hierarchy,…) Run the scripts (this takes about 6 weeks!) Evaluate results Find solution for unplausible results create tables,…

Use case story/ example Statistics Minutes Kilometer Mean 22,77 28,00 Q0=min 0,05 0,03 Q1 8,93 7,97 Q2=median 12,56 12,42 Q3 25,69 31,13 Q4=max 422,33 666,77 Statistics Minutes Kilometer Mean 25,38 31,22 Q0=min 0,02 0,01 Q1 5,49 3,04 Q2=median 10,19 6,09 Q3 26,91 26,44 Q4=max 360,85 581,35

Technologies and Standards used ESRI ARCGIS 10.1. on PC and in a Network Environment Operating System: Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise; RAM: 16 GB; Processor: 2,4 GHz Quad Core ESRI Network Analyst Extension Adapted Routing network 2013 based on TomTom (Company Geomarketing for Austrian streets), missing transit streets outside Austria) Scripts in Python 2.7 SQL-scripts for tabular results

Modelling a speed profile Missing traffic light information  modelled speed depending on max speed and location of road section (e.g. built-up areas) Modell is based on selection of routes calculated in various programs and derived from that in comparison to experienced time. ArcGIS (Min opt) Google Maps Bing Maps OSRM Graphhopper maps Speed Profile: ArcGIS (Minutes STAT)

Unplausible results all pupils of a primary school travel more than 15km  coordinate of that school was wrong  corrected coordinates and recalculated routes. Distance 0,0 km for commuters ? Buildings on the same roadsection  used euclidian distance Problems with the road network…

Unplausible results 2 Problem: unplausible commuting time/distance within a municipality commuters commuting within home municipalities had distances of >60km Various Reasons road network mountainous areas in border regions…

Unplausible results 2 - situation

Solution for unplausible results 2 For each municipality calculate Q1, Q3 … first and third quartile IQR=Q3-Q1 … interquartile range of commuting distances travelled within this municipality Distance considered unplausible if Distance > Q3 + 1,5 * IQR Solution: use 1,5 x length of the diagonale of the minimum bounding rectangle of the municipality as substitute value ArcGIS: minimum bounding geometry – rectangle by area

Comparison Results M1(LAU2 matrix) and M2(now)

Potential Reuse Repeatable action algorithms developed for 2011 data can be reused in the years to come already calculated data from 2012 just started calculations for data from 2013 Benefit for the ESS STAT will document the work STAT will provide the model and routing script Countries having a similar data basis only have to organise the routing system for their country and should be able to derive comparable results.

Resume The crux of it is the routing network and technical infrastructure Results for „local“ commuters (within municipality or vienna district) were not available before Results for distances are much more precise (in particular for short distances < 30km) A straight forward process? No, it is cumbersome, but it is worth it!

Calculating commuting distance – a straight forward process? Contact: Ingrid Kaminger Guglgasse 13, 1110 Wien Tel: +43 (1) 71128-7773 Fax: +43 (1) 7128622 Ingrid.Kaminger@statistik.gv.at Calculating commuting distance – a straight forward process?