What are sponsors looking for in research fellows?

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Friday, April 04, Applying for a Fellowship Research Staff Conference 2012 Rebecca Stokes Research Policy Officer Research and Graduate Services.
Advertisements

NIHR Trainees’ Meeting
Appointments and Promotions Lynn M Schnapp Professor, Dept of Medicine University of Washington Thanks to Ginny Broudy, Brad Anawalt.
Imperial College London July 2010 The Wellcome Trust.
EPSRC Fellowships Dr. Anne-Louise Holloway Research Capability Imperial College London, 19 th June 2009.
Transitioning from Trainee to Assistant Professor Alana L. Welm Assistant Professor Department of Oncological Sciences Huntsman Cancer Institute University.
WCHRI Graduate Studentship Competition 2014 WCHRI Grants Contacts: Chelsey Van Weerden, Research Grants Administrator Lorin Charlton,
Fulbright Scholar Program for U.S. Faculty Much of this is taken from
Clinical research career development Ian Hall Chair, MRC Clinical Training Fellowship Panel.
PROMOTION OF ACADEMIC STAFF Professor Merlin Crossley Acting Deputy-Vice-Chancellor (Research)
PICKING THE RIGHT JOB FOR YOU Post Doc versus Faculty Teaching and/or Research Large versus Small Institution.
Tenure and Promotion The Process: –Outlined in Article 15 of the FTCA. When you are granted tenure, you are also promoted to Associate (15.7.6). One application.
How Your Application Is Reviewed Vonda Smith, Ph.D. Scientific Review Officer (SRO)
Wellcome Trust Neuroscience Funding
Wellcome Trust - Funding the best science
Newcastle Cancer Centre at the Northern Institute for Cancer Research “Getting that first post-doc” Anthony Moorman Professor of Genetic Epidemiology.
© Imperial College LondonPage 1 Applying for Fellowships Physics RAs June 2009.
Securing Wellcome Trust Funding as an Established Researcher
Temple University Russell Conwell Learning Center Office of Senior Vice Provost for Undergraduate Studies GETTING INVOLVED IN RESEARCH AT TEMPLE UNIVERSITY.
Alina Schilling EPSRC Career Acceleration Fellow School of Maths & Physics
Wellcome Trust - Funding the best science Dr Helen Fisher Science Programme Manager Molecules, Genes and Cells Fellowship for Researcher Day: Sheffield.
Wellcome Trust - Funding the best science
Preparing a Successful Graduate Student Award Application Karen Beattie, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Dept. of Medicine McMaster University
Research Support Services
The Wellcome Trust Funding opportunities 5 December 2007 Tracy Halpin and Savita Ayyar.
Dr Emma Hudson Grants Adviser Molecular & Physiological Sciences University of Bath – Funders Day 20 th May Funding opportunities.
Funding and Fellowships Dr. Ian Prior School of Biomedical Sciences
“Current Fellows present their experiences in research and information on fellowships” Royal society BBSRC, MRC, ESRC Wellcome trust Human Frontiers Science.
Building An Academic Career
1 EPSRC Fellowships Dr Tracy Hanlon Research Capability Imperial College London 17 th July 2008.
PROMOTION AND TENURE FOR CLINICAL SCIENTISTS – BOTH PATHWAYS Peter Emanuel, M.D. Laura Lamps, M.D.
AHRQ 2011 Annual Conference: Insights from the AHRQ Peer Review Process Training Grant Review Perspective Denise G. Tate Ph.D., Professor, Chair HCRT Study.
Fellowships Day at Imperial College Sarah Fox 3 rd July 2007.
Postdoctoral Fellowship Opportunities in Engineering 11 June 2012 Jane Williams Research Strategy Manager Faculty of Engineering.
The Royal Academy of Engineering is Britain’s national Academy of Engineering dedicated to the promotion of excellence in the science, art and practice.
Research Fellowships Dr John Burden Research and Impact Services.
Post-PhD Career Trajectory & Funding Ian Humphreys Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellow Institute of Infection and Immunity
Programme Grants for Applied Research and Programme Development Grants Programmes Supporting a successful application September 2014.
Research Fellowships. Overview Introduction Why apply for a fellowship Finding the right fellowship The application process Assessment criteria for funding.
About me: Steven Penfield, URF  I worked as a post-doc at York University studying seeds.  During this time I realised that temperature responses.
ACADEMIC PROMOTIONS Promotions Criteria Please note, these slides only contain a summary of the promotions information – full details can be found.
What are sponsors looking for in research fellows? Melissa Bateson Professor of Ethology, Institute of Neuroscience Junior Fellowships.
2016 Academic Staff Promotion Round Briefing Session Professor Debra Henly Deputy Vice Chancellor (Academic)
WCHRI Graduate Studentship Competition 2016 WCHRI Grants Michelle Bailleux, Research Grants Administrator
ERC grants Funding for excellent ideas. European Research Council - mission 2 To encourage the highest quality research in Europe through competitive.
NSERC Coach - Dr. Steve Perlman, Dept. of Biology
The Academic CV UCL Careers Researchers.
How to land an amfAR grant
Wellcome Trust Neuroscience Funding
Thoughts on How to Initiate An Academic Career - Research
Overview of ERC grant schemes
NIHR Research Training Opportunities
Applying for Fellowships Henry Wellcome experience Ben Wilson benjamin
Feinberg School of Medicine Faculty Promotion and Tenure Program
Thomas Mitchell, MA, MPH Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics
What are sponsors looking for in research fellows?
Future Fellowships: perspective from a SAC member
What Reviewers look for NIH F30-33(FELLOWSHIP) GRANTS
Making Successful Grant Applications
ESRC Postdoctoral Fellowship Applications
“Getting that first post-doc”
Rick McGee, PhD and Bill Lowe, MD Faculty Affairs and NUCATS
Labmeeting Gernot Walko 15/12/2017
Wellcome - Funding Opportunities for Clinical Academics
ESRC Postdoctoral Fellowship Applications
Early career researchers & bibliometrics
“Getting that first post-doc”
from a Post-doc to a Research Fellowship - in 7 steps
Thomas Mitchell, MA, MPH Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics
Preparing for Fellowships
Presentation transcript:

What are sponsors looking for in research fellows? Junior Fellowships Event What are sponsors looking for in research fellows? Melissa Bateson Professor of Ethology, Institute of Neuroscience Melissa.Bateson@ncl.ac.uk

My career Year Stage University Papers* 1987-90 BA/MA in Zoology with Biological Anthropology Oxford 1990-93 DPhil in animal behaviour Dept. Zoology, Oxford 1993-95 Post-doctoral RA 1995-96 Wellcome Advanced Training Fellowship 3 (2 first author) 1996-98 Dept. Psychology, Duke, USA 1998-07 Royal Society University Research Fellowship Dept. Psychology, Newcastle 8 (5 first author) 2007-09 Lecturer IoN, Newcastle 2009-12 Reader 2012- Chair in Ethology * Published at time of application.

Aims: To present an insider’s view of how a fellowship selection panel works To summarise the main considerations of a panel in assessing fellowship applications

Royal Society Dorothy Hodgkin Fellowships “This scheme offers a recognised first step into an independent research career for outstanding scientists at an early stage of their research career who require a flexible working pattern due to personal circumstances, such as parenting or caring responsibilities or health-related reasons.”

Royal Society Dorothy Hodgkin Fellowships selection process 2013 72 eligible applications across all sciences Selection panel comprised 14 senior academics spanning all disciplines from psychology to particle physics (not clinical medicine) I covered neuroscience, psychology and behavioural ecology Each application scored (1-7) by 2 panel members Each panel member gets ~20 applications Many will be well outside their area of direct expertise First short list based on mean of 2 panel members’ scores First short list of 25 applications sent out to external referees 3 external referees are selected by the panel members External referees are experts in the area of the application Second short list of 14 chosen using panel and referee scores Second short list interviewed by the panel Applicants invited to present a short (5 min) talk on their work at the start Most appropriate panel member chosen to lead the questioning for each applicant 5 fellowships awarded = 7% success rate (14 awards in 2017; 13 female).

Take home messages: Most fellowship schemes are hugely competitive; you must be prepared for failure A triage step will often be applied; panels will often use crude criteria to do this; if your CV is not competitive for your career stage, it doesn’t matter how good your project is Your project needs to be accessible to non-expert scientists Your project needs to stand up to scrutiny by experts in your field You need to come across strongly in interview

So what are panels looking for? Ultimately, they want to give fellowships to those applicants that they think will be future research leaders Therefore, your job is to convince the panel that you have the makings of a future leader

Traits that panels want to identify: Productivity – how much have you done? Quality of work – how good is it? Independence – how much of your track record is yours versus that of your group/supervisor? Scholarship – knowing your field and where you fit Ambition to answer big questions Creativity – novelty of approach Clarity in both thought and writing

What they actually look at: Publications (journals and contributions) Other evidence of achievement (degree results, prizes, scholarships, grant awards etc.) Where you have worked and with whom Your proposed project The appropriateness of your chosen host institution and lab. Referees’ letters (Budget)

Publications These are the most important factor, and are often used in triage stages. You must have sufficient first/senior author primary research papers to be competitive. Reviews, commentaries and sole-author papers help demonstrate independence. Having publications with people other than your supervisor/research group shows initiative and independence. Citations and journal impact factors matter. Take home messages: Publication is the most important thing you can do to increase your competitiveness for fellowships. Seek advice on your publication list before applying. There is no point in applying if you don’t have sufficient quality or quantity of papers. Include journal impact factors and citation information in your publication list to help panels understand the impact of your work.

Other evidence of achievement Excellent degree results, prizes, scholarships etc. all help to demonstrate your achievements Any grant income that you have won is also very impressive and demonstrates ambition and independence Invited talks at other institutions/meetings look impressive Take home messages: Make sure any awards are prominently listed in your CV and/or personal statement. Investigate applying for external money; even small grants look good (e.g. travel grants, vacation scholarships for undergraduates etc.) Take advantage of any invitations to present your work either at conferences or at other institutions.

Your project Panels will look for the following qualities: A clearly articulated and important research question Hypotheses and predictions that you will test Novelty of the work Appropriate, well-justified methodology Feasibility and contingency planning for risky projects Potential impact of the work both in your field and beyond Clarity of writing Take home messages: Seek advice and input on your project ideas at an early stage (before you start writing). Consider giving a talk about your proposed project to your research group/institute/post-doc association to get feedback Have your project read by several other people including non-experts .

Where you have been and plan to be Scientists usually benefit from periods working in different labs. Leaving the lab where you did your PhD is usually vital for achieving and demonstrating independence. Panels will require a strong justification from someone wanting to stay in the same place for a fellowship. Panels will assess the quality of your chosen host institution and lab in assessing your fellowship application. Take home messages: Consider carefully whether you should move labs or institutions. If you are planning to stay where you did your PhD, is this really the best place to be? How can you develop and demonstrate independence from your supervisor? Consider short-term visits to other labs if you have to stay.

Referees Letters from referees are important in helping to create the impression that you are a future research leader. Panels will be impressed by referees from other institutions and especially from abroad, since this demonstrates the reach of your work. Panels will be impressed by referees that they know or have heard of. Take home messages: Choose your referees carefully: the most important thing is that they say positive things about you! If prominent people in your field know your work well and like it, then ask them if they will be a referee for you. Be strategic: if you are applying for a Royal Society fellowship and you know an FRS, then ask them if they would be a referee for you.

Costs Most fellowships require you to cost your project. Sponsors will typically set limits on what costs can be requested. Most sponsors are interested in getting good value for money. The panel I was on never discussed costs… Take home messages: Make sure your project is appropriately costed Your institute research support officers can help with this. Make sure all your requested costs are eligible. Carefully justify any large costs.

A final note on eligibility Most fellowship schemes have requirements E.g. number of years since PhD Check you meet these Make sure that the date of your PhD and the number of years full-time equivalent you have worked in research since your PhD are clearly stated on your CV/application.

Any questions? Melissa.Bateson@ncl.ac.uk