MSFD PoMs workshop on CEA/CBA input to WG ESA

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Reporting on Programme of Measures (Art. 13)
Advertisements

The Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) The key and only legislation completely focused on the marine environment Clear ecosystem based thinking.
Mini seminar, Brussels, 22 February 2012
Methodology for the assessment of Member States’ reporting on Programme of Measures (Article 16) MSCG Sarine Barsoumian 7 April /09/2018.
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Framework contract ENV.D2/FRA/2012/0025
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Guidance report: Methodology for the assessment of ecological coherence of MPA’s Henk Wolters 30 October 2014.
Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Workshop on synergies & differences between WFD and MSFD
MSFD PoMs workshop on CEA/CBA WRAP-UP
Action C - Concretising scientific knowledge for economic analyses
Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)
Improving assessment of GES Draft conclusions and Way forward
Action points – ESA meeting
Workshop on synergies & differences between WFD and MSFD
Review of Decision 2010/477/EU and MSFD Annex III
State of play on the preparation of PoMs
WG ESA meeting 9th of March 2015
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
12th meeting of ESA working group
Reporting for MSFD Article 13 and 14 –
An Introduction to STAGES
Initial Assessment: reflections on structure and contents
WG GES Workshop Art. 8 MSFD Assessment
Draft CIS work programme
Draft CIS work programme
Marine Strategy Framework Directive State of play and follow up
European Commission DG Environment
Water/Marine Directors meeting May 2013
Breakout groups: reporting back
Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)
Activity on environmental objectives and exemptions
WG DIS May 2016 Based on a presentation prepared by
Conclusion and action points 13th meeting of ESA working group October 2015, Brussels MSCG 5th November 2015, Brussels.
Preliminary methodology for the assessment of Member States’ reporting on Programme of Measures (Article 16) WG DIKE Sarine Barsoumian (12/10/2015, Brussels)
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Links between MSP and MSFD DG ENV & DG MARE
WG GES, 6 December 2016, Brussels
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Revision of Decision 2010/477/EU Overview of main changes
WG GES: Decision review progress
Developing a common understanding of Articles 8, 9 & 10 MSFD
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Common Understanding Way forward
Progress of intersessional work
Economic Analysis for MSFD: the ESA guidance review.
Working group on data & information sharing DIS under CIS of WFD
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
PT Position Paper MSFD Implementation 2nd Cycle 15th MSCG Meeting
European Commission, DG Environment, Marine Unit
Reporting for MSFD Article 13 and 14 –
Draft CIS work programme
Guidance Document - Generic Outline
5.b3 Monitoring & Reporting 2019
Scene setter European Commission DG Environment
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Feedback from Meeting of the Working Group on Economic and Social Analysis 14th October 2014 MSCG November 2014, Brussels.
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Conclusion and action points
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
WG A ECOSTAT Draft Mandate
DG Environment, Unit D.2 Marine Environment and Water Industry
Marine Environment and Water Industry
Marine Strategy Coordination Group 14 November 2011, Brussels
MSFD PoMs workshop on CEA/CBA April 1, 2014
Our attempt to bridge the Science Policy gap: Volunteers needed
Item 4 b) Marine Strategy Framework Directive and CIS WFD
Presentation transcript:

MSFD PoMs workshop on CEA/CBA input to WG ESA 1 April 2014 Brussels

Deliverables (documents) Some text in PoM Recommendation paper (changes due to workshop exchanges in the main text + possible annex summary report) Presentations and minutes on CIRCA Best practice exchange document including cases from workshop, other references and provide further insight into approaches applied Deliverables (documents)

Deliverables (further actions) Future issues of WG ESA Issues that sit outside of WG ESA, to be included in MSCG, WG GES

PoM recommendation On economic analysis: - Requirements of the Directive - Different functions of CBA/CEA mentioned (briefly, extended in best practice paper) - Table (category of measures) CBA not necessarily being monetized baseline worked out as described in the WG ESA guidelines (Baseline includes future scenario) Existing measures: - don’t report again if reported elsewhere. - are included in the baseline and expected effect of already implemented legislation delivers the baseline (if baseline includes future scenario)

PoM recommendation If no quantified target, CEA/CBA can still be done. Environmental effects: in time, monitoring will provide evaluation of “extent of success” of (sets of) measures (adaptive management) Good practices presented: Pragmatic approach, stakeholder consultation & integration in decision-making are key CBA does not necessarily have to be fully monetized (to be included in PoM Recommendation)

WG GES MSCG & other Environmental effects WG GES Baseline MSCG

Possible stepwise approach (PoMs recomm paper)

Can the stepwise approach be considered as a universal framework and be included in the PoMs Recommendation paper / best practice exchange doc? Is it too general or already too prescribing? What changes should be made? Which elements are lacking? Or /and adapt step-wise approach under PoMs recommendation IV to have it as a more pragmatic approach?

BEST PRACTICES DOCUMENT FOR COST-EFFECTIVE “MARINE” MEASURES