Preliminary results of a systematic review.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Introduction Methods Results Conclusions References In light of the lack of eligible studies for this review, the uncertainties around the effects of electric.
Advertisements

Authors and affiliation Research, University of Sheffield, 3 East Midlands Ambulance Service Study flow Conclusion In addition to measures relating to.
15 de Abril de A Meta-Analysis is a review in which bias has been reduced by the systematic identification, appraisal, synthesis and statistical.
September 26, 2012 DATA EVALUATION AND ANALYSIS IN SYSTEMATIC REVIEW.
What are Developmental Disorders? Presented by Carol Nati, MD, MS, DFAPA Medical Director, MHMRTC.
RESULTS INTRODUCTION Laurentian_University.svgLaurentian_University.svg‎ (SVG file, nominally 500 × 87 pixels, file size: 57 KB) Screening for Developmental.
Systematic Reviews.
Identifying the evidence Laura Macdonald Health Protection Scotland
According to the MECIR conduct standards, item 41, it is now mandatory for authors to provide a PRISMA study flow diagram in their reviews. It is essential.
Barriers & facilitators associated with initial and continued attendance at community-based interventions among families of overweight & obese children.
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING Review of Criteria for EAP Disability Categories of: Autism Spectrum Disorder Intellectual Impairment and Speech-Language.
Systematic Review Krit Pongpirul, MD, MPH. Johns Hopkins University.
Pre-Conference Symposium: H eterogeneity in the DSM-5/ DM-ID-2 Autism Spectrum: Linking Biological Traits, Clinical Traits and Treatments Pre-Conference.
 Bullying is a significant problem for ~ 20% of youths › Numerous associated issues:  Internal & external psychological disorders  Physical and psychosomatic.
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING Common Components across the EAP Disability Categories of: Autism Spectrum Disorder, Intellectual Impairment and Speech-Language.
Mental health workgroup UPDATE 15 TH WASHINGTON GROUP MEETING OCTOBER 2015.
Psychodynamic Psychotherapy: A Systematic Review of Techniques, Indications and Empirical Evidence Falk Leichsenring & Eric Leibing University of Goettingen,
Depression Screening in Primary Care and Impact on Suicide Prevention Anne-Marie T. Mann, BSN, RN, DNP Candidate Diane Kay Boyle, PhD, RN, FAAN.
Centre for Diet and Activity Research Social inequalities in physical activity: do environmental and policy interventions help reduce the gap? A pilot.
© 2016 Dr Mark A Stokes A meta-analysis of education interventions in children with High Functioning ASD Dr Mark Stokes Associate Professor Deakin University.
LITERATURE REVIEW OF DECISION MODELS FOR DISEASES WITH SHORT-TERM FLUCTUATIONS/EPISODES: The Case of COPD Dr. Orpah Nasimiyu Wavomba
Contact: Patrick Phillips,
FIGURE 3. FOREST PLOT AFTER CONTROLLING FOR NETWORK INCONSISTENCY
A Systematic Review of Discourse’s Outcomes
Life expectancy and causes of death of people with
Systematic reviews and meta-analyses of evidence on comorbid health conditions in people with autism spectrum disorder: A systematic review Ewelina Rydzewska,
Sophie Landa, Dr. Jacqui Rodgers, Dr. Emma Honey & Dr
NURS3030H NURSING RESEARCH IN PRACTICE MODULE 7 ‘Systematic Reviews’’
Interprofessional Online Learning for Primary Health Care:
9/2/2017.
Complex abdominal wall reconstruction in the setting of contamination and active infection: a systematic review of fistula and hernia recurrence rates.
HEALTH PROMOTION, INTEGRAL CARE AND SOCIAL INCLUSION
Introduction Research project: “Project Bayesian updating IQ”
After removal of duplication
A Meta Analysis of the Impact of SBI on Healthcare Utilization
Systematic Review Summary: Human Trafficking
Supplementary Table 1. PRISMA checklist
Elaine Walklet1,2, Kate Muse2, Jane Meyrick1, Tim Moss1
The impact of transition on health
Recommendations for Schools
Y W Liao1, S Shaman1, C S Chean1, S S Poon1, A Soltan1
Determinants of Elementary School Participation
Rebecca Frantz, M.A., Sarah Hansen, M.A., and Buket Erturk, M.A.
Performance Measurement and Rural Primary Care: A scoping review
Lifestyle factors in the development of diabetes among African immigrants in the UK: A systematic review Alloh T. Folashade Faculty of Health and Social.
Module 1 Federal Legislation and Florida State Process
The efficacy of using CAD for detection of
Migrant Health Research in the Republic of Ireland:
3. Practical screen Theory development with systematic literature reviews Chitu Okoli for ICT University, Fall 2015.
Hospital organization, management, and structure for the infection prevention and control of healthcare-associated infection in Chinese hospitals:
مدل زنجیره ای در برنامه های سلامت
Acknowledgements Thai Cochrane Network Prof. Malinee Laopaiboon.
Identification Screening Eligibility Included Included
Recommendation: ASD Licensed Specialist
Leah McClimans Associate Professor, University of South Carolina
Primary care healthcare professionals’ knowledge, attitudes and practices towards promoting the reduction of children’s secondhand smoke exposure Jaidev.
Therapeutic writing for eating disorders: A systematic review
Critically reviewing the literature
Genevieve Young-Southward1 Christopher Philo2 Sally-Ann Cooper3
Physical and Mental Health Literacy and Its Impact on Asian Americans’ Health Outcomes Young-Me Lee, Kunsook Bernstein, Scarlett Choi, Shinhi Han, Hyeonkyong.
Google Scholar: 8,554 publications Systematic search:
قطب قلب اصفهان 12/8/2016.
Delayed cerebral ischaemia prevention and treatment after aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage: a systematic review  M. Veldeman, A. Höllig, H. Clusmann,
Systematic review of atopic dermatitis disease definition in studies using routinely-collected health data M.P. Dizon, A.M. Yu, R.K. Singh, J. Wan, M-M.
Patient reported outcome measures for facial skin cancer: a systematic review and evaluation of the quality of their measurement properties Tom Dobbs,
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Dr. Charmayne Dubé Dr. Beverley Temple
Trent Regional SAPC Conference 19 March 2019
Identification Screening Eligibility Included Included
Critically reviewing the literature
Presentation transcript:

Preliminary results of a systematic review. Sensory processing and associated behavioral outcomes of individuals with an Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and an Intellectual Disability (ID): Preliminary results of a systematic review. M.F. Werkman, J.A. Landsman, A.S. Fokkens, Y. Dijkxhoorn, I. van Berckelaer-Onnes, S. Begeer, S.A. Reijneveld Introduction ASD and ID each affect sensory processing. Consensus lacks on the effect of the combined occurrence. For the ASD population 40 to 90% experience atypical sensory processing (since the DSM-5 a possible symptom of ASD). 25-50% of individuals with ASD also have ID. The combination of ASD with ID could lead to more and/or different atypical sensory processing compared to ASD alone, of relevance for their functioning. Consensus lacks on the extent to which atypical sensory processing is associated with behavioral outcomes for individuals with both ASD and ID. Therefore, the aims of this systematic review were to investigate: how individuals with ASD with ID differ in their sensory processing from individuals with ASD without ID, and to examine how atypical sensory processing is related to behavioral outcomes for individuals with ASD with ID compared to individuals with ASD without ID (see figure 1). Method A systematic review was performed (see figure 2). English language primary studies 2000 - 2017. Articles were selected for full text reading based on these inclusion criteria: individuals with ASD was a distinct research group; sensory processing was the main focus. 11 studies met the final inclusion criteria of our review: the relation between sensory processing and behavioral outcomes was researched for the ASD population; a within group analysis of the role of ID/IQ for the association between 1) ASD and sensory processing or 2) sensory processing and behavioral outcomes was performed for the ASD population. ID/IQ (Aim 1) ID/IQ (Aim 2) Sensory processing* Behavioral outcomes** ASD Figure 1. Aims review. * = the registration and/or modulation of sensory information and the internal organization of sensory input. ** = outcomes for the individual, e.g. adaptive behavior, repetitive behavior. ‘The Sensation of a Good Life’ (SGL) This PhD project is part of the Participatory Action Research project SGL. Figure 3 is developed by one of the participants with ASD. Ideally, sensory processing would be a perfect balance between under- and overresponsiveness. Figure 3. Output SGL project. (Left image in the logo: designed by Marek Zamaro and with his permission included in the SGL logo. ‘The Fifth Element, collection Special Arts’. Preliminary findings Many studies have been published about the sensory processing of individuals with ASD since 2000 (640 articles). Studies about the sensory processing of individuals with both ASD and ID are scarce: of the 11 studies included in our review, 2 studies investigated the sensory processing of individuals with both ASD and ID. The other 9 studies made a differentiation in IQ within the ASD population for individuals with and without ID. Mixed results for aim 1. No impact of ID/IQ on the sensory processing of individuals with ASD, different sensory processing clusters. Atypical sensory processing is associated with behavioral outcomes. Mixed results for aim 2. No impact of ID/IQ on the relation between sensory processing and behavioral outcomes, differences between sensory processing subtypes, different types of analyses. More primary studies about the sensory processing of individuals with both ASD and ID are needed. Records identified through database searching (n = 998) Additional records identified through other sources (n =0) Identification Records after duplicates removed (n =640) Screening Records excluded (n = 581) Records screened (n =640) Full-text articles assessed for eligibility (n =59) Full-text articles excluded (n =48) Eligibility Studies included in qualitative synthesis (n = 11) Included Figure 2. Flow diagram of the search and included studies.