One band or two? See SKA Memo 140 for starting point in performance – cost analysis (70-450 MHz) No a priori advantages for either 1 or 2-band with current.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SKA New Technology Demonstrator Ray Norris CSIRO Australia Telescope National Facility.
Advertisements

Paul Alexander, Peter Hall Design Issues and Implementation ChallengesAAVP 2010 Design issues and implementation challenges Paul Alexander and Peter Hall.
Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy 1 ASTRON is part of the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO) From LOFAR design to SKA1 System.
Array Antenna Designs for the SKA-AAlo Eloy de Lera Acedo 1 AAVP 2010, Cambridge, UK. 10/12/10.
SKA AA-Low Station Configurations and Trade-off Analysis Nima Razavi-Ghods, Ahmed El-Makadema AAVP 2011, ASTRON, Dwingeloo Dec
DVA Series Work Flow P. Dewdney Apr 15, SPDO DVP Work Flow 2 DVA-1 CPG.
Distributed Adaptive Control and Metrology for Large Radar Apertures Principal Investigator: James Lux, P.E. (337) Dr. Elaine Chapin (334), Samuel Li (337),
Senior Project – Electrical Engineering Amateur Radio Repeater Daniel Harkenrider Advisor – Professor James Hedrick Abstract There are a number.
2 nd convergence workshop: introduction R. T. Schilizzi Penticton 22 July 2004.
Andrew Faulkner 2 nd SKADS Workshop October 2007 SKADS Benchmark Scenario Andrew Faulkner.
divergent 2.absolutely convergent 3.conditionally convergent.
AAVS 0.5: An Overview Peter Hall ICRAR/Curtin, Bologna, October 22, 2012.
Summary of the Paris SKA Meeting 4-8 September 2006 R. T. Schilizzi.
Rosie Bolton 2 nd SKADS Workshop October 2007 SKADS System Design and Costing: Update and next steps Rosie Bolton University of Cambridge.
SKA1-low: Cost Considerations AAVP Meeting, ASTRON 14 December, 2011 Tim Colegate, Peter Hall (ICRAR/Curtin) Andre Gunst (SPDO/ASTRON)
EoR/Cosmic Dawn SWG Feedback on SKA1-Low Array Configuration Cath Trott Brad Greig, Leon Koopmans, Andrei Mesinger, Garrelt Mellema, Jonathan Pritchard.
Citizenship in the United States of America
ITEC 6120 System Requirements Management
Deep Learning RUSSIR 2017 – Day 1
Chapter 4 Statistics.
Day 1: Introduction Course: Superscalar Architecture 12th International ACACES Summer School July 2016, Fiuggi, Italy © Prof. Mikko Lipasti Lecture.
PROJECT PLANNING AND CONTROL
Registered Electrical & Mechanical Engineer
Genetic Programming Hyper-heuristics for Combinatorial Optimisation
Welcome to . Week 11 Thurs . MAT135 Statistics.
Mixed Models in Three Flavors
Introduction to Data Conversion
Final Project Presentation ERROR CONCEALMENT TECHNIQUES IN H
The Low Frequency Array (LOFAR)
Solving Linear Programming Problems: The Simplex Method
Mathematical Theories of Communication:
Vacuum for Particle Accelerators, Glumslov, Sweden, June, 2017
Warm-Up: February 17/18, 2016 Where do we encounter waves? Write down all the examples of waves that you can think of.
Testing of Hypotheses. Decision
Kinetics Unit E Lundquist 2017.
AAVS1 Calibration Aperture Array Design & Construction Consortium
DEPT. OF PHARMACEUTICS & PHARM. TECH
FSA- Algebra 2 Statistics.
Intro to Science Sept 2011 Biology 112.
BASIC PRINCIPLES AND EXTENSIONS
Manufacturing and Services
INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW OF MANUFACTURING
Optimal Multi-Agent Path Finding under the Sum of Costs Objective
Anomaly Realization in Condensed Matter
Database System Implementation CSE 507
Trigonometry and Geometry
EVLA Project Peter Napier
HEAT AND MASS TRANSFER Heat and Mass Transfer a Practical Approach by Cengel Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer by Incropera Heat Transfer by Holman.
Taking ACTion on the ACT Your Guide to Acing the ACT
Light PHYSICS – UNIT TWO.
1Kyung Hee University, Korea 2Mercu Buana university
תרגול מס' 1 מערכת ההפעלה UNIX תכניות סטנדרטיות ב UNIX
Vectors.
Equilibrium Chapter 15.
اختلالات سطح هوشیاری.
Fundamental concepts, the zeroth law, heat, internal energy and work
Business Statistics Experimental Design and Analysis of Variance
Aperture Array Station Processing
Trip Distribution Meeghat Habibian Transportation Demand Analysis
Lect. 6 Pole Placement Basil Hamed
Quantum One.
Analysis of Adaptive Array Algorithm Performance for Satellite Interference Cancellation in Radio Astronomy Lisha Li, Brian D. Jeffs, Andrew Poulsen, and.
Lecture 8: Introduction to Neural Networks
Trip Distribution Meeghat Habibian Transportation Demand Analysis
Data Science 100 Lecture 9: Modeling and Estimation II
DVA1 as Part of the Dish Verification Program (DVP) Washington, DC P
Principles of Machine Learning
Unit 2 – Algebra Mathematics (9-1) - iGCSE Year 07
Lecture #7 3D Geometric Transformations
Chapter 9: Factor pricing models
Presentation transcript:

One band or two? See SKA Memo 140 for starting point in performance – cost analysis (70-450 MHz) No a priori advantages for either 1 or 2-band with current SKA goals Particular specs and site/operations issues influence relative and absolute costings Tweaks on original analysis: FoV, array configuration etc Processed FoV above ~200 MHz is a major relative cost driver, due b/f With a “relaxed” FoV spec, 1-band array has cost advantage Deployment costs are a significant absolute cost driver for SKA-low Huge number of elemental antennas demands optimized strategy Worrying global indifference to Memo 140 absolute costs Very sparse array at 450 MHz may be a problem for 1-band calibration (sidelobes) May just be OK at 400 MHz Need information from pathfinders Need to be able to pay the calibration power bill ! Push for 50 MHz is growing but no-one wants to give up on high-freq (and some want >450 MHz) We may need 2–bands anyway Frequency coverage and FoV are primary inputs for our design brief Urgent need for science convergence Active role needed for pathfinders to contribute pre-SRR info SKA-low (LFAA) – Peter J Hall